Back to New York Unemployment

StarSailor

Who pays into unemployment? Trying to understand how NYSDOL UI actually works

So I've been on unemployment for about six weeks now and my brother-in-law got into this whole argument with me at dinner last weekend claiming that employees pay into the unemployment fund themselves and that's why we're 'entitled' to collect it. I always thought it was employers who funded the whole thing, not workers. Now I'm second-guessing myself and went down a rabbit hole trying to figure out the actual answer. The more I read the more confused I got because some articles talk about federal taxes and state taxes separately and I genuinely can't piece together how NYSDOL unemployment insurance gets funded. Can someone break this down in plain English? Like who actually contributes the money that pays out UI benefits — is it workers, employers, or both? And does it matter for how much I'm eligible to collect?

Your brother-in-law is mixing up unemployment with Social Security, which is a really common mistake. The money that funds New York unemployment insurance benefits comes entirely from employers — your boss pays a tax into the state's UI trust fund based on how much they pay you and how many former employees have filed claims against their account. Workers in New York don't have anything withheld from their paychecks for unemployment. You never contributed a dime directly to it. So when people say you 'earned' your benefits, they mean through your work history, not through payroll deductions. The amount you can collect is based on your highest-earning quarter during your base period, not on any fund you personally built up.

0 coins

My pay stubs actually confirm this — I just pulled up my last few from my old job and there's nothing labeled unemployment tax taken out of my check. So my employer was paying into this the whole time without me even knowing. That settles the argument with my brother-in-law at least.

0 coins

My pay stubs show the same thing, state income tax and that's about it on my end. Never saw a UI deduction. Your employer was definitely the one funding it.

0 coins

Worth adding that there are a few states where employees do contribute, New Jersey being one of them, but New York is not one of those states so your brother-in-law's logic doesn't apply here at all.

0 coins

While you're sorting out questions about your claim, if you ever need to actually get someone at NYSDOL on the phone to ask about your benefit amount or base period — I burned through two full days redialing before I found Claimyr (claimyr.com). The way it works is it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you, and you end up speaking directly with a live agent. There's a demo video at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE if you want to see it before trying. Saved me from completely losing my mind during adjudication.

0 coins

I actually do have a question about my base period that I've been wanting to ask an agent directly. Been putting it off because every time I try calling I get a busy signal or the line drops. Might look into this.

0 coins

I tried for three weeks to get through to NYSDOL on my own and gave up. Wish I'd known about Claimyr earlier.

0 coins

Does it work for questions about the employer tax stuff too or just for claimants? Asking for a situation I'm dealing with on the employer side.

0 coins

Your question actually touches on two separate tax systems layered on top of each other. Employers in New York pay into the state unemployment insurance fund — that's the NYSDOL side of things — and they also pay a federal tax called FUTA which funds things like extended benefits during high unemployment periods and covers administrative costs. The state tax rate an employer pays isn't flat, it shifts based on how often their former employees file claims. So a company that lays people off constantly ends up paying a higher rate than one with stable employment. This is called experience rating and it's meant to give employers a financial incentive to hold onto workers.

0 coins

The experience rating piece is new to me entirely. So my former employer's tax rate could go up because I filed? That's interesting — almost like a feedback loop built into the system.

0 coins

Exactly right on the experience rating. It's one of the main structural features of how UI is designed across most states. Employers with higher layoff rates essentially subsidize higher-risk industries through the pooled fund.

0 coins

I had no idea employers paid different rates depending on their history. I always assumed it was just some flat percentage everyone paid. The more you know I guess.

0 coins

my coworker told me employees DO pay into it through income taxes and that's wrong right? like income taxes and unemployment taxes are completely different things

0 coins

Your coworker is confusing two different things. Income taxes and unemployment insurance funding are completely separate. What you pay in income taxes goes to the general government budget, not to any unemployment insurance fund. The UI fund in New York is funded exclusively by employer payroll taxes, not worker income taxes, not employee withholdings. Your coworker might be thinking of the fact that unemployment benefits you receive are taxable income — meaning you pay income tax on what NYSDOL pays you — but that's the opposite direction of money flow from what you're asking about.

0 coins

oh okay that makes more sense now. so we pay income tax ON the benefits we receive but we never paid into the fund in the first place. got it

0 coins

I filed my weekly claim this morning and saw a notice about my employer's response to my separation — does the employer's history with NYSDOL affect how quickly they respond or is that a separate thing from the tax rate discussion?

0 coins

Those are two separate tracks. The employer's response to your separation is about whether they contest your eligibility — that goes through adjudication. The tax rate experience rating is purely a financial calculation that happens on the employer's account and doesn't directly affect the timeline of your claim. Some employers fight every single claim because they want to keep their rate low, which is exactly why that incentive structure exists. If your employer contests your separation, expect your claim to go into adjudication and potentially take several weeks before NYSDOL makes a determination.

0 coins

My account has been showing adjudication pending for about nine days now. I didn't know the employer contesting it was possibly the reason. That actually explains a lot.

0 coins

My adjudication dragged on for over a month because my former employer disputed my separation reason. The good news is NYSDOL does eventually make a ruling and in my case they sided with me. Keep filing your weekly claims the whole time though — that part is really important.

0 coins

BEEN FIGHTING WITH NYSDOL FOR WEEKS and I still don't even understand why my benefits got reduced. I contributed to this system by working and my employer paid taxes on my wages and now they're telling me my benefit amount is lower than it should be?? How does that even happen

0 coins

Your benefit amount is calculated from your base period wages — that's the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before you filed. If your hours were reduced, you had a low-earning quarter, or you weren't employed the full period, your calculated benefit rate might be lower than you expected. NYSDOL isn't taking anything away, they're calculating from the wages that were actually reported to them. You should be able to see your base period wage breakdown in your Unemployment Services account. If the numbers look wrong compared to what you actually earned, that's worth fighting.

0 coins

I pulled up my Unemployment Services account and checked the wage breakdown they have on file and one of my quarters is showing way lower than what I actually made. My employer might not have reported my wages correctly. How do I even start fixing that?

0 coins

Wage discrepancies like that go through a process where you submit proof of your actual earnings — W-2s, pay stubs, employer records — and NYSDOL investigates. File a wage protest. The form is in your Unemployment Services account under the monetary determination section. Keep filing your weekly claims while that gets sorted out.

0 coins

My situation was similar — I needed to dispute my base period wages and kept getting nowhere trying to figure out the right department to reach at NYSDOL. After about two weeks of busy signals and dropped calls I tried Claimyr and ended up speaking with an actual live agent who pulled up my account right there and walked me through exactly what documentation to submit for the wage protest. Got the whole thing sorted instead of just guessing at which form to use.

0 coins

I need this. I've been going in circles on the NYSDOL website for days and can't figure out the wage protest process from the online info alone. An actual person explaining it would make a huge difference.

0 coins

Tried to call NYSDOL myself again this morning after reading earlier comments — sat on hold for 45 minutes and the line just went silent. No agent, no explanation. At this point I'm genuinely considering Claimyr just to actually get through.

0 coins

The dropped calls are the worst part. You invest an hour and then nothing. I ended up with the same situation and Claimyr at least got me to a real person instead of dead air.

0 coins

To get back to the original question about who pays in — there's actually a wage base cap that matters here. Employers don't pay New York UI tax on every dollar of wages, only on the first chunk of wages per employee per year. That cap changes periodically. Beyond that cap the employer still pays the worker but doesn't owe additional UI tax on those wages. It's one reason why higher earners don't necessarily collect proportionally higher benefits — the tax base and the benefit calculation both have ceilings built in.

0 coins

My former salary was well above average so I always wondered why my weekly benefit amount felt capped. The taxable wage base ceiling you're describing explains exactly why — my employer wasn't paying UI tax on my full salary, only on the portion under the cap.

0 coins

I never knew there was a cap on what employers pay tax on. So they're contributing on a limited slice of your salary and your benefit gets calculated from your actual wages up to a different ceiling. Two separate caps. That's weirdly complicated for something that's supposed to be simple.

0 coins

You've got it right. The employer-side taxable wage base and the claimant-side maximum benefit rate are two different numbers that exist for different reasons, but they both create a ceiling effect. It's baked into how federal law set up the UI system nationally.

0 coins

My aunt used Claimyr when she was dealing with an overpayment notice from NYSDOL and kept getting nowhere with the phone lines — she said she finally got to a live agent after trying it and was able to ask about the appeal process directly instead of just guessing from the website. She walked away knowing exactly what she needed to submit and by when.

0 coins

My overpayment question has been sitting unanswered for two weeks because I can't get anyone on the phone. Good to know that's a viable route for getting actual answers from an agent.

0 coins

i didn't know you could appeal overpayment notices, i thought you just had to pay whatever they said. is that actually a thing?

0 coins

Overpayment determinations are absolutely appealable within 30 days of the notice date. You have the right to a hearing before an administrative law judge. If you believe the overpayment determination is wrong, or even if you agree it happened but believe repayment would cause undue hardship, those are both grounds to appeal or request a waiver. Don't just ignore those notices — the deadline matters.

0 coins

I've seen people in this thread and others confuse FUTA with SUTA and I just want to be clear for anyone reading — FUTA is the federal unemployment tax employers pay, SUTA is the state version. In New York the state one goes to NYSDOL's UI trust fund and that's where your weekly benefits actually come from. The federal one funds the administrative structure and extended benefit programs. Both are employer-only taxes.

0 coins

I'd been seeing those acronyms tossed around and had no idea they were different things. So when NYSDOL sends you benefits it's pulling from the state trust fund that employer SUTA taxes built up. Got it.

0 coins

Correct. And the trust fund balance actually matters — if it gets depleted during a recession, New York has to borrow from the federal government to keep paying benefits, which then creates repayment obligations that can affect future employer rates. The whole system is more interconnected than most people realize.

0 coins

okay so to make sure I understand — my paycheck never had anything deducted for unemployment, my employer paid a separate tax on my wages to NYSDOL, that money went into a fund, and now when I collect benefits that fund pays out. And the more people get laid off from a company the more that company pays going forward?

0 coins

Your summary is accurate. The employer tax goes into the state trust fund, the fund pays out benefits, and yes — an employer's layoff history directly influences their future tax rate through the experience rating formula. It's designed so the cost of unemployment doesn't fall on workers at all, only on the businesses that generate the layoffs.

0 coins

I feel like this should be explained somewhere obvious when you first file. I had zero idea how any of this worked when I submitted my initial claim.

0 coins

NYSDOL's onboarding information when you first file is pretty minimal. Most people learn all this by asking on forums or by actually running into a problem with their claim. It's genuinely one of those things the system assumes you'll figure out.

0 coins

I had to get on the phone with NYSDOL last month about a question related to my employer's reported wages and I'd been getting nowhere on my own — a friend mentioned Claimyr and I tried it. It waits on hold with NYSDOL for you and I ended up talking with a live agent who actually pulled up the records and confirmed what my employer had reported. Turned out the discrepancy was on NYSDOL's end, not mine, and the agent flagged it for correction while I was on the call.

0 coins

My wage discrepancy situation sounds almost identical to yours. Having an agent pull the records up live while you're on the phone sounds like exactly what I need to actually resolve this instead of submitting forms and waiting in the dark.

0 coins

Employer wage reporting errors are more common than people think. I've seen it in this forum a lot. The key is getting an agent who can actually see both sides of the record at the same time, which sounds like what you got.

0 coins

Does any of this change if you were a part-time worker? Like my employer paid taxes on my wages even though I was only part-time, right?

0 coins

Part-time employment doesn't change the basic structure at all. Your employer paid New York UI taxes on your wages just like they would for a full-time employee, up to the taxable wage base. The difference shows up in your benefit calculation — since your part-time wages were lower, your base period earnings are lower, and your weekly benefit amount will reflect that. But you absolutely have a claim if you were separated and meet the eligibility criteria, even as a part-time worker.

0 coins

My former employer actually told me that part-time workers don't qualify for unemployment and that's why I didn't file for the first few weeks. I finally filed anyway and found out he was completely wrong. I wish I hadn't waited.

0 coins

Your former employer either didn't know the rules or was hoping you wouldn't find out. Part-time workers can absolutely file. The only requirements are that you earned enough wages in your base period and that you're able to work and available for work going forward — the fact that your prior job was part-time doesn't disqualify you.

0 coins

I'm on the employer side of this and our payroll company handles FUTA and SUTA automatically so I'd never really dug into how it worked. Reading this thread I realize I should actually understand what we're paying and why. Can someone explain how NYSDOL determines the initial rate for a brand new employer who doesn't have a claims history yet?

0 coins

New employers in New York get assigned a standard new employer rate — it's not based on experience because there's no claims history to work from yet. After you've been in business long enough and have a few years of payroll and claims data, NYSDOL recalculates your rate annually using the experience rating formula. That's when having a stable workforce with low turnover starts working in your favor financially.

0 coins

The transition from the new employer rate to the experience-rated system usually happens after three years of reportable wages. So a business just starting out has a few years before their claims history starts directly affecting their cost.

0 coins

My payroll company never explained any of this transition. I just see the quarterly payments go out and that's it. Good to know there's an actual formula behind what we pay.

0 coins

I'm a little confused about something — if my employer paid these taxes and I got laid off, do they owe me anything directly or does it all go through NYSDOL? Like is there any situation where I'd go after the employer for unpaid wages separately from unemployment?

0 coins

The unemployment insurance system and unpaid wage claims are two completely separate things. UI benefits come from the state trust fund through NYSDOL — your former employer doesn't pay you directly. If your employer owes you unpaid wages, overtime, or final paychecks that's a different claim entirely, usually filed through the New York State Department of Labor's Division of Labor Standards, not through unemployment. You can pursue both simultaneously if both apply to your situation.

0 coins

My last paycheck from my employer was short by what I calculated as about two weeks of accrued PTO they were supposed to pay out. I didn't know I could file a separate complaint about that while also collecting UI. That's really helpful.

0 coins

Wage theft complaints are a whole separate process but they're worth filing if you have documentation. NYSDOL handles both but through different divisions so don't let one confuse the other.

0 coins

if the employer is paying into it this whole time why do employers fight your claim when you file? seems like they already paid so what do they care

0 coins

The experience rating system your question is really getting at — employers fight claims because every successful claim gets charged against their account, which raises their future tax rate. It's not that they want to keep the money they already paid in, it's that approving your claim increases what they'll pay going forward. So contesting claims is basically a financial move to protect their future rate even though it creates a lot of headaches for people trying to collect what they're entitled to.

0 coins

oh so they're not trying to get back money they already paid, they're trying to avoid paying more in the future. that's honestly kind of messed up when you think about it

0 coins

It is frustrating, especially when you were clearly laid off through no fault of your own and they still contest it hoping you'll give up or not appeal. NYSDOL adjudicators see through most of it but it delays the process for everyone.

0 coins

Coming back to update — I finally got all my questions answered. My base period wages were accurately reported, my weekly benefit amount is what it should be based on my highest quarter, and my claim is processing normally. The original argument with my brother-in-law feels pretty settled now. Employer pays in, worker collects when eligible, no money comes out of your own paycheck for this. Straightforward once someone explains it properly.

0 coins

My questions got answered by reading through this whole discussion too. Way more useful than the FAQ on NYSDOL's official site, honestly.

0 coins

The core concept really is simple but it gets buried under the complexity of the tax structure and the base period calculations. Glad it clicked.

0 coins

I still have my wage discrepancy to sort out but I at least understand the system now. Filing a wage protest this week and going from there.

0 coins

One thing worth making explicit for anyone else finding this thread — the fact that you personally never paid into the unemployment fund does not make collecting it any less legitimate. You worked, your employer paid taxes on your labor, and the system exists precisely for when that employment ends. The moral framing some people put on collecting UI as if it's taking something for nothing ignores how the funding structure actually works.

0 coins

My brother-in-law's whole argument had this undertone that I shouldn't be comfortable collecting because I hadn't personally 'paid in.' Understanding that my employer was paying on my wages this whole time actually shifted how I think about it.

0 coins

I felt weirdly guilty filing at first for the same reason. Someone told me early on that it was funded by employers not workers and I still internalized some shame about it. This thread kind of helped clear that up.

0 coins

My coworkers who got laid off at the same time as me had similar feelings. I think a lot of people just don't know how the funding works and default to feeling like they're asking for a handout. The reality is very different.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure