Back to New York Unemployment

Gianna Scott

Who pays for unemployment insurance in NY? NYSDOL explained

So I've been collecting unemployment for about six weeks now and my brother-in-law got into this whole debate with me at dinner last weekend saying I'm basically taking money from other workers' paychecks. I told him that's not how it works but honestly I couldn't back it up because I don't actually know the specifics. Like where does this money come from? Does it come out of my taxes, my former employer's pocket, some state fund? I worked in restaurant management for four years before the place I was at downsized and cut my position, and now I'm getting weekly benefits through NYSDOL. My claim went through fine, no adjudication issues, I'm doing my three job search activities every week. But this question is nagging at me and I figured someone here would actually know the answer. Who is actually paying for unemployment insurance and does it vary based on how long someone collects or how many people a company lays off?

Your brother-in-law has it backwards actually. Unemployment insurance in New York is funded entirely by employers, not workers. What happens is every business that has employees pays into a state UI trust fund based on a tax rate applied to each worker's wages. The rate isn't the same for every company though — employers who lay off workers more frequently end up paying higher rates over time. It's called an experience rating system. So if a restaurant group keeps laying people off seasonally, their tax rate climbs. The money that funded your claim came from taxes your former employer paid, not from anything deducted from your paycheck. Employees in New York don't contribute to unemployment insurance at all.

0 coins

Wait so my paycheck stubs never had any deduction going toward this? I always assumed some of those line items were UI related.

0 coins

Federal income tax, Social Security, Medicare — those show up on your stub. But there's no New York unemployment insurance deduction from employee wages. Your former employer was the one writing that check to the state, not you.

0 coins

This is accurate. I did payroll for a small business for years and the FUTA and SUTA payments came entirely from the employer side of the ledger. Workers never see that deduction because it doesn't exist for them.

0 coins

Trying to get answers from NYSDOL directly on stuff like this is a nightmare by the way. I had a question about my own claim funding situation a few months ago and spent three days redialing their number. A friend told me about Claimyr — claimyr.com — there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. Basically it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up on the phone with a live agent instead of getting dropped after an hour. Got my question answered same day I tried it. Might be useful if you need to dig into the specifics of your own claim.

0 coins

Three days redialing sounds about right honestly. I hit redial so many times on a Monday morning that my thumb was actually sore.

0 coins

Does that actually land you a real person at NYSDOL? I've used online chat and they just bounce you to FAQs.

0 coins

Yeah I ended up talking to an actual NYSDOL agent who could look at my account. Way different from the automated stuff or the chat bot.

0 coins

Does the employer tax thing mean bigger companies pay more than tiny ones? Like is my old boss at a ten-person diner paying less than some corporation?

0 coins

Both the size and the layoff history matter. A larger payroll means more taxable wages so the absolute dollar amount is higher. But the rate itself goes up or down based on how many former employees claimed benefits against that employer. A small diner that never lays anyone off could actually have a lower rate than a mid-size company that routinely cuts staff every slow season.

0 coins

So my restaurant basically raised its own tax rate by laying me off. That's kind of poetic justice.

0 coins

Exactly, and that's intentional design. The experience rating is meant to discourage unnecessary layoffs by making them cost more over time.

0 coins

I'm confused about something — if employers pay into this fund does that mean they can fight your claim to protect their rate? Because my former manager told me they were going to contest my separation and I didn't know if that was related.

0 coins

Yes that's directly connected. Employers have a financial stake in UI claims because approved claims affect their experience rating and eventually their tax rate. So they sometimes protest separations, especially if they can argue the employee quit voluntarily or was terminated for misconduct. If NYSDOL agrees with them, the claim goes into adjudication and potentially gets denied. That's why separation reason matters so much when you file.

0 coins

My separation was a layoff due to position elimination, not anything I did wrong. Should I still be worried about them contesting it?

0 coins

Position elimination is one of the cleaner separation reasons for UI purposes. Document everything you have showing the role was cut, not that you were fired for cause. If they do contest, you have an appeal right and NYSDOL will look at both sides.

0 coins

My employer contested my claim after a layoff and I was terrified but the adjudicator sided with me once I sent in the offer letter and the termination notice showing it was a business decision. Keep your paperwork.

0 coins

Does the federal government put any money into unemployment or is it purely a state thing in NY?

0 coins

Both levels are involved but differently. Employers pay two separate taxes — the state one (SUTA) goes into New York's trust fund and covers regular UI benefits. There's also a federal unemployment tax (FUTA) that employers pay, and that money goes toward administrative costs and also funds extended benefit programs when unemployment rates hit certain thresholds. During normal times your weekly check is coming from the New York trust fund, not federal money.

0 coins

So the FUTA is basically the backup system and what I'm collecting right now is state money.

0 coins

That's a solid way to think about it, yes.

0 coins

My former coworker told me employees DO pay into unemployment in some states and she was shocked New York works differently. Is she wrong or is there actually variation?

0 coins

She's right that it varies. A handful of states do have small employee contributions to unemployment funds. New Jersey is one that comes to mind where workers chip in a bit. But in New York it's fully employer-funded. So your coworker isn't wrong about the concept existing, just about how New York specifically handles it.

0 coins

Interesting. So my brother who lives in New Jersey might actually be paying into his state's UI fund out of his wages?

0 coins

If he looks at his pay stub he'd probably see a NJ UI deduction. It's usually pretty small but it's there.

0 coins

This whole conversation is making me feel vindicated because I definitely told my brother-in-law we don't pay into it here and I was right apparently.

0 coins

Does the amount I get weekly have anything to do with how much my employer paid into the fund or is it based on something else entirely?

0 coins

Your weekly benefit amount is calculated from your own wage history, not from how much your specific employer contributed. NYSDOL looks at your base period earnings — roughly the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters — and applies a formula to set your weekly benefit rate. The employer's contribution rate affects the fund as a whole but doesn't directly set your individual benefit level.

0 coins

So even if my employer was a small business that paid minimal taxes into the fund I still get my full calculated benefit?

0 coins

Correct. Your benefit is between you and the state formula. The employer's tax history is a separate calculation that affects their own rate going forward.

0 coins

I actually had to call NYSDOL to get a question answered about my base period wages and I could not get through to anyone for over two weeks. Ended up using Claimyr and finally got to speak with an agent who explained exactly how my wages were being counted. Worth it if you're stuck in phone limbo.

0 coins

Two weeks is brutal. I gave up after three days and just waited for stuff to resolve in my account which took forever.

0 coins

The wait to actually talk to someone was messing with my claim timeline so I needed to figure it out faster than online stuff allowed.

0 coins

Did the agent you reached actually have access to your wage records or were they just giving you general info?

0 coins

They pulled up my account while we were talking and went through each quarter with me. It was an actual account review not just reading me the website FAQ.

0 coins

Is there a maximum to how much employers can be taxed for UI purposes? Like if a company lays off a ton of people can their rate just keep climbing forever?

0 coins

There's a ceiling. New York caps the UI tax rate so it doesn't spiral indefinitely. The taxable wage base also has a cap, meaning employers only pay the rate on wages up to a certain threshold per employee per year, not on the full salary above that. So a company paying an executive $400k isn't paying UI tax on all $400k of that salary.

0 coins

That feels like it benefits the companies with highly paid workers the most since the cap cuts off faster.

0 coins

That's a fair critique and it's a pretty common policy debate in labor economics circles. The taxable wage base in New York gets adjusted periodically but it hasn't kept pace with wage growth in higher-paying industries.

0 coins

Can anyone tell me if collecting unemployment hurts my former employer in real time or does it lag? I want to know if my claim is already affecting what they pay.

0 coins

There's a lag built into the experience rating system. Your employer's rate is recalculated periodically based on the history of claims charged against their account. It doesn't update week by week in real time — the adjustment typically shows up in the next rate determination cycle. So they won't feel it immediately but it does catch up over time.

0 coins

So they'll see it in their next tax year calculation basically.

0 coins

This is kind of satisfying to know if the layoff was handled badly.

0 coins

My claim got stuck in adjudication for almost a month and I was completely in the dark about why. I tried calling NYSDOL every single morning for two weeks and the line would either drop or hit capacity. Someone in another thread mentioned Claimyr and I tried it — ended up talking to a rep who told me there was a flag on my account about my separation reason that I didn't even know existed. Got it cleared up way faster than waiting around for a letter.

0 coins

A flag you didn't know about — that sounds terrifying. How would you have ever found out without reaching someone by phone?

0 coins

Honestly I don't think I would have for a long time. The online account just said 'pending' with no detail. The agent explained the specific issue and what documentation I needed to send through the portal.

0 coins

Adjudication holds without any explanation are genuinely one of the most stressful parts of this whole process. At least you got someone who could actually tell you what was happening.

0 coins

Does it matter to NYSDOL whether I was full time or part time when it comes to what gets paid into the fund on my behalf?

0 coins

Your employment status affects your wage history and therefore your benefit calculation, but as far as the employer's tax obligation goes, they owe UI tax on covered wages regardless of whether you were full or part time. A part-time employee's wages are still taxable wages. You'll just have lower total base period earnings if you were working part time, which means a lower weekly benefit amount.

0 coins

Makes sense. I was part time for most of my base period so I figured my benefit would be lower than coworkers who were full time.

0 coins

Is there a minimum earnings threshold to even qualify for benefits in New York?

0 coins

Yes, you need to meet minimum earnings thresholds in your base period. The specifics are on the NYSDOL website and they do get updated, so worth checking current figures rather than relying on what someone posts here.

0 coins

Does a company that closes entirely still have its former employees' claims charged against it? Like if a restaurant shuts down completely does the closed business still see rate adjustments?

0 coins

If the business is fully dissolved it obviously can't pay future taxes anyway. Claims get charged to the account but if there's no ongoing entity to adjust rates for, the practical effect is zero on the former owner. The fund absorbs those costs essentially. This is one reason the UI trust fund can get stressed during waves of business closures — the charges don't have a live employer account to draw against.

0 coins

So the state fund just eats that cost. That explains why the fund balance matters so much and why it got depleted during certain economic periods.

0 coins

Months ago I spent an entire Thursday morning redialing NYSDOL trying to understand why my benefit amount was lower than I expected based on my salary. Never got through. Someone at my local workforce development office mentioned Claimyr so I tried it the following week — waited on hold through Claimyr and reached a live agent who walked me through the base period wage calculation. Turned out one of my quarters was miscounted. The agent submitted a wage correction request while I was on the phone with them.

0 coins

A miscounted quarter — that could have meant collecting less money for the entire benefit year if you hadn't caught it.

0 coins

Exactly why I needed to actually speak with someone who had access to my records. The online tools don't show you the quarter-by-quarter breakdown in enough detail to spot an error.

0 coins

How long did the wage correction take to process after the agent submitted it?

0 coins

About ten business days before I saw the adjusted amount in my account. The agent gave me a reference number to track it.

0 coins

Does how long you worked for a company affect how much they paid into UI on your behalf, or is it just about your wages?

0 coins

Tenure itself isn't the variable — wages are. If you worked for two years at a higher salary you'd generate more taxable wages and therefore more employer UI tax contributions than someone who worked five years at a lower wage. The length matters only insofar as it determines how many quarters of wages show up in your base period.

0 coins

So someone who worked a short time at a good salary could have a higher benefit rate than a longtime low-wage worker.

0 coins

That's how the math works out, yes. The benefit formula is percentage-based on your wages so higher earners generally get higher weekly amounts, up to the state maximum weekly benefit rate.

0 coins

Is my employer notified every time I certify for my weekly benefits or only when there's some kind of dispute?

0 coins

Your former employer isn't pinged every week when you certify. They receive notice when a claim is initially filed against their account and have an opportunity to respond or protest at that point. After that, the weekly certification process is between you and NYSDOL unless a new issue comes up that requires employer input.

0 coins

Good to know. I was worried they were getting weekly updates and might find reasons to contest after the fact.

0 coins

My ex-manager made it sound like they'd be watching everything I did with my claim. That was apparently just intimidation.

0 coins

Does New York's UI trust fund ever run out and what happens if it does? I saw something about states borrowing from the federal government during certain periods.

0 coins

Yes, that actually happened in New York. When the trust fund gets depleted — typically during recessions or mass layoff events — the state can borrow from the federal government's loan program to keep paying benefits. The downside is that this borrowing eventually leads to higher employer tax rates as the state works to repay the federal loan and rebuild the fund balance. Workers keep receiving benefits during that period but it creates a tax burden on employers for years afterward.

0 coins

So workers don't feel it directly but employers end up paying more for a while after a recession.

0 coins

And then those higher employer costs potentially affect hiring decisions during the recovery period. The whole thing is interconnected in kind of a painful way.

0 coins

Does my employer have to report my wages to NYSDOL or do I report them myself when I file?

0 coins

Employers report wages to NYSDOL on a quarterly basis as part of their normal tax and reporting obligations. When you file a UI claim, NYSDOL pulls that wage data from employer records to calculate your base period earnings. You don't bring your own pay stubs to establish the base period — the state already has that information from employer quarterly filings. That said, if there's a discrepancy you can challenge it with documentation.

0 coins

That explains why my claim went through so smoothly. I was expecting to have to gather a ton of records.

0 coins

Mine had a gap because one of my employers hadn't filed their quarterly report on time and it caused a delay in my claim being processed. So it doesn't always go smoothly if the employer is behind on their filing.

0 coins

Does a staffing agency situation change any of this? I was placed through a temp agency but I worked at a client site — which employer is on the hook for the UI taxes?

0 coins

The staffing agency is typically the employer of record for UI purposes when you're a temp worker. Even though you showed up at a client site, your paycheck came from the agency and that's the entity that paid your wages and therefore owes the UI taxes. If you file a claim after a temp assignment ends, it would generally be charged against the staffing agency's experience rating account, not the client company's.

0 coins

That's actually helpful because I wasn't sure if I'd have to track down the client company to file properly.

0 coins

My staffing agency never explained any of this during onboarding which feels like a gap in what they should tell people.

0 coins

Thank you everyone — this thread answered way more than I originally asked. So to summarize what I learned: employers pay into a state UI trust fund based on their payroll and their layoff history, workers in New York contribute nothing, my weekly benefit is based on my own wage history, and my former employer's tax rate may go up over time partly because of my claim. My brother-in-law was completely wrong and I now have about fifteen paragraphs of backup.

0 coins

Your summary is accurate. The experience rating piece is probably the most underappreciated part of the system — it's genuinely designed to make layoffs cost something for the employers who do them.

0 coins

Your brother-in-law owes you an apology at the next family dinner.

0 coins

He absolutely does and I am prepared to deliver this entire thread to him.

0 coins

Honestly this came up at a family gathering for me too once. People have strong opinions about UI without knowing the basics of how it's funded.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure