Back to New York Unemployment

Sarah Jones

Who is exempt from SUI in New York? NYSDOL rules explained

Been doing payroll for a small nonprofit for about two years now and this question keeps coming up whenever we bring on a new type of worker. We have a mix of full-time staff, part-time seasonal people, and some contractors, and I genuinely cannot figure out who is exempt from SUI contributions in New York. I called NYSDOL twice and got two different answers, which somehow made me more confused than before. I know there are categories around certain family members working for a business, some agricultural workers, church employees, and maybe certain corporate officers? But I keep second-guessing myself. Is there an actual clear list somewhere? And does being exempt from paying SUI mean those workers also can't collect unemployment if they lose the job? That part especially is tripping me up for our seasonal workers who we let go every fall.

Your seasonal workers question is actually the most important one here because that's where nonprofits get burned. Workers who are exempt from SUI coverage generally can't collect UI benefits either — the two things go together. If you're not paying into the system for them, they're not building eligibility. For the exemptions themselves, the main categories NYSDOL recognizes are: children under 21 working for a parent's sole proprietorship or partnership, spouses working for each other's sole proprietorship, parents employed by their child's sole proprietorship, certain corporate officers who own a substantial share of the company and choose to exclude themselves, some clergy and religious order workers, student workers in certain school settings, insurance agents paid purely on commission, and casual labor under a pretty low earnings threshold. Nonprofits have a separate track where you can elect to be a reimbursing employer rather than paying quarterly SUI taxes — but that's different from an exemption, your workers would still be covered.

0 coins

Our seasonal folks are definitely W-2 employees, not contractors, so it sounds like we should absolutely be paying SUI for them. The corporate officer exemption is interesting though — we have two board members who also do paid consulting work for us. Does that apply?

0 coins

Pretty sure the corporate officer thing only applies to for-profit corporations, not nonprofits. Your board members who also consult might just be regular employees for SUI purposes depending on how that relationship is structured.

0 coins

Watch out with the reimbursing employer election for nonprofits — it sounds great until you have a bad year and three people file claims at once. We switched back to the tax method after one rough quarter nearly wiped out our reserves.

0 coins

My whole understanding of this shifted when I hired my teenage kid to work summers in my landscaping business. Everyone told me I didn't have to pay SUI on those wages and I assumed it meant if something went wrong he just couldn't collect — but it turned out the exemption is narrower than I thought. The family member exemptions under New York Labor Law specifically cover children under 21 employed by a parent in a sole proprietorship or partnership, NOT an LLC or corporation. When I restructured to an LLC a few years back, that exemption stopped applying automatically. My accountant caught it, thankfully. The structure of your business entity matters as much as the relationship itself.

0 coins

That's a really useful distinction — we're a 501c3 so none of the family exemptions would apply to us anyway, but good to know for anyone reading this who has a family business.

0 coins

Wait, so if someone converts their sole prop to an LLC they lose the family member SUI exemption? That seems like something nobody warns you about when you form the LLC.

0 coins

Exactly what happened to me. The exemption language in the NY Labor Law ties specifically to sole proprietorships and partnerships. An LLC is treated differently even if one person owns 100% of it.

0 coins

My accountant told me the same thing last year when I was setting up my business. The entity type really does matter for more things than people realize.

0 coins

Bit of a detour but relevant — when I was trying to sort out our SUI obligations after getting audited by NYSDOL, I could not get anyone on the phone for weeks. Kept hitting the main line during peak hours and getting a busy signal or getting disconnected after 45 minutes. Someone in a different forum mentioned Claimyr (claimyr.com) — it's a service that waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up speaking directly with a live agent. There's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. I was skeptical but I ended up talking to an actual NYSDOL rep within a couple hours instead of spending another entire day redialing. For something like SUI classification questions where you really need a definitive answer, getting to an actual person makes a huge difference.

0 coins

Two failed phone attempts in is exactly where I am right now, so this is well-timed. I'll check out the video.

0 coins

Does it work for employer-side questions or just claimant stuff? I always assumed it was just for people filing claims.

0 coins

Employer account questions are what I used it for — the NYSDOL line handles both employer SUI and claimant inquiries through the same system, so yes it works for employer-side calls too.

0 coins

Had a similar situation last spring trying to reach someone about a UI rate notice that looked wrong. Ended up using Claimyr and finally got a live person who walked me through the whole rate calculation. Way less stressful than the phone marathon I'd been running.

0 coins

The agricultural exemption is one people get wrong constantly. There's a threshold — if you pay less than $20,000 in cash wages to farm workers in a calendar quarter AND employed fewer than 10 workers in any 20 weeks during the year, you might not be covered under the standard UI rules. BUT New York extended agricultural worker protections significantly in recent years, so this isn't a blanket 'farm workers are exempt' situation anymore. The rules got more complicated. If you're an agricultural employer in NY you really should not be relying on secondhand forum info for this — the state has specific guidance and the thresholds matter a lot.

0 coins

The 2019 Farm Laborers Fair Labor Practices Act changed a lot of this in New York specifically. NY is different from federal rules on agricultural workers in a bunch of ways now.

0 coins

Not in agriculture so this doesn't directly apply to us, but I appreciate the heads up — good reminder that NY state rules often diverge from federal.

0 coins

My family runs a small orchard and we've been trying to figure this out for two years. The threshold thing is real — we hover right around those numbers some years.

0 coins

One thing that tripped me up early on: being classified as an independent contractor does NOT automatically make someone SUI-exempt in New York. NYSDOL can reclassify workers as employees if they don't pass the right tests, and then you'd owe back SUI taxes plus penalties. I learned this when a former 1099 worker I'd paid filed for unemployment. NYSDOL investigated, determined he met the criteria to be treated as an employee, and I got a liability notice for unpaid SUI contributions going back almost two years. The classification has to actually hold up — it's not just about what you call someone on a form.

0 coins

This is probably the most practically important point in this whole thread. The 'just pay them 1099' approach to avoiding SUI is a ticking clock if the work relationship looks like employment.

0 coins

We've been careful about this — our contractors are genuinely independent, set their own hours, work for other clients, etc. But it's always worth double-checking, especially with NYSDOL's recent enforcement focus.

0 coins

NYSDOL uses a pretty strict ABC test framework. All three prongs of that test need to work in your favor for a 1099 classification to hold.

0 coins

Had this exact situation audited at a former job. The company lost on the 'B' prong because the contractor's work was central to our regular business operations. Cost them significantly in back assessments.

0 coins

Church employee exemptions are more specific than people assume — it's not just 'you work for a church, you're exempt.' Services performed for a church or church-controlled organization ARE generally exempt from SUI, but there are wrinkles depending on whether the organization qualifies under the IRS definitions, what type of work is being done, and whether the worker is ordained vs. lay staff. A church's daycare workers, for example, might be treated differently than its clergy. Worth getting a specific answer from NYSDOL rather than assuming.

0 coins

My wife works for a church-run school and we've never been totally sure whether she'd be eligible for UI if she were laid off. The exemption question is genuinely confusing for those situations.

0 coins

This is helpful context — we're not a religious organization but several of our volunteers have asked about their status and I want to make sure I'm giving accurate information when I point them elsewhere.

0 coins

Volunteers are a whole separate issue — unpaid volunteers aren't earning wages, so SUI doesn't apply to them at all. The exemption questions only come up for paid workers.

0 coins

Corporate officer elections to exclude from SUI coverage in New York require specific paperwork filed with NYSDOL — it's not automatic. Officers who own at least a certain percentage of the corporation can elect exclusion, but both the officer and the corporation have to affirmatively opt in and NYSDOL has to accept it. If you've been assuming corporate officers are excluded without filing anything, you might have an issue. The election also isn't retroactive, so there's no fixing past quarters where it wasn't filed.

0 coins

How many officers can be excluded under this — is there a cap on how many can elect out?

0 coins

New York allows up to two officers to exclude themselves under certain conditions, and both have to meet ownership and other criteria. It's worth looking at the actual NYSDOL employer handbook section on this because there are nuances around corporations with very few shareholders.

0 coins

The timing of filing the election matters too — there are specific enrollment windows and you can't just file whenever.

0 coins

Spent probably six hours over three separate days trying to get through to NYSDOL's employer line about exactly this kind of classification question. Total calls in that stretch: probably 30 or 40 redialing attempts. A colleague mentioned Claimyr and I tried it. Ended up talking to a live NYSDOL agent within the same day — she was able to look at our specific account and give us guidance on our officer exclusion election. Way better than the generic info you get from FAQs.

0 coins

Six hours is about where I'm heading if I try the phone route again on my own. Good to know there's a workaround.

0 coins

The employer line is genuinely brutal on Monday mornings especially. Anything that reduces the time you spend listening to hold music is worth knowing about.

0 coins

My office manager had the same experience last fall trying to sort out our quarterly SUI filing. She burned most of a Tuesday on the phone before finding a better way.

0 coins

Student FICA and SUI exemptions are related but not identical — sometimes people conflate them. Full-time students working for the school they're enrolled in can be exempt from SUI in New York under specific conditions. The exemption is narrow: it's about services performed by students in the employ of their school, not just 'this person is a student.' A college student working their on-campus dining hall job is in a different position than a student working at a local coffee shop. The school job may be exempt; the coffee shop job is not.

0 coins

My daughter works in her college's library and I always wondered if that counted as exempt. Sounds like it might depending on how the university classifies it.

0 coins

University employment offices usually know exactly how to classify this — your daughter could ask HR at the school directly. For federal purposes and for state SUI they may handle it differently.

0 coins

There's also a question of whether it's work-study funded vs. regular student employment, which can affect how the wages are reported and taxed.

0 coins

Real estate agents operating as independent contractors under a qualified real estate contract are another exempt category that comes up for people who broker-own small agencies. NY follows federal guidelines here — if the agent is licensed, paid on commission only (not salary), and has a written contract stating they're not employees, the SUI exemption can apply. The moment you start guaranteeing a draw against commission or treating them like W-2 employees in practice, that protection starts to get shaky.

0 coins

This was actually the scenario that made my broker partner file all our agents as 1099 from day one. The structure has to match the written agreement though — informal payment arrangements muddy the water.

0 coins

The 'in practice' part is what trips people up. Paying someone commission only on paper but then requiring them to show up every day, attend mandatory meetings, work set hours... that starts looking like employment to an auditor.

0 coins

Exactly — NYSDOL auditors look at economic reality and actual control, not just what the contract says.

0 coins

After spending way too long confused about SUI exemptions for my own LLC, I finally got clear answers by using Claimyr to reach a live NYSDOL agent. All the forums and FAQ pages I found gave me conflicting information, and the agent was able to look at the specific structure of my business and tell me definitively how my situation was classified. Sometimes the specifics of your situation just don't fit neatly into a list of exemption categories.

0 coins

That's honestly my situation — the mix of workers we have doesn't fit cleanly into any single FAQ answer, which is why the two phone calls I made gave me different information.

0 coins

I had the same problem trying to figure out if my part-time hire counted as a casual laborer under the threshold. No FAQ covered the exact dollar amounts and hours I had.

0 coins

Casual labor is an exemption people overlook — New York has a provision where certain incidental work falls below a threshold where SUI contributions aren't required. The threshold is pretty low though (something like under $500 in a calendar quarter with limited other conditions), so it really only applies to truly minor, one-off work. If you're regularly hiring the same casual worker, the casual labor exemption probably doesn't apply.

0 coins

The 'casual' part is key — NYSDOL looks at whether the work is occasional and incidental to your main business or a regular part of your operations. Hiring someone repeatedly to do work that's core to what you do isn't casual even if the pay is low.

0 coins

Worth noting that the dollar threshold for casual labor hasn't kept pace with actual wages — it's been pretty low for a long time, so in practice it rarely applies anymore unless it's truly minimal work.

0 coins

Yeah, the person I was paying $450 to help move equipment once qualified. The same person doing equipment work every month definitely would not.

0 coins

My HR background makes me want to flag one common misunderstanding: federal SUI exemptions and New York state SUI exemptions don't always match. Some categories exempt under FUTA are still covered under New York's unemployment insurance law, and vice versa. If you're using a federal resource to figure out your New York obligations you might be working from the wrong rulebook. Always check the NYSDOL employer handbook or the actual New York Labor Law, not federal guidance.

0 coins

This is an important point — the agricultural worker situation in NY is a good example, where NY law ended up providing broader coverage than the federal floor.

0 coins

This explains some of the confusion I've had — I was cross-referencing federal sources and NY state guidance and getting different answers. Makes sense now that they're genuinely different.

0 coins

New York has historically been more expansive in coverage than the federal minimum, which is why you'll sometimes find workers covered here who wouldn't be in other states.

0 coins

Leased employees and PEO arrangements add another wrinkle — if your workers are technically employed by a Professional Employer Organization that co-employs them, the SUI might be handled through the PEO's account rather than yours. This isn't an exemption exactly, but it changes who's responsible for the SUI contributions and filings. Some employers assume being on a PEO means they don't have to think about SUI at all, which can lead to coverage gaps if the PEO relationship ends.

0 coins

We used a PEO for two years and switching away from it was surprisingly complicated from a payroll tax perspective, including SUI. The transition period where both accounts might be active needs careful attention.

0 coins

Our PEO handles SUI and it's one of the main reasons we use them — the administrative burden reduction is real. But you're right that understanding whose responsibility it is matters.

0 coins

Domestic workers in New York are worth mentioning specifically — NY actually extended UI coverage to domestic workers in private homes several years back. If you're a household employer (nanny, housekeeper, etc.) and paying someone above a certain wage threshold, you're likely required to cover them for SUI. This is a category where a lot of household employers don't realize they have obligations.

0 coins

My neighbor just went through this when her nanny filed for UI after leaving. She had no idea she was supposed to be paying SUI as a household employer.

0 coins

New York's Domestic Workers Bill of Rights and subsequent legislation really changed the landscape for household employers. The obligations are real and NYSDOL does investigate when claims come in.

0 coins

The threshold to trigger household employer SUI obligations is wages paid of $500 or more in a calendar quarter to a domestic worker. Worth knowing even if you're not a business — plenty of families hit that threshold easily.

0 coins

Posting an update after getting through to NYSDOL finally — our seasonal W-2 employees are definitively covered and we're handling their SUI correctly. Our paid consultants who also sit on the board are classified as employees for the work they perform, not exempt as officers, since our nonprofit doesn't have a typical shareholder structure that would allow the officer election. The exemption categories are more situational than any single list makes them look. Thanks everyone for helping me think through this more clearly.

0 coins

Glad you got a definitive answer. The nonprofit/officer question trips up a lot of people because for-profit corporation rules get applied incorrectly to nonprofits.

0 coins

Glad Claimyr helped get you to an actual agent who could look at your account specifically. Generic answers to these questions only go so far.

0 coins

Your update is useful for anyone else running a nonprofit with similar staffing. The reimbursing employer election is worth revisiting during your next budget cycle — for a small nonprofit it can sometimes be more predictable than the quarterly tax approach.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure