Back to New York Unemployment

Emma Davis

What reasons can you quit a job and still get unemployment in NY?

I've been going back and forth on this for weeks and finally decided to post here because I genuinely can't figure out where I stand. I left my job at a distribution warehouse back in February — not because I wanted to, but because the situation there had become completely untenable. My supervisor had started scheduling me exclusively for overnight shifts after I told HR I had a medical issue that made those hours dangerous for me. I have documentation from my doctor, I submitted it through the proper channels, and nothing changed. So I quit. Now NYSDOL is telling me my claim is under adjudication and there's a note about a possible disqualification for voluntarily leaving. I had no idea that quitting for health reasons might not automatically qualify me. I'm trying to understand — what reasons can you quit a job and still get unemployment in NY? Are there specific situations where NYSDOL recognizes a quit as justified? Because I feel like being forced to work shifts your doctor says are medically harmful should count for something.

I went through something similar about eight months ago and spent two weeks trying to reach NYSDOL to explain my situation before my adjudication even got reviewed. The phone lines were impossible — I'd sit on hold for over an hour and then the line would just drop. Eventually someone in another forum told me about Claimyr (claimyr.com) — it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up talking directly to a live agent. There's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. I was skeptical but I ended up on the phone with an actual NYSDOL rep within the same day, and she walked me through exactly what documentation I needed for my medical quit claim. For your situation, being able to explain everything directly to an agent could make a real difference in how your adjudication goes.

0 coins

I hadn't heard of that before. The phone situation has been exactly as you described — I tried three mornings this week and got nowhere. Did they ask you to submit anything specific in writing or was the phone call enough to get things moving?

0 coins

The phone line dropping after an hour of hold is honestly the most infuriating part of this whole system. I've had it happen four times in one week before. Glad you found something that worked.

0 coins

I tried calling at 8am sharp when they open and still waited 90 minutes before giving up. The hold situation is genuinely broken right now.

0 coins

Your doctor's note situation is actually one of the clearer-cut cases when it comes to what NYSDOL recognizes as good cause for leaving. Here's the question you want to be ready to answer when they review your claim: did you give your employer a reasonable chance to fix the problem before you walked out? That's really the crux of it. The way NYSDOL looks at it, if you told HR, submitted documentation, and they still put you on those shifts, you can argue you exhausted your options inside the company first. The rule is basically that if continuing the job would have caused real harm to your health and you had a doctor backing that up and you gave the employer a shot to accommodate you, that's considered good cause. Keep everything — the original accommodation request, the HR acknowledgment, the schedule they gave you anyway, and the doctor's paperwork.

0 coins

That sequence of steps is actually what I did, in roughly that order. My concern is whether NYSDOL will treat a written HR submission the same as, say, a formal accommodation request under a specific policy. I didn't use the word 'accommodation' — I just gave them the note and asked to be kept off overnight shifts.

0 coins

The word 'accommodation' matters less than the paper trail showing you asked and they said no or just ignored you. What format did you submit the HR request in — email, paper form, something else?

0 coins

It was an email to my direct HR contact. I have the sent copy and I never got a response, which I think actually helps my case since it shows they didn't engage with it at all.

0 coins

No response from HR after a documented request is actually useful here. The silence can be framed as constructive denial. Make sure you print that email chain.

0 coins

There are a handful of situations NYSDOL tends to accept as good cause for quitting and I'll lay out the main ones because they come up constantly in these threads. Medical necessity where staying would genuinely harm you — that's yours. Unsafe working conditions the employer refused to fix after being told about them. Domestic violence situations where staying at the job created a safety risk. A significant cut to your pay or hours that you didn't agree to. Having to leave to care for a seriously ill immediate family member when no other care was available. Being asked to do something illegal. Relocating to follow a spouse or domestic partner who had to move for their job. The common thread across almost all of them is that you told the employer, gave them a reasonable window to fix it, and they didn't. NYSDOL calls this exhausting your alternatives before quitting.

0 coins

I've seen the domestic violence one trip people up because they don't realize they need documentation for it too — it's not just a self-reported thing. Is that right or has the process changed recently?

0 coins

You're right that documentation is typically expected, but NYSDOL does have some accommodation in how that documentation is provided for DV situations specifically — it doesn't have to be a police report. A statement from an advocate or shelter can work. But yes, something is usually required.

0 coins

The 'significant pay cut you didn't agree to' one is interesting — does a shift from full time to part time count as a substantial reduction even if the hourly rate stays the same?

0 coins

Losing hours involuntarily is generally treated as a reduction in compensation, yes. The key framing is whether the employer changed your original terms of employment without your agreement, not just whether the hourly number moved.

0 coins

What about toxic environment stuff — like a genuinely hostile coworker situation? I've heard people say harassment qualifies but I've also heard it gets denied constantly.

0 coins

Workplace harassment is one of the harder ones to get approved honestly. NYSDOL's standard is similar to the medical case — you need to show you reported it, the employer had an opportunity to address it, and they didn't. Where people run into trouble is when they just quit without documenting the harassment to management first. If you went to HR or a supervisor in writing about it and nothing happened, you're in a better position than if you walked out without that paper trail.

0 coins

That matches what I've read but it still feels like an unfair bar in situations where the harasser IS management. What's someone supposed to do when the person you'd report to is the problem?

0 coins

When the harasser is a supervisor, you're supposed to go above them — to HR, to their manager, or to whatever higher level exists. If the company has no meaningful mechanism to report upward, that itself can become part of the argument. It's not a perfect system but there's usually some path documented.

0 coins

I reported harassment to HR twice at my old job and both times they did literally nothing. When I finally quit they still contested my claim and I had to appeal. The appeal took three months but I did eventually win with the written HR complaints as evidence.

0 coins

My situation was the schedule change type — I'd been hired as a Monday through Friday daytime worker and three months in they switched me to a rotating weekend schedule with no extra pay. I asked the question you're supposed to ask yourself in this situation: would a reasonable person in my position have found those conditions intolerable enough to justify leaving? That's actually the standard NYSDOL uses. I went into my adjudication interview prepared to explain that I hadn't just quit on a whim, that the job had materially changed from what I was hired for, and my claim was approved. The interview was low-key, they asked straightforward questions, and having my offer letter showing the original schedule was what clinched it.

0 coins

How much notice did they give you ahead of your adjudication interview? And was it a phone interview or did you have to go somewhere?

0 coins

They mailed a letter about ten days before, and it was a phone interview. Mine lasted maybe twenty minutes. They want to hear your version of events in your own words, not just what your former employer says.

0 coins

The 'reasonable person' framing is useful — I'd never heard it put that way before. It reframes the whole thing from 'did you technically have a reason' to 'would anyone in your shoes have made the same call.

0 coins

I keep seeing people say you need to have 'tried to fix it first' before quitting but I want to push back a little — there are definitely situations where that's genuinely not possible. Like if staying even one more day creates a physical safety risk, NYSDOL isn't going to hold it against you that you didn't file a formal grievance before leaving. The 'exhaust your alternatives' requirement has exceptions built in when the situation is urgent.

0 coins

That's a fair point and worth clarifying. For immediate safety risks — a physically dangerous environment, being threatened, something like that — NYSDOL does recognize that waiting around to pursue internal remedies isn't always realistic. The documentation burden is higher afterward to prove urgency, but the requirement to try internal fixes first isn't absolute.

0 coins

Right, the trade-off is you end up having to work harder after the fact to demonstrate why you couldn't wait. It's not impossible but you have to be prepared to really explain the timeline.

0 coins

My brother had a situation where a machine at his job had a safety violation he'd flagged multiple times and the third time it almost hurt someone he left that day. OSHA complaint + his written reports to management + the incident report from the near-miss were what NYSDOL used to approve his claim.

0 coins

I want to get back to the original poster's specific situation for a second. The medical accommodation angle, combined with the fact that you have a written HR submission they never responded to, is actually a stronger setup than a lot of people walk into adjudication with. When I had my adjudication phone call, I used Claimyr to actually get an agent on the line beforehand so I could ask exactly what to emphasize. It helped me understand that NYSDOL's adjudicators are specifically looking for whether you gave the employer a genuine opportunity to correct things. You've done that. The silence from HR might read as the employer choosing not to engage with a known medical issue.

0 coins

Hearing that the HR silence might actually support my case rather than complicate it is reassuring. My worry was that the lack of a formal denial would make it look like things were still pending when I quit.

0 coins

The absence of a response after a reasonable amount of time can itself be treated as a constructive refusal. How long did you wait between submitting the note and quitting?

0 coins

About three weeks. During which time they scheduled me for two more overnight shifts that I had to call out of citing the medical issue, which is also documented in my attendance records.

0 coins

Three weeks of waiting plus two additional scheduling violations of the stated medical issue — that's a pretty solid documentation trail. I'd pull those attendance records before your interview.

0 coins

Three weeks and two schedule violations with no response from HR really does look like the employer ignored a known medical accommodation need. That's a meaningful pattern.

0 coins

For people reading this who are still figuring out whether their situation qualifies — the actual question you want to ask NYSDOL isn't just 'did I have a reason' but 'did I have a reason AND did I try to stay.' Those are two separate things and both matter. I've seen people get denied not because their underlying reason wasn't valid but because they quit the same day a problem happened, without giving the employer any chance to respond. The timing of when you quit relative to when you reported the issue is part of what gets evaluated.

0 coins

The timing angle is something I hadn't thought about. I quit the same day I found out my pay was being cut. No prior written complaint, nothing. I wonder if I should have sent an email first and then quit.

0 coins

If the pay cut notification and your resignation happened the same day, you're in a gray area. Some people argue that an involuntary pay change doesn't require prior reporting the way a harassment situation does, since the employer already knows about it. But it would have been cleaner with a written objection first.

0 coins

Pay cuts are a little different because the employer is the one who initiated the change — they can't claim they didn't know you objected if you resign in direct response to their announcement. The sequence of events is the evidence.

0 coins

I work with a tenants' rights organization and we sometimes help people with unemployment paperwork and I've noticed the biggest mistake people make in adjudication is treating it like a conversation rather than documentation exercise. Everything you say in that phone interview is going in a file. You want to come in with a clear narrative — here's what changed at my job, here's when I reported it, here's what happened next, here's why I left when I did. Don't go off-script about feelings or complain about the employer generally. Keep it factual and sequential.

0 coins

The 'factual and sequential' advice is so important. My adjudicator seemed to appreciate that I had specific dates rather than 'sometime in the fall' type answers.

0 coins

Preparing a clear written timeline before the interview sounds like something I should do regardless of anything else. Even just for my own clarity on the sequence.

0 coins

Exactly — write it out for yourself first. Date of employment, date of medical issue starting, date you gave HR the note, dates of subsequent overnight schedule assignments, date you resigned. When someone asks you a question you can answer it cleanly without having to remember details under pressure.

0 coins

My claim had an adjudication hold for almost six weeks because there was a discrepancy between what I reported and what my employer reported about the reason I left. I tried NYSDOL's phone line so many times I stopped counting. A friend told me about Claimyr and I finally got to speak with an actual agent who explained that my employer had filed a different separation reason than what I'd submitted. I would not have known that without getting a live person on the phone. If your adjudication seems like it's dragging without explanation, being able to actually speak with someone is the only way to find out what's really happening.

0 coins

The employer filing a different separation reason than you is incredibly common and nobody warns you it might happen. That alone can cause an adjudication that should take days to stretch into weeks.

0 coins

Exactly — and there's no notification that tells you that's the holdup. You're just sitting there watching weeks pass with no updates on your Unemployment Services portal.

0 coins

What did you do once you found out about the discrepancy? Did the agent tell you how to respond or did you have to do something else?

0 coins

The agent made a note of my account and told me an adjudicator would review both statements. I also submitted a written response through the portal with my documentation attached. The claim was approved about two weeks after that call.

0 coins

Employer separation reason filing is a whole thing that I think more people need to know about before they file. When you separate from a job, your employer has to file their version of why you left. If they say you were fired for misconduct and you say you quit for medical reasons, those two filings create a conflict that triggers adjudication. The adjudicator is basically refereeing between two competing accounts.

0 coins

My employer filed that I'd resigned 'without cause' even though I'd given them a written notice explaining the accommodation issue. They basically used my resignation letter against me by omitting the reason I gave.

0 coins

That's a frustrating and unfortunately common move — employer submits that you quit voluntarily without including your documented reason. That's why having your own copies of everything you gave them matters so much, so you can show the adjudicator the full picture they're missing.

0 coins

Can an employer legally omit your stated reason from their filing or is there some rule about them having to report accurately?

0 coins

Employers are required to give accurate information but there's no mechanism that checks their filing against your paperwork before it triggers adjudication. The adjudication process itself is where the accuracy gets sorted out.

0 coins

There's a timing thing that tripped me up that I want to flag for people reading. Even when you have a genuinely good reason to quit and your claim should be approved, you still have to keep filing your weekly certifications while adjudication is in progress. If you stop filing because you assume adjudication means your claim is paused, you can lose those weeks entirely even after you get approved. The certification keeps the weeks in the queue.

0 coins

I've been doing that — filing every Sunday even though I don't know if anything is processing. Good to know that's the right move.

0 coins

I didn't know this when I was going through it and I lost about three weeks of benefits because I stopped filing while I waited. When my claim was approved those weeks weren't recoverable.

0 coins

That gap in filings is one of the most common and painful mistakes. NYSDOL doesn't have a way to retroactively award weeks you didn't certify for in most cases.

0 coins

NYSDOL should honestly put this in the adjudication notification letter but they don't. The letter just says your claim is under review and says nothing about continuing to file.

0 coins

The appeal process is worth knowing about even if you're hoping adjudication goes your way. If your claim gets denied, you have thirty days from the date on the determination letter to file an appeal. The appeal goes to an Administrative Law Judge and it's a formal hearing — usually by phone — where both you and your employer can present evidence. A lot of people win at the appeal level who lost at adjudication, especially in medical or hostile environment cases where the documentation shows up more clearly under questioning.

0 coins

The thirty-day window moves fast. By the time you get the letter, read it, process that you've been denied, and figure out how to appeal, two weeks can be gone.

0 coins

True — I'd recommend setting a calendar reminder for the date on the letter the moment you open it. Missing the appeal deadline forfeits your right to challenge the denial at that level.

0 coins

I went through an appeal and I want to say the ALJ hearing was way less intimidating than I expected. It's structured but not like a courtroom — the judge walks you through what they need to understand about your situation.

0 coins

The job search requirement is something I want to bring up because a lot of people with approved 'good cause quit' claims get tripped up on this afterward. Even after your claim is approved, you're generally required to do three job search activities per week and log them. There are some exceptions — standby status, for example — but if your claim is a straight resignation with approved good cause, you'll still need to meet that requirement for each week you're certifying.

0 coins

I had no idea the job search requirement kicked in even after approval. I thought the approval was the end of the process.

0 coins

Approval means your claim is valid and you can receive benefits — but you have to keep earning them week by week by certifying that you were able and available to work and that you completed your job search activities.

0 coins

What counts as a job search activity? I've seen conflicting answers on this.

0 coins

NYSDOL accepts employer contacts, applying for jobs, attending a job fair, using the NY Career Center, registering with an employment agency, and a few other things. Each one counts as one activity and you need three per week. The activity has to be documented in your online job search log on the NYSDOL Unemployment Services portal.

0 coins

For anyone who gets to the ALJ appeal stage, I want to share something that helped me — Claimyr came up in my own research before my hearing and I ended up using it to speak with an NYSDOL agent who could tell me what the specific basis for my denial was. The determination letter uses generic language and knowing the actual factual finding the adjudicator made helped me prepare my appeal much more specifically. Going into that hearing knowing exactly what the adjudicator believed to be true versus what the evidence showed made the whole thing much more focused.

0 coins

Knowing the specific factual basis of your denial rather than just the generic 'voluntary quit without good cause' language sounds like a real advantage going into an appeal.

0 coins

It made a huge difference. The determination letter said I hadn't exhausted alternatives before quitting — but when I actually spoke to someone I found out the adjudicator hadn't seen my HR email at all because it hadn't been attached to the right submission. I resubmitted it with my appeal and that was essentially the whole case.

0 coins

The HR email not being attached is exactly the kind of administrative gap that changes outcomes. How did you even find out it wasn't in your file without talking to someone directly?

0 coins

I didn't — that's the point. The determination letter gave me no clue. It just said my claim was denied. Without getting an agent on the phone I would have written an appeal rebutting the wrong thing entirely.

0 coins

My cousin went through a UI claim after quitting because her commute changed dramatically — the company relocated their office about 40 miles further and effectively doubled her travel time. She was under the impression that commute-related quits automatically qualify, but her claim was initially denied. NYSDOL's view was that the commute, while longer, wasn't 'unreasonable' given the area's norms. She appealed and won, but the ALJ's reasoning was specifically that the relocation had been unilateral and undisclosed when she was hired.

0 coins

The commute thing depends heavily on how far is 'too far' and courts in NY have treated that inconsistently. The fact that it was unilateral and not disclosed upfront is usually what tips these cases.

0 coins

That was definitely what the ALJ focused on — not the mileage itself but whether she had agreed to that commute when she took the job. She hadn't.

0 coins

An employer physically relocating a job without prior notice really is changing your conditions of employment without consent, which is kind of a unifying theme across a lot of these approved quit categories.

0 coins

There's a misinformation thing I see come up a lot in these discussions — people assuming that if they gave two weeks notice when they quit, NYSDOL will automatically see them as having left voluntarily without good cause. That's not how it works. Notice is professional courtesy and it doesn't change the underlying reason you left. If your reason qualifies, giving notice doesn't disqualify you. If your reason doesn't qualify, notice doesn't help you either.

0 coins

I've seen people say the opposite — that giving notice somehow looks better for the UI claim. It doesn't seem to actually matter one way or the other?

0 coins

From what I've seen and experienced, the reason you left is what matters — not the form of your departure. Notice period is irrelevant to eligibility. What matters is the documented cause and whether you gave the employer a chance to address it.

0 coins

The only time notice really comes up in these cases is when an employer claims you abandoned the job versus resigned, and you have your resignation notice as proof that you actually did give formal notice. But that's about the nature of the separation, not whether your cause was good.

0 coins

I just want to add from personal experience that the adjudication interview itself is not adversarial even though it can feel that way. The adjudicator isn't trying to deny you — they're trying to gather enough information to make a determination. When I went into mine expecting a fight I actually came off worse than when I went in just telling my story clearly. Answer what they ask, don't volunteer complaints that aren't directly relevant, and if they ask something you're not sure about, say you're not certain rather than guessing.

0 coins

The 'answer what they ask' part is probably harder than it sounds when you're anxious and want to make sure they understand everything. I'd probably be tempted to over-explain.

0 coins

Over-explaining is exactly what I did in my first adjudication and I ended up confusing the timeline I was trying to lay out. In my second one — different job, later situation — I just answered the question and stopped. Much cleaner.

0 coins

Adjudicators have a lot of claims to get through. Clear and concise actually serves you better than exhaustive. They're asking because they need to fill in specific boxes, not because they want your full employment history.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure