Back to New York Unemployment

Isabella Costa

What are the reasons to not qualify for unemployment in NY? NYSDOL breakdown

My supervisor pulled me into a meeting two weeks ago and told me my position was being 'restructured' - basically I was let go but they're calling it a voluntary separation to avoid paperwork on their end. HR gave me a form to sign agreeing I resigned, and honestly I almost signed it without thinking. I didn't sign it, but now I'm terrified about what this means for my UI claim. I filed with NYSDOL last Thursday and I'm already second-guessing everything. I've been reading about all the different reasons to not qualify for unemployment and I can't figure out which category my situation falls into or if I even have a shot at benefits. My claim shows 'pending' but nothing else. Anyone been through something like this where your employer tried to frame a layoff as a resignation?

Claimyr worked for me when I was stuck in exactly this kind of limbo - couldn't get anyone at NYSDOL on the phone for two weeks straight, tried mornings, tried afternoons, nothing. What it does is wait on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up talking to a live agent there. Site is claimyr.com and there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE - in my situation I needed to explain to an agent that my employer had mislabeled my separation type, and once I actually got someone on the line they flagged it for review same day.

0 coins

My claim had the exact same mislabeling issue last spring and I could not get through on the phone for the life of me. Trying Claimyr now based on this.

0 coins

Two weeks of busy signals is genuinely maddening. Glad something worked for you.

0 coins

HR pulling that move - framing a layoff as a voluntary resignation - is actually pretty common and NYSDOL adjudicators see it constantly. The key thing in your favor is that you did NOT sign that form. Your refusal to sign is huge. When your claim goes through adjudication, the burden shifts to your employer to prove you quit voluntarily. If they can't produce a signed resignation, their case gets a lot weaker. Document everything right now: the date of that meeting, what your supervisor said word for word, any emails, any texts. If you have a written job description showing your role still exists under a different title, that's gold.

0 coins

Already writing up my notes from the meeting. My supervisor actually said the words 'we're eliminating this position' - does that phrasing help my case if it goes to adjudication?

0 coins

Yes that phrasing matters a lot. 'Eliminating the position' is not voluntary separation language, that's employer-initiated. Write it exactly as you remember it and date your notes today.

0 coins

Adjudicators at NYSDOL are specifically trained to look past the label an employer puts on a separation. The actual facts of what happened matter more than whatever box HR checked.

0 coins

Went through something almost identical at a marketing firm in 2023. They called it a 'mutual agreement to part ways' but I had emails showing they'd already posted my job under a different title before I even left. NYSDOL approved my claim after adjudication took about five weeks. The pending status you're seeing is normal at this stage - it just means no one has touched it yet.

0 coins

Five weeks is a long time to wait without income. Did they pay you back to your original filing date once approved?

0 coins

My payments did cover back to my original filing date yes, every week I'd certified showed up in a lump. Keep certifying every week even during adjudication.

0 coins

This is the part people mess up - they stop certifying because they think their claim is frozen. Keep certifying no matter what your status shows.

0 coins

ok so i thought if u quit for ANY reason u get nothing but my roommate quit bc his boss was making the workplace unsafe and he still got approved?? so im confused on the reasons to not qualify for unemployment - does quitting automatically mean denied

0 coins

Your roommate's situation actually falls under what's called 'good cause' for leaving - there are specific circumstances where quitting doesn't disqualify you. Unsafe working conditions is one of them. Basically NYSDOL recognizes that sometimes an employer makes it impossible to stay, so the law doesn't treat every quit the same way. But it has to be documented and provable, not just 'I didn't like the job.

0 coins

ohh ok that makes way more sense. so its not just did u quit yes or no, its more about WHY

0 coins

Exactly right. The 'why' behind a separation is what adjudication is designed to figure out.

0 coins

The list of reasons to not qualify for unemployment in NY is longer than most people expect when they first file. Getting fired for misconduct, quitting without good cause, not being available for work, refusing suitable work, failing to meet the job search requirements each week - any one of those can knock out your claim or pause it. In your specific case the employer is essentially trying to manufacture a 'quit without good cause' scenario by pressuring you to sign that resignation form. You sidestepped it by not signing, which puts you in a much stronger position going into adjudication.

0 coins

The job search requirements - those apply even while my claim is in adjudication? I wasn't sure if I needed to start logging job searches before the claim was actually decided.

0 coins

Your job search activity has to be logged starting from your first week of eligibility, adjudication status doesn't pause that requirement. Three job search activities per week is the current standard in NY unless you're on standby status, which you wouldn't be in this situation.

0 coins

Missed this my first time filing and it caused a whole separate issue. Three activities per week, keep records with dates and contact info.

0 coins

My old coworker got denied because NYSDOL said he 'voluntarily left without good cause' even though his hours had been cut from 40 to 12 per week. He appealed and won. A substantial reduction in hours can actually count as constructive discharge - meaning the employer effectively pushed you out even if they never said 'you're fired.' Not saying that's exactly your situation but it shows how the reasons to not qualify for unemployment aren't always as simple as people think when you fight back through the appeals process.

0 coins

Appeals are genuinely worth pursuing in cases like your coworker's. The hearing process gives you a real shot at presenting your side.

0 coins

How long did the appeal take for your coworker from filing to decision?

0 coins

His appeal hearing was scheduled about six weeks after he filed it, then the written decision arrived roughly three weeks after the hearing. So around two months total start to finish.

0 coins

NYSDOL DOESN'T CARE ABOUT ANY OF THIS. I had receipts, emails, witnesses, everything showing my employer lied on the separation paperwork and they still denied me twice. The system is designed to protect employers not workers. Spent four months fighting it.

0 coins

Four months of fighting is exhausting and I'm sorry that happened. Did you end up winning on the second appeal or did it go to the board of review?

0 coins

Board of review. Finally got approved at that level but by then I'd already borrowed money from my parents just to cover rent. The win felt hollow.

0 coins

The board of review level is where a lot of reversals actually happen - the problem is most people give up before getting there.

0 coins

My initial denial letter last year listed 'voluntary separation' as the reason even though I was escorted out by security with a box of my stuff. I know that sounds absurd but it happened. When I finally reached an agent at NYSDOL through Claimyr, the agent pulled up my file while I was on the phone and immediately saw the employer had checked the wrong separation code. Having that live conversation was the only thing that actually moved my case forward.

0 coins

Wait - employers can just check the wrong box and that determines your whole claim outcome? That seems like a massive flaw.

0 coins

Your employer submits their version of events and NYSDOL starts from there. If they put the wrong code or description, you have to actively correct it. That's why getting a live agent to look at your file matters.

0 coins

This is why I always say document your side independently and don't assume NYSDOL has accurate information from your employer.

0 coins

pending status for two weeks after filing is actually fast compared to what I dealt with. Mine sat at pending for six weeks before moving to adjudication and then adjudication took another month. The whole time I was certifying weekly and logging job searches like nothing was wrong. Try not to read too much into the status screen - it updates slowly and doesn't reflect actual work happening on your claim behind the scenes.

0 coins

Six weeks at pending before even reaching adjudication - that's brutal. How were you covering expenses during that time?

0 coins

Honestly not gracefully. Dipped into savings and asked my landlord for a short extension. When the back payments finally hit it was a relief but those weeks were rough.

0 coins

The lag between claim activity and status updates is real. I've seen statuses not change for weeks and then jump two stages at once.

0 coins

Misconduct is probably the most misunderstood of all the reasons to not qualify for unemployment in NY. A lot of people assume that getting fired for any reason means misconduct disqualification, but that's not how NYSDOL defines it. Poor job performance, making honest mistakes, being late occasionally - those generally don't meet the legal bar for misconduct. Misconduct in the UI context means intentional, willful behavior that violates a known workplace policy or harms the employer. So if someone gets fired for being bad at their job versus fired for intentionally stealing or violating a clear rule, those are very different outcomes for the claim.

0 coins

my friend got fired for 'performance issues' and was told he wouldn't get unemployment bc he was fired. is that actually true tho

0 coins

Your friend should absolutely file. Getting fired for performance doesn't automatically disqualify you - file first and let NYSDOL make the determination. Don't take the employer's word for it.

0 coins

Employers tell people this constantly and it's often wrong. File regardless of what HR says.

0 coins

something i never understood until it happened to me - being 'able and available' for work is an ongoing requirement not just something you prove once when you file. Had a week where I was caring for a sick family member and couldn't have accepted a job offer if one came. I didn't report it correctly and lost benefits for that week. The reasons to not qualify for unemployment aren't just about how you left your job, they can kick in week to week based on your situation.

0 coins

Able and available catches a lot of people off guard. Each week you certify you're essentially re-confirming you meet that standard. Travel, medical issues, family care - anything that would prevent you from accepting a job can affect that week's payment.

0 coins

Wish someone had explained it that way when I first filed. I thought 'available' just meant I was looking for work.

0 coins

Does this mean if I had a scheduled vacation coming up and I wasn't available those days, I'd have to report that?

0 coins

Refusing suitable work is another one that gets people. NYSDOL can offer you a job referral through the career center and if you turn it down without a valid reason that can disqualify you. The 'suitable' part does involve some judgment - a job paying dramatically less than your previous one or requiring a totally different skill set might not be considered suitable. But a lot of people don't know this rule exists until they're already in trouble.

0 coins

The career center requirements also include showing up for scheduled appointments. Missing those without a good reason is treated the same as refusing to participate in the job search process.

0 coins

Got flagged for missing a career center appointment I genuinely didn't know about. Had to explain the situation in writing before my payments resumed.

0 coins

After weeks of unanswered messages and busy phone signals, Claimyr finally got me to a live agent at NYSDOL. I'd been trying to ask a pretty specific question about whether a contract position I was considering would affect my benefits eligibility, and that's not something you can figure out from the website. The agent walked me through exactly what to report and when.

0 coins

Part-time and contract work while on UI is genuinely confusing to navigate. Good that you got a real answer directly.

0 coins

How complicated is it to report partial wages if you pick up some freelance work during a claim?

0 coins

Your weekly earnings get reported and NYSDOL calculates how much to reduce your benefit for that week. There's a formula involved but the agent explained it clearly - you don't necessarily lose all your benefits if you earn something, just a portion.

0 coins

Not meeting the base period earnings requirement is something people don't find out about until after they file. NYSDOL looks at wages earned in a specific period before your claim - if you haven't earned enough or worked enough weeks, the claim gets denied right at the start before adjudication even enters the picture. For anyone switching jobs frequently or coming off a long period of self-employment, this is worth checking before you even file so you understand what to expect.

0 coins

wait so u can get denied not bc of anything u did wrong but just bc u didnt earn enough? that seems unfair

0 coins

Technically the system is designed around wage-based contributions to the fund, so yes - lower earnings during the base period mean lower or no benefits. It's not a character judgment, it's math, but it definitely hits certain workers harder.

0 coins

There's also an alternate base period you can request if the standard one doesn't capture your actual work history. Worth asking about if your claim is denied for monetary eligibility reasons.

0 coins

The appeals timeline in NY is strict in a way that gets people caught off guard. From the date on your determination letter you have 30 days to file an appeal. Miss that window and you're essentially starting over or pursuing a much harder reconsideration process. I've seen people post here who didn't open their mail promptly and found out their window had closed. Whatever your determination says, read it the day it arrives.

0 coins

My claim is still pending so no determination yet, but I'm going to put a reminder on my calendar now to open and read any NYSDOL mail same day.

0 coins

Also check your Unemployment Services account online regularly - some notices appear there before the physical letter arrives, and the 30-day clock starts from the date on the notice, not the date you receive it.

0 coins

Had a situation where I was denied because NYSDOL said I was 'not actively seeking work' even though I had a job search log with 15 documented activities. The issue was my log didn't include employer contact information for three of the listings, which apparently made those entries invalid. When the adjudicator reviewed my log they only counted the entries with complete contact info. Lost benefits for two weeks before I could appeal and correct it.

0 coins

Every job search entry needs the employer name, contact information, position title, date, and method of contact. Missing any one of those fields can get the entry discounted. Keep your log detailed.

0 coins

Learned that the hard way. Now I keep a spreadsheet with a column for every required field.

0 coins

My career center counselor actually gave me a template for this. If you have an appointment coming up, ask them for the standard format NYSDOL expects.

0 coins

Going back to the original situation here - the employer trying to get you to sign a resignation form is essentially them trying to manufacture one of the clearest reasons to not qualify for unemployment: voluntary separation without good cause. The fact that you held firm and didn't sign puts the burden squarely on them to prove you chose to leave. In adjudication, your employer will get a questionnaire to fill out. What they write there will either support or contradict what you've told NYSDOL. If they write 'employee voluntarily resigned' and you have no signed resignation form and have testimony that they said your position was eliminated, that contradiction works in your favor.

0 coins

Should I proactively send NYSDOL my written notes from the meeting before they even ask, or wait until they request information from me?

0 coins

Proactively submitting documentation is generally a good move - it creates a record and shows you're engaged with the process. Send it through your Unemployment Services account message portal and reference your claim number so it gets attached to the right file.

0 coins

Agreed - I sent in my supporting documents before adjudication even started and the adjudicator mentioned them in my determination letter, which showed they were actually reviewed.

0 coins

My neighbor mentioned Claimyr after I'd spent three days trying to get through to NYSDOL about a question on my claim. Tried it and ended up talking to an agent the same day. Useful when you need a real answer fast rather than waiting to see if the website updates.

0 coins

Three days of trying is about where my patience runs out too. Good to hear it worked for a specific question situation, not just for major claim issues.

0 coins

Phone access to NYSDOL is kind of underrated for smaller questions like that - stuff the website and FAQ just doesn't cover.

0 coins

NOBODY TELLS YOU that even if you win adjudication you might face a whole new issue if your employer appeals the decision. They have the same 30 day window you do. Had mine approved after five weeks of adjudication then got a letter saying employer was appealing. Had to go through a full hearing after that. The employer can drag this out way longer than you expect.

0 coins

Employer appeals do happen, especially in higher-wage claims where the employer's unemployment insurance experience rating takes a bigger hit. It's worth being prepared with documentation even after an initial approval.

0 coins

My hearing actually went fine because I had everything documented. But the stress of waiting for it after already thinking I'd won was rough.

0 coins

Okay this is something I hadn't even considered. So even after approval there's still potential for more process?

0 coins

Three weeks into my own adjudication period I got a request for additional information from NYSDOL asking me to explain why I left my previous employer. The letter had a deadline to respond - I think it was 10 days. I almost missed it because it went to spam. Check your email and your Unemployment Services account messages constantly during adjudication, not just when you think something should be happening.

0 coins

Missed information requests are one of the biggest reasons adjudication ends in denial without the person even realizing there was something they could have addressed. Set up email notifications in your account settings.

0 coins

Responded to mine within two days and my claim moved to a decision within a week after that. Response time seemed to matter.

0 coins

The deadline on those requests is real and they will make a decision based on available information if you don't respond in time, which usually means deciding in the employer's favor by default.

0 coins

My case worker at the career center told me something that clarified a lot of confusion I had - the reasons to not qualify for unemployment fall into two different buckets. Some are about how you left your job, which get decided at the start through adjudication. Others are ongoing conditions you have to keep meeting every week while you're collecting. People mix these up and think once they're approved they don't have to worry about disqualification anymore, but that's not how it works.

0 coins

That's a really useful way to frame it. So approval isn't a one-time gate, it's more like a continuing status you have to maintain week to week?

0 coins

Exactly how the case worker put it. Your weekly certification is essentially you re-confirming you still meet all the ongoing conditions.

0 coins

This took me two full months of collecting to really understand. Wish someone had explained the two-bucket thing to me up front.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure