Back to New York Unemployment

Javier Torres

Unemployment car dealership job - NYSDOL claim questions

My situation is a little specific so bear with me. Worked at a car dealership for about 2 years as a finance and insurance manager - decent pay, commission-heavy structure, and then the owner sold the business to a larger regional group back in January. The new ownership came in and completely restructured the sales floor. They kept me on for about six weeks during the transition but then eliminated my position entirely in mid-February, said the incoming group had their own F&I team from another location. So I filed with NYSDOL pretty quickly after that. My weekly benefit rate got calculated weird though - it shows a much lower amount than I expected given what I was earning. I know the base period calculation can get complicated when your income is partly commission-based, but mine is showing only $412/week when I was pulling in roughly $5,800/month on average across my base period quarters. I've been trying to get someone at NYSDOL on the phone to explain how they arrived at that number because the math just doesn't track for me. Has anyone dealt with this when commission income is involved? Or had their benefit rate recalculated after questioning it? I want to understand if I even have grounds to dispute this before I go further.

Your $412/week rate against $5,800/month average earnings does look low. NYSDOL uses your highest-earning quarter from the base period to set your weekly benefit amount - they take that quarter's wages, multiply by a set fraction, and that becomes your WBA. With commission work, if one quarter was way higher than others, the averaging can hurt you, but if your highest single quarter was around $6,000-$7,000 or more in total wages, your WBA should be considerably above $412. You can see the quarterly breakdown they used by checking your Monetary Determination letter in your Unemployment Services account - it'll show exactly which four quarters they counted and what wages they credited for each.

0 coins

My Monetary Determination is definitely showing one of my quarters much lower than I expected - like $9,200 for Q3 when I know I earned closer to $14,000 that quarter because of a big floor bonus. The employer might not have reported it correctly, or it got split somehow.

0 coins

That gap between what you earned and what NYSDOL has on record is worth pursuing. If the dealership reported your wages wrong - like splitting a bonus into a different quarter than when you received it - you can request a wage investigation and ask NYSDOL to contact your former employer to verify the correct amounts. Had a similar thing happen with tip income at a restaurant job, and the wage investigation actually bumped my WBA up.

0 coins

The commission thing at dealerships is brutal for unemployment calculations. I was a salesperson at a Chevy store for three years and when I filed, two of my base period quarters showed almost nothing because the manufacturer holdbacks and spiffs got reported on a different schedule than my regular draw. NYSDOL had no idea how to handle it and just used what the employer submitted. Took me forever to even get someone to explain what had happened.

0 coins

That's exactly my fear - that the numbers NYSDOL has just reflect whatever the dealership submitted and nobody checked whether it matched reality. What ended up happening with your claim?

0 coins

Mine dragged on for weeks. The employer wasn't being malicious, it was just the way their payroll system batched certain pay types. Eventually got it sorted but it required documentation from me showing the actual pay dates on my stubs.

0 coins

Dealership payroll is notoriously messy for UI purposes. Draws against commission, charge-backs, bonus pools - the way it hits W-2 boxes doesn't always reflect when you actually received it.

0 coins

Months of trying to get NYSDOL on the phone about my own wage dispute and I finally had a real conversation with an agent after using Claimyr - it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up talking directly to a live agent instead of spending your morning hitting redial. I'd been getting dropped after 45-minute holds for weeks before that. Check claimyr.com if you want to see how it works, there's also a video at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. For a commission income issue like yours where you need someone to actually pull up your wage records and walk through them with you, talking to an agent is really the only path forward.

0 coins

45-minute holds and then getting dropped is basically my entire experience the last two weeks. I'll check that out - at this point I just need someone who can actually see my file.

0 coins

The hold situation at NYSDOL this year has been genuinely terrible, especially for anything that isn't a simple status check. Wage dispute stuff really does need a human on the line.

0 coins

Tried calling first thing in the morning three days in a row and still couldn't get through. Eventually mailed a written inquiry but that's been sitting unanswered for two weeks now.

0 coins

Your base period for a claim filed in February 2025 would cover October 2023 through September 2024 - four calendar quarters. If you had a strong Q3 2024 (July-September) that might actually fall outside your base period entirely since it closes in September and your claim opened in February. Worth checking whether a high-earning quarter got excluded because of timing.

0 coins

Wait - so if I had a really good September 2024, that entire quarter might be in an alternate base period instead?

0 coins

Your September 2024 wages would be in Q3 2024, which IS in the standard base period for a February 2025 claim (October 2023 - September 2024). What would be excluded is October-December 2024 and January 2025. So if your big commission months were in that final stretch before the layoff, those wages wouldn't count under the standard base period. You could potentially file under the alternate base period which uses the four most recently completed quarters.

0 coins

The alternate base period option is real and underused. If the standard base period misses your highest earnings, ask NYSDOL to calculate your WBA under the alternate base period - they're supposed to use whichever gives you the higher benefit rate.

0 coins

WAIT does NYSDOL actually automatically check both base periods or do you have to ASK them to run the alternate calculation?? Because I just accepted whatever rate they gave me and now I'm wondering if I left money on the table

0 coins

You generally have to request it - NYSDOL defaults to the standard base period. If you think your alternate base period earnings would produce a higher WBA, you need to contact them and ask specifically for an alternate base period calculation. There are some time limits on this so don't sit on it.

0 coins

Oh no. I accepted my rate like two months ago without questioning it. Is it too late for me??

0 coins

Your claim being two months old doesn't necessarily close the door. File the request and explain you weren't aware of the alternate base period option. Worst they say is no, and you're no worse off than you are now.

0 coins

Fourteen months working service drive at a dealership and when they cut the whole service department I filed and ran into the commission problem too. Mine was a flat-rate technician situation so the weekly hours fluctuated wildly and so did my pay. The NYSDOL rep I eventually reached said the wage investigation form is what triggers them to go back to the employer for corrected wage records. It's Form IA 11.3 or something in that range - honestly the form number might be slightly off but the wage investigation request is the right process.

0 coins

A formal wage investigation form - that's more structured than I expected. I thought it would be more like 'call and complain and hope.

0 coins

Ha, I mean it sort of still is that, but having the formal process behind you helps. The employer has to respond to NYSDOL's inquiry or risk penalties. If your dealership just mis-coded your compensation type it may be an easy fix.

0 coins

That form reference is useful. I've been going in circles on a similar issue and didn't know there was a specific process rather than just calling and explaining everything from scratch every time you reach a different rep.

0 coins

My brother-in-law had a wage dispute on his claim from a trucking company - similar deal with variable pay - and after weeks of nowhere he used Claimyr to get through to NYSDOL and the agent he reached actually initiated the wage review right there on the call. Took maybe 20 minutes once he had someone on the line versus months of trying on his own.

0 coins

20 minutes to initiate the wage review once he had an agent - that's what I need. The documentation I have is solid, I just can't get anyone to look at it.

0 coins

That's the whole thing - the information isn't the problem, access to a person who can do something with it is the problem. These disputes don't resolve themselves through the portal.

0 coins

Same experience here. The online tools are fine for basic claim stuff but the moment something is complicated - commission income, wage discrepancies, anything involving the employer's reporting - you need an actual agent.

0 coins

NYSDOL's phone system is honestly just broken for complicated cases. I've been in automotive too (parts manager, 4 years at an import dealer) and when my store closed I had three separate issues with my claim - the commission calculation, a severance offset question, and an adjudication flag that appeared out of nowhere. Getting those resolved through the website was impossible. The agents vary a lot in how much they actually know but at least when you reach one they can see your file and move things forward.

0 coins

Three issues at once sounds like a nightmare. Did the severance affect your benefit amount significantly?

0 coins

Your severance timing matters a lot - if it was paid as a lump sum rather than salary continuation, NYSDOL may not have allocated it against your benefits the same way. Mine was salary continuation so it delayed my effective claim date by several weeks. The agent explained it clearly once I had one on the phone.

0 coins

I didn't know severance could delay the whole claim start date, I thought it just reduced weekly amounts. This is why talking to someone actually knowledgeable matters.

0 coins

Used Claimyr for a completely different reason - my claim had been sitting in adjudication for five weeks with no explanation - but same idea, couldn't get anyone to pick up. Once I actually had an agent on the line they told me there was an employer response pending that nobody had followed up on. The whole thing was resolved in another week after that call. For your wage rate question, an agent can pull the base period wages they calculated from and you can compare them line by line against your pay stubs.

0 coins

Five weeks in adjudication because of an employer response nobody chased - that's infuriating. At least it got fixed once you had someone looking at it.

0 coins

Adjudication delays from pending employer responses are super common and almost never get resolved without someone physically touching the file. The system doesn't automatically escalate them.

0 coins

Does NYSDOL ever notify you when something like a pending employer response is holding up your claim, or do you just sit there wondering??

0 coins

My account showed adjudication in progress the entire five weeks with zero additional detail. No notification, no explanation, nothing. Only found out what was happening when I spoke to an agent.

0 coins

Your Q3 wage discrepancy - $9,200 showing vs $14,000 you actually received - is a $4,800 difference in just one quarter. Even if that's the only quarter with a problem, fixing it could move your WBA significantly. The formula NYSDOL uses takes your highest base period quarter and divides by 26. So if that quarter should be $14,000 instead of $9,200, your WBA could jump from around $354 to $538 (before the weekly max kicks in). The state maximum WBA right now is $535/week so you'd basically be hitting the cap.

0 coins

If that math is right then fixing just that one quarter takes me from $412 to basically the maximum. That's a meaningful difference over months of benefits.

0 coins

Worth every bit of effort to pursue. Get your pay stubs or any employer documentation showing what you actually received in that quarter and have it ready when you reach an agent.

0 coins

The $535 current weekly max figure sounds right for 2025. And yeah the formula is roughly highest quarter divided by 26, though there are some minor adjustments depending on dependents - claimants with dependents can receive slightly higher amounts under New York's dependency allowance.

0 coins

am i reading this right that he might be getting $120+ less per week than hes supposed to because of a payroll reporting error at the dealer?? thats insane over a few months that's thousands of dollars

0 coins

That's exactly what I'm looking at, yes. And the frustrating part is that if I hadn't thought to look at the quarterly breakdown I might not have even noticed - I would have just accepted the $412 and moved on.

0 coins

the system really does count on people not digging into the details

0 coins

It's not entirely intentional design - the base period calculation is genuinely complex and even employers often don't realize their payroll reporting creates these gaps. But the result is the same: claimant gets less than they're owed.

0 coins

Your situation also raises the question of whether the new ownership's elimination of your position counts cleanly as a layoff in NYSDOL's view. When a business is sold and positions are restructured, NYSDOL sometimes treats it differently depending on whether the new owner offered you comparable work or whether there was a true break in employment. If the new group offered you a sales floor role at lower pay and you declined, that could complicate your eligibility even if the layoff feels straightforward to you.

0 coins

They didn't offer me any alternative role - the new ownership just said the F&I position was being eliminated and there was nothing else for me. My separation paperwork says 'position eliminated - business restructuring.' Does that phrase on the paperwork matter?

0 coins

That language on your paperwork is actually helpful. 'Position eliminated' is unambiguous and much cleaner than 'resigned' or 'mutual agreement.' As long as the former employer doesn't file a protest claiming otherwise, that classification should support straightforward layoff eligibility.

0 coins

Business sale situations can get complicated if the acquiring company contests the layoff characterization. The key factor is whether there was genuine continuity of employment offered - no offer at all is the clearest case in the claimant's favor.

0 coins

i worked at a ford dealership for six years and when they sold it was a whole mess. new owners offered some people jobs with worse benefits and people who didn't take those offers had a hard time with unemployment because nysdol said they refused suitable work. glad your situation sounds different

0 coins

The 'refused suitable work' issue is one I hadn't thought about but I see why it would be a problem - if they'd offered me any role and I turned it down it would look like I quit.

0 coins

yeah exactly. my buddy took the offer and i didn't and i had to fight for my benefits for months while he just moved on. the job they offered me was 40% less pay though so I argued it wasn't suitable and eventually won but it took forever.

0 coins

Suitable' work in New York has some definition to it - the offered position needs to be reasonably comparable in wages, hours, and conditions to what you had. A 40% pay cut is a strong argument that it'wasn tsuitable.

0 coins

Following the wage investigation angle closely. I have a similar issue from a construction company where my prevailing wage and regular wage kept getting lumped together wrong in their reporting. Have been meaning to push on this for weeks.

0 coins

Your construction situation with prevailing wage is actually a different layer of complexity - how prevailing wage supplemental benefits get counted for UI purposes varies. Worth getting that specific question in front of a NYSDOL rep who handles wage matters rather than a general claims rep.

0 coins

Is there a way to request specifically a rep who handles wage issues rather than just whoever answers?

0 coins

Not really - you generally get whoever picks up. But you can ask the rep who answers to transfer you to the wage unit or the monetary unit. Some reps will do it, others won't. Getting through at all is the first hurdle.

0 coins

The employer reporting issue is real and way more common than people think. I did payroll for a dealership group (three locations) for two years and the way commission, draw, chargeback, and spiff income gets categorized across different pay periods is genuinely chaotic. Lots of well-meaning payroll departments are still doing it wrong for UI purposes and they don't know it until NYSDOL sends a wage inquiry.

0 coins

Coming from someone who actually did that payroll work, that's both validating and kind of alarming. If even the people running payroll aren't sure how it should flow into UI-reportable wages, what chance does a claimant have of catching the error?

0 coins

Honestly that's why the wage investigation process exists. NYSDOL can send the employer a formal inquiry with a deadline and that tends to focus minds in the payroll department in a way that the claimant calling to complain doesn't.

0 coins

This whole discussion makes me want to go check my own base period wages against what I actually earned. Never occurred to me to verify that the employer reported correctly.

0 coins

Three weeks into my claim and stumbled onto this thread while trying to understand my own WBA. Mine's from an auto finance company (not a dealership but adjacent industry) and I had the same gut feeling that the number looked wrong. After reading through here I pulled my Monetary Determination and yes - one full quarter of my wages is about $6,000 lower than my records show. I didn't even know I could dispute it until this thread.

0 coins

Three weeks in and you caught it already - that's actually the right time to push on it since you have months of benefit payments ahead where the difference adds up.

0 coins

Your discovery is exactly why people need to actually read the Monetary Determination letter instead of just accepting the WBA number. The quarterly breakdown is all there, you just have to compare it to your records.

0 coins

Mine went straight to the pile of NYSDOL mail I hadn't fully processed. Lesson learned. Going to call tomorrow morning - or try Claimyr if the lines are impossible.

0 coins

submitted a wage inquiry online through the portal about six weeks ago and got a form acknowledgment and nothing since. is there actually a way to check on the status of that or is it just a black hole

0 coins

Your online wage inquiry status isn't visible in the portal in real time - you typically have to call to get an update on where it stands in the process. Standard processing is supposed to be a few weeks but it often runs longer.

0 coins

So I've been waiting six weeks on something that should have been a few weeks and my only option to check is to try to get someone on the phone. Great.

0 coins

Unfortunately that's accurate. The online systems are good for filing and weekly certifications but they're not built for status tracking on wage disputes or investigations. Phone access is really the only way to get a real update.

0 coins

My wife went through something similar when she was laid off from a leasing company - not a dealership but same kind of fluctuating compensation. The thing that finally moved her case was getting a letter from the former employer's HR department confirming the correct quarterly wages. NYSDOL accepted that and updated her benefit rate without needing the full formal investigation process.

0 coins

HR letter confirming wages is a good idea - easier to get than waiting for NYSDOL to run the investigation, and might be faster if the employer is cooperative.

0 coins

Her former employer was actually pretty cooperative about it once she explained what NYSDOL had on file versus what her pay stubs showed. They seemed embarrassed about the payroll error and wanted to fix it.

0 coins

Employer cooperation makes a huge difference. When they push back or ignore NYSDOL's inquiry is when things drag on for months.

0 coins

What documentation is everyone using to prove earnings in a commission situation? Pay stubs show gross commission earned but sometimes the check dates don't match when the sales actually happened, which is what creates the quarter assignment problem in the first place.

0 coins

Your W-2 is what NYSDOL officially goes by for wage reporting, but the per-quarter breakdown on pay stubs showing payment dates is what matters for a wage investigation. Even if the commission was earned in one quarter and paid in the next, what counts for UI purposes is when it was paid and recorded as income.

0 coins

This is exactly the nuance that trips up dealership payroll. Manufacturer incentive payments especially often get paid 60-90 days after the qualifying sales period, so a December performance bonus hits in February and suddenly it's in a completely different base period quarter.

0 coins

So if my big monthly bonuses always hit the first week of the following month, they'd all be recorded in the quarter after they were actually earned. No wonder my numbers looked weird.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure