Starting an LLC while on unemployment - will NYSDOL cut off my benefits?
So I've been collecting unemployment for about six weeks now after getting laid off from my project management job in the construction industry. While I've been job searching, I've also been thinking about finally launching the consulting side business I've had on the back burner forever. A friend suggested I go ahead and form an LLC now while I have the downtime. Here's what's freaking me out though - I have no idea what NYSDOL's rules are around this. Like does simply registering an LLC automatically disqualify me from benefits? Or is it only if I actually start earning money through it? My weekly UI payment is the only thing keeping me afloat right now and I don't want to accidentally trigger a disqualification or end up with an overpayment notice six months from now. I've been trying to find clear answers on NYSDOL's website but the language is really vague. And I've been certifying my weekly claims reporting zero hours worked and zero earnings, which is accurate because I haven't actually done any paid work yet - just some planning and research. Am I reporting correctly? Should I be disclosing the LLC formation itself even before I earn anything? Really stressed about this.
81 comments

Taylor Chen
My situation was almost identical to yours a while back - had an LLC I was setting up during a period I was drawing UI benefits and absolutely could not get anyone at NYSDOL on the phone to get a straight answer. After burning through so many mornings on hold just to get disconnected, I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) - it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up speaking directly with a live agent. There's a video at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE that shows how it works. I finally got to talk to an actual NYSDOL rep who walked me through exactly what I needed to report. Seriously saved me from just guessing at the rules.
0 coins
Keith Davidson
How long did it take before you got to talk to someone? I've been trying to reach NYSDOL about a totally different issue for two weeks and every time I call I either get a busy signal or sit on hold for 90 minutes then the line drops.
0 coins
Taylor Chen
My wait on NYSDOL's end was pretty long but I didn't have to sit there listening to hold music - that's the whole point. When I eventually got the agent it was maybe a combined hour total but I wasn't glued to the phone the entire time. Worth it to actually get someone.
0 coins
Ezra Bates
Came here to say this exact kind of thing. Getting NYSDOL on the phone when you have a nuanced question like this is nearly impossible without some help. The agents who answer DO know the rules, they just don't publish them in plain English anywhere.
0 coins
Ana Erdoğan
The LLC registration itself is what tripped me up when I went through this. I formed an LLC in December during my claim period thinking the same thing - no income yet, so no problem. The issue NYSDOL cares about is whether you're 'self-employed' and whether you're doing work for that business. The way the rule actually plays out: forming the LLC is a business activity. If you spent hours that week doing work related to your business - setting up contracts, reaching out to clients, writing proposals - NYSDOL generally considers those hours worked even if you got paid zero dollars. You're supposed to report hours spent on business activities on your weekly certification, not just paid hours. The zero earnings piece is separate from the hours piece. You can have zero earnings but still have hours to report if you were actively working on the business.
0 coins
Avery Saint
AuthorWait, so even unpaid hours planning the business count as hours worked for weekly certification purposes? That's not at all how I interpreted the form. I thought 'work' meant paid employment.
0 coins
Ana Erdoğan
Yeah, the certification question asks about work performed, not just wages received. If you're doing activities that would normally be compensated - client outreach, actual consulting work, drafting service agreements - those hours count. Pure research or general reading probably doesn't. It's a gray area NYSDOL agents sometimes interpret differently, which is exactly why getting an actual human at NYSDOL to clarify your specific situation is worth the effort.
0 coins
Sophia Carson
This is the nuance that gets people into trouble. I had a friend who started doing freelance graphic design during her UI claim, didn't report the hours because she wasn't paid yet, and ended up with an overpayment determination months later when NYSDOL audited her claim. The dollar amounts they wanted back were brutal.
0 coins
Elijah Knight
I went through this exact thing in 2024. Here's what the NYSDOL agent told me when I finally reached one: the state distinguishes between being self-employed and operating an active business. Having an LLC formed does not by itself mean you're disqualified - what matters is whether you're doing substantial work and especially whether you have any self-employment income. If your LLC is dormant - no clients, no contracts signed, no money coming in - you're in a gray zone. But the moment you start taking on actual consulting work, even if payment is deferred, you need to report it. The rule as I understand it from that conversation: hours of business activity go on your weekly cert, and any income needs to be reported in the week it's earned, not the week it's paid.
0 coins
Avery Saint
AuthorThe 'week it's earned, not when it's paid' part is new information for me. So if I do a consulting project in week 10 but invoice and get paid in week 14, I report that income in week 10 on my certification?
0 coins
Elijah Knight
That's how the agent explained it to me - when you performed the work, that's the week you report the earnings. It's meant to prevent people from strategically deferring payment to avoid affecting their UI weeks. Talk to NYSDOL directly though because honestly every situation has different wrinkles.
0 coins
Brooklyn Foley
The earned vs. paid distinction is one that burns a LOT of self-employed people. The weekly cert asks about earnings in the week being claimed, and NYSDOL interprets that as when the work happened. I've seen people on this forum get overpayment notices because they reported on the payment date rather than the work date.
0 coins
Jay Lincoln
Does this mean you lose the whole week's UI if you do even one hour of consulting work in that week? Or does it reduce based on what you earned?
0 coins
Jessica Suarez
I actually called NYSDOL about this a few months ago and the agent was really helpful. She said that in New York, self-employment while on UI is a complicated area and the outcome often depends on how much you're working and earning. She mentioned the 'less than four days worked and less than $504 earned in a week' threshold being relevant but cautioned me that self-employment gets calculated differently than regular employment wages in some situations. She specifically said forming an LLC doesn't trigger disqualification but actively soliciting clients, performing work, or generating revenue changes the analysis. I'd really recommend calling NYSDOL to get this clarified for your specific situation rather than relying on secondhand accounts here.
0 coins
Marcus Williams
The $504 and four day thresholds exist for traditional part-time work but self-employment income often gets treated differently in my experience. NYSDOL sometimes looks at net income after expenses which can complicate things further.
0 coins
Jessica Suarez
You're right that the self-employment calculation can differ - the agent I spoke to mentioned deducting business expenses before the income affects your benefit amount, but said the specifics vary. That's why I keep saying get it from an agent directly because these edge cases aren't handled uniformly.
0 coins
Lily Young
My experience with NYSDOL on self-employment questions is that you can sometimes get three different answers from three different agents. The underlying rule is consistent but interpretation varies. Document every conversation - date, time, what was said - in case you ever need to dispute a determination.
0 coins
Kennedy Morrison
ok so i set up an llc while getting unemployment two years ago and nothing happened to me. I didn't report it and never had any issues. I think people are overcomplicating this.
0 coins
Ana Erdoğan
The fact that nothing happened to you doesn't mean it was correct - NYSDOL audits can come a year or more later, and overpayment determinations carry interest. Getting lucky isn't the same as the rules not applying.
0 coins
Kennedy Morrison
fair point i guess. I just never heard anything so assumed it was fine
0 coins
Sophia Carson
NYSDOL cross-references tax records eventually. If that LLC filed taxes showing income in a year you were on UI, that's how audits get triggered. Two years later is not outside the window unfortunately.
0 coins
Wesley Hallow
My cousin went through something kind of similar and what I remember her saying was that NYSDOL's main concern is whether you're 'available for full-time work.' If your LLC business would prevent you from accepting a full-time job offer if one came through, that's a separate disqualification issue - the able and available requirement. So even setting aside the earnings piece, if you're running a business that occupies your weekday hours, that could affect your eligibility on the availability front.
0 coins
Avery Saint
AuthorThe availability piece hadn't even occurred to me honestly. I've been making sure to apply to full-time jobs every week for my job search record, but I hadn't thought about whether the LLC business activity would be seen as limiting my availability.
0 coins
Wesley Hallow
My cousin said the agent told her that as long as you'd genuinely accept a suitable job offer if one came through, the availability requirement is usually satisfied. It's when the business becomes your primary occupation and you'd turn down employment to keep running it that it becomes a problem.
0 coins
Keith Davidson
The availability requirement and the earnings reporting are two separate things and both matter. You can be available for work and still mess up your claim by not properly reporting LLC income. Keep them straight in your head.
0 coins
Justin Chang
Tried to muddle through this whole situation on my own last year and ended up in adjudication because I misreported some consulting hours. The adjudication process is brutal - you're in limbo for weeks not knowing if you're approved or disqualified, and payments stop while they investigate. What eventually got me sorted was using Claimyr to reach an agent who could look at my account in real time. The agent saw that my adjudication issue was about how I'd reported self-employment hours versus income and was able to flag it for the right department. Having that specific conversation with a live person made a huge difference versus just waiting and hoping.
0 coins
Avery Saint
AuthorThe adjudication freeze is exactly what I'm afraid of triggering. Did your payments resume right after the adjudication was resolved or was there more waiting?
0 coins
Justin Chang
Payments resumed within a week of the adjudication closing in my favor. The rough part was the five weeks of limbo before that. Having that phone conversation with the NYSDOL agent at least let me understand what was being looked at so I wasn't completely in the dark.
0 coins
Grace Thomas
Adjudication is terrifying when you're depending on that money. I went through a three-week adjudication over a question about my separation from my previous employer and it was awful. Knowing what the issue is at least helps you prepare documentation.
0 coins
Jay Lincoln
How did you document your self-employment hours to satisfy the adjudication? I'm trying to figure out what records I should be keeping now so I don't have this problem later.
0 coins
Hunter Brighton
My brother was in this exact thread of trouble last year and he also had a hard time getting NYSDOL on the phone. He ended up using Claimyr and got an agent who gave him a really clear breakdown of what needed to be reported and when. He said the agent also flagged that his weekly certifications had a few errors and helped him understand how to correct them before they became an overpayment issue. If you've already been certifying with possibly incorrect hours reported, talking to an agent sooner rather than later is genuinely important - you can sometimes proactively address small errors before they become formal determinations.
0 coins
Avery Saint
AuthorThis is making me realize I should probably address this proactively rather than waiting to see if something flags on my account. I've been certifying zero hours because I didn't know business planning activities might count.
0 coins
Hunter Brighton
Proactive is definitely the right move with NYSDOL. Voluntary corrections look very different from discovered errors. The overpayment process is much more complicated than just amending a certification before anything has been flagged.
0 coins
Ezra Bates
The difference between 'I self-corrected' and 'we found an issue' in NYSDOL's system is significant. Self-corrections don't necessarily trigger overpayment determinations - discovered ones almost always do.
0 coins
Dylan Baskin
Former HR professional here, dealt with unemployment claims from the employer side for years. The NYSDOL rules around self-employment during a UI claim have a few distinct components that keep getting mixed together in this thread. First: the LLC as a legal entity is basically irrelevant to your eligibility. You could be a named member of twenty LLCs and still collect UI. Second: the activity you do for that LLC is what matters. Hours of business activity should be reported as work performed on your weekly cert. Third: income earned through the LLC reduces your weekly benefit amount or can eliminate it depending on how much you earn. Fourth: the self-employment income calculation often differs from W-2 income - business expenses can be deducted before the income is applied against your UI benefit. All four are separate issues and different agents sometimes conflate them.
0 coins
Avery Saint
AuthorBreaking it into four separate pieces actually makes this much clearer. So theoretically I could have an LLC and do some planning activity, report those hours on my certification, have zero income yet, and still receive a reduced benefit based on how those reported hours work out?
0 coins
Dylan Baskin
Exactly right. Hours of work can reduce your benefit amount but won't necessarily eliminate it, depending on how many hours and what your weekly benefit amount is. It's the combination of your hours reported AND any income earned that determines your benefit for a given week.
0 coins
Elijah Knight
The four-part breakdown is the clearest explanation of this I've seen on this forum. The hours piece and the income piece being separate is what confuses almost everyone initially.
0 coins
Marcus Williams
The business expense deduction piece is something a lot of people don't know about. If you have genuine business expenses - software subscriptions, professional fees, supplies - those reduce your net self-employment income for UI calculation purposes.
0 coins
Keith Davidson
My situation when I went through this was slightly different because I was doing freelance work rather than setting up a formal LLC, but the reporting rules were the same. What I found is that NYSDOL's weekly cert system is pretty blunt - it asks 'did you work' and 'how much did you earn,' and those two questions cover both traditional employment and self-employment. I'd report hours worked for the business even weeks when I earned zero, and my benefit was reduced based on those hours. Some weeks I had earnings too and those also reduced the benefit. The system still paid me something most weeks because my earnings were below my weekly benefit amount.
0 coins
Avery Saint
AuthorWait, so hours alone reduce your benefit even without earnings? I really did not understand that. I thought it was purely income-driven.
0 coins
Keith Davidson
Hours worked reduce your benefit based on a formula - I believe the first 80 hours or so of a week aren't penalized but after a certain threshold your benefit starts to decrease. It's the same formula used for people working part-time traditional jobs. NYSDOL treats business activity hours the same way.
0 coins
Sophia Carson
The specific formula has changed a bit over the years so I'd verify the current numbers directly with NYSDOL. But yes, hours are definitely a factor independent of income.
0 coins
Ezra Bates
I want to flag something nobody's really stressed enough in this thread - the job search requirement doesn't go away just because you're running a business. You still need to be making those required contacts each week and logging them properly. Some people get so wrapped up in the business side that they let the job search log slip and that creates a whole different disqualification issue.
0 coins
Avery Saint
AuthorI've been keeping up with job search activities - three contacts per week as required. But I hadn't thought about whether the LLC business activity complicates how NYSDOL views my job search. Like would they think I'm not genuinely searching if I'm building a business?
0 coins
Ezra Bates
NYSDOL's official position is that you can be building a business AND genuinely seeking employment simultaneously. Many people do both. The job search requirement is about demonstrable activity - as long as you're making the contacts and logging them, you're meeting that piece of your obligation regardless of the LLC.
0 coins
Jay Lincoln
What counts as a valid job search contact in NY right now? I know it used to be three per week but I've heard conflicting things about what qualifies.
0 coins
Dylan Baskin
Three contacts per week is the current standard in New York. Valid contacts include applying for a job directly with an employer, registering with a staffing agency, or attending job fair events. Each contact needs to be documented with employer name, contact method, position applied for, and date.
0 coins
Brooklyn Foley
My accountant told me something that totally changed how I was thinking about this. The tax treatment of the LLC income and the NYSDOL reporting of that income aren't the same thing - what you report to NYSDOL on your weekly certification can differ from what shows up on your LLC tax return. NYSDOL cares about gross income earned in a given week; your tax return will show net profit after all deductions for the year. These can produce very different numbers.
0 coins
Avery Saint
AuthorThat's a really important distinction. So for NYSDOL weekly cert purposes, I'm reporting gross earnings in the week earned, but my tax situation reflects the net annual picture?
0 coins
Brooklyn Foley
Basically yes. And NYSDOL can and does cross-reference your tax return with your UI claim records - they look for income during weeks you claimed benefits. If your tax return shows significant LLC income in a year you were on UI, that can trigger a review. But if you reported properly week by week, you can demonstrate you handled it correctly.
0 coins
Marcus Williams
Cross-referencing with tax records is exactly how most self-employment overpayment cases get discovered. The state has access to your Schedule C and they compare it to your weekly cert records. It's not 'did you cheat' - it's 'do the numbers match what you told us.
0 coins
Grace Thomas
Went through NYSDOL adjudication after my LLC situation became a mess, and I ended up needing to do an appeal hearing. The appeals process for unemployment is actually pretty accessible - you request a hearing, present your case to an administrative law judge, and can submit documentation. I won my appeal because I had records of my weekly certifications and could show I'd reported accurately to the best of my understanding at the time. That said, winning an appeal doesn't get you the weeks of payments you missed during the process. You eventually get back pay if you win, but the gap in income during the appeal period is brutal.
0 coins
Avery Saint
AuthorThe idea that even a successful appeal still means weeks or months without income is really sobering. This is making me want to be extra careful upfront rather than dealing with any of this later.
0 coins
Grace Thomas
Exactly the lesson I took from it. The appeal process works but it's slow and stressful. Getting the reporting right from the start - even if that means proactively reaching out to NYSDOL to ask what to report - is so much better than navigating the appeals process afterward.
0 coins
Lily Young
Appeal hearings are formal proceedings and claimants often don't realize they can bring documentation, witnesses, and even legal representation. The administrative law judges are usually fair but you need to present your case coherently. The initial hearing request deadline is 30 days from the determination notice date - don't miss that window.
0 coins
Sophia Carson
There's something worth knowing about how NYSDOL handles the self-employment determination that sometimes surprises people. The question isn't whether your LLC made money - it's whether you were 'in business.' An LLC that is actively operating, even without income yet, may be considered self-employment for UI purposes in some adjudicators' interpretation. This is the gray zone that makes getting a definitive NYSDOL answer important. I know several people who got determinations that their LLC activity disqualified them from certain weeks not because of income but because the adjudicator determined they were engaged in self-employment activity during those weeks. The hours piece matters more than most people realize.
0 coins
Avery Saint
AuthorThis is genuinely alarming. So 'being in business' might be the threshold, not 'earning money from business,' and adjudicators can interpret that differently?
0 coins
Sophia Carson
The ambiguity is real and that's exactly why written or documented guidance from NYSDOL is valuable. If an agent tells you something specific, write it down with the date and their ID number if they give it. That documentation can matter later.
0 coins
Elijah Knight
The 'in business' interpretation vs. 'earning income' interpretation is the core dispute in a lot of self-employment UI cases. NYSDOL's own publications are genuinely ambiguous about where that line is. Getting an agent to put something definitive in a note on your claim file is the gold standard.
0 coins
Lauren Wood
Came across Claimyr trying to deal with a completely different NYSDOL question but ended up using it again when I had self-employment questions during my claim. Got to talk to an agent who pulled up my account and walked through what I needed to report given my specific circumstances. The fact that I could have a real conversation rather than submitting questions through the online portal and waiting days for a vague answer made a big difference in actually understanding what applied to my situation.
0 coins
Avery Saint
AuthorThe online portal responses being vague is exactly my experience - I sent a message through Unemployment Services two weeks ago and the response I got back was basically a copy-paste from their FAQ that didn't answer my actual question at all.
0 coins
Lauren Wood
That's exactly the problem - the system is set up to give you generic answers to specific questions. Having a live agent who can see your actual claim, your specific certifications, and your account history is a completely different level of help.
0 coins
Ezra Bates
The online message system is useful for some things but for nuanced questions about self-employment during a UI claim, there's no substitute for speaking with an agent who has your file in front of them.
0 coins
Lily Young
Pulling this thread back to something practical for the original poster - here are the actual steps I'd recommend based on navigating this myself. First, stop certifying until you have clarity, or at minimum stop certifying with hours you're uncertain about. Second, reach NYSDOL by phone and specifically ask them to note on your account that you're in the process of forming an LLC and want guidance on reporting. Third, once you have guidance, follow it consistently and document every weekly certification you submit. If you end up needing to correct past certifications, do it promptly and explain the basis for the correction.
0 coins
Avery Saint
AuthorThe idea of pausing certifications worries me - doesn't that create gaps in my claim and potentially affect my benefit year?
0 coins
Lily Young
You raise a fair point - missing a certification week does create a gap and you can't typically recover that week. What I'd modify slightly: certify based on your best honest understanding, but do it promptly alongside reaching NYSDOL for clarification. If a correction is needed, you can usually address it. The bigger risk is certifying definitively inaccurately for weeks on end.
0 coins
Wesley Hallow
Missing certification weeks is a real risk - NYSDOL's system has deadlines and gaps can be hard to recover. Certifying honestly to the best of your knowledge while simultaneously seeking clarification is probably the right balance.
0 coins
Marcus Williams
My experience with the NYSDOL self-employment question was that the rules looked clear until I got into the details of my specific situation, at which point everything became murky. What seemed obvious from the FAQ didn't match what the agent told me, and what the first agent told me didn't match what the second agent told me. The only thing that actually resolved it was getting a formal written determination on my account after a third agent documented our conversation. If you can get an agent to document their guidance on your actual claim account, that's protective. Verbal guidance without documentation is better than nothing but documentation is better.
0 coins
Avery Saint
AuthorHow do you request that an agent document their guidance on your account? Is that something you can specifically ask for?
0 coins
Marcus Williams
You can ask the agent directly - 'can you add a note to my account reflecting what you just told me?' Some agents do this routinely, others are more resistant. If they won't, ask for their employee ID number and document the call yourself immediately after.
0 coins
Brooklyn Foley
The employee ID documentation approach saved someone I know in a dispute. NYSDOL can pull up call records and notes by employee ID. If an agent gave you guidance and there's a record of that call, it creates accountability for the information you received.
0 coins
Dylan Baskin
Asking for account documentation is completely within your rights as a claimant. The more specific your documentation - date, time, what was said, what they agreed to note - the more protective it is if you ever face a determination you need to dispute.
0 coins
Jay Lincoln
I'm in a somewhat similar situation and reading this thread has made me realize I've also been underreporting. I was doing some part-time freelance writing during my claim and only reporting the weeks I actually got paid, not the weeks I did the work. After reading this thread I'm now understanding that might be wrong and I need to figure out how to handle it.
0 coins
Ana Erdoğan
You're right to be concerned. Reporting in the week of payment rather than the week the work was performed is one of the most common self-employment reporting errors NYSDOL encounters. The sooner you address it - proactively versus waiting for NYSDOL to find it - the better your position.
0 coins
Jay Lincoln
How do I proactively address past certification errors without triggering an automatic overpayment determination? Is there a process for this?
0 coins
Dylan Baskin
Reach out to NYSDOL directly and explain the situation. There's no guaranteed path to avoiding an overpayment determination if you underreported, but voluntary disclosure is treated more favorably than discovered errors. An agent can explain your options for the specific weeks and amounts involved.
0 coins
Keith Davidson
Reading everything that's come up in this discussion, the one thing I keep coming back to is that NYSDOL's rules about self-employment during UI were clearly written for simpler situations. The reality of modern freelance and LLC work is complicated in ways the system wasn't really designed for. That doesn't excuse not following the rules, but it does explain why so many people end up in adjudication not because they were trying to game the system but because the rules are genuinely hard to apply correctly to their situations.
0 coins
Sophia Carson
The complexity is real and the enforcement consequences are equally real regardless of intent. Good faith misreporting still results in overpayment determinations - NYSDOL doesn't typically adjust for 'I didn't know.' This is why getting actual agency guidance before you have a problem matters so much.
0 coins
Avery Saint
AuthorThis whole thread has made clear to me that I need to get a direct NYSDOL answer before I do anything further with the LLC. I've been treating this as a simple question with a simple answer and it's clearly neither. Thank you all - this has been genuinely eye-opening.
0 coins
Elijah Knight
Glad this helped clarify things. Seriously though, get the guidance in writing or documented on your account if you possibly can. The specifics of your situation - what kind of work the LLC will do, how you'll be compensated, your weekly hours - all affect how the rules apply to you. No forum thread can substitute for guidance tailored to your actual claim.
0 coins