Back to New York Unemployment

Amina Diallo

Should I have taxes withheld from unemployment benefits? NYSDOL question

Okay so I've been collecting unemployment for about six weeks now and it just hit me that I never thought about taxes when I set everything up. My weekly benefit amount is $498 and I've just been taking the full amount each week without any withholding. My sister-in-law mentioned over dinner last weekend that she got hit with a surprise tax bill after her unemployment stint a few years ago and had to scramble to pay it. Now I'm wondering if I made a mistake not electing withholding from the start. I work in hospitality and got laid off when my restaurant location closed in February, so I'm not sure how long I'll be on UI. Can I still change my withholding election? And honestly, is it worth doing or should I just set money aside myself? Would love to hear from people who've been through this.

Week four of my own claim when I had the same panic, so I totally get where you're at. Before I get to the tax stuff - I want to mention Claimyr (claimyr.com) because it became my lifeline for getting actual answers from NYSDOL. It waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up talking to a live agent instead of spending your morning redial-ing. There's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. For your actual question: yes, you can update your federal tax withholding election through your Unemployment Services account at any point during your claim. NYSDOL will withhold 10% of each weekly benefit payment for federal income tax if you opt in. I'd strongly suggest doing it, especially since unemployment compensation is fully taxable as ordinary income at the federal level.

0 coins

I had no idea I could change it mid-claim - I assumed once you set it up you were locked in. I'm going to log in right now and look for that option. Where exactly is it in the account portal, do you remember?

0 coins

My first week I didn't know any of this either. The withholding setting in the Unemployment Services portal is under your payment preferences or benefit payment options section - it's not super obvious but it's there.

0 coins

About five months into unemployment two years ago, I completely forgot to handle taxes and ended up owing around $2,100 in April. That was a rough surprise. The 10% federal withholding they offer doesn't always cover everything if you had other income during the year, like part-time gigs or anything freelance, so keep that in mind when deciding whether the flat 10% is enough for your situation.

0 coins

That $2,100 number is kind of alarming honestly. I had a few weeks of sporadic catering gig work before I filed, so I might have a more complicated tax picture than I realized.

0 coins

My tax situation was similar - mixed income year with some 1099 stuff and UI benefits together made it messy. The 10% withholding didn't fully cover what I owed because my effective rate ended up being higher once everything was added together.

0 coins

My accountant told me the same thing. If your total income for the year puts you in a higher bracket after adding UI, the 10% might not cut it and you'd still owe at filing.

0 coins

The form 1099-G is what NYSDOL sends you in January showing your total benefits paid and how much was withheld. You'll use that when you file your taxes. I didn't get mine until mid-January last year and almost missed it - NYSDOL puts it in your online account under tax documents but also mails it. Worth checking both places.

0 coins

Mid-January sounds about right for when mine appeared in the portal too. I actually didn't realize it was there digitally and panicked thinking it got lost in the mail.

0 coins

Good to know it shows up in the online portal as well as by mail. I'll keep an eye out come January. Does the amount on the 1099-G reflect the gross payment before withholding or the net amount I actually received?

0 coins

Box 1 on the 1099-G shows the total unemployment compensation paid to you before any withholding, and Box 4 shows the federal income tax withheld. So if you elect 10% withholding, you'd see both numbers there.

0 coins

My neighbor told me unemployment benefits aren't taxable in New York so I went a whole claim without withholding anything and then got confused when my preparer said I owed federal taxes. Turns out my neighbor was half right - New York State doesn't tax unemployment benefits, but the federal government absolutely does. I wish someone had spelled that out more clearly when I first filed.

0 coins

Your neighbor probably heard the state part and thought it applied everywhere. That distinction trips up so many people. Federal taxes still apply fully, state taxes don't - it's one of the more confusing aspects of UI for first-timers.

0 coins

My first claim I made the exact same mistake, assumed state and federal matched. Ended up owing the IRS about $900 that spring and had to set up a payment plan which was not fun.

0 coins

Wait, so New York State doesn't tax unemployment at all? That's actually a relief. So the only withholding I'd be doing is for federal purposes?

0 coins

That's correct - the 10% optional withholding through NYSDOL is strictly for federal income tax. No New York State tax on UI benefits, so you don't need to worry about state withholding from your weekly payments.

0 coins

My claim got stuck in adjudication for almost a month and I couldn't get anyone on the phone to explain what documents they needed from me. Claimyr was actually what finally got me in front of an agent - it sat on hold with NYSDOL so I didn't have to, and I eventually got to speak with someone directly who walked me through everything. Once that was resolved I also asked the agent about updating my withholding election and they confirmed I could do it anytime through the online portal, no need to call for that specific thing.

0 coins

Adjudication delays sound genuinely stressful. Good to know there's a way to actually reach someone when the portal alone isn't enough.

0 coins

My adjudication dragged on for three weeks too. The phone line situation is brutal - I tried for days and kept hitting automated messages or getting disconnected. Glad there's a workaround.

0 coins

Twenty-three days into my current claim and the tax question keeps me up at night too. I opted for withholding from day one because I'd read too many stories about people getting blindsided. Here's the thing though - if you're worried about owing more than 10%, you can also make estimated quarterly tax payments directly to the IRS on top of whatever NYSDOL withholds. The IRS Form 1040-ES covers that. It's what self-employed people typically do but it works for anyone with income that isn't fully covered by withholding.

0 coins

I hadn't thought about quarterly estimated payments as an option. Is there a threshold where you're required to do that or is it optional?

0 coins

Generally if you expect to owe $1,000 or more in federal taxes after subtracting withholding and credits, the IRS wants you to pay estimated taxes quarterly. If you're short and don't, you can get hit with an underpayment penalty on top of what you owe.

0 coins

My tax person told me the same thing last year. For most people on unemployment with no other income, the 10% withholding is usually sufficient, but if you had W-2 income earlier in the year the picture changes fast.

0 coins

My first week filing weekly certifications I noticed the portal asks about your withholding preference but I honestly didn't understand what I was agreeing to. I just clicked through. Definitely go back and double-check your setting is actually what you want it to be, not just whatever default you clicked on when you were stressed and speed-reading the setup screens.

0 coins

This is exactly what I did - rushed through setup and didn't think carefully about that screen. Going to verify what my current election actually is before anything else.

0 coins

The portal doesn't make it super obvious whether you've opted in or out. I had to look at a couple of my payment history entries to figure out if anything was being taken out.

0 coins

My payment details showed the exact amount withheld each week once I found the right section. That was the easiest way to confirm my election was actually active.

0 coins

I've been on UI twice in the last four years and both times I chose not to withhold, figuring I'd rather have the full payment each week and handle taxes myself. First time it worked out fine because I had offsetting deductions. Second time I completely forgot to set money aside and scrambled in April. I'd probably just opt for withholding now honestly, the peace of mind is worth more than having that extra 10% available each week.

0 coins

My exact same logic the second time around. The 'I'll save it myself' plan sounds good in theory but the money has a way of disappearing into regular expenses.

0 coins

Yeah I think that's what would happen to me too. The discipline required to actually quarantine that money each week is probably more than I have right now when every dollar feels critical.

0 coins

My HR department at my old job actually handed out a sheet when they processed our layoffs that mentioned the tax withholding option for unemployment. I thought it was surprisingly useful info coming from them. The sheet said NYSDOL recommends setting it up at the start but can be changed anytime through Unemployment Services - so your situation is totally fixable.

0 coins

Your HR department was unusually helpful there - most people find out about this the hard way.

0 coins

Wish my restaurant had given me something like that. We basically got a 'sorry, good luck' and that was the extent of it.

0 coins

My layoff notice was similarly bare. The sheet I got was apparently because HR had been through a round of this before and learned from complaints.

0 coins

My fourth week of claiming was when I realized I needed to actually talk to an NYSDOL agent to sort out some questions about my partial unemployment situation, not just the tax thing. I used Claimyr to get through - it handles the hold time for you and you end up with an actual agent on the line. The agent I spoke with was really helpful and explained that updating my withholding election in the portal takes effect the very next payment, not the following week or anything like that.

0 coins

That's useful - same-next-payment timing is better than I expected. So if I change it today it would affect my payment this week?

0 coins

My understanding from the agent is yes, if you update before your payment processes it takes effect right away. I'd log in and make the change as soon as possible if you want it to hit this cycle.

0 coins

My experience matched that too - I changed my election and the very next deposit reflected the withholding. It's not like some settings that take a billing cycle or something to kick in.

0 coins

My cousin works as a tax preparer and she says unemployment is one of the top three things people forget to account for when they expect a refund and then don't get one. The withholding option through NYSDOL is specifically designed so this doesn't blindside people, but it's entirely opt-in so a lot of folks just miss it.

0 coins

Your cousin is probably right that it's super common. I've seen the same complaint on this forum repeatedly every February and March when people start doing their taxes.

0 coins

Okay I'm definitely opting in today. This whole thread has convinced me the small reduction in weekly payment is worth avoiding the April scramble.

0 coins

My claim approval came through faster than I expected and I was so relieved I completely blanked on the withholding question. Ended up calling NYSDOL weeks later to ask about changing it - Claimyr made that way easier because I actually got through to an agent rather than sitting on hold for two hours myself. The agent walked me through the portal steps in real time, which is honestly the fastest way to get it done if you're confused by the interface.

0 coins

Having an agent walk you through it live sounds helpful. The portal can be counterintuitive and knowing you're clicking the right thing makes a difference.

0 coins

My phone anxiety makes the idea of sitting on hold unbearable. Good to know there are ways around that because sometimes you genuinely do need to speak with someone.

0 coins

My weekly benefit came out to $467 and 10% of that is about $47 withheld each payment. Over a 26-week claim that adds up to roughly $1,200 in federal taxes prepaid which feels like a lot week to week but is way better than a lump sum bill. Worth doing the math for your own benefit amount to see what it looks like.

0 coins

I should do that calculation. At my $498 weekly benefit, 10% is $49.80 per week. If I end up collecting for another 15 or 16 weeks that's close to $750 going toward federal taxes, which covers a solid chunk of the liability.

0 coins

My math worked out similarly. And if you end up not owing that much, you get a refund when you file - it's not like the money disappears, it's just held until tax season.

0 coins

The refund possibility is a good point. I've had years where my actual tax liability was lower than what was withheld and I got a small refund, which felt like a bonus after what had been a stressful unemployment period.

0 coins

The deadline people miss is that your withholding election for the current benefit year has to be updated before your final payment processes if you want it to count across your whole claim period. There's no going back to adjust prior payments after they've been issued - what's done is done. So the earlier you update, the more payments it covers. NYSDOL doesn't retroactively withhold anything from payments that already went out.

0 coins

Your point about retroactive withholding is important. I think some people assume they can fix it all at year-end somehow through NYSDOL directly, which isn't how it works.

0 coins

That makes sense - I figured the past six weeks of payments are already out the door without withholding, so my goal now is to minimize the gap going forward by updating the election immediately.

0 coins

My job search requirements and all the certification stuff has been keeping me so busy that the tax question was genuinely the last thing on my radar. This thread reminded me I haven't even checked my withholding setting since the first day I signed up. Going to go look right now.

0 coins

My certification routine takes longer than I expected too. The activity log entries and documenting the required contacts each week adds up.

0 coins

The weekly certification process definitely takes some mental energy. Glad this thread was useful as a reminder - easy thing to push off until it becomes a problem.

0 coins

My accountant mentioned that some people on extended UI claims strategically choose not to withhold during the year and instead make a one-time estimated payment in January before the filing deadline to avoid the underpayment penalty. That can work if you're disciplined about actually saving the money, but most people aren't and it backfires. The withholding route is just simpler for the average person.

0 coins

Your accountant's point is valid but the January estimated payment has to cover a certain threshold relative to your prior year tax liability or current year tax to avoid the penalty, so it's not as simple as just paying everything at once in January.

0 coins

My accountant explained that nuance too - the safe harbor rules matter a lot there. For most UI claimants it's honestly not worth the complexity and just doing the 10% withholding is cleaner.

0 coins

My layoff happened last October so my tax year was split between regular W-2 income and UI benefits. That combination made the 10% withholding clearly not enough to cover my federal liability because my earlier income had already pushed me up a bracket. If you had significant employment income earlier in the same tax year, 10% from UI alone is probably underpaying.

0 coins

My situation is exactly this - I worked through most of February before the closure, so I have W-2 wages plus UI for the same tax year. That 10% might not be enough for me either.

0 coins

My preparer suggested that in that situation, supplementing the NYSDOL withholding with a quarterly estimated payment to the IRS in the amount of the gap can protect you from underpayment penalties. Definitely worth running your numbers before the next quarterly deadline.

0 coins

Your preparer gave solid advice. The IRS quarterly due dates are worth noting - April 15, June 16, September 15, and January 15 for the following year. Missing those when you owe can add penalties on top of the tax itself.

0 coins

About two months into my claim and I opted out of withholding because I read somewhere that you could just adjust your W-4 at your next job to make up for it. I'm starting to think that was bad advice because there's no guarantee of timing on when I'll be working again, and if that's not until next year the tax year with UI income is already locked in.

0 coins

Your read on that is unfortunately correct. The W-4 you fill out at a future employer only affects future withholding going forward - it can't retroactively cover a prior year's tax liability from UI. Each tax year stands on its own.

0 coins

My plan was clearly flawed then. I'm updating my withholding election in the portal today. At least I've only been out five or six weeks so there's still most of the claim period left for withholding to kick in if I end up needing the full 26 weeks.

0 coins

I was in a similar situation with the same kind of wishful thinking. Changing mine today too.

0 coins

My benefits just got approved last week and I specifically asked the NYSDOL rep who processed my claim about taxes and she said the withholding election sits in your account under 'payment options' or something close to that. She said most claimants don't opt in which is why so many people get surprised at tax time. She seemed a little exasperated about it, like it was a common problem she hears about every year.

0 coins

Your rep's frustration makes sense - it's probably one of the most common calls they get in the spring when people realize what they owe. The opt-in design of the system puts the burden entirely on the claimant to know to look for it.

0 coins

I appreciate the confirmation that it's under payment options - that matches what a few other people said in this thread. At this point I'm not waiting any longer, logging in now to get this done.

0 coins

My rep said to look for a checkbox or toggle, it might just be labeled 'voluntary withholding' or similar. It's not a prominent feature on the page so don't get discouraged if it takes a moment to find.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure