NYSDOL unemployment claim denied for job abandonment - what are my options?
I've been dealing with this for going on five weeks now and I'm honestly at a loss. Background: I was a warehouse supervisor for about two years, decent job, nothing spectacular. Things started getting rough when my shift got changed without any notice - they moved me from days to overnight with literally zero discussion, just a memo slipped under my locker on a Thursday saying I'd be starting nights the following Monday. I have two kids in elementary school and no overnight childcare, so I couldn't just flip my entire life around in four days. I told my floor manager I needed time to arrange care and asked if we could work something out, but I never got a written response, just silence and then a week later they marked me as a voluntary quit due to job abandonment because I hadn't shown up for the new overnight shifts. I didn't quit. I showed up for my regular day shifts. HR said the schedule change was 'within company policy' and that by not reporting for nights I'd effectively abandoned the position. Now NYSDOL has flagged my claim as potentially disqualified under voluntary separation rules. I filed my initial claim, got the interview letter, did the phone interview, and the adjudicator said a decision would be mailed within 10 business days. That was three and a half weeks ago. My online account still just shows 'pending' on the monetary determination page. I've been filing my weekly certifications this whole time because I read somewhere you're supposed to keep doing that even during adjudication, but I genuinely don't know if I'm doing any of this right. Has anyone actually fought a job abandonment label from their employer and won? What does NYSDOL actually look for in these situations?
66 comments

Maggie Martinez
Week six of my own adjudication when I finally got a decision letter, so I feel this post in my bones. The thing they don't tell you upfront is that NYSDOL adjudicators are specifically looking at whether you had what they'd call 'good cause' for not following the employer's directive. In your case the overnight shift change with four days notice when you have school-age kids and no childcare is exactly the kind of thing that can qualify - childcare obligations for dependent children have been recognized as good cause in a lot of these cases. The key is making sure you documented that you told them about the childcare issue before things escalated to them marking you abandoned. Did you put anything in writing to your manager or HR about not being able to make the switch?
0 coins
Zane Gray
AuthorI did text my floor manager twice about it - once to explain the childcare issue and once asking if there was a day shift opening I could transfer to. I don't have emails but I have those texts saved. Would text messages be acceptable as documentation?
0 coins
Alejandro Castro
Texts absolutely count as documentation in NYSDOL adjudication hearings. Screenshots with timestamps showing you raised the childcare issue before the abandonment marking are worth saving in multiple places. The fact that you proposed an alternative (day shift transfer) also matters - it shows you weren't trying to avoid work entirely, just the specific impossible schedule.
0 coins
Monique Byrd
My situation was different - shift change dispute but no kids involved - and I ran into the same wall trying to reach NYSDOL to check where my adjudication stood. I tried phoning for two weeks straight and kept getting the busy signal or the automated message telling me to try again later. Eventually someone in another forum mentioned Claimyr (claimyr.com) and I tried it - it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up actually talking to a live agent instead of spending your day redialing. There's a video at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE that shows how it works. The agent I reached was able to tell me exactly where my claim was in the adjudication queue and what notes were attached to my case. That information alone was worth it because I finally knew what I was dealing with.
0 coins
Zane Gray
AuthorFive weeks of pending with no updates and I genuinely don't know what notes are on my case. This might be what I need - I want to know if the adjudicator actually recorded what I said about the childcare issue in the interview.
0 coins
Jackie Martinez
My third week of trying to reach NYSDOL by phone before I gave up and mailed a written inquiry instead. Got a response postcard 12 days later saying my claim was 'under review.' That told me basically nothing. Getting to an actual agent sounds way more useful.
0 coins
Lia Quinn
I'd been skeptical about third party services for government stuff but reaching NYSDOL directly on the phone has become genuinely difficult. If it actually gets you to a live agent that's valuable especially during adjudication when you need real answers about your specific case.
0 coins
Haley Stokes
Three separate unemployment claims over the years and job abandonment disputes are honestly among the trickiest to fight - but they're also winnable when the facts support you. Here's how I'd frame what happened in your case: employers can change schedules but they generally can't make a change so drastic and with such short notice that it becomes impossible for you to comply without upending your entire life, and then call it abandonment when you can't immediately comply. NYSDOL adjudicators look at whether the employer gave reasonable notice, whether you raised a concern, and whether you had a legitimate reason. You've got all three. Keep filing your weekly certifications no matter what - stopping them is a mistake people make during adjudication that costs them payments they were owed.
0 coins
Zane Gray
AuthorThe 'reasonable notice' piece is interesting - is four days considered unreasonable as a standard? Or does it depend on the type of change?
0 coins
Haley Stokes
Four days for an overnight flip when you have kids in school would be considered pretty short by most measures. The more dramatic the change and the shorter the notice, the harder it is for the employer to claim abandonment with a straight face. Document the specific date on the memo and the specific start date of the new shift - that gap matters.
0 coins
Asher Levin
My employer tried something similar - moved me to a location 90 minutes away with one week's notice and then marked me AWOL when I didn't show. NYSDOL sided with me because I'd raised the transportation hardship in writing before the whole thing imploded. The pattern here seems to be: raise the issue formally, propose alternatives, let the employer make the final call. Then it's on them, not you.
0 coins
Serene Snow
Pending for about two months before I finally got my decision letter last year. I know the waiting is brutal but the five weeks you're at isn't necessarily a sign anything is wrong - some adjudications just take longer when the employer contests the claim or when the adjudicator has to review additional documentation. The fact that you completed the phone interview is actually a good sign because it means they took your statement. Some people never even get a scheduled interview.
0 coins
Zane Gray
AuthorThe interview felt like they were actually listening so I guess that's something. I just wish the account would show literally anything other than 'pending.
0 coins
Issac Nightingale
My account showed pending for 11 weeks after my adjudication interview and then a decision letter showed up without any change in the online status at all. The online dashboard is notoriously behind the actual process. The decision came in the mail first.
0 coins
Romeo Barrett
I keep checking my account like it's going to magically update and you're right that it basically never does in real time. So frustrating.
0 coins
Marina Hendrix
My fourth attempt to reach a NYSDOL agent by phone that week before I finally got through using Claimyr. The agent confirmed my adjudication was actually complete on their end but the system hadn't sent the letter yet. Without that phone call I'd have kept waiting in the dark. If you're at five weeks and your account shows nothing, talking to an actual agent who can pull up your file is the fastest way to know what's actually happening.
0 coins
Zane Gray
AuthorWait - the decision can be complete but the letter not sent yet? So the system could have already ruled and I wouldn't even know?
0 coins
Marina Hendrix
That's exactly what happened in my case. The adjudicator had closed the case on their end but the letter took another week to arrive. The agent told me the decision and the determination code over the phone, which at least let me start thinking about next steps.
0 coins
Justin Trejo
My experience matches this - there's a delay between when NYSDOL closes the adjudication internally and when the letter actually processes. Physical mail adds another layer. The online account usually updates after the letter, not before or at the same time.
0 coins
Alana Willis
My HR rep actually told me - without realizing she was helping me - that the schedule change had been posted 'per company policy' but that the policy didn't specify minimum advance notice for shift changes. I screen-recorded the Teams meeting where she said it. That ended up being one of the most useful pieces of evidence in my adjudication because it showed the company didn't even have a written policy on notice periods. When you're pulling together documentation, look at whether your employer's actual written policy supports what they did.
0 coins
Zane Gray
AuthorI actually don't know if there's a written policy on schedule change notice. HR just said the change was 'within company policy' verbally. I should request that in writing.
0 coins
Alana Willis
Request it now in writing, via email if you can. If they claim 'company policy' allows something, ask them to send you the relevant policy section. If the policy doesn't actually address notice periods for major shift changes, that's useful. If it does and they violated it, that's even more useful.
0 coins
Tyler Murphy
My termination paperwork said 'voluntary separation' but the actual employee handbook had a 72-hour notice requirement before marking someone absent without leave. They hadn't followed their own procedure. NYSDOL adjudicators do look at whether the employer followed their own stated policies.
0 coins
Sara Unger
My first claim ever and I was completely lost on the difference between being disqualified and having my claim denied outright. For anyone in the same confusion: a disqualification for voluntary separation means you're found to have left without good cause, but it doesn't necessarily end your eligibility permanently. You can appeal the determination if you disagree, and you have 30 days from the date on the determination letter to file that appeal with the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board. The appeal is a full hearing where you present your evidence. It's worth knowing this upfront so you're ready to move fast if the decision goes the wrong way.
0 coins
Zane Gray
AuthorThirty days from the letter date - I need to remember that. Is the appeal process something I can do myself or do I need a lawyer?
0 coins
Sara Unger
You can absolutely do it yourself and many people do. The hearing is relatively informal - more like a recorded conversation than a courtroom. You present your evidence, the employer gets to respond, and the hearing officer asks questions. Having your texts, any emails, the schedule memo, and any notes from your interview all organized would put you in decent shape.
0 coins
Butch Sledgehammer
My appeal hearing was over the phone and lasted maybe 35 minutes. I'd been terrified it would feel like court but it was actually just me explaining what happened with the adjudicator asking clarifying questions. I won on the same childcare-disruption argument you're describing. Keep everything chronological.
0 coins
Freya Ross
My coworker went through almost this exact scenario - overnight shift imposed with minimal notice, didn't show, got marked as job abandonment - and her claim was approved at the adjudication stage without even needing an appeal. The adjudicator found that the employer's failure to provide reasonable accommodation for the childcare situation constituted constructive dismissal rather than voluntary quit. She'd kept a written record of every conversation where she asked for alternatives. That paper trail was apparently decisive.
0 coins
Zane Gray
AuthorConstructive dismissal - I hadn't heard that term in the unemployment context. Does NYSDOL use that framework explicitly?
0 coins
Maggie Martinez
NYSDOL doesn't always use that exact phrase but the concept maps to their 'good cause' standard for voluntary separations. Basically: if the conditions the employer created made it genuinely impossible for a reasonable person to continue working, the separation may not be treated as a true voluntary quit even if the employee technically stopped showing up.
0 coins
Freya Ross
My coworker's adjudicator literally used the phrase 'constructive discharge' in the determination letter. So yes, they do apply the concept, though the specific language in decisions can vary.
0 coins
Leslie Parker
My phone attempts to reach NYSDOL ran into the same wall - busy signal, automated message, then disconnect after a 45-minute wait. A friend told me about Claimyr after I complained about it enough. They waited on hold with NYSDOL for me and I ended up speaking directly with an agent who clarified what documentation my adjudicator still needed. It cut down my adjudication by what I think was at least a week just because I could answer their questions promptly once I knew what they were actually looking for.
0 coins
Sergio Neal
My sister-in-law's situation - her adjudicator had left a note requesting additional employer documentation but the online account showed nothing. She didn't know until an agent told her. By the time she figured it out the standard window had nearly closed. Getting to an agent early when things feel stalled is not a bad instinct at all.
0 coins
Zane Gray
AuthorThe idea that the adjudicator might have outstanding questions and I just don't know because the account says nothing is genuinely stressful. I might reach out through Claimyr just to make sure there's nothing sitting unresponded to on my case.
0 coins
Alejandro Castro
My determination letter arrived on a Saturday and said I was disqualified - and I'll be honest, I panicked. But then I actually read the whole thing carefully and realized the adjudicator had gotten one of the dates wrong - they had me not showing up two days before the overnight shift was even supposed to start. That factual error became the basis of my appeal and I won. Moral: when your letter arrives, read every single detail for accuracy before you do anything else.
0 coins
Zane Gray
AuthorThat is both horrifying and weirdly reassuring. So errors in the determination are actually appealable on factual grounds, not just legal ones?
0 coins
Alejandro Castro
Absolutely. If the facts in the determination don't match what actually happened you raise that in the appeal and show your documentation. The hearing officer can correct factual findings. That's actually often cleaner to argue than a pure 'good cause' dispute.
0 coins
Romeo Barrett
I did not know you could appeal on a factual error basis. I always assumed appeals were only for disputing the legal interpretation. This is really useful.
0 coins
Sergio Neal
My HR told me verbally that I was 'walking out' when I didn't come in - but the written separation notice they gave me said 'voluntary resignation due to no-call no-show.' Those two things are different and both were wrong. When I got to adjudication I pointed out that I'd texted twice to explain I couldn't make the new schedule work, so the 'no-call no-show' characterization was factually false. NYSDOL determined in my favor. The employer's paperwork is not the final word on what happened.
0 coins
Zane Gray
AuthorMy separation paperwork also says 'voluntary quit' but I never submitted any resignation. I didn't even know I'd been 'quit' until HR told me after the fact.
0 coins
Sergio Neal
That's a strong point in your favor. If you have texts showing you were still actively trying to find a workable solution right up until they marked you abandoned, that directly contradicts the 'voluntary' framing. Voluntary implies a choice made freely - you were trying to solve a childcare problem, not walk away.
0 coins
Haley Stokes
The word 'voluntary' in the unemployment context has a specific meaning that's narrower than what most employers use it for internally. Employers use it as an administrative category. NYSDOL applies a standard that actually examines whether the person had a reasonable alternative to leaving.
0 coins
Lia Quinn
My first unemployment claim years ago was for a job abandonment situation too - mine was messier and I didn't win, partly because I'd never told anyone about the problem before just not showing up. The lesson I took from it: the moment a workplace situation starts becoming unworkable, start writing things down and communicating formally. Even texts. Especially texts. Because when it ends up in adjudication, it becomes your word against the employer's and documentation is what breaks the tie.
0 coins
Zane Gray
AuthorI wish someone had told me this while everything was still happening. At least I have the texts I sent to my manager. Going to make sure I've got backups of those saved somewhere besides my phone.
0 coins
Lia Quinn
Export them to email or screenshot and save to cloud storage. If you switch phones before the case resolves you don't want to lose them. Also, if you have any old emails from HR or anything about the original shift schedule, keep those too - anything that establishes what your normal hours were.
0 coins
Jackie Martinez
My old phone died mid-claim and I lost some texts I hadn't backed up. It set my adjudication back because I had to try to reconstruct the timeline from memory. Back everything up now, before anything else happens.
0 coins
Asher Levin
My unemployment claim from a job abandonment situation two years ago - and I want to say this for people earlier in the process than OP: continue filing your weekly certifications every single week without fail during adjudication. The common mistake is thinking that because your claim is 'pending' or 'in adjudication' your certifications don't matter. They absolutely do. If NYSDOL decides in your favor, the payments go back to cover all the weeks you certified. If you stopped certifying, you lose those weeks permanently.
0 coins
Zane Gray
AuthorI've been filing every Sunday like clockwork even without any payments showing. Good to know I'm doing that part right at least.
0 coins
Asher Levin
You're doing exactly the right thing. Keep doing it. Some people also mistakenly think they need to stop job searching during adjudication - you don't. Keep doing your required job search activities and logging them. If your claim is approved those logs will matter.
0 coins
Justin Trejo
My claim got approved three months after the initial dispute and I was retroactively paid for every week I'd certified during adjudication. It was a substantial amount. If I'd stopped certifying thinking it was pointless I'd have lost all of it.
0 coins
Butch Sledgehammer
My adjudicator actually asked me during the phone interview whether I had made any attempt to find alternative arrangements before the situation reached the breaking point. The question surprised me but in retrospect it makes sense - NYSDOL is trying to establish that you didn't have a reasonable alternative you chose not to pursue. For your situation: the texts to your manager asking about a day shift transfer are exactly the kind of 'alternative arrangement attempt' that answers that question favorably.
0 coins
Zane Gray
AuthorI hadn't thought about it that way - that by asking for a day shift transfer I was actually demonstrating I was trying to stay employed, not looking for a way out.
0 coins
Butch Sledgehammer
Exactly. The request for a transfer shows you wanted to work and tried to find a solution the employer could accept. If the employer ignored that request or refused without offering anything, that strengthens your position considerably.
0 coins
Alana Willis
My adjudicator asked me the same question and I didn't have a great answer because I'd mostly just vented to coworkers instead of formally requesting alternatives. I ended up needing the appeal to get approved. The claimants who win at the adjudication stage almost always have documentation of trying to work something out first.
0 coins
Tyler Murphy
My determination came back as 'disqualified' on a Friday and I was devastated, but my appeal was filed the following Monday with everything I had. The hearing was scheduled for three weeks later. I want to say this clearly because I've seen people on this forum assume that a disqualification is the end: it is not. The appeals process exists specifically for situations where the adjudication got it wrong or where additional evidence changes the picture.
0 coins
Zane Gray
AuthorHow did your appeal go, if you're okay sharing?
0 coins
Tyler Murphy
I won. The hearing officer looked at the same documentation the adjudicator had supposedly reviewed and immediately asked the employer's representative why the alternative shift arrangement request had been ignored. The employer couldn't give a satisfying answer. The hearing officer overturned the disqualification and I received all the back payments for the pending weeks within about two weeks of the hearing.
0 coins
Issac Nightingale
My appeal also overturned a disqualification for a voluntary separation case. The hearing is a genuinely fair process - it's not rigged in the employer's favor even though it might feel that way going in.
0 coins
Romeo Barrett
My claim has been pending for eight weeks and I'd basically given up on understanding what was happening until I found this thread. I didn't even know you could ask NYSDOL directly what's in your case notes or where you are in the queue. I've just been... waiting and refreshing my account.
0 coins
Maggie Martinez
Eight weeks of watching a pending status would drive anyone to distraction. Getting to a live agent at NYSDOL is the only real way to find out what's actually in your file. The online account gives you almost nothing specific during active adjudication.
0 coins
Romeo Barrett
I didn't even realize you could talk to an agent about where your adjudication specifically stands. I thought they'd just tell me to wait for the letter.
0 coins
Serene Snow
Agents can actually see your full claim file including adjudicator notes and pending documentation requests. It's worth finding a way to get through to one if your case has been sitting without updates for a while.
0 coins
Justin Trejo
My work schedule showed I'd been a morning shift employee for 14 straight months - I had paystubs that all listed the same shift times and that became key evidence because the employer tried to argue night shifts were 'always part of the role.' The specific job description in my offer letter didn't mention overnight availability at all. If yours doesn't either, that's worth noting in your documentation.
0 coins
Zane Gray
AuthorMy original job posting and offer letter both said 'day shift warehouse operations.' I still have the offer letter. I hadn't thought to include that but it directly contradicts them treating overnight shifts as a standard expectation.
0 coins
Justin Trejo
That offer letter could be one of your most useful documents. It establishes what you were actually hired to do. A sudden move to nights becomes much harder to characterize as standard company business when the written offer says day shift specifically.
0 coins
Alejandro Castro
My offer letter was similarly specific and I hadn't even thought to include it until the hearing officer asked if I had any documentation of my original terms of employment. Bring everything - documents you think might not matter sometimes matter the most.
0 coins