Back to New York Unemployment

Connor O'Neill

Is it bad to apply for unemployment? First time filing with NYSDOL

So I got laid off two weeks ago from my job at a small manufacturing company where I'd been working for about four years. My manager said the position was being eliminated due to budget cuts, and HR gave me a two-week severance package. Now I'm sitting here wondering - is it bad to apply for unemployment? I keep second-guessing myself because I've never filed before and I honestly don't know if it'll somehow come back to bite me. My coworker told me applying might make it harder to get hired somewhere else because employers can see your claim history, and now I have this whole anxiety spiral going. I went ahead and created an account on the NYSDOL Unemployment Services portal but I haven't actually submitted the claim yet. Is there any real downside to filing? Does my old employer get penalized somehow? Will it affect my taxes? I genuinely have no idea how this all works and I'm kind of freaking out.

Wait, your coworker told you employers can see your claim history? That's not how it works at all. Future employers have no way to look up whether you filed for UI benefits - that information is private. You paid into this system through your paycheck every week you worked, so you're literally just accessing something you already contributed to. File the claim. The only thing waiting around does is delay your first payment.

0 coins

Okay that's honestly such a relief to hear. I had no idea the information was private - my coworker seemed so sure about it.

0 coins

Yep, your coworker was just wrong. Happens a lot with unemployment myths. The claim is between you and NYSDOL, full stop.

0 coins

Honestly I believed the same myth for like 2 years after getting laid off from a previous job. Filed eventually and nothing bad happened at all.

0 coins

Have you been able to get through to NYSDOL on the phone yet? I ask because when I first filed I had a ton of questions and kept hitting a wall trying to reach anyone. A friend pointed me toward Claimyr - claimyr.com - it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you actually end up talking to a live agent instead of sitting there for hours. There's also a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. Helped me get answers about exactly this kind of stuff when I was starting out.

0 coins

I haven't even tried calling yet, I was scared to even start the process. Maybe I should use that before I file so I can ask someone directly.

0 coins

Honestly calling before you file is a smart move if you have specific questions about your severance and how it affects your first week of benefits. Good tip.

0 coins

NYSDOL phone lines are brutal, glad there are options now. Spent two full days trying to get through when my adjudication started last year.

0 coins

To put your mind at ease about your employer - yes, your former employer does get notified when you file a claim because NYSDOL gives them a chance to respond if they think you left voluntarily or were fired for misconduct. But in your situation, since you were laid off due to position elimination, they'd have nothing to dispute. If anything, a legit layoff is the clearest path to an approved claim.

0 coins

So my employer actually gets contacted? Does that mean they could try to fight my claim even though they laid me off?

0 coins

They get a notice asking if they contest it, but if the layoff was legitimate - budget cuts, position eliminated, that kind of thing - there's really nothing for them to contest. And even if they tried, you'd have the right to appeal.

0 coins

This is accurate. My company laid off about 30 of us last spring and I never had any issues. Employer confirmed the separation and my claim was approved within a couple weeks.

0 coins

Does the severance you got affect when your benefits start? I went through something similar and remember being confused about whether the two weeks of severance I received counted as wages that would delay my first payment.

0 coins

Hmm, I'd double-check the exact rules here with NYSDOL directly because it can depend on how the severance was structured. Some severance arrangements can affect your benefit start date, some don't.

0 coins

This is worth asking NYSDOL specifically. I had a lump sum severance and it got allocated over a period of weeks which pushed back when I could collect. Definitely not something to assume on.

0 coins

I hadn't even thought about this, adding it to my list of questions to ask when I call.

0 coins

Why are people so afraid to use something they paid into?? This drives me absolutely crazy. UI taxes come out of your employer's payroll, yes, but those exist so workers like you have a safety net when this exact thing happens. You got laid off through no fault of your own. Apply TODAY. Every week you wait is a week of benefits you're just leaving on the table.

0 coins

You make a fair point. I think it's just the stigma I grew up with around asking for help from any government program.

0 coins

The stigma is real but unemployment is legitimately different from other assistance programs. You were employed, you contributed, now you're between jobs. That's literally what it's for.

0 coins

Preach. I delayed filing for almost three weeks because of the same mental block. Cost myself real money.

0 coins

Here's something worth knowing before you file - you can't get paid for the week you file or the week before it. That's your waiting period, it's baked into the system for everyone. So the sooner you file, the sooner that waiting period is behind you and you can start certifying weekly claims. Each week you delay your filing date is a week of potential benefits gone.

0 coins

Wait, so there's always a waiting week no matter what? I thought maybe I'd get paid for time I'd already been unemployed.

0 coins

Yep, everyone goes through one unpaid waiting week in New York. It's standard. That week gets claimed but not paid. After that your weekly certifications start generating payments.

0 coins

I did not know this when I filed my first claim. Lost a week unnecessarily by putting it off thinking I'd somehow backdate things.

0 coins

Does filing for unemployment impact your taxes? Like do you owe money at the end of the year because of it?

0 coins

Unemployment benefits are taxable income at the federal level and in New York, so yes, you do need to report them. When you file you can choose to have NYSDOL withhold 10% federal and 2.5% state automatically, which I'd strongly recommend to avoid a surprise bill.

0 coins

Oh wow, I had no idea. That's good to know before filing. I'll definitely set up withholding.

0 coins

I'm glad someone asked this because I had no idea either. Withholding it makes way more sense than scrambling to pay a tax bill later.

0 coins

I was in almost your exact position about 18 months ago - first layoff ever, convinced I didn't 'deserve' benefits, worried about some vague negative consequence. My neighbor literally sat me down and said just ask yourself what filing actually costs you. The answer was nothing. I filed, got approved, collected for about 10 weeks while I job searched, found something new, done. Zero negative consequences.

0 coins

This is genuinely what I needed to hear. Did you have to do anything specific during those 10 weeks beyond filing the weekly claims?

0 coins

Yes - you do have to certify weekly by answering questions about your work search activities. NYSDOL requires you to do three job search activities each week and log them. It's not onerous but you have to actually do it and document it.

0 coins

The weekly certification is easy once you get the hang of it. Takes maybe 10 minutes online. The job search log matters though - keep records of every application you submit.

0 coins

What's the actual worst case scenario you're imagining here? I'm asking sincerely because sometimes naming the fear makes it smaller. If you file and you're approved, great. If you file and something flags for adjudication, they look into it and usually resolve it. If you're somehow disqualified, you can appeal. The system has a lot of steps before anything bad actually sticks.

0 coins

Honestly I think the fear is just... general embarrassment? And not understanding the process at all, which makes everything feel scarier than it probably is.

0 coins

Makes total sense. The unknown is always the scariest part. Once you've filed and you can see your claim status in the portal, it feels much more manageable.

0 coins

Adjudication sounds terrifying until you've been through it once. Mine was triggered by a totally routine question about my separation and was resolved in about 10 days with no action needed from me.

0 coins

I want to circle back to the NYSDOL phone situation because I had a genuinely rough time getting answers when I was filing for the first time. If you're someone who learns better by talking to a person rather than reading FAQs, Claimyr is worth trying - I ended up speaking with an actual NYSDOL agent and got straight answers to my separation questions in one conversation rather than piecing together info from forums.

0 coins

That's actually exactly what I think I need - to just talk to someone at NYSDOL who can confirm my situation qualifies. I might try this.

0 coins

Talking to a real NYSDOL rep before you file when it's your first time is genuinely valuable. They can tell you what to expect from the adjudication process if any flags come up.

0 coins

The agents are actually pretty helpful when you can reach one. The barrier is just the phone queue, which is absurd on most days.

0 coins

About the employer thing - I want to clear up a misconception I had when I filed. My boss actually called me after I got laid off and said 'don't worry we won't fight your claim' as if that was a favor. I later learned that unless you quit or were fired for misconduct, there's really nothing for them to fight in the first place. A layoff is a layoff. Your former employer agreeing to it is kind of irrelevant.

0 coins

My manager said something similar and I took it as them doing me a favor. Interesting to know they don't really have grounds to dispute a straight layoff.

0 coins

This is mostly accurate but worth noting that employers can and do dispute claims sometimes even in layoff situations, claiming the person quit or committed misconduct. It's rare with clean layoffs but it happens. That's why having your separation documentation matters.

0 coins

Fair point - keep any paperwork they gave you about the position being eliminated. I had an email from HR that I held onto just in case.

0 coins

My first week certifying I completely forgot to log my job search activities separately and just answered the weekly questions on autopilot. Got a letter asking me to verify my job search for that week and panicked. I had actually done the searches, I just hadn't logged them anywhere trackable. Lesson: keep a simple spreadsheet from day one with dates, company names, job titles, and how you applied.

0 coins

This is super practical advice, thank you. I'll set up a spreadsheet before I even file so I'm ready from the start.

0 coins

This exact tip saved me too. I used a Google Sheet and it made the weekly certification take about 5 minutes because I already had everything written down.

0 coins

The letter asking to verify job searches genuinely scared me the first time. So much easier to just track from the beginning rather than reconstruct everything.

0 coins

For real though, filing for unemployment after a layoff is the system doing exactly what it's supposed to do. I work in HR now and I can tell you we have never once looked at whether a candidate filed for unemployment between jobs. It's not a thing. We look at experience, skills, references. That's it.

0 coins

Hearing this from someone in HR is actually the most reassuring thing in this entire thread, thank you.

0 coins

This is the definitive answer to that coworker myth. HR literally doesn't have access to unemployment claim records and wouldn't care if they did.

0 coins

I always assumed there was some secret database employers checked. Apparently not. Good to know.

0 coins

How long does it normally take to get a decision after you file? I'm asking for someone else who filed last week and hasn't heard anything yet.

0 coins

Typically NYSDOL aims to process straightforward claims within two to three weeks. If the claim gets flagged for adjudication it can stretch out longer, sometimes four to six weeks depending on what needs to be verified.

0 coins

Your person should be checking their Unemployment Services account online regularly - that's usually where status updates show up before any physical mail arrives. If it goes past four weeks with no movement, that's when reaching out to NYSDOL directly makes sense.

0 coins

They've been checking the portal daily and it still shows as processing. Sounds like they're within normal range then. Good to know there's no specific action needed yet.

0 coins

The stigma around applying is real but I think it's generational too. My parents told me growing up that unemployment was a last resort and shameful. When I actually filed last year I realized it was a completely normal administrative process. Filed online in maybe 25 minutes, portal walked me through every question, nothing dramatic.

0 coins

Yeah it's definitely a generational mindset I inherited. My parents would never have filed even if they were struggling.

0 coins

Same experience with my family. The generation that grew up in harder times attached a lot of shame to any government assistance. Unemployment benefits genuinely don't belong in that category though - it's insurance.

0 coins

The 'it's insurance' framing really helped me mentally. You wouldn't feel ashamed of filing a homeowner's insurance claim. This is the same concept.

0 coins

I just want to add - when I had a messy situation involving a partial layoff where I was still working a few hours a week, Claimyr was what finally got me to an agent who actually understood my case. Partial unemployment has its own rules and I couldn't get a clear answer from the website or the automated phone system. The agent I spoke with walked me through exactly how to report my partial wages each week.

0 coins

Partial unemployment is a whole thing I hadn't even considered - what if I pick up some freelance work while I'm looking for a full-time job?

0 coins

You can work and still collect partial benefits as long as you report every dollar you earn when you certify. NYSDOL reduces your benefit amount based on what you earned that week but doesn't necessarily cut you off. The formula is specific though - worth asking an agent about your exact situation.

0 coins

This is accurate. I picked up some gig work during my claim period and reported it faithfully every week. Never had an issue. Just make sure you don't underreport or omit earnings - that's where people get into trouble with overpayment notices.

0 coins

Okay this thread convinced me to finally submit my own claim that's been sitting in draft status for a week. I literally had the same fears as the OP and kept stalling. Submitting it tonight.

0 coins

Let's both do it! Honestly reading everyone's responses here has helped me more than anything else I found online.

0 coins

Both of you, go file right now. The portal is straightforward and you can do it in one sitting. You've got nothing to lose and actual money to potentially gain.

0 coins

Please report back when you both get approved. This thread needs a happy ending.

0 coins

To bring it all together for anyone reading this later - being laid off and filing for UI through NYSDOL is a standard, private process. It won't follow you to future employers, it won't penalize your old employer in a dramatic way, and it won't disqualify you from anything. What you do need to do is file promptly, certify weekly, complete your required job search activities each week, and report any income you earn while collecting. Keep your paperwork from your layoff. Set up tax withholding when you file. And use the Unemployment Services portal to check your status rather than waiting for mail.

0 coins

This is the clearest summary I've seen. Bookmar- wait, I'm saving this whole comment. Thank you to this entire thread for helping me get out of my own head about this.

0 coins

Well said. The practical steps are simple once you strip away the anxiety around it. File, certify, search, report. That's really the whole job while you're between positions.

0 coins

For anyone who gets into their claim and hits a snag that needs a real NYSDOL person to untangle - the phone line is brutal but agents do exist and they can resolve things that the portal and website can't. Worth being persistent about reaching one when you genuinely need help.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure