Back to New York Unemployment

Mateo Silva

If you resign are you eligible for unemployment in NY? My NYSDOL situation explained

I handed in my resignation two months ago from a marketing coordinator position I'd held for about four years. At the time I genuinely felt like I had no choice — my manager had been systematically cutting my hours, changing my schedule without notice, and at one point reassigned most of my core responsibilities to a new hire without any explanation. I finally hit a wall and put in my two weeks. Now I'm sitting here with a pending UI claim and a determination notice that says I may be disqualified because I 'voluntarily left without good cause.' I didn't just quit on a whim — there were real documented issues. I have emails, a written warning I received that felt retaliatory, and records of the schedule changes. My question is: if you resign are you eligible for unemployment in NY, or is that basically an automatic denial? I've heard people say there are exceptions but I can't find clear information about what NYSDOL actually looks for when they decide these cases. My claim has been sitting in adjudication for going on five weeks now and I'm honestly not sure what to expect.

Your situation with the reduced hours and reassigned duties — that actually matters a lot here. NYSDOL doesn't treat every resignation the same way. When someone quits because their employer made the job significantly different or worse in a way a reasonable person couldn't just tolerate, that's what they call 'good cause' for leaving. The bar isn't super low, but schedule manipulation and stripping you of your core duties can absolutely qualify if you can show it was substantial and ongoing. The fact that you have emails is big. Keep all of that.

0 coins

My schedule went from consistent 40-hour weeks to as few as 22 hours over about six weeks, and I never got a written reason for it. Would that kind of documentation be enough or do they want something more formal?

0 coins

Hour reductions that size are definitely the kind of thing that gets flagged as a material change in employment. I'd write out a timeline with dates and hours for each week if you haven't already — that kind of organized evidence tends to land better in adjudication reviews.

0 coins

wait does this only apply if you asked them to fix it first? i thought you had to like formally complain before quitting or they just deny you automatically

0 coins

Five weeks in adjudication is honestly not unusual for a voluntary quit case — those take longer because an adjudicator actually has to review the circumstances rather than it being a straightforward separation. That said, you should probably try to get someone on the phone at NYSDOL to confirm they have your documentation and that your case is actually moving. Calling is the nightmare part.

0 coins

I've tried the main NYSDOL line probably eight times in the past three weeks. Either I sit on hold until it drops or I get the automated message that says the system is at capacity. I haven't been able to reach a single human.

0 coins

My experience with that line was identical — hours wasted and nothing to show for it. It's genuinely one of the most frustrating parts of an already stressful process.

0 coins

My adjudication went on forever and I was doing the same thing — redialing over and over and getting nowhere. Eventually I found Claimyr (claimyr.com) and that's what finally got me in touch with an actual NYSDOL agent. The way it works is it stays on hold with NYSDOL for you, so you end up on the phone with a live agent instead of wasting your whole day redial. There's a video that shows how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE if you want to see before trying it. For a voluntary quit case in adjudication specifically, talking to someone directly can make a real difference because you can ask what documents they have and whether anything else is needed.

0 coins

Had no idea this existed. I'll check out the video tonight — at this point anything that gets me to an actual person is worth trying. Did you have a voluntary quit situation or something different?

0 coins

I used it last spring when my claim got flagged and I had no idea why. Ended up talking to an agent who told me exactly what was missing. Would've taken weeks longer to figure out otherwise.

0 coins

Sounds kind of too good to be true honestly, the NYSDOL phone situation is so bad I've basically stopped trying

0 coins

My skepticism was the same until I actually tried it. The agent I spoke with was able to pull up my claim right there and answer questions I'd been guessing at for weeks.

0 coins

The 'good cause' standard under New York unemployment law comes down to whether a reasonable person in your shoes would have felt they had no real choice but to leave. Courts and NYSDOL have consistently found that a substantial reduction in hours — we're talking 20-25% or more sustained over time — can meet that threshold. Reassignment of duties can too, especially if it changed your job title's core function or effectively demoted you without changing the title. What they also look at is whether you raised the issue with your employer before leaving. Even a documented email or HR complaint goes a long way toward showing you tried to resolve it.

0 coins

There was one email I sent to HR about the schedule situation about three weeks before I resigned. They responded saying they'd 'look into it' and then nothing changed. Does that count as making an effort to fix it, or do they expect you to escalate further?

0 coins

Your HR email is exactly the kind of thing NYSDOL adjudicators look for. It shows you didn't just walk out the door impulsively. The fact that HR acknowledged the issue and then didn't fix it actually strengthens your position — it shows the employer had the chance to address a legitimate problem and chose not to. I'd print that entire email exchange and have it ready.

0 coins

My former coworker had almost the same setup — documented complaints, no resolution, then quit — and she was approved after a pretty thorough adjudication review. It took about seven weeks total but she did get approved.

0 coins

Ugh this whole topic stresses me out because I'm in kind of a similar situation and trying to figure out the same thing. My employer has been making things miserable on purpose I think and I'm worried if I quit I'll just get denied automatically. Is there any way to know ahead of time whether your reason would qualify??

0 coins

Your specific circumstances matter more than any checklist here. The honest answer is there's no way to guarantee approval before you file — NYSDOL decides case by case. What I'd suggest is documenting everything happening right now while it's happening, before you make any decisions about leaving. That paper trail is way more credible than reconstructed timelines after the fact.

0 coins

That's kind of terrifying honestly. So basically I'd be quitting and then hoping they agree my situation was bad enough? There's no like pre-approval process or anything?

0 coins

My coworker asked NYSDOL that exact question by actually getting someone on the phone through Claimyr — she said the agent couldn't tell her what the outcome would be but was able to explain what the adjudicators look for so she knew how to frame her documentation. That ended up being really useful even without a guarantee.

0 coins

People in this thread keep saying 'good cause' like it's simple but it really isn't. I've seen NYSDOL deny cases where the hour reduction was 30% because the person couldn't prove they raised the issue formally before quitting. And I've seen approvals where someone just had a toxic environment with no paper trail because they had a witness. It's genuinely inconsistent.

0 coins

That inconsistency is real and it's frustrating. The adjudicators have discretion and the same set of facts can land differently depending on who reviews it. That's part of why getting your documentation as organized and specific as possible matters — you want to remove as much ambiguity as you can.

0 coins

Exactly, and that's also why I think people in adjudication should try to actually reach someone rather than just waiting. The wait-and-see approach is risky when your case might have a simple fixable issue.

0 coins

wait they have actual humans reviewing each voluntary quit case individually?? i thought it was more automated than that

0 coins

How many weekly claims have you certified since you filed? I ask because some people going through adjudication stop certifying thinking there's no point, and that's a mistake — you need to keep certifying every week even while your case is pending, otherwise you lose those weeks and can't get them back even if you're ultimately approved.

0 coins

Every week without missing one so far, I made sure of that. Though I'll admit the first time I saw 'pending adjudication' on the certification screen I panicked and almost didn't submit it.

0 coins

You did the right thing. A lot of people stop right there and lose weeks of benefits they were owed. As long as you keep certifying and doing your required job search activities each week, you're protecting yourself regardless of how the adjudication turns out.

0 coins

My cousin almost made that exact mistake — stopped certifying after two weeks because he thought the whole claim was rejected. When he finally got approved he only got paid back to when he started certifying again, not from the original filing date. Cost him like three weeks of benefits.

0 coins

Does anyone know if NYSDOL actually contacts your old employer to get their version of why you left? Because I'd be worried about what a vindictive manager might say if they're asked.

0 coins

Your old employer gets notified when you file — they have a window to respond and contest the claim. NYSDOL does consider their account alongside yours. This is another reason documentation matters: contemporaneous evidence like emails and timestamped records is harder to refute than he-said she-said.

0 coins

My former employer disputed my claim and tried to characterize my departure differently than what actually happened. Having written records from before I left was what made the difference — the adjudicator could see the documented timeline, not just competing stories.

0 coins

That's actually really good to know. I was imagining it was basically just my word against theirs with no way to tip the scales.

0 coins

Five weeks feels like a long time but voluntary quit adjudications at NYSDOL really can run six to eight weeks, sometimes longer if the employer disputes it. I know that's not what you want to hear. The good news is the determination will cover all the weeks you've been certifying, so you don't lose those weeks of potential benefits while you wait.

0 coins

Eight weeks is a lot when you're watching your savings drain. I'm managing for now but the uncertainty is the worst part — not knowing whether I'll owe them money or whether I'll actually get paid.

0 coins

Your savings situation is incredibly stressful and I don't want to minimize that. What helped me mentally was treating the weekly certifications as my one controllable thing — keep doing them, keep logging job search activities, and try not to refresh the portal every hour. The outcome is out of your hands at that point.

0 coins

Easier said than done when you're watching your bank balance honestly

0 coins

The job search requirement doesn't pause during adjudication. You're still required to complete the minimum number of job search activities each week and log them — NYSDOL can audit this later and if the records aren't there it creates additional problems on top of the adjudication.

0 coins

I've been doing three contacts per week and logging them through the portal. Is that the right number or has it changed recently?

0 coins

Three per week is the standard requirement for most claimants in New York right now. Keep logging through the Unemployment Services portal with as much detail as the system asks for — employer name, contact method, position applied for, date. The more complete your log the better if it ever gets reviewed.

0 coins

My job search log got audited about two months into my claim and I was so relieved I'd been keeping it detailed. They wanted contact information for every employer listed and I had it all.

0 coins

My voluntary quit adjudication wrapped up last month after seven weeks and I want to share what actually helped move things. I ended up reaching NYSDOL through Claimyr after my own failed marathon of trying the main line. The agent I spoke with told me my file had a documentation gap — they were missing the HR response email I'd submitted through the portal. We wouldn't have known that for who knows how long otherwise. I re-uploaded it during the call and my determination came about ten days later.

0 coins

Ten days after re-uploading the document — that's wild. So there might be something sitting incomplete in my file right now and I'd have no way of knowing without actually talking to someone. That's making me want to try Claimyr tonight.

0 coins

My exact situation was probably different from yours in the specifics but the core problem — a file sitting there with something missing that nobody tells you about — seems to be pretty common based on this thread. Getting eyes on your actual claim status from an agent is worth it.

0 coins

My file had the same kind of issue, a missing form that I'd submitted but that apparently never processed correctly. Only found out when I finally got through to someone. Weeks of waiting avoided if I'd known sooner.

0 coins

Does resigning for health reasons work differently? I keep seeing people say you need 'good cause' but I'm wondering if a medical situation that makes it impossible to keep doing your job counts separately or the same way.

0 coins

Your health circumstances can absolutely constitute good cause under NYSDOL rules, but they look at it somewhat specifically — they want to see that the medical issue was directly connected to the job or working conditions, that you informed the employer and they couldn't accommodate you, and in some cases they want documentation from a healthcare provider. It goes through the same adjudication process but the factors they weigh are different from a situation about hours or duties.

0 coins

That makes sense. So it's not an automatic approval just because you had a medical reason — they still want to see that you tried to make it work first?

0 coins

Exactly right. The pattern NYSDOL looks for is: problem existed, you tried to address it with the employer, employer couldn't or wouldn't fix it, leaving became the only real option. Health situations fit that pattern when you can document the steps.

0 coins

I hate to be the pessimist here but I've known two people who had really solid cases for voluntary quit and both got denied in the first determination. Both ended up having to appeal and one of them won on appeal while the other gave up. The appeal process is a whole additional thing — the tribunal hearings, the waiting. The system really does make you fight for it.

0 coins

My first determination was also a denial and I appealed and won. It's genuinely not uncommon for voluntary quit cases to go that way — the initial adjudication sometimes doesn't fully consider all the evidence, and the tribunal hearing is a more formal process where you can present your case more thoroughly.

0 coins

Did you have a rep at your hearing or did you go in alone? I've heard having someone is better but also that most people can't afford an attorney for this.

0 coins

My hearing I did alone with just my organized documentation. The administrative law judge actually told me my records were unusually thorough. You don't need a lawyer if you have clear evidence — but you do need to be really organized about presenting it.

0 coins

Knowing there's a whole appeal process if the first determination goes wrong is actually kind of reassuring? Like it's not just one shot and done.

0 coins

Okay can I ask something that might be obvious — when they say you have to look for work during adjudication, does that mean they'd actually take away your benefits retroactively if the job search log is incomplete? Like even if you get approved for the voluntary quit issue?

0 coins

Your job search log is a separate requirement from the adjudication issue — they're evaluated independently. So yes, technically you could be approved on the quit question and still have specific weeks disqualified if the job search activities for those weeks weren't completed or logged correctly. It's one of those cases where fixing one thing doesn't automatically fix everything.

0 coins

That is genuinely alarming information that I did not know before. Going to log every single contact I've made going forward.

0 coins

Weekly certification and job search logging are really the two things fully in your control while adjudication is happening. Those are the ones to stay strict about.

0 coins

My department was essentially dissolved and they offered me a different role at reduced pay. I took it at first but left three months later when it was clear the new role wasn't what they described. NYSDOL still treated that as a voluntary quit from a standing job even though the original layoff situation is what set everything in motion. It was really complicated to explain in adjudication.

0 coins

Your timeline involving a role change after a restructuring is exactly the kind of multi-step separation that adjudicators need a clear written narrative to follow. If you haven't already written out a plain-language timeline of the original dissolution, the new offer, what you were told vs. what the role turned out to be, and when you left — that document can help an adjudicator understand a situation that might otherwise look like a simple quit.

0 coins

My written statement I submitted when I filed was pretty long but I tried to include all of that. The adjudication still took over nine weeks so I'm not sure how much it helped streamline things.

0 coins

Nine weeks is brutal. Did it resolve in your favor eventually?

0 coins

Approved finally, yes. The determination letter actually cited the material change in position and pay as the basis, which was validating after all that time.

0 coins

My claim was similar in that it sat in adjudication while I had no idea what was actually happening. I ended up speaking to a NYSDOL agent through Claimyr — that service stays on hold for you so you end up talking to a live agent — and finding out there was a discrepancy between what my employer reported as the reason for my separation and what I'd written in my statement. I was able to submit a clarifying document the same day. The determination came through about two weeks later in my favor.

0 coins

Every time I see someone in this thread mention finding a documentation issue through actually talking to an agent I feel more anxious about what might be sitting in my file right now. I'm definitely going to try to get through tomorrow.

0 coins

My advice is don't wait for the portal to tell you something — it usually won't. The portal gives you a status but not a diagnosis. An actual agent can tell you if there's a discrepancy or missing piece that's holding things up.

0 coins

That gap between what the portal shows and what's actually happening in the file is so real. Status showing 'in review' means nothing about whether something's wrong or not.

0 coins

How long does it typically take to receive the actual determination letter after the adjudicator makes their decision? I ask because I've seen some people say they found out through the portal first and others say the letter came out of nowhere.

0 coins

Your Unemployment Services account portal usually updates before the physical letter arrives in the mail. The letter might come days later. I'd keep checking the portal, especially the message center — the determination is usually posted there first with an explanation of the decision and your options if you disagree.

0 coins

My portal has honestly been kind of glitchy so I never fully trust what it's showing. Good to know the message center specifically is where to look.

0 coins

My determination showed up in the message center on a Thursday evening — I almost missed it because I'd stopped checking as obsessively. Would recommend setting a reminder to check every few days at minimum.

0 coins

For anyone reading this who's still early in the process and hasn't filed yet — if you're thinking about resigning and want to try to preserve your options, documenting conditions before you leave is so much easier than reconstructing them afterward. Screenshots of communications, copies of scheduling emails, any HR responses, notes with dates. Future you will be grateful.

0 coins

Wish I'd seen advice like this two months ago. I did save most of the scheduling emails but there were some verbal conversations with my manager that I wish I'd followed up on in writing at the time. Those are the gaps I'm worried about.

0 coins

Your email records and HR exchange are still a solid foundation. The verbal stuff — if you can remember specific dates and what was said, writing a contemporaneous summary now (noting that it's written from memory) is better than nothing. It's just weaker than a document from the time.

0 coins

My biggest regret from my claim was not sending follow-up emails after verbal conversations with HR. 'Per our conversation today...' emails feel awkward but they create a paper trail that matters a lot later.

0 coins

What actually happens at the adjudication interview if they call you? Do you have to have all your documents in front of you? I've been reading conflicting things about whether it's always a formal interview or sometimes just a document review.

0 coins

Your adjudication might or might not involve a phone interview — NYSDOL handles voluntary quit cases differently depending on complexity. For some cases they make a determination based solely on the written record, the separation statement and any documents submitted. Others get a phone interview with the adjudicator. If they do schedule one, you'll get a notice and they'll give you a date and time. Having your documentation accessible during that call is helpful.

0 coins

So it's possible they already have everything they need and are just reviewing it without ever contacting me? The waiting in silence is what's making this hard.

0 coins

My adjudication was entirely document-based — I never got an interview call, just a determination notice. The silence is normal even though it feels like nothing is happening.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure