Back to New York Unemployment

Luca Esposito

How to stop receiving unemployment benefits in NY - NYSDOL process explained

So I landed a full-time position after about four months of collecting UI benefits through NYSDOL and I want to make sure I handle this correctly on the way out. I keep reading conflicting stuff online about how to stop receiving unemployment benefits and I'm honestly not sure what the right steps are. Do I just... stop filing my weekly claims? Do I need to call NYSDOL and officially close my claim? Or does the system automatically figure it out when I report my new job and earnings? I started the new job this Monday and I already have my first week of hours to report. The last thing I want is to accidentally trigger an overpayment situation because I did the paperwork wrong on the way out. My whole experience with NYSDOL has been pretty smooth so I don't want to mess it up at the end. Anyone who's been through this transition - what's the actual process here?

Week six of my claim I went through almost exactly this same situation. The honest answer is that stopping is simpler than starting - you don't need to phone NYSDOL or formally close anything. What you do is file your next weekly claim and report your full earnings from the new job honestly. If those earnings push you above your weekly benefit amount, NYSDOL calculates it out and you'll receive nothing (or a reduced amount depending on the math). Then you just stop filing after that. The claim stays open technically but it goes dormant on its own. You have up to a year from your original claim date to reopen it if something goes wrong with the new job, which is worth knowing.

0 coins

Got it - so the main thing is I keep filing while I'm reporting earnings from the new job, not just go silent?

0 coins

My first week at a new job I made the mistake of just stopping cold without reporting the earnings and NYSDOL flagged it as a discrepancy. Had to send in documentation proving I was employed. Definitely report everything even if the benefit ends up being zero dollars that week.

0 coins

This is accurate. The partial earnings formula in NY is you keep 25% of your weekly benefit amount before your benefits start reducing dollar for dollar. So depending on your WBA and your first week's pay you might still get a small payment that first week even with full-time hours.

0 coins

My claim had a weird overlap period that caused me headaches for weeks so I want to share what I learned. When you report earnings in your weekly certification, NYSDOL asks for gross wages earned that week (not what you get paid, but what you EARNED - so if you worked Monday through Friday of a claim week, report all five days of earnings even if the actual paycheck doesn't hit your account until the following Friday). A lot of people mess this up and report based on when they get paid rather than when they worked, which creates discrepancies later.

0 coins

Wait, earned vs. paid - that's a really important distinction I didn't know about. So for my first week Monday through Friday, I report those earnings on the weekly claim for that specific week?

0 coins

Yes exactly. NYSDOL goes by when wages are earned, not deposited. I had a whole adjudication issue because I reported by pay date instead of work date and had to submit my offer letter and first paystub to clear it up. Took three weeks to resolve.

0 coins

earned not paid yes this tripped me up too lol

0 coins

My HR department actually told me the wrong thing about this when I asked them - they said to report when I get paid. NYSDOL's own website says earnings are reported for the week in which they're earned. Always go by the NYSDOL instructions, not your employer's HR.

0 coins

My situation when I went back to work was that I had a question about partial benefits during my transition week and I could NOT get through to anyone at NYSDOL for like five days straight. Tried early morning, tried midday, kept hitting the automated system and getting disconnected. A friend told me about Claimyr (claimyr.com) - it basically waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up on the phone with a live agent without sitting there for hours yourself. There's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. I used it and finally got my question answered in one shot. For something like stopping your claim correctly, it might be worth having that direct conversation with an agent just to be sure.

0 coins

Five days without getting through sounds absolutely brutal. I'll keep that in mind if I end up needing to actually speak to someone about my transition week.

0 coins

NYSDOL phone lines are genuinely one of the most frustrating parts of the whole UI experience. I spent three weeks trying to reach someone about an unrelated adjudication issue and never got through. Good to know there's something that can help with the hold time.

0 coins

My work schedule makes it impossible to sit and wait on hold, so I've been looking for exactly this kind of option. Thanks for sharing.

0 coins

My last day of benefits I was so paranoid I called NYSDOL to triple-check my final week certification. The agent told me something I hadn't seen written anywhere: if you have a remaining balance on your claim (meaning your benefit year hasn't expired and you haven't used up all your weeks), that balance just sits there. You don't need to do anything with it. If the new job doesn't work out within a year of your original claim date, you can reopen and pick up where you left off without filing a whole new claim.

0 coins

Year from the original claim date - does that mean the date I first applied, or the date my claim was approved?

0 coins

My understanding is from when your benefit year started, which is typically the week you filed the initial claim. The notice you got when your claim was approved should show your benefit year begin and end dates.

0 coins

I tried to reopen a claim once and the year had technically expired by like two weeks. Had to file a whole new claim and go through the whole base period calculation again. So keep track of that date if there's any chance you might need to come back to it.

0 coins

My benefit year end date showed up in my Unemployment Services account under the claim summary section. Easy to find once you know to look for it.

0 coins

I went through this in the spring and want to clear up something I believed for the longest time that turned out to be wrong. I thought you HAD to call NYSDOL to cancel or stop your benefits officially - like there was some formal cancellation process. My former coworker had warned me about this and I spent like two days trying to get through on the phone because of it. Turns out the weekly certification IS the entire mechanism. When you stop certifying, benefits stop. That's it. The only reason to contact NYSDOL is if you have a specific question about your transition week earnings calculation or if something looks off in your account afterward.

0 coins

My cousin told me the same wrong thing about needing to formally cancel. This misconception seems really widespread.

0 coins

Genuinely relieved to hear this - the idea of having to navigate a cancellation process on top of everything else starting a new job was stressing me out.

0 coins

My stress level went way down once I understood the weekly cert is the whole thing. Report your earnings, see what NYSDOL sends you (possibly nothing), then just stop certifying when you're comfortable the transition is clean.

0 coins

My job search requirements question when I went back to work - does anyone know if you have to keep logging job search activities during the transition week when you're reporting new employment? I always forget which requirements stay active until your benefits fully stop vs. which ones end when you get the job offer.

0 coins

My claim supervisor actually addressed this in a letter. The job search activity requirement applies to weeks in which you're certifying as fully unemployed and available for work. Once you're reporting employment on your weekly certification, you're not certifying as unemployed anymore, so the job search activity requirement doesn't apply the same way. If you're partially employed and still receiving some benefit amount, technically the requirements could still apply - worth confirming with NYSDOL for your specific situation.

0 coins

That makes sense - I figured the job search log requirement would tie to the certification status. I'll check my account to see if it still shows as a requirement when I certify with earnings.

0 coins

My experience with this was confusing because the weekly cert form still shows the job search section even when you're reporting full-time earnings. I ended up entering my new employer's information in the job search section just to be safe and nothing bad happened. An agent can give you the definitive answer on whether that's required in your situation - I used Claimyr to reach someone at NYSDOL when I had a similar question during my own transition week and they clarified it quickly.

0 coins

My claim went inactive a few years before my recent one and I want to point out the difference between letting a claim go dormant naturally vs. having your claim actually expire. Dormant just means you stopped certifying but the benefit year is still active. Expired means your benefit year end date has passed. These are very different situations and it matters if you need to file again later. A dormant claim within the benefit year = reopen it easily through Unemployment Services online. An expired claim = file a new claim and go through the whole eligibility determination again.

0 coins

Dormant vs expired - this is a distinction I would never have thought to ask about. How do I confirm my claim is in dormant status vs something else if I wanted to check?

0 coins

My Unemployment Services account shows claim status directly on the main dashboard. If your benefit year end date hasn't passed and you haven't exhausted your weeks, it'll show something like 'claim open' or similar. I'd log in and look at your claim summary after your last certification week to see the status reflected.

0 coins

I checked mine after stopping and it showed as open with remaining balance for months. Never needed to do anything with it - just sat there until the benefit year ran out.

0 coins

My first week of new employment I was so stressed about the partial benefit calculation that I actually wrote out the math by hand before certifying. For anyone who wants to understand the formula before they certify: NY uses a system where your first 25% of your weekly benefit amount is disregarded, and then benefits reduce dollar for dollar after that. So if your WBA is $400 and you earned $600 in the transition week, here's how it works - $400 times 0.25 equals $100 disregarded, then $600 minus $100 equals $500 countable earnings, $500 is greater than your $400 WBA so your benefit for that week would be zero. But if your WBA is $500 and you earned $400 gross, $500 times 0.25 equals $125 disregarded, $400 minus $125 equals $275 countable, $500 minus $275 equals $225 benefit payment. The partial benefit can still be meaningful during transition weeks.

0 coins

This math is incredibly helpful, thank you. I had no idea there was a 25% disregard built in - that changes my mental model of how partial benefits work.

0 coins

My weekly benefit amount calculation also surprised me when I first learned about the disregard. It's actually more generous than I expected compared to some other states I've heard about.

0 coins

wait so i might still get some money the first week even if im working full time hours?? nobody explained this to me when i started my job last month

0 coins

Depending on your wage rate and your WBA yes it's possible. Run the math with your actual numbers. If you undereported earnings you should contact NYSDOL to correct it.

0 coins

My benefits stopped abruptly a few months ago and I didn't understand why until I realized I'd been certifying correctly and simply hit my maximum weeks. When you're thinking about how to stop receiving unemployment benefits on purpose, it's worth knowing that the system also stops you automatically in two ways: you exhaust your maximum weeks, or your benefit year expires. Either way the claim closes on its own. The voluntary stopping (just ceasing to certify) is the same end result, just initiated by you instead of the system running out.

0 coins

Makes sense that the system has its own natural stopping points regardless of what I do. Good to have the full picture.

0 coins

My claim actually expired before I used all my weeks because I found work. Had remaining weeks on the books when the benefit year ended and those weeks just disappear - you can't carry them over to a new claim.

0 coins

I did not know you couldn't roll unused weeks into a new benefit year. That's unfortunate. Though I guess it makes sense from a program design standpoint.

0 coins

My only regret going through this process was not asking sooner about the tax implications of stopping mid-year. Benefits are taxable income and NYSDOL withholds federal taxes if you opted in - but once benefits stop, you should update your W-4 at your new employer accordingly. Also, at the end of the year you'll get a 1099-G from NYSDOL showing what you received in UI benefits, which you need to include in your tax filing even for the partial year.

0 coins

Oh wow I hadn't even thought about the 1099-G yet. Good reminder that the administrative stuff doesn't fully end when the weekly certs stop.

0 coins

My accountant flagged the 1099-G issue for me. The withholding settings you chose at the start of your claim are worth reviewing before year-end to make sure you're not under-withheld.

0 coins

My tax surprise was significant the year I collected UI without withholding - I owed a lot come April. If you haven't been withholding from your benefits, make sure to set something aside or adjust your new employer withholding to compensate.

0 coins

My situation involved a return-to-work offer from my former employer partway through my claim, which introduced a whole additional layer of complexity I wasn't prepared for. The key thing I learned: if you have a return-to-work offer, NYSDOL considers the date you could have returned, not necessarily the date you actually started, when evaluating ongoing eligibility. If you delay a return-to-work offer without good cause, it can affect your eligibility going back to when the offer was made. This is different from accepting outside employment, but I wanted to flag it since some people in similar situations might be reading this thread.

0 coins

My situation is a completely new employer, not a former one, so I think this doesn't apply to me - but that's a genuinely important nuance for others.

0 coins

My ex-employer actually reported my return date incorrectly to NYSDOL when I went back and I had to submit documentation to correct it. Employer-reported information and your own certification have to match - if they don't, NYSDOL investigates the discrepancy.

0 coins

I had no idea employers report information back to NYSDOL. I thought it was all self-reported on the claimant side.

0 coins

My shock at discovering that was real. Employers get notices from NYSDOL and respond with wage and return-to-work information. It cross-references against your certifications.

0 coins

My phone situation during my claim transition was genuinely terrible - I had a question about whether my signing bonus counted as wages in the week I received it and I could not get a human on the line for over a week. Eventually a coworker mentioned Claimyr and I tried it. Ended up speaking with a NYSDOL agent who told me signing bonuses are typically considered wages in the week received and needed to be reported. Would have never known without that call.

0 coins

Signing bonus as wages in the week received - that's another thing that would have tripped me up. I don't have one but good to know the principle.

0 coins

My bonus question was similar - I had a performance bonus hit in my last month of certification and wasn't sure how to handle it. These edge cases are exactly why having access to an actual agent matters.

0 coins

My experience with Claimyr was similar - I had a very specific question that the NYSDOL website FAQ didn't cover and the agent I reached through it knew the answer immediately. Way better than trying to interpret the website language on your own.

0 coins

My fourth week of a new job I noticed my Unemployment Services account still showed my claim as active and briefly panicked that benefits were still somehow being issued even though I'd stopped certifying. Logged in more carefully and realized the account just stays open and shows the claim as active until the benefit year end date - it doesn't update to 'closed' the moment you stop certifying. If you see that and wonder if something is wrong, check the last payment date shown in your payment history instead to confirm no payments are going out.

0 coins

Payment history section to verify - noted. I'll check that after my first transition week certification just to make sure the math shook out the way I expected.

0 coins

omg i had the same mini panic when i saw my account still said active. thought id been collecting by accident somehow

0 coins

My bank account was easier to check than the portal honestly - once I stopped seeing deposits I knew I was clear. But the payment history in the portal is the official record.

0 coins

My unemployment claim taught me that the online Unemployment Services portal at labor.ny.gov actually has a lot more information than most claimants ever look at. Under your claim details you can see your original monetary determination, your remaining weeks balance, your benefit year end date, and your complete payment history. If you're trying to figure out how to stop receiving unemployment benefits correctly, that summary page tells you everything you need to know about where your claim stands before you make your final certification.

0 coins

I'll do a full review of that claims detail page before I certify this week. I've honestly only ever used the portal to file my weekly certs and never dug into the full claim summary.

0 coins

My first month on UI I didn't even know half those fields existed on the portal. The monetary determination letter that shows your WBA and your remaining weeks is worth saving as a PDF so you have it for reference.

0 coins

The remaining weeks balance counter is useful to watch as you approach the end - it updates after each payment is processed. When you stop certifying you'll see that counter freeze at whatever weeks remain unused.

0 coins

My transition off unemployment was about eight months ago now and I want to offer a final reassurance to OP and anyone else anxious about this: the system is genuinely forgiving about the stopping process as long as you keep certifying honestly while you have earnings to report. The overpayment situations that become serious problems are almost always from people who stop certifying without reporting earnings, or who keep certifying without reporting earnings. The honest path through - report what you earned, get whatever you get (or zero), then stop certifying - has very little margin for error.

0 coins

Honest certification through the transition and then stop - that's the clearest summary of this whole thread. Thank you to everyone who responded. This community is genuinely one of the most helpful corners of the internet for navigating NYSDOL stuff.

0 coins

My sign-off advice would just be to screenshot your final certification confirmation and save your last payment notice from NYSDOL for your records. Having that documentation is useful if anything ever gets questioned down the road.

0 coins

My records from my last claim saved me when I filed again two years later and NYSDOL had questions about my prior benefit year. Keep everything - correspondence, payment history, determination letters - at least through your next tax filing season.

0 coins

My records habit now is to export the full payment history PDF from Unemployment Services before my benefit year expires. After it expires you lose some of the online history access. Get it while you can.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure