Back to New York Unemployment

Omar Zaki

How much is unemployment city workers in NY get from NYSDOL?

So I work for the city - sanitation department, been there going on 11 years now. My whole crew got hit with a temporary layoff notice last week, some budget restructuring thing they're doing, and I'm trying to figure out what I'd actually be bringing in if I file for unemployment. I know the NYSDOL has formulas and stuff but I honestly don't understand any of it. My base pay is around $72,000 a year. Does being a city employee change how much you get? I've heard city workers sometimes get treated differently with UI claims. And do they look at gross pay or take-home when they calculate your weekly benefit amount? I want to know if I can actually cover my rent and groceries on whatever UI pays before I commit to filing. Any city workers out there who've done this?

City worker here, transit actually. The formula NYSDOL uses - they look at your highest earning quarter in your base period, which is roughly the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before you file. For most people making around $72k annually, your highest quarter is probably somewhere around $18,000. They take 1/26th of that highest quarter amount, so you'd be looking at roughly $692 a week. The state max right now caps at $504 for most standard claims though, so you'd hit the ceiling. Being a city employee doesn't disqualify you or change the formula itself - what matters is whether the city contests the claim.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

Author

Wait, the max is $504? That feels really low for NYC. My rent alone is $1,650 a month. So no matter what I earned, I'm capped there?

0 coins

The cap hasn't moved much in years, that's the frustrating part. City employees I know have all hit that same ceiling. The city being your employer doesn't usually mean they fight the claim harder, but sanitation specifically sometimes has union agreements that affect things - worth checking with your rep.

0 coins

Yeah the cap is what it is unfortunately. Though there's a $26 dependent allowance per dependent you can add on top, up to a few of them, which helps a little if you have kids.

0 coins

Trying to get anyone at NYSDOL on the phone is a whole ordeal. I burned through almost two full weeks of mornings before I got anything done. A coworker of mine put me onto Claimyr - it basically sits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up actually talking to a live agent instead of getting the busy signal loop forever. Site is claimyr.com and there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. Got my benefit amount question answered plus they fixed a wage record issue I didn't even know I had.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

Author

Two weeks of mornings is insane. Did your wage records being wrong affect how much you were getting paid out?

0 coins

Mine were off by almost a full quarter of reported wages. The agent corrected it on the spot and my weekly benefit amount went up. Would've never known without reaching someone.

0 coins

Honestly the hold times at NYSDOL are brutal no matter when you try. 7am, noon, 3pm - doesn't seem to matter anymore.

0 coins

Does anyone know if city employees get unemployment differently because the city is self-insured? I heard something about that once and now I'm paranoid my claim is gonna get stuck.

0 coins

New York City is indeed a reimbursing employer meaning they pay unemployment costs directly to the state rather than through the tax pool. What that means for you practically is that the city has a financial reason to review claims carefully, but it doesn't block you from filing or change your weekly benefit amount calculation at all. Your eligibility and payment are determined the same way.

0 coins

Okay that's slightly reassuring but also kind of scary that they're watching more closely. Do they usually contest city worker claims or just let them go through?

0 coins

My layoff from a city agency went through without any issue, no contest, approved in about 10 days. Yours being a budget layoff should be even cleaner since there's no misconduct angle.

0 coins

the $504 max is brutal man. i did the math when i was laid off from my city job in 2023 and basically it covers like half of real life expenses in this city. make sure you apply for the dependent allowance if you have kids, every bit adds up

0 coins

Omar Zaki

Author

No kids but yeah I'm looking at a serious budget crunch. Did you end up getting approved pretty fast or did it take forever?

0 coins

took about 3 weeks for first payment, the weekly claims process after that is easy tho, just the initial waiting period that gets you

0 coins

My layoff paperwork came on a Thursday and I filed that same Friday. The base period thing tripped me up at first - I kept thinking they looked at my most recent paycheck which they don't. They go back further than you'd expect. For anyone in a similar spot, the NYSDOL website has a base period calculator that actually helps clarify which quarters they're pulling from.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

Author

Where on the NYSDOL site is that calculator? I've been hunting around and can't find it easily.

0 coins

If you go to labor.ny.gov and search 'benefit rate calculator' it should come up. It's not super prominent but it's there. Plug in your quarterly wages and it'll show you the estimated weekly benefit amount.

0 coins

I used that calculator before I filed and it was pretty accurate - came within $8 of what I actually got approved for.

0 coins

ELEVEN YEARS and they just hand you a layoff notice?? I'm sorry but city jobs are supposed to be stable that's literally the whole trade-off. The benefit amount not covering real NYC costs on top of that is such an insult. I went through this two years ago and was absolutely furious the entire time I was collecting.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

Author

Budget cuts hit different when you thought you were locked in. I'm not even angry yet, just in shock mode trying to figure out the numbers.

0 coins

the shock wears off and then the anger kicks in. just warning you. get your union involved immediately if you haven't already, they sometimes know ways to accelerate the claims process or at least make sure the city doesn't drag their feet on the wage verification.

0 coins

The union angle is real. Mine got involved with my layoff paperwork and it moved noticeably faster through the initial review stage.

0 coins

Filing online through the NYSDOL Unemployment Services portal is way less painful than trying to do it over the phone. The portal lets you enter your work history, your reason for separation, everything. You can also check your claim status there once it's filed. Just make sure your city employment wages show up correctly when they populate - sometimes the quarterly wage data has a lag.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

Author

Wages having a lag is exactly what I'd be worried about. How do you catch that early?

0 coins

After you file, check your 'monetary determination' letter which comes either by mail or in your NYSDOL portal inbox. It lists the exact wages they used for each quarter. If a quarter looks wrong or missing, that's when you need to get someone at NYSDOL on the phone to get it corrected before your first payment.

0 coins

This is the right move. Catching a wage discrepancy early saves so much headache versus trying to fix it after payments already started at a wrong amount.

0 coins

My first week of collecting, I got confused about the waiting week. NYSDOL has this thing where your first week is basically a waiting period and you don't get paid for it even if you file your weekly claim correctly. I didn't realize it and thought my claim was broken somehow. Spent days trying to reach someone before figuring out it was normal.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

Author

Is the waiting week still a thing? I thought I heard they changed that at some point.

0 coins

Still a thing as of when I filed last spring. You certify for it and it shows up as a valid week but you don't receive money for that first one.

0 coins

Confirmed still happening. It's baked into how the system works - think of your effective claim date and then week two is when payment actually starts flowing.

0 coins

Weekly certification is where people mess up. You have to certify every single week during your designated claim week, usually Sunday through Saturday, and you have to honestly report any work or earnings during that period. Even partial earnings get reported and they just reduce your benefit proportionally rather than cutting it off entirely.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

Author

What if I pick up some part-time work while laid off? Does that immediately end my UI benefits?

0 coins

Part-time work while collecting doesn't end your claim at all. You report the gross earnings, NYSDOL reduces your benefit by a portion of what you earned, and you keep collecting the difference. It's actually encouraged because you still get something and you're bringing in income.

0 coins

I didn't know the reduction was partial and not total. That changes how I think about taking any temp work during my claim.

0 coins

Tried calling NYSDOL myself for three weeks straight about a wage record question - kept getting the 'high call volume' message and getting cut off. My neighbor mentioned Claimyr to me and I figured why not. Ended up speaking with an actual NYSDOL rep who walked me through the whole wage record situation. Would've been impossible to sort out otherwise at that point.

0 coins

Three weeks straight and nothing? That's the kind of thing that makes people just give up on the whole claim.

0 coins

Honestly almost did give up. The issue was that one of my employers hadn't properly reported my wages and I had no way to flag it without talking to someone. Got it sorted through the agent.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

Author

Wage records being wrong seems like a bigger risk than I realized going into this.

0 coins

You mentioned your pay is around $72k. Just so you're clear on the math: $72k divided by 4 quarters is $18k per quarter assuming it's evenly distributed. NYSDOL takes that $18k and divides by 26 to get your weekly benefit amount. $18,000 ÷ 26 = $692, but since the state max is $504, that's what you'd receive. Dependent allowances can add $26 per dependent on top of that up to I believe 3 or so dependents.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

Author

$504 a week works out to about $2,180 a month. My rent is $1,650 so it's technically survivable but just barely with nothing else left.

0 coins

Welcome to NYC unemployment math. Most people here are in the same squeeze. The 26 weeks maximum duration at least gives you time to land something else without it running out immediately.

0 coins

26 weeks goes faster than you'd think tho. start job searching seriously from week one not week twelve

0 coins

does the city being your employer mean they can say you weren't really laid off and just deny the whole thing? i'm asking because my uncle worked for a city agency and his claim got contested even though he definitely got laid off

0 coins

Claims can get contested by any employer including city agencies, but a budget-driven layoff is about as clean a separation reason as it gets for unemployment purposes. If your uncle's got contested, it usually means there was some paperwork discrepancy or the agency listed a different separation reason. The claimant almost always wins a properly documented budget layoff contest.

0 coins

his was weird because they said he 'resigned' in the paperwork even though he definitely didn't. took him like two months to get it sorted through an appeal.

0 coins

Separation reason mismatch is the most common reason city employee claims get held up. Worth verifying that whatever your agency puts in their paperwork matches what you're submitting as your reason for separation.

0 coins

I want to add some color on the job search requirements since it'll come up for you. While you're collecting, NYSDOL requires three job search activities per week. That includes applying to jobs but also things like reaching out to your union about work referrals, attending a career fair, or doing certain career-related things. As a sanitation worker with union membership, your union referral activities count toward your weekly job search requirement.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

Author

Union referrals count as job search activities? That's actually useful since my local is likely going to be working the placement angle anyway.

0 coins

They do count. Keep a log of every contact, date, what you did, outcome. NYSDOL can audit your job search record at any time and you need to be able to produce documentation. It doesn't have to be fancy, a simple spreadsheet works fine.

0 coins

The job search log audit is real - happened to me. Having everything documented made it completely stress-free. People who don't keep records apparently get panicked when they get the audit letter.

0 coins

Just got through my own NYSDOL claim process last month for a totally different industry but same city. The portal itself is fine but their response time for anything that needs a human is legitimately awful. My monetary determination letter took 19 days to show up in the portal.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

Author

19 days is a long wait. Were you able to certify weekly and get paid while waiting for the determination letter?

0 coins

You can certify before the determination letter arrives but payment doesn't start processing until the monetary determination is done. So you're doing the weekly certifications but nothing moves until that letter hits.

0 coins

This delay is what causes people to blow up their emergency savings unnecessarily because they don't realize there's a gap between filing and actual payment.

0 coins

Came across Claimyr while trying to handle a situation where NYSDOL had the wrong employer listed in my claim. Needed a live person to fix it and the phone line was absolutely useless for weeks. Tried Claimyr and it handled the hold for me - finally got an agent on the line and they corrected it same day. If your wage records end up being off, that kind of thing is exactly when you need to reach someone.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

Author

Wrong employer listed sounds like a nightmare. How does something like that even happen?

0 coins

My last employer before filing had a parent company name that showed up differently in the state wage system than what I knew them as. Small thing but it flagged my claim for review.

0 coins

Data mismatches between what employers report to the state and what employees know about their own employer are more common than people realize. Always verify your monetary determination details carefully.

0 coins

Every city worker should know that NYSDOL can't just sit on your claim forever without issuing either an approval or a denial. If your claim has been pending for more than 21 days with no monetary determination and no explanation, you have grounds to escalate. Document every portal login and every phone attempt - timestamps matter if it ever goes to a complaint.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

Author

How do you even escalate if you can't reach anyone on the phone?

0 coins

There's a written complaint process through the NY Department of Labor and you can contact your local state assembly representative's office - they have caseworkers who deal with NYSDOL delays regularly and can often unstick a claim faster than anything else.

0 coins

The assembly rep office angle is underrated. My aunt used that and her pending claim got resolved within 48 hours of that office making a call on her behalf.

0 coins

In 2024 my layoff was temporary like yours sounds like it might be. NYSDOL has a standby status you can request if your employer expects to bring you back within 8 weeks. If you're approved for standby, you don't have to do the weekly job search activities while still collecting. Might be worth asking your union rep if the layoff has a return date attached.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

Author

The layoff notice did mention 'subject to recall' but no specific date. Would that qualify for standby?

0 coins

Subject to' recall language is exactly what NYSDOL looks for in a standby request. File for standby status when you submit your initial claim and explain the recall situation.'They ll determine eligibility. If approved you check a box on your weekly certification saying'you re on standby rather than logging job searchactivities.

0 coins

Standby is specifically designed for situations like this. Many people don't know it exists and do all the job search requirements unnecessarily when they're just waiting to go back to their same job.

0 coins

Standby approval isn't guaranteed but with 11 years at sanitation and a recall clause in the layoff notice, that's a solid standby application.

0 coins

Is there any difference in what you get if the layoff becomes permanent versus staying temporary? Like does NYSDOL treat the claim differently if recall never actually happens?

0 coins

Your weekly benefit amount stays identical regardless of whether the layoff stays temporary or becomes permanent. The difference is administrative - if standby status expires because recall didn't happen in time, your status changes to a standard claim and job search requirements kick in going forward. Your payment amount doesn't change.

0 coins

Standby can be extended in some cases if the recall date gets pushed out. The request for extension has to be made before the original standby period expires though, not after.

0 coins

For the rent situation, worth knowing NYC has emergency rental assistance programs that exist separately from UI. If your UI benefit amount genuinely can't cover housing costs, programs through HRA exist independently of your unemployment claim status and don't affect your UI eligibility.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

Author

HRA programs - is that something you apply for separately or does it link somehow to the NYSDOL claim?

0 coins

Completely separate application process, different agency entirely. UI and HRA assistance don't affect each other's eligibility calculations. You can receive both simultaneously if you qualify for both.

0 coins

The fact that these systems don't talk to each other is both annoying and actually useful when you're in a crunch. Apply for everything available to you at the same time rather than waiting to see how one plays out first.

0 coins

My brother in a similar situation used Claimyr to get through to NYSDOL when he had a certification issue eating into his payment. Got an agent at NYSDOL who resolved it on the first try. The standby status thing mentioned above is actually worth confirming by phone with an agent since the portal doesn't always make it obvious whether your request was actually received and processing.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

Author

Certification issues affecting payment is exactly the scenario keeping me up at night. Good to know there's a way to actually reach someone when that happens.

0 coins

Confirming standby by phone is genuinely good advice. I submitted mine through the portal and it showed no status for days. Agent confirmed they had it and it was just in queue - saved me from refiling the same request twice.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure