How do you stop unemployment benefits with NYSDOL?
I've been collecting unemployment for about four months now and I actually landed a full-time position starting next Monday. Really relieved, but now I'm sitting here staring at my Unemployment Services account wondering what exactly I need to do to close everything out properly. I don't want to accidentally certify for a week I'm not supposed to, and I definitely don't want NYSDOL sending me an overpayment notice six months from now saying I owe them money back. When I filed my first weekly claim I remember there being a question about whether I worked or earned wages that week, but I'm not 100% sure if just answering that correctly is enough to close the claim or if I need to do something else. Do I call them? Send something in writing? Just stop certifying? I've seen conflicting things online and I'm getting nervous about doing it wrong.
51 comments

GalaxyGlider
My first week back at work I had that exact same panic — I went looking for a 'close my claim' button and there isn't one, which threw me off completely. The honest answer is you mostly just stop certifying. When your new job starts, the week your earnings kick in, you report those wages on your weekly claim like normal. NYSDOL calculates whether you earned over your weekly benefit rate and if so, you get zero for that week. After a few weeks of reporting wages that wipe out your benefit, the system essentially goes dormant. No formal close-out form required. That said, I'd really suggest getting a live agent on the phone to confirm your specific situation, especially if your start date falls in the middle of a benefit week. I'd been trying to reach NYSDOL for days and kept hitting the busy signal wall, so I ended up using Claimyr — claimyr.com — which waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up talking directly to a live agent. There's a demo video at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE if you want to see how it works before trying it. Saved me a lot of frustration and I actually got my questions answered the same day.
0 coins
Emma Davis
AuthorMy new job starts on a Wednesday, right in the middle of a NYSDOL benefit week (they run Sunday to Saturday if I remember right). So I'd be working part of the week and not the other part. That's exactly the kind of edge case I was worried about — I'll definitely look into getting someone on the phone before I certify that first partial week.
0 coins
Malik Robinson
My experience matched this — I just reported my earnings honestly on the weekly claim and after two weeks of wages I was making too much to get benefits, the claim just sat there and eventually I got a notice that it had expired. No drama at all.
0 coins
Isabella Silva
Your point about reporting wages correctly that first partial week is key. I've seen people get overpayment notices specifically because they assumed they should just skip certifying entirely rather than certifying and reporting their earnings. NYSDOL wants the weekly certification completed with accurate wage info even if the benefit amount comes out to zero.
0 coins
Ravi Choudhury
The benefit week question is the part that tripped me up when I went back to work. NYSDOL's benefit weeks run Sunday through Saturday, so if you start a job on, say, a Thursday, you technically worked three days in that benefit week. You still certify for that week and report however much you earned those three days. If your gross earnings for those three days exceed your weekly benefit amount, you get nothing for that week. If they're under it, you might still get a partial payment. Either way, you certify and report — you don't skip.
0 coins
Emma Davis
AuthorMy gross weekly pay at the new job will definitely be higher than my weekly benefit amount, so I'm guessing the payment for that partial week just zeros out. But I still need to certify and report those earnings rather than just go silent, right? I want to make sure I understand the sequence.
0 coins
Freya Andersen
Your read is correct. Silence looks like fraud to their system — if you just stop certifying without reporting the reason, you can end up with a fraud flag or at minimum a confusing adjudication situation that takes weeks to unravel. Always certify and report accurately, even if the benefit ends up being zero.
0 coins
Omar Farouk
My sister stopped certifying cold turkey when she got her job and six months later got a letter asking why she stopped and whether she was still eligible during those weeks she went silent. Caused a whole mess. Report the wages and let the math do the work.
0 coins
CosmicCadet
There's also the question of when your claim officially expires versus when you close it. UI claims in New York last for a year from the date you established the claim, and your maximum benefit amount is calculated at the start. If you go back to work, stop certifying, and then get laid off again within that same benefit year, you might actually be able to reopen the same claim rather than filing a new one — as long as you still have a remaining balance. Worth knowing before you mentally 'close' the claim.
0 coins
Emma Davis
AuthorMy claim was opened back in October, so I've got some runway left on the benefit year. Genuinely didn't know reopening was an option if something went sideways with the new job. That's useful to have in the back of my mind.
0 coins
Chloe Harris
I had a layoff situation where I'd gone back to work, then the company downsized again about three months later. I was able to reopen my original claim and it had a remaining balance. Saved me the headache of going through the whole new claim process. The reopen option is in your Unemployment Services account under claim status.
0 coins
Diego Mendoza
Your claim doesn't just disappear when you go back to work though — I want to make sure people reading this know you DO still need to report wages properly. The reopen feature is a safety net, not a reason to skip certifying accurately on your way out.
0 coins
Anastasia Popova
Something I didn't see mentioned yet — if you were on standby status during your claim (some people are while waiting to be recalled by an employer), going back to work while on standby has slightly different reporting rules. You'd want to flag that with NYSDOL directly if standby applied to your claim.
0 coins
Emma Davis
AuthorMy claim wasn't standby, I was doing the regular weekly job search requirements, so I think I'm in the standard situation. But good flag for anyone reading who was on standby.
0 coins
Sean Flanagan
My cousin was on standby and got confused about this exact thing. The employer she was waiting to hear from ended up not recalling her so she just kept certifying normally, but she always wondered if she should have reported it differently when the recall fell through.
0 coins
Zara Shah
I'll be honest, I read half this thread while eating lunch and had the same exact question brewing because I start a new job next week too. The 'just report your wages and let the math work' explanation finally clicked for me. I'd been imagining some complicated cancellation process.
0 coins
GalaxyGlider
My impression when I went back to work was the same — I expected some formal off-ramp and there basically isn't one. The weekly certification IS the off-ramp. As long as your wages are reported correctly, the claim closes itself out naturally.
0 coins
NebulaNomad
My HR person at my new job had no idea what I was asking when I mentioned 'closing my unemployment claim' — she thought I meant something on their end. It's entirely on the NYSDOL side, your employer doesn't do anything to close it.
0 coins
Luca Ferrari
I want to push back a little on 'just stop certifying' as advice for everyone. If you've got an adjudication issue or an open disqualification on your account, going silent can make things way more complicated down the road. I had a flag on my claim that I didn't even know about, and when I stopped certifying after getting a job, it sat unresolved for months until NYSDOL sent me a determination letter asking for information. The safe move is to actually get an agent on the phone and confirm your account is clean before you stop. Claimyr is worth using for that — I eventually got an agent on the line through it after I'd been trying on my own for the better part of two days with no luck.
0 coins
Emma Davis
AuthorMy account shows no flags or pending issues that I can see in Unemployment Services. But the point about hidden adjudication stuff is making me want to verify before I just walk away from the claim. I didn't even know there could be flags you couldn't see.
0 coins
Malik Robinson
My claim had a thing on it from an employer verification that I genuinely didn't know was pending. I found out when I finally got through to an agent. It was resolved quickly once someone looked at it, but I would never have known from just reading my account screen.
0 coins
Nia Wilson
Your point about hidden issues is real — the online account doesn't always show everything that's sitting in your file on their end. Agents can see the full picture in a way the claimant portal doesn't display.
0 coins
Mateo Martinez
The job search log is a thing people forget to close out mentally too. When you go back to work, you obviously stop needing to log your three job search activities per week. But if you're certifying for a partial week (day one or two of your new job, for example), you technically still had to have met the job search requirement for the earlier days of that week. Most people don't realize the job search requirement is per-week, not per-day, so if you searched earlier in the week before your job started, you're fine for that certification.
0 coins
Emma Davis
AuthorMy job search log for last week already has three entries in it from before I got the offer, so I should be okay on that front for the first partial week.
0 coins
Isabella Silva
My understanding of the job search requirement is that you need the activities for any week you're claiming to have been unemployed and available for work. Once you're employed full-time, those weeks you're no longer filing don't require any log entries, obviously — but that last partial week is worth making sure you're covered.
0 coins
Aisha Hussain
I actually asked an agent about this when I went back to work and she said the job search activities need to be recorded for any week you file a claim, period. Even if you worked part of the week. So yes, make sure your log is complete for whatever week you certify.
0 coins
Freya Andersen
The employer notification piece is something nobody brings up but it tripped me up. When I went back to full-time work, my new employer submitted wage information to the state as part of normal payroll reporting. NYSDOL cross-references those employer wage records with what claimants report on their weekly certifications. If you don't report wages on your weekly claim but your employer reports them to the state, that discrepancy creates a fraud detection flag automatically. It's not like you can just go quiet and hope it sorts itself out.
0 coins
Omar Farouk
My cousin did exactly what you're describing — figured nobody would notice a week or two of wages if she just didn't certify. She got an overpayment notice about $1,400 later that referenced employer wage records she didn't know NYSDOL had access to. Report everything.
0 coins
Zara Shah
I had no idea NYSDOL matched employer payroll filings with claimant certifications automatically. That changes my whole understanding of why honest reporting matters — it's not just about being ethical, the system will catch discrepancies.
0 coins
Ravi Choudhury
Your description of the cross-matching is accurate. The state's tax authority and NYSDOL share data. Employers file quarterly wage reports, and NYSDOL audits claims against those records regularly. The lag means sometimes overpayment notices show up six or eight months after the fact.
0 coins
Ethan Clark
After weeks of trying to reach NYSDOL myself to sort out a question about my final week of certification, I finally had an actual conversation with an agent by going through Claimyr — it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up speaking with a live agent instead of listening to hold music for three hours. The agent walked me through exactly what my account showed, confirmed there were no pending issues, and told me which week would be my last certifiable week. I'd been going in circles trying to figure this out from the website alone.
0 coins
Sean Flanagan
My attempts to reach NYSDOL by phone have all ended with either a busy signal or a disconnection after 45 minutes of holding. At that point I just gave up and hoped I was doing things right. Good to know there's a way to actually get through.
0 coins
Chloe Harris
My last week of claiming was the thing I was most confused about too. The agent I eventually spoke with was really clear about it — the week your earnings first exceed your benefit rate is the week you stop getting paid, but you still certify that week to report the wages. After that you just stop. Simple once someone explains it.
0 coins
Diego Mendoza
I appreciate you sharing that — my experience with NYSDOL phone is that the information on the website is too vague for edge cases and an actual agent conversation is the only way to get a definitive answer for your specific situation.
0 coins
StarStrider
My case was a little complicated because I had an open appeal on a disqualification from earlier in my claim period that was still being processed when I got a new job. My question was whether going back to work affected the appeal outcome. I used Claimyr to reach an agent and was told the appeal process continues independently of employment status — winning the appeal would mean I'd receive back pay for the disqualified weeks regardless of whether I was currently working. So getting a job didn't mean abandoning the appeal.
0 coins
Emma Davis
AuthorMy situation is cleaner than that — no open appeals, no disqualifications — but I'm glad you raised it because I would have assumed getting a job meant any pending appeal became moot.
0 coins
Nia Wilson
Your experience with the appeal continuing is the correct rule. Appeals adjudicate whether you were eligible during those specific weeks in the past. Your current employment status is irrelevant to that historical question. The hearing board looks at the facts as they existed at the time you were disqualified.
0 coins
NebulaNomad
My aunt had a similar situation and she let her appeal lapse thinking it didn't matter anymore since she was employed. She lost out on something like six weeks of back pay that she probably would have won. Don't abandon an appeal just because you got a job.
0 coins
Malik Robinson
I keep seeing people stressed about this and wanting to pile on with one more piece of information — your claim going dormant doesn't hurt your credit, doesn't affect your taxes in any special way beyond the normal 1099-G you'll get in January for whatever you were paid during the year, and doesn't affect future unemployment eligibility. The 1099-G thing surprises people though. Whatever NYSDOL paid you is taxable income, and they'll send you a form for it even if the claim has long gone quiet.
0 coins
Emma Davis
AuthorThe 1099-G piece I actually knew about — I set aside a portion of every payment knowing I'd owe taxes on it. But good reminder for anyone who didn't do that.
0 coins
Anastasia Popova
My first time on unemployment I had no idea about the 1099-G until tax season. It was a rude surprise. I'd had no taxes withheld either, hadn't elected withholding when I filed, so I owed a chunk at filing time.
0 coins
Isabella Silva
You can opt into voluntary tax withholding on NYSDOL payments — 10% federal and a small state amount. If you're still certifying for a partial week, it might be worth checking your withholding election in Unemployment Services before your last certification.
0 coins
Aisha Hussain
My situation when I stopped claiming was that I'd already filed my weekly claim for a week that overlapped with my job start date before I fully understood the rules. I panicked thinking I'd filed incorrectly. What actually happened was I went back into the system and there was no way to un-submit a weekly claim once it's in. The only fix is to contact NYSDOL directly to report the error.
0 coins
Emma Davis
AuthorMy heart rate went up reading this because I was about to ask if you can edit a submitted weekly claim. The answer being 'no' is important — better to get it right the first time and not need to course-correct.
0 coins
Freya Andersen
Your experience illustrates why it's worth pausing before you certify when you're in a transition week. Once it's submitted you're relying on NYSDOL to fix it manually, which means a phone call that may or may not go smoothly.
0 coins
Sean Flanagan
I made an error on a submitted weekly claim once and spent a week trying to get through to anyone at NYSDOL to correct it. The error fixed itself eventually but I had no idea if that was because an agent processed my correction request or if the system auto-corrected it after matching employer records.
0 coins
Nia Wilson
The last thing I'll add for completeness — if you're still within your benefit year and your new job ends for some reason (layoff, company closure, doesn't work out during a probationary period), you don't file a brand new claim if the old one still has a balance. You reopen your existing claim through Unemployment Services. The reopen option usually appears within a couple days of becoming unemployed again. Your weekly benefit rate stays the same as your original claim.
0 coins
Emma Davis
AuthorMy new job is a solid company with good tenure so I'm not planning for that scenario, but it's genuinely reassuring to know there's a safety net option that doesn't require starting from scratch.
0 coins
Chloe Harris
My original claim had something like eight weeks of balance remaining when I went back to work. When I got laid off again four months later I reopened it and was back to receiving benefits within the week. Way faster than the initial filing process.
0 coins
Omar Farouk
Your point about the weekly benefit rate staying the same is key — people assume reopening means going through the whole wage calculation again, but it doesn't. You pick up where you left off.
0 coins
CosmicCadet
My one addition to what you said — if you've exhausted your original claim balance and your new job ends, then you do need to file a new claim. The reopen option only exists when there's a remaining balance on the existing claim and you're still within the benefit year. Worth checking your remaining balance in your Unemployment Services account before your first day at the new job, just so you know what you have if you ever need it.
0 coins