Back to New York Unemployment

Romeo Barrett

Does your previous employer have to approve unemployment in NY? NYSDOL explained

So I got laid off from my warehouse job about five weeks ago and finally filed my UI claim with NYSDOL. Everything seemed fine at first — my weekly claims are going through, the portal shows them as processed — but then my neighbor told me my old employer could just 'deny' my claim and I'd lose everything. Now I'm spiraling a little. I called my old job and they wouldn't even talk to me about it, which made me MORE nervous. Does your previous employer have to approve unemployment before NYSDOL releases payment? Or is this just a myth people keep spreading? I've never filed before and I have no idea how this actually works.

Week two of my own claim when I was asking the exact same thing. My sister-in-law convinced me my boss had to sign off on something and I nearly had a heart attack. Here's how it actually works: your employer doesn't approve or deny your claim — NYSDOL makes that call entirely. What your former employer CAN do is respond to NYSDOL's questionnaire and contest your eligibility, usually by saying you quit voluntarily or were fired for misconduct. But even if they do that, it doesn't automatically disqualify you. NYSDOL reviews both sides and decides. If you were laid off, your employer contesting it would be really hard for them to win.

0 coins

Tried reaching NYSDOL to ask this directly but I keep getting the busy signal recording. So for now your explanation is the best thing I've got. Does NYSDOL notify you if the employer contests?

0 coins

Mailed a letter and got a notice in my Unemployment Services portal both times it happened to me. You'll see a message saying something like 'employer response received' and then usually it goes to adjudication while they sort it out. Keep checking your portal.

0 coins

My employer tried to contest mine after a layoff and NYSDOL sided with me. The whole thing resolved in like three weeks. Don't panic yet.

0 coins

Spent probably six hours across three days trying to get someone on the phone at NYSDOL about a similar question on my claim. The hold music alone is traumatic. A friend told me to try Claimyr — it's at claimyr.com and there's a demo at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE — basically it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so that you end up on the phone with a live agent. I was skeptical but I ended up actually talking to someone at NYSDOL that same afternoon. The agent confirmed everything about how the employer response process works. Worth it when you've got a real question that needs a real answer.

0 coins

Going to look this up right now — I've been going in circles trying to reach anyone at NYSDOL for days.

0 coins

Claimyr worked for me too, got to speak with a NYSDOL agent after weeks of busy signals. The agent explained exactly what my employer had submitted and what would happen next.

0 coins

i was super skeptical but my roommate used it and talked to an actual person at NYSDOL same day. i'm trying it next time i hit a wall with the phones

0 coins

My portal flipped to 'adjudication in progress' on week three and that's when I went hunting for answers. The employer response thing confused me too at first. What I learned the hard way: employers in New York have a window — I think around ten days — to respond to NYSDOL's questionnaire after your claim is filed. If they don't respond, NYSDOL typically just moves forward based on what you submitted. If they do respond and contest it, that's when you might see adjudication kick in. Either way, you have the right to present your side.

0 coins

Mine has been showing 'in progress' for two weeks now and I'm not sure if that means the employer responded or something else triggered it.

0 coins

Two weeks isn't unusual. Mine cleared at week four. Frustrating but it doesn't mean they're leaning toward denying you.

0 coins

adjudication doesn't always mean the employer fought it — sometimes NYSDOL just flags claims randomly for review. happened to me and my employer hadn't even responded yet

0 coins

Fired after nine years at my last company and I went through the whole employer-contest situation. What nobody explains clearly is the difference between an employer 'responding' and an employer 'protesting.' Every employer gets notified when you file — that's just standard. But only some choose to push back. If your layoff is documented as a reduction in force or position elimination, most employers don't even bother contesting because they know NYSDOL won't side with them. The cases where employers win contests are almost always ones where someone quit or got fired for a clear policy violation.

0 coins

Mine was definitely a documented layoff — they even gave me paperwork. That makes me feel significantly better.

0 coins

Keep that paperwork somewhere safe. If your claim ever goes to a hearing, documentation of a formal layoff is basically bulletproof.

0 coins

Nine years and they still contested?? Companies are wild. Mine tried the same thing after a mass layoff and NYSDOL denied their protest within two weeks.

0 coins

my employer submitted something and NYSDOL still approved me in like 10 days. the protest didn't do anything

0 coins

week one of my claim and already panicking about this. my old manager literally texted me saying 'good luck with that' when i mentioned unemployment. so now im convinced they're going to do something to block me

0 coins

Your manager's attitude doesn't translate into legal authority over your claim. Employers don't have veto power — they can submit their version of events but NYSDOL weighs the evidence. A hostile text from a manager isn't evidence of anything that would disqualify you.

0 coins

Printing this out and taping it to my wall honestly. Thank you.

0 coins

My former supervisor tried to badmouth me to NYSDOL and it still didn't change the outcome. What mattered was what I actually did or didn't do, not what she said about me.

0 coins

AFTER THREE MONTHS OF FIGHTING I finally got my benefits approved and can tell you the employer response process is real but also way less scary than it sounds. My employer submitted a full written protest saying I quit — I was laid off, I had the email to prove it — and NYSDOL scheduled a phone interview with me. I presented my documentation, the agent asked maybe five questions, and two weeks later I got a determination letter saying I was eligible. The whole thing felt impossible while I was in it but it did eventually resolve correctly.

0 coins

Three months sounds absolutely brutal. But knowing it resolved in your favor even after a full written protest is genuinely reassuring.

0 coins

Hang in there. The system is slow and confusing but it does work if you documented your layoff properly.

0 coins

Three months without income is no joke. Claimyr at least helped me shorten the information gap — getting a live NYSDOL agent on the line to explain where my claim stood saved me weeks of wondering.

0 coins

the phone interview step is not as scary as it sounds. they're not trying to trap you, they just need to reconcile what you said vs what your employer said

0 coins

My determination letter arrived on day 29 after I filed, which felt like forever. By that point I had already convinced myself my employer's response had tanked my claim. It hadn't. The letter said eligible, benefits released for all weeks I'd certified. If you're within your first month of waiting, you're probably still in normal processing territory.

0 coins

Day 29 for a determination — that's actually not too far off from where I am now. I'll stop catastrophizing for at least a few more days.

0 coins

Mark your calendar. If you hit six weeks with nothing, then start pushing harder.

0 coins

five weeks here and nothing. my portal just says pending. no letters nothing. this is making me insane

0 coins

Five weeks into my claim and my portal just says 'pending review' with zero explanation. I did the same job search activities and weekly certifications as instructed. Never got a letter about anything. Does employer response take this long or is something else going on?

0 coins

Pending review can mean a lot of things — employer response being evaluated, identity verification, wage record mismatch. Five weeks without any letter or notice in your portal is unusual. I'd push to get someone on the phone.

0 coins

My claim sat at pending review for almost six weeks before I found out through a NYSDOL agent that my employer had filed a protest and they never mailed me the notice. Used Claimyr to get to an agent who explained the whole situation. Knowing what was actually happening made all the difference — I could prepare my side of the story instead of just waiting.

0 coins

Six weeks and they never mailed the notice?? That's infuriating. I'm going to try harder to reach someone this week.

0 coins

idk if this helps but my employer never responded at all — just completely ignored the NYSDOL questionnaire — and my claim processed totally fine. i think a lot of employers especially bigger ones have so many former employees filing at once that they don't even bother responding unless it's something they really want to fight

0 coins

Mine is a mid-sized warehouse operation, probably 80-100 employees. I could see them not bothering if they laid off a bunch of people at once.

0 coins

yeah layoffs in bulk almost never get contested because the employer basically admitted it by laying off so many people at once. individual firings are where they're more likely to push back

0 coins

My former employer apparently had a policy of contesting everyone just to slow down the payout process. Some companies do it strategically. Still didn't work though.

0 coins

Letter in hand on week seven after the most confusing experience of my UI life. My employer contested my claim — a layoff, mind you, with a signed separation agreement — and I genuinely didn't know I had to respond until a NYSDOL agent explained it to me over the phone. Turns out there was a deadline I almost missed for submitting my rebuttal documents. If you're in adjudication, check your portal messages constantly. Deadlines get buried in there.

0 coins

Wait — there's a deadline to respond to the employer's contest? I had no idea that was a thing. What kind of timeframe are we talking?

0 coins

The notice I got gave me ten days to submit my response with supporting documents. It was in a portal message I'd almost missed because I was only checking the main claim status page. Check every section of your portal.

0 coins

This is a really important point. NYSDOL sends notices with deadlines and missing them can hurt your case even if you have solid documentation. Set reminders to check your portal messages daily during adjudication.

0 coins

oh wow i did not know this. checking my portal messages right now

0 coins

My first week filing I called the NYSDOL number probably nine times and got a busy signal every single time. It is genuinely one of the most frustrating experiences I've had dealing with any government office. I eventually got through on a Thursday morning around 8:05am. Someone somewhere told me the phones are lighter right at opening and that actually worked for me.

0 coins

Eight in the morning Thursday — writing that down. I'll try it this week.

0 coins

No guarantees, it might've just been luck. But I've heard from multiple people that mid-week early morning is better than Monday or Friday at any time.

0 coins

i tried 8am monday and got the busy signal for 45 minutes straight. never again

0 coins

My determination came back disqualified even though I was laid off because my employer told NYSDOL I had been warned for performance issues before the layoff. I had no idea they could mix those two things together. I appealed and won, but it added two more months to the whole process. Keep records of literally everything — your performance reviews, emails, anything that shows the layoff was about the company's situation, not your behavior.

0 coins

Performance issues mixed into a layoff determination — that's a nightmare I hadn't even considered. I've got my layoff notice and a couple of emails about headcount reduction. Hoping that's enough.

0 coins

Emails about headcount reduction are gold. That's exactly the kind of documentation that shows the decision wasn't about you personally.

0 coins

Appeals do work — the fact that you won two months later proves it. The system has a correction mechanism even when the initial determination is wrong.

0 coins

My appeal also overturned a wrong initial determination. The appeals process is legitimately more thorough than the initial review.

0 coins

My portal has been saying 'employer response pending' for 11 days and I'm losing my mind refreshing it every hour. I've been reading this thread trying to calm down. Someone upstairs mentioned getting to an actual NYSDOL agent — how are you all doing that? I've called probably 20 times and can't get through.

0 coins

Tried calling at every hour of the day for two weeks before I found a way through. NYSDOL's phone system is brutal. I ended up using Claimyr — it waits on hold for you so that you eventually end up speaking directly with an agent at NYSDOL. Got real answers about where my claim actually stood instead of just staring at a status screen.

0 coins

Trying that today. The portal status hasn't moved in almost two weeks and I need to know if my employer actually submitted anything or if something else is flagging my claim.

0 coins

Employer response pending usually just means they haven't submitted theirs yet. 11 days is within the window. It might just clear on its own.

0 coins

My adjudication wrapped up yesterday after 31 days and I want to share what I learned about the employer response process for anyone searching for answers. Employers do not approve or deny your claim — full stop. What they do is respond to NYSDOL's fact-finding. If they contest, you get to respond too. NYSDOL then decides based on the totality of what both sides submitted. In my case the employer claimed I was fired for cause. I had documentation showing otherwise. NYSDOL sided with me. The key is responding to every notice by the deadline stated in that notice.

0 coins

31 days and resolved — that's the kind of update I needed to see. Congratulations and thank you for coming back to share the outcome.

0 coins

Worth the wait. Hang in there, everyone. Document everything and check your portal messages daily.

0 coins

This is the most useful summary in this whole thread. Saving the part about responding to every notice with its deadline.

0 coins

Claimyr also helped me understand the notice deadline situation before I missed one — the agent walked me through exactly what I needed to submit and when. Actual lifesaver for that claim.

0 coins

My cousin — who works in HR at a mid-size company — told me once that a lot of employers don't even realize they can contest unemployment claims. They get the NYSDOL questionnaire and either ignore it or answer it neutrally because they don't have strong grounds to push back. Contested claims are actually the minority. Most former employees just get approved without a fight.

0 coins

HR perspective from inside a company — that's actually really interesting. Might explain why mine hasn't done anything yet.

0 coins

Even when companies DO contest, HR folks know the bar for winning is high. Layoffs are especially hard to contest because the company essentially admitted it was their decision.

0 coins

worked in HR briefly and yeah the questionnaires mostly just get a quick factual response. full protests are reserved for situations where the company thinks it has a real case

0 coins

Received my approval letter on week five and I want to be clear: my former employer submitted a response. They didn't contest — they just confirmed the layoff details. NYSDOL used that as corroborating information and approved me quickly. Sometimes the employer response actually helps you because it confirms what you already told NYSDOL.

0 coins

Hadn't thought about it that way — employer response as corroboration rather than opposition. That reframes the whole thing.

0 coins

Exactly. If your layoff paperwork and your employer's NYSDOL response say the same thing, that's pretty hard for NYSDOL to argue with.

0 coins

This is an underrated point. The questionnaire asks employers to describe the reason for separation. If they confirm 'lack of work' or 'position eliminated,' that essentially aligns with what you told NYSDOL.

0 coins

My ex-manager actually called me and asked me to agree to say I resigned so the company wouldn't have to deal with the unemployment 'costs.' I said absolutely not and filed accurately as a layoff. Employers pay into a fund for unemployment insurance — their individual 'approval' of your claim doesn't even work the way they might imply. My claim was approved two weeks later.

0 coins

They actually called and asked you to lie to NYSDOL?? That's wild. Good for you for holding the line.

0 coins

Yep. And I've since learned that's not uncommon. Some employers try to pressure former employees into claiming they quit so the layoff doesn't affect the employer's UI tax rate. Don't fall for it.

0 coins

This is an important point — employers have a financial incentive to contest claims because it can affect their experience-rated tax contributions to the UI fund. That's the real reason some companies push back aggressively on claims they know they won't win.

0 coins

My employer did the same thing to me. I declined and filed accurately. Approved without issue.

0 coins

Three weeks in here and trying to understand the job search requirements while also stressing about the employer response thing. Do I still have to log my three job search activities every week even while my claim is in adjudication?

0 coins

My mistake in my first claim taught me this the hard way — yes, you keep doing your three weekly job search activities no matter what your claim status says. Adjudication doesn't pause that requirement. Missing weeks because you assumed adjudication meant everything was paused can disqualify you for those specific weeks even if the underlying claim resolves in your favor.

0 coins

Logging all three activities as of right now — not risking it.

0 coins

Your weekly certification is also still due every week. Missing a weekly claim during adjudication is one of the most avoidable mistakes people make.

0 coins

i made exactly this mistake my first time. missed two weeks of job search logging because i thought adjudication froze everything. lost benefits for those two weeks even though i got approved overall

0 coins

My situation cleared last week and I wanted to drop in because I found this specific question — does your previous employer have to approve unemployment — when I was at my most anxious and nothing I read was clear enough. So here's the clearest I can make it: they don't. They get asked questions. They can share their version of events. NYSDOL decides. That's it. If you were laid off and have documentation, your odds are good. Keep filing your weekly claims, keep doing your job search activities, and check your portal messages every single day.

0 coins

This is the summary I've been looking for since I posted this. Thank you for coming back to lay it out so plainly. I feel like I can breathe again.

0 coins

bookmarked this comment specifically. everything i needed in one place

0 coins

Checking my portal messages daily starting right now. Never thought to check that separate from the main status screen.

0 coins

Wish this thread existed when I first filed. Would have saved me weeks of unnecessary panic.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure