Back to New York Unemployment

Malik Johnson

Does your former employer pay unemployment in NY? NYSDOL explained

So I got laid off two weeks ago from a marketing agency I'd been with for almost four years. First time filing for unemployment and I genuinely have no idea how the whole funding thing works. My coworker told me my former employer pays unemployment directly out of their own pocket every time I certify, like it comes straight from them. But then my brother said no, that's not right, that employers just pay into some kind of state fund and it doesn't actually come from the company specifically. I'm confused because if it's coming directly from my old employer, does that mean they can somehow hold it up or block it? I already filed my initial claim on the NYSDOL Unemployment Services portal and I'm waiting on a determination. Just want to understand how this actually works before I start stressing about whether my former boss is going to cause problems with my benefits.

Your brother is closer to the truth here. The way it works in NY is that employers pay into a pooled state fund — it's a tax on their payroll that goes to NYSDOL. When you file and get approved, the money comes out of that fund, not directly from your former employer's bank account like a bill they receive each week. So your old boss can't just refuse to pay or hold up your benefits because they're annoyed you filed. What they CAN do is respond to NYSDOL's questionnaire about why you separated — that response can affect whether you get approved or face adjudication. But the actual dollars? That's the state fund paying you, not them writing you a check.

0 coins

My coworker had me genuinely panicked thinking my former boss could just... not pay and I'd be stuck. The employer questionnaire thing is what I'm actually worried about now though. They laid me off but I'm nervous they might spin it differently to NYSDOL.

0 coins

The separation reason is really the key thing with employer responses. As long as you have documentation that it was a layoff — email, severance paperwork, anything written — you're in a much stronger position if the employer tries to claim something different.

0 coins

My termination letter just says 'position elimination due to restructuring.' That should be solid documentation of a layoff, right? I'm going to screenshot everything just in case.

0 coins

Spent almost two weeks trying to get a straight answer from NYSDOL by phone about almost this exact question when my claim got tangled up in adjudication after my employer submitted something unexpected. Couldn't get through — the line was dropping or just endless hold music. Ended up trying Claimyr (claimyr.com) — there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE — it basically sits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up talking to an actual live agent. That agent explained the whole employer tax fund situation AND looked at the notes on my file from the employer questionnaire response. Genuinely don't know how long I'd have been spinning my wheels otherwise.

0 coins

My claim hit adjudication after my former employer disputed the reason for separation and I had the same wall of silence from the phone lines. I'll keep Claimyr in mind if this drags on much longer.

0 coins

Two weeks of dropped calls and hold music before finding something that actually worked sounds about right for NYSDOL honestly. glad you got through to someone.

0 coins

Adjudication is exactly what I'm afraid of landing in. Good to know there are options if the phone situation becomes impossible. My portal is still just showing 'in progress' on my claim.

0 coins

The employer tax question trips a lot of people up. Here's the cleaner version: every business in NY that has employees pays what's called the State Unemployment Insurance tax — it's a percentage of wages up to a certain threshold per employee per year. That money all goes into New York's UI trust fund, which is what NYSDOL draws from to pay claimants. Your specific employer doesn't get a bill each week you certify. However — and this matters for your situation — employers DO have their tax rate adjusted over time based on how many of their former workers file successful claims. So employers with high turnover who keep laying people off end up paying higher rates. That's why some employers bother contesting claims even when they know they laid someone off legitimately. It's about their future tax rate, not about blocking your specific payment.

0 coins

The experience-rating piece is exactly why some employers fight claims they'd probably lose anyway. The calculus is their long-term tax rate versus the cost of contesting, and sometimes contesting wins even on cases where the employer was clearly in the wrong on the facts.

0 coins

wait so my old company was fighting my claim not to actually stop me from getting it but because of their insurance rate thing?? that explains SO MUCH. they lost the dispute but still, made the whole thing take an extra month

0 coins

Your former employer running the dispute just to protect their rate — that's pretty common with larger companies especially. They have HR departments that handle contests almost automatically regardless of the merits. For smaller employers it's more of a case-by-case decision.

0 coins

ugh the amount of people who think their boss is personally writing the unemployment check every week. i had this same argument with my roommate lmao. NYSDOL is paying you. the state. your employer already paid their taxes into the fund before you even got laid off. they cant stop it once your claim is approved, they can only mess with whether it gets APPROVED by fighting the reason for separation

0 coins

Okay this is making me feel better about the actual payment side. The separation dispute part is still the thing I'm watching. My former employer never gave me a reason to think they'd fight it but I also never thought I'd be filing unemployment, so.

0 coins

My former employer tried to claim I'd resigned when I definitely hadn't — the dispute added almost six weeks to my adjudication. If anything like that happens to you, start gathering your documentation immediately, don't wait for NYSDOL to ask for it.

0 coins

The adjudication concern you're raising is real and worth preparing for. When an employer responds to NYSDOL's separation questionnaire with something that conflicts with your version — even if what they say is false — NYSDOL has to investigate before they can pay. That's what adjudication is: a fact-finding process where they weigh both sides. While your claim is in adjudication, your certifications still get recorded but no payment releases until the determination comes out. If you disagree with the determination, you have 30 days from the mailing date to file an appeal. The key thing for you right now: keep certifying every week even while you're in adjudication, and document every job search contact. Missing certifications or incomplete job search records can create new issues separate from whatever the employer dispute is about.

0 coins

I've been certifying every week since I filed, so that part is covered. I didn't realize the job search log was something they could check separately from the employer dispute though. I've been keeping track in a spreadsheet — full employer name, contact method, date, outcome for each one.

0 coins

A spreadsheet with that level of detail is exactly what an adjudicator or appeals referee would want to see if your claim gets challenged on the job search side. Three contacts per week, all logged that way, is solid.

0 coins

the 30 day appeal window caught me off guard when I got a denial last year. I didnt even open the letter for a week because I was stressed and almost missed the deadline. open every piece of NYSDOL mail immediately is the lesson

0 coins

Coming at this from a slightly different angle — I work HR for a mid-size company and we handle NYSDOL responses regularly. The separation questionnaire usually asks us: date of separation, reason for separation, whether there was any misconduct, and what the employee was told. Honest answers from an employer who did a legitimate layoff for business reasons should not create problems for the claimant. The cases that cause adjudication issues are when the employer checks 'voluntary quit' instead of 'layoff/reduction in force,' or when they mention performance issues that look like misconduct. If your situation was genuinely a position elimination, a reasonable HR person should answer accordingly and your claim should move through without getting hung up.

0 coins

That breakdown of the questionnaire is really helpful. My role was eliminated as part of a wider team restructuring — not performance, not anything I did. So if whoever answers that questionnaire at my former employer is being straight, it should reflect that.

0 coins

should being the operative word lol. some HR departments just check 'resigned' as default and let the employee figure it out

0 coins

That does happen with poorly run HR, unfortunately. It's usually not malicious, just careless data entry. Which is exactly why having a written termination notice naming the reason matters — it's your counter-evidence if the form answer doesn't match reality.

0 coins

my employer actually told me upfront when they laid me off that they'd be contesting my unemployment claim because of some clause in my severance agreement. i didn't even know that was a thing. does signing a severance change whether your former employer pays unemployment or whether you can file at all?

0 coins

Severance agreements sometimes include language about unemployment — specifically, some contain clauses where the employee agrees not to file. NYSDOL's position is that these waiver clauses are generally not enforceable in New York because UI rights are established by state law, not contract. So even if you signed something like that, you can still file. The employer can still respond to the separation questionnaire and contest the reason, but the existence of a severance agreement alone doesn't disqualify you.

0 coins

genuinely didn't know those clauses were unenforceable in NY. the company made it sound like signing meant I was giving up the right to file. filing anyway now.

0 coins

The unenforceable waiver thing is a classic employer move that works mainly because most employees don't know their rights. NY courts have consistently said you can't sign away statutory unemployment rights, full stop.

0 coins

I'm three months into what started as a simple layoff claim and it's been a nightmare. First the employer questionnaire response flagged something they called 'performance-related restructuring' which kicked me into adjudication. Then I got a determination I disagreed with and filed an appeal. Now I'm waiting for a hearing date with an appeals referee. Meanwhile I certified every single week but haven't seen a dime. The whole 'employers pay into a fund so they can't block your claim' thing is technically true but in practice there are so many ways the system can slow things down to almost nothing.

0 coins

Three months without payment while you're certifying every week is brutal. The hearing process can take another 6-8 weeks from the date you filed the appeal in some cases. Have you been able to get anyone at NYSDOL on the phone to at least confirm your appeal file is complete and assigned?

0 coins

Calling NYSDOL has been the most demoralizing part of all of this. I've dialed that line more times than I can count and either it cuts out after long hold times or I get a message about high call volume. I did eventually reach someone using Claimyr — a friend told me about it and it got me talking to a live NYSDOL agent — and that agent confirmed my appeal file was complete and assigned to a referee. That's the first actual status update I'd gotten in weeks.

0 coins

Appeals hearings are actually more claimant-friendly than the initial adjudication in my experience — the referee is a neutral party and you get to actually present your side. Bring everything: the original termination notice, any emails about the restructuring, your complete job search log.

0 coins

My termination paperwork and the HR email chain about the restructuring are what I'm building my hearing case around. The referee will see that the employer's characterization and the actual written record don't match.

0 coins

something nobody explained to me when I first filed: even if your claim gets delayed by an employer dispute, the payments don't just disappear — if you're ultimately approved, NYSDOL releases back-pay for all the weeks you certified during adjudication. So keep certifying no matter what, every single week.

0 coins

This is genuinely one of the most useful things I've read in this whole thread. I was worried that if the determination took a long time, those weeks were just... gone.

0 coins

Yep the weekly certifications are like placeholders. As long as you kept certifying and doing your job searches, those weeks get paid when the determination finally comes through. Missing a week is what actually loses you that week's payment permanently.

0 coins

i missed two weeks of certifications when I first filed because nobody told me I still had to certify while in adjudication and lost those weeks entirely. wish someone had told me this earlier

0 coins

My adjudication dragged on for eight weeks after my former employer's questionnaire came back with a different separation reason than what I'd told NYSDOL. I kept trying the phone line and getting nowhere — either disconnected after long waits or the same recorded message about staffing. A colleague mentioned Claimyr and I tried it — ended up speaking directly with an NYSDOL agent who could actually see the notes in my file from the employer response. That agent told me exactly what information the adjudicator needed from me, which I submitted the same day. Got my determination about two weeks after that.

0 coins

Knowing exactly what the adjudicator needs rather than guessing and submitting everything you can think of is a huge difference. Without getting someone on the phone you're basically flying blind on what's actually holding the case up.

0 coins

The agent told me the adjudicator had one specific question about my final day of work and the transition period — something I never would have known to address from the standard portal messages. Targeted submission versus a pile of documents I hoped covered it.

0 coins

eight weeks and then resolved two weeks after getting that targeted info... that's how much of adjudication time can just be waiting for a thing that takes ten minutes to clarify

0 coins

my situation was a bit different — I quit my job, not a layoff, and I was trying to understand whether my former employer's tax contributions had any bearing on whether I'd qualify. short answer from NYSDOL after I finally got someone on the phone via Claimyr: the fund contribution question is completely separate from the eligibility question. whether your employer paid in doesn't determine whether you're eligible. eligibility for voluntary quit situations comes down to whether you had 'good cause' for leaving — like unsafe conditions, significant pay cut, that kind of thing. the fund just determines whether there's money available to pay approved claims.

0 coins

Your experience illustrates a really important distinction a lot of people miss. Funding mechanism and eligibility rules are two completely different tracks. 'Good cause' for a voluntary quit in NY is a high bar — it generally needs to be a substantial change in your working conditions or something that made continuing employment genuinely untenable, not just dissatisfaction with the job.

0 coins

In my case it was a 30% pay cut with no warning that HR called a 'compensation adjustment.' NYSDOL ultimately agreed that counted as good cause since it was a material change to my employment terms. Took about 10 weeks total between filing and first payment.

0 coins

30% pay cut suddenly being called a 'compensation adjustment' is wild. glad you got approved. that kind of unilateral change feels like it should obviously be good cause

0 coins

For what it's worth, I've been through three separate layoffs over about twelve years and dealt with NYSDOL each time. The employer fund thing confused me the first time too. By the third time I had the whole process figured out. A few things that made each successive claim smoother: responding immediately to any NYSDOL mail, never missing a weekly certification, keeping a detailed job search log from day one, and knowing that any employer response that conflicts with your version just starts a process — it doesn't automatically disqualify you. The adjudicator is supposed to be neutral and weigh both sides. The process is slow but it's not rigged against claimants by default.

0 coins

Three layoffs and you kept a detailed job search log from day one each time — that level of discipline is what I need to be building right now. I've been decent about it but 'decent' might not be enough if things get complicated.

0 coins

Your spreadsheet with employer, contact method, date, and outcome that you mentioned earlier? That's the format. Keep that going every week. If you ever face an audit of your job search activity, that documentation is what saves you.

0 coins

The 'adjudicator is neutral' point is worth emphasizing. I've seen people assume an employer dispute means automatic denial and then not even bother responding to NYSDOL's request for their side of the story. Responding with documentation consistently wins the close cases.

0 coins

does anyone know what happens to the money if your claim gets denied after you've been certifying for weeks?? asking bc im terrified this is gonna happen to me

0 coins

Your question turns on whether the denial was for the initial period of adjudication or for new weeks going forward. If your claim gets denied — say, the determination says you were disqualified — then those weeks you certified during adjudication don't get paid, because the denial covers them. That's why the employer response question matters so much: it's not just future weeks at stake, it's all the weeks you've been waiting. If you disagree with the denial, filing an appeal within 30 days is what keeps those weeks in play.

0 coins

okay so the 30 day appeal window is literally the most important deadline in this whole thing. writing that on a sticky note and putting it on my monitor

0 coins

30 day window from the date on the letter, not the date you receive it — NYSDOL mails the determination and the clock starts on that mailing date. So open every piece of mail from them the day it arrives.

0 coins

My whole situation with NYSDOL dragging into month three finally got resolved after I reached an actual agent using Claimyr. That agent pulled up my file and saw a note from the employer's questionnaire that my adjudicator had been waiting to get a response on for weeks — a response that apparently nobody had told me I needed to submit. Without getting that agent on the phone I'd still be waiting with no idea why nothing was moving.

0 coins

The portal messages are almost useless for understanding what's actually blocking a claim. 'Your claim is in adjudication' tells you nothing about whether they need something from you or whether it's just processing time.

0 coins

Exactly — I had checked my portal every day for two months and it just said 'pending determination.' Nothing actionable. The agent seeing the actual file notes changed everything.

0 coins

This matches what I see on the employer side too. The claimant portal shows very little of what's actually happening in the file. The adjudicator may have questions or needs that never make it to the claimant as a clear message, especially during heavy volume periods.

0 coins

the employer fund explanation in this thread is the clearest I've seen it laid out anywhere honestly. I spent like a week thinking my old boss was personally deciding whether to pay me every two weeks and stressing accordingly.

0 coins

The mental shift from 'my boss is paying me unemployment' to 'the state fund is paying me and my boss just answered some questions' is huge for the stress level honestly

0 coins

That exact mental shift was why I posted this. Four years working somewhere and then wondering if the person who managed you is now controlling your financial lifeline — that's a stressful way to think about it.

0 coins

To bring it back to the original question one more time for anyone who finds this thread later: employers in NY do not directly pay unemployment benefits to former employees. They pay State Unemployment Insurance tax as a payroll tax throughout the year, that money goes into New York's UI trust fund, and NYSDOL pays approved claimants out of that fund. The employer's only direct influence on a specific claim is through their response to the separation questionnaire, which can affect whether you're approved, not whether a check actually goes out once you are. If your layoff was genuine and your employer answers the questionnaire honestly, your claim should not face serious obstacles.

0 coins

This is the summary I needed from the beginning. Everything in this thread has made me genuinely less anxious about my claim. Still watching my portal every day but at least I understand what I'm watching for now.

0 coins

The separation questionnaire response is really the whole ballgame for most straightforward layoff claims. Everything else — the fund mechanics, the tax rates, the experience rating — matters more to the employer than to the claimant.

0 coins

Bookmarked this whole thread to send to friends when they inevitably file for the first time and panic about the same question. The 'does my boss pay me personally' confusion is so common.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure