Back to New York Unemployment

Giovanni Martello

Does getting unemployment affect tax return? NYSDOL claimants need to know

So I've been on unemployment since February and my coworker just told me I'm going to owe a ton of money when I file taxes next year. I honestly had no idea unemployment benefits were even taxable - nobody mentioned anything about this when I filed my claim through NYSDOL. I just assumed it was like any other government assistance and wouldn't count as income. Now I'm freaking out a little because I've been collecting for about 4 months and haven't set aside anything for taxes. Does getting unemployment affect tax return in a major way? Like am I going to owe the IRS a huge amount? I did see something in my Unemployment Services account about withholding but I didn't really understand what it meant so I skipped past it. Anyone who's been through this please help me understand what I'm actually looking at here.

Week 11 of my claim and I went through exactly this panic last filing season. Unemployment benefits from NYSDOL count as fully taxable income at the federal level - same as wages from a job. The state of New York also taxes them. So yes, your tax return absolutely gets affected. The amount you might owe depends on your total income for the year including those benefits. If you never turned on federal or state withholding through your Unemployment Services account, that's where people get hit hard come April. You can still switch it on now - go into your account settings and there's an option to have NYSDOL withhold 10% federal and 2.5% state from each weekly payment going forward. Won't fix the past months but stops the bleeding from here.

0 coins

I went back and looked and I definitely never set up withholding. So for the 4 months I already collected, that money is just going to be sitting there as taxable income with nothing taken out?

0 coins

My first year on UI I had the same situation. Yeah, what's already been paid out won't have anything withheld retroactively. Your options are to set up withholding now for future payments, or make estimated quarterly tax payments directly to the IRS to cover what you've already received. A lot of people just set money aside in a separate account - roughly 15-20% of each benefit payment is a decent rough estimate depending on your tax bracket.

0 coins

This is accurate. I work in accounting and the 1099-G form NYSDOL sends in January covers the full amount paid out during the year. That's what you report on your return.

0 coins

My claim got complicated around week 6 because I needed to talk to an actual agent about some withholding questions and the NYSDOL phone lines were absolutely brutal. Spent three days trying to get through. A friend told me about Claimyr - it basically waits on hold with NYSDOL so you end up on the phone with a live agent without sitting there yourself for hours. Used it and finally got my tax withholding situation sorted out directly with someone at NYSDOL. You can check it out at claimyr.com and there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. Worth knowing about if you need to actually speak to someone about your account settings.

0 coins

Four months in and I haven't been able to reach anyone by phone yet. Every time I try I get the busy signal or get disconnected after waiting 45 minutes. I'll check out Claimyr for sure.

0 coins

My experience with NYSDOL phones was the same thing - disconnected after a long wait, tried again and got a busy signal. Ended up emailing through the portal which took 8 days to get a response. Wish I'd known about other options earlier.

0 coins

The phone situation there is genuinely terrible. I tried for two straight weeks before I finally got through by calling at exactly 7:58am before the lines filled up.

0 coins

Tax season hit me hard two years ago because of this exact thing. I collected about $9,000 in UI benefits and figured since I had no other income that year I wouldn't owe anything. Wrong. Got hit with a federal tax bill of about $900 and a smaller state amount. The 1099-G arrived in January and I genuinely didn't know what to do with it at first. Now I always set up withholding from day one of a new claim.

0 coins

$900 is actually less scary than what I was imagining. Though I've collected more than $9,000 so I'm probably looking at more than that.

0 coins

My bill was higher because I had part-time work income on top of the UI benefits. When you combine different income sources it can bump you into a higher bracket and suddenly the math gets worse than you expected.

0 coins

Yeah the bracket issue is real. If you did any part-time work while collecting and reported it correctly to NYSDOL, that partial income still gets added to your total taxable income for the year.

0 coins

My situation was a little different - I actually got a bigger refund the year I was on unemployment than the year before. That's because I had withholding from my job for the first part of the year before I got laid off, and my overall income dropped enough that I ended up in a lower bracket. So it's not always bad news. It really depends on your total year income picture.

0 coins

Oh that's interesting, I hadn't thought about it that way. I was laid off in February so I did have about 6 weeks of regular wages first.

0 coins

Those early wages with regular withholding might actually help your situation. If your employer was taking out the standard amount based on a full year's salary, but you only worked a fraction of the year, you might have had more withheld from wages than you ultimately owed.

0 coins

My refund actually went up slightly the year I collected UI because of this exact dynamic. I had two months of wages with normal withholding then benefits the rest of the year with no withholding set up - but the wage withholding covered more than my actual liability ended up being.

0 coins

I want to flag one thing people get confused about - there's a difference between how your return is AFFECTED and whether you owe money. The UI benefits definitely show up on your return and change your numbers. But whether you end up owing versus getting a refund depends on your total picture. I see people say 'unemployment hurts your taxes' and others say 'I got a bigger refund' and both can be true for different people.

0 coins

My tax preparer explained it this way and it finally clicked for me: unemployment is ordinary income, so it goes in the same bucket as wages. The question is just whether you pre-paid enough through withholding or estimated payments to cover your share.

0 coins

Exactly that. And if you're doing your own taxes for the first time after a year with UI benefits, the 1099-G from NYSDOL goes on Schedule 1 of your federal return, Line 1. Some first-timers panic when they see it but it's very straightforward to enter.

0 coins

Okay this is making a lot more sense now. I think I was conflating 'my return will look different' with 'I will definitely owe money.

0 coins

My sister went through this and she did owe about $1,200 extra - but she also had freelance income that year on top of UI, so that was a double hit on the self-employment side. If you just have UI with no other complicating income, it's more predictable.

0 coins

Freelance plus UI is rough because the UI doesn't cover the self-employment tax on the freelance portion either. Those are two separate tax problems stacking on each other.

0 coins

She ended up on a payment plan with the IRS which apparently is not that hard to set up if you can't pay the full amount at once. Just wanted to mention that as an option in case anyone is looking at a bill they can't cover immediately.

0 coins

Good to know there's a payment plan option. I've been catastrophizing about owing something I literally cannot pay.

0 coins

My claim ran through most of last year and I called NYSDOL specifically to ask about the withholding options. The agent told me the 10% federal withholding they offer is often not enough if you have other income during the year because it doesn't account for your bracket. She actually suggested I do 10% withholding PLUS put an extra 5% aside myself in savings. That way I had a cushion.

0 coins

This is a really underrated point. The 10% withholding is a flat rate and doesn't adjust for your situation. If you're in a higher bracket it falls short. If you're in a low bracket you might have more than enough. It's a starting point, not a guarantee.

0 coins

I wish this was explained somewhere obvious when you sign up. I would have set it all up from the start if I'd understood it.

0 coins

The enrollment process for unemployment really doesn't emphasize the tax piece enough. I stumbled onto the withholding option almost by accident when I was looking for something else in my account.

0 coins

My first week of my claim I actually called NYSDOL trying to ask about taxes and the person I reached gave me wrong information - told me unemployment benefits weren't taxable at the state level in New York. They are. I ended up not setting up state withholding based on that bad info and had a small state tax bill. Always double-check what agents tell you, especially on tax questions - they're claim specialists not tax professionals.

0 coins

My tax preparer has seen a lot of clients come in with incorrect info they got from NYSDOL agents. The agents know the claim process well but tax advice isn't really their area. For the tax side, a CPA or even a free VITA volunteer is a better source.

0 coins

I ended up at a VITA site the following year and the volunteer confirmed the state does tax UI benefits. No charge, they're trained specifically on this. Might be useful for anyone who wants a real answer on their specific tax situation.

0 coins

I had no idea VITA existed, that's going to be really useful. Free tax help for exactly this kind of situation sounds perfect for me right now.

0 coins

Around week 8 of my claim I realized I had completely ignored the tax part of everything. Getting through to NYSDOL to sort out my withholding setup was an ordeal - I tried calling maybe a dozen times over two weeks with nothing but busy signals and one dropped call after an hour on hold. A coworker mentioned Claimyr and I figured I'd try it. It did the hold waiting for me and I ended up speaking to an agent who walked me through enabling withholding right in my account. The whole conversation with the agent was maybe 10 minutes once I actually got to one.

0 coins

Two weeks of trying sounds exhausting. Did you end up being able to retroactively sort anything out or was it just setting up withholding going forward?

0 coins

My conversation with the agent was about setting it up going forward, plus she helped me understand what my 1099-G would look like at year end so I could start saving appropriately. No retroactive fix for what was already paid, but having a real person explain the numbers to me was way more helpful than trying to figure it out from the website.

0 coins

Two weeks of busy signals is unfortunately pretty normal for NYSDOL phones. I've had the same thing happen when I had a question about my adjudication status - just endless busy or disconnected.

0 coins

My accountant made me realize something when I went through this: if your total household income including UI is below the standard deduction ($14,600 for single filers in 2024, $29,200 for married filing jointly), you might owe nothing at all even without withholding. A lot of single people on UI for most of the year don't actually cross that threshold. Worth running the rough numbers before panicking.

0 coins

I'm single and I think between my 6 weeks of wages plus 4 months of UI I'm probably around $22,000 total. So I'd be over the standard deduction but not by a huge amount.

0 coins

At $22,000 single filer you'd be in the 12% federal bracket. Your tax would be on the amount over $14,600 so roughly $7,400 taxed at 12% which is about $888 federal before any credits. Then a small NY state amount. It won't be fun but it's not catastrophic.

0 coins

My total was similar one year and the actual tax owed was much less than I had feared. The standard deduction really does absorb a chunk of it.

0 coins

This is a good back-of-napkin approach. And don't forget to check if you qualify for the Earned Income Tax Credit based on the wages portion of your income. Some people on UI still qualify and it can offset a lot of what you might owe.

0 coins

My benefits ran out last October and I had no idea until I did my taxes that my UI benefits had also made me ineligible for a tax credit I had been getting while employed. When your income situation changes year to year all these things interact with each other in ways that aren't obvious. Worth actually sitting with someone who knows taxes or at least using a good software that asks the right questions.

0 coins

Tax software like TurboTax or FreeTaxUSA walks you through entering your 1099-G and usually handles the interaction with credits automatically. FreeTaxUSA is free for federal and very cheap for state - good option if you're watching expenses while on UI.

0 coins

FreeTaxUSA is what I ended up using the second year and it was much clearer. It specifically asked about UI benefits and the 1099-G and I didn't have to figure out where it went on my own.

0 coins

My claim overlapped with a short period where I did part-time gig work and I did not handle the reporting to NYSDOL correctly at first. Got that sorted out but it also made my taxes messier - I had UI income plus gig income with no withholding on either. Ended up owing a decent chunk. I really wish I had set up at least the 10% federal withholding from the start of my claim.

0 coins

How did you handle the gig income reporting to NYSDOL while you were collecting? I've been worried about that side of things too if I pick up any freelance work.

0 coins

You have to report any earnings in the week you earned them, even if you haven't been paid yet. NYSDOL reduces your benefit for that week based on a formula - you don't lose the full benefit dollar for dollar, there's a partial benefit calculation. But you have to report it or it's fraud, and they do catch it through wage cross-matching after the fact.

0 coins

Okay I'll keep that in mind. I haven't done any freelance yet but it's good to know exactly how it works before I do.

0 coins

My tax preparer last year said she sees more surprises from UI income than almost anything else because people genuinely don't expect it to be taxable. She said the question she gets most is 'but I already lost my job, why do I owe taxes on the help I got?' which is fair but unfortunately not how it works. The benefits are considered replacement income by the federal government.

0 coins

My first reaction when I found out was pretty much that exact complaint. It does feel strange to owe taxes on money you received because you were unemployed. But logically it makes sense that it's income replacement.

0 coins

There was briefly a federal exclusion during the pandemic years where some UI was tax-free but that ended. There's been some talk of making it permanent but nothing has actually changed, it's fully taxable again.

0 coins

I've seen people online confidently saying UI is still partially tax-free because of that pandemic rule. It is not, as of the current tax year. Worth being clear about that so nobody files incorrectly thinking they have an exclusion they don't.

0 coins

My adjudication dragged on way longer than expected and I had a question about whether the back-paid benefits covering multiple weeks would all count as income in the year I received them or be spread across the weeks they covered. Couldn't get anyone at NYSDOL by phone for weeks - busy signals every single time. Used Claimyr to get through the hold line and finally reached an agent. She confirmed that the year the payment hits your account is the year it's taxable, regardless of which weeks it was for. So a lump of back-paid benefits all received in December counts entirely in that tax year.

0 coins

Oh that's actually a really important detail. So if someone's adjudication resolves in January and they get back pay for the previous year's weeks, it's still taxed in the year they receive it not the year it was for?

0 coins

My agent confirmed it's based on when you receive the funds, not the period they cover. So yes, if adjudication resolves in January and pays out in January, that's income for the new year even if the weeks were from December. Something to keep in mind strategically if you have any control over timing.

0 coins

This came up with my claim too. The 1099-G reflects what was actually paid out in the calendar year. NYSDOL doesn't split it by the period the payment relates to.

0 coins

This is a standard tax rule that applies to most income - it's called the 'cash basis' timing rule. The year you constructively receive it is the year you report it.

0 coins

My mom went through this last year and was absolutely convinced she didn't have to file at all because she was 'only on unemployment.' She ended up needing to file because her UI benefits exceeded the filing threshold. If you're wondering whether you even need to file - yes, you almost certainly do if you collected UI benefits and your total income was above the standard deduction, because you need to report that 1099-G income.

0 coins

My neighbor had the same misconception. She thought 'I'm unemployed, I have no income to report.' But the UI benefits themselves are income. Easy mistake to make.

0 coins

The 1099-G actually gets reported to the IRS too, not just sent to you. So even if someone tried to skip reporting it, the IRS would see the mismatch. Better to report it correctly from the start.

0 coins

My first time filing after a year on UI I went to H&R Block and the person there had to explain the 1099-G form to me three separate times before I understood what was happening. I genuinely thought the box marked 'unemployment compensation' was some kind of penalty I'd incurred, not my benefit payments. The tax form language is confusing if you've never seen it before.

0 coins

I would have made the same mistake honestly. 'Compensation' sounds like something you paid to someone, not something you received.

0 coins

My preparer showed me that the form also shows whether you had any withholding taken out during the year, in a separate box. So when you get your 1099-G in January you can see at a glance how much was withheld versus how much was paid out total.

0 coins

The 1099-G usually arrives by late January. Some states let you access it electronically through their online portal before the paper copy arrives - NYSDOL puts it in your Unemployment Services account so you can grab it early if you're antsy to file.

0 coins

My benefits extended through December last year and I was really stressed about the tax situation. I made a simple spreadsheet where I tracked every weekly payment as it hit and set aside 15% of each one into a savings account. By January I had exactly the right amount sitting there ready. It made tax season way less stressful than the alternative of hoping I had enough in checking.

0 coins

That's such a simple and obvious solution, I'm going to do this for the remaining payments I get. Even 15% of what's left will help soften the eventual bill.

0 coins

My spreadsheet also helped me estimate what my 1099-G would show before it arrived, so I wasn't blindsided. I had a pretty accurate picture of my tax situation by November.

0 coins

Tracking it week by week is so much better than getting the 1099-G in January and doing the math backwards. I wish I had done that my first year instead of being shocked in the spring.

0 coins

My tax situation that year was complicated by moving mid-year as well. Had wages in a different state before moving to New York, then collected NYSDOL benefits after establishing residency here. That meant two state tax returns plus the federal. Each state only taxes the income earned or received while you were a resident, so it's manageable but annoying.

0 coins

I'm fortunate that I didn't move at all this year, that sounds like it would add a whole extra layer of complexity.

0 coins

Part-year resident returns are honestly not that bad with good software - both states know you were part-year and have the right forms. The key thing is making sure you don't double-count the NYSDOL benefits on both state returns. You were only a resident of one state when you collected them.

0 coins

My claim had an unusual situation where I received a small overpayment notice from NYSDOL and had to pay some money back. I always wondered whether that reduces what I report on my taxes. Got some conflicting info on this.

0 coins

My tax preparer handled this - if you repaid an overpayment in the same tax year you received it, the repayment reduces your 1099-G amount or at least what you report. If you repaid it in a different tax year, there's a deduction called a 'claim of right' deduction you can take. It's more complex but there is a way to account for it.

0 coins

My repayment happened in a different tax year so the claim of right situation applied. The IRS has a specific worksheet for it in the instructions for Schedule A. It's annoying but at least it's not just lost money.

0 coins

Repayments are definitely something to flag for a tax preparer or look up carefully. The rules differ based on the amount of the repayment and the year it occurred.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure