Back to New York Unemployment

Zoe Papadopoulos

Do S corp owners have to pay unemployment tax in New York?

So I've been running my small business as an S corp for about two years now and my accountant just dropped this on me last week - apparently there's a question about whether I owe unemployment taxes as an owner-employee. I honestly had no idea this was even a thing. I pay myself a salary through the S corp (W-2 wages, the whole deal) and suddenly I'm reading conflicting stuff online about whether S corp shareholders who work in the business have to pay into the NY unemployment insurance system. The confusing part is that some sources say owner-employees of S corps ARE covered employees for UI purposes and others say they're excluded. My accountant wasn't even 100% sure and told me to look into it further. I've been trying to get a straight answer out of NYSDOL but their phone lines are basically impossible to get through. Has anyone dealt with this directly? Do S corp owners have to pay unemployment tax here in New York, and if so, can the owner actually collect if the business closes?

Wow, $1,800 in potential back UI taxes is what woke me up to this same issue. The rule in New York is actually pretty specific - if you own more than 25% of the S corp, you're excluded from unemployment insurance coverage. That means the S corp doesn't pay UI taxes on your wages and you can't collect benefits if the business goes under. But if you own 25% or less, you're treated just like any other employee for UI purposes.

0 coins

Thanks - so the 25% threshold is the actual cutoff? That's really the number I needed. I own 100% so I guess I'm excluded from both paying in and collecting.

0 coins

wait so if two people own an s corp 50/50 neither of them can get unemployment? thats kind of wild

0 coins

Exactly right on that. Two 50/50 owners are both over 25% so neither would be covered under NY UI. The business also wouldn't owe UI contributions on their wages. Only W-2 employees who aren't majority owners would be covered.

0 coins

My CPA had me going in circles on this for months. The way NYSDOL looks at it is based on ownership percentage, not on whether you're an officer or how much control you have over the business. I've seen people assume that being president or CEO of your own S corp automatically excludes you, but it's purely the ownership stake that matters for UI purposes in New York.

0 coins

Good to know it's strictly ownership percentage and not the title. So theoretically a 20% shareholder-employee who's also the CEO would still be covered?

0 coins

Yes, that's correct. A 20% owner-employee would be a covered employee, the S corp would owe UI contributions on their wages, and they could potentially file a claim if they lost that employment. The 25% line is what NYSDOL cares about.

0 coins

i think i messed this up for like 3 years at my company lol. we had a minority shareholder working for us and i never paid UI on her wages because i thought owners were all exempt. guessing thats gonna be a problem

0 coins

Honestly after spending three days trying to get NYSDOL on the phone about an ownership exclusion question, I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) - it basically waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up on the phone with a live agent instead of sitting there listening to hold music for hours. There's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. I ended up talking to an actual NYSDOL rep who confirmed the 25% rule and also told me whether our specific situation required us to file amended returns. Saved me an enormous headache.

0 coins

Three days trying - yeah that's about where I am. Did the agent actually know the S corp ownership rules specifically or did you have to get transferred around?

0 coins

The first agent I spoke to knew it right away. She pulled up the relevant section and walked me through what records NYSDOL would want if they ever audited the ownership structure. It was a pretty thorough conversation honestly.

0 coins

Does that work for employer-side questions too or just claimants? I'm trying to reach the employer registration side of NYSDOL and the number I have just rings forever.

0 coins

My question was entirely on the employer side - UI contributions, ownership exclusions, all of that. So yes, Claimyr works for employer account questions too, not just people filing claims.

0 coins

Former HR manager here and I dealt with this exact question for years. The 25% threshold comes from Section 511 of the New York Labor Law. What catches people off guard is that the exclusion applies to the WAGES paid to those owners - so if your 100% shareholder-employee earns $90,000 a year, the S corp doesn't remit UI contributions on any of that. For everyone else on payroll under 25% ownership, you're paying the standard NY UI rate on the first $12,800 of each employee's wages per year (the taxable wage base in 2025).

0 coins

The $12,800 taxable wage base is new info for me - I had no idea it was capped. So for my regular employees I'd only pay UI on the first $12,800 each earns in a year?

0 coins

Correct. After an employee hits $12,800 in wages for the calendar year, no more UI contributions are owed on that person until January resets the clock. The rate itself varies by employer experience rating but new employers typically start at 4.025% in New York.

0 coins

wait the taxable wage base changed again? i thought it was lower than that. they keep bumping it up every year it seems like

0 coins

My business partner and I had a whole argument about this last year. He was convinced we had to pay UI on both our salaries because we took W-2 wages. I kept saying we were exempt because we each own 50%. We finally got it sorted out when I used Claimyr to reach a NYSDOL agent directly - confirmed we were both excluded because we're both over 25%. My partner was so annoyed he'd been worrying about it for nothing.

0 coins

Ha - my husband and I did the same thing with our S corp. Took us way too long to find out we were both excluded.

0 coins

The frustrating part is it's not like NYSDOL advertises this clearly anywhere. You have to really dig or actually talk to someone to get a straight answer.

0 coins

Yep, that's exactly where I landed - couldn't find a clear NYSDOL publication that spelled it out plainly for S corps specifically.

0 coins

ok genuine question - if you're excluded from unemployment as a 100% s corp owner can you just... voluntarily elect to be covered? like pay in anyway so you have the safety net if things go bad?

0 coins

Interesting question - actually yes, New York does allow certain excluded workers to elect voluntary coverage under UI. You'd need to file for it with NYSDOL and there are specific conditions, but it's not impossible. The issue is you'd need to maintain it consistently, you can't just turn it on when the business starts struggling.

0 coins

ok that's actually really useful. so you opt in, pay the contributions for a certain period, and then you'd have coverage? seems worth looking into for people with volatile industries

0 coins

The voluntary coverage election has to be approved by NYSDOL and typically needs to be maintained for at least two calendar years once elected. It's not commonly used but it does exist. Worth calling NYSDOL's employer accounts line to ask about the specifics for your situation.

0 coins

My S corp question was different but related - I have one employee who's also a 10% shareholder (bought in last year). I had been treating her as fully excluded from UI which was wrong. Had to do some amended filings. The good news is NYSDOL was pretty reasonable about it when I explained what happened.

0 coins

That's reassuring - did they charge penalties on the missed contributions or were they understanding about an honest mistake?

0 coins

They waived the penalties because it was clearly an inadvertent misclassification and I came to them proactively. The interest was minimal because we caught it within the same tax year. I'd recommend getting ahead of it if you think you owe anything.

0 coins

ok this is making me very nervous about my situation that I mentioned above. probably need to actually call them and sort it out before they find it themselves

0 coins

THE NYSDOL PHONE LINE IS ABSOLUTELY USELESS. I spent literally 6 hours across two days trying to reach employer accounts. Got disconnected twice, sat on hold for 90 minutes once and then the line just went dead. This is why small business owners make mistakes on this stuff - there's no easy way to just ASK someone the question!!

0 coins

Six hours is brutal. I've had days like that with NYSDOL too. At some point it just becomes demoralizing.

0 coins

AND THEN when you finally get someone they're sometimes not even sure of the answer and want to transfer you and you get disconnected AGAIN. The system is broken.

0 coins

Honestly I had the same rage-quit moment with NYSDOL phones before someone in another thread told me about Claimyr. It waits on hold for you so you actually end up talking to a real agent without burning your whole afternoon. The difference was night and day - I had my answer in one shot instead of a week of frustration.

0 coins

Does it actually work for employer account questions specifically? Because I feel like the employer line is a different beast than the claimant line

0 coins

My accountant also flagged this issue for me and suggested I call NYSDOL to verify our specific ownership percentages against their records. I tried Claimyr after reading about it somewhere and ended up speaking with an agent in the employer accounts division who pulled our account and confirmed how we were coded. Turns out we were actually coded incorrectly in NYSDOL's system - as covered employees when we should've been excluded - and the agent walked me through getting it corrected.

0 coins

Wait - so NYSDOL had your ownership status coded wrong in their system? How does that even happen?

0 coins

From what the agent told me, it happens when the initial registration doesn't include ownership percentage documentation, so they default to treating everyone as covered. We'd been technically paying UI contributions we didn't owe for two years. Got a credit applied.

0 coins

Claimyr also worked well for me when I needed to sort out an employer account issue - ended up on the phone with an agent the same afternoon I tried it. These employer-side questions are way easier when you can actually reach a human.

0 coins

hold on you got a credit back for overpaid contributions? i thought NYSDOL never gave money back once it was paid in

0 coins

My understanding is that C corps and S corps get treated differently for some tax purposes but for NY UI it's really just that ownership percentage question that matters. The corporate structure itself - S election, number of shareholders, etc. - doesn't change the analysis beyond who owns what percentage.

0 coins

What about LLC members? I always wondered if the same 25% rule applies to LLC owners or if that's a whole different analysis

0 coins

LLCs are actually more complicated because it depends on how the LLC is treated for tax purposes. A single-member LLC taxed as a sole prop is handled differently than an LLC that elected S corp status. That one's worth a direct call to NYSDOL rather than relying on forum wisdom.

0 coins

Agreed - LLC treatment for UI purposes is genuinely complicated and there have been some changes in how NYSDOL handles it. For the standard S corp question the answer is cleaner.

0 coins

I've been lurking this thread and there's one wrinkle nobody's mentioned - what about S corps with family members as employees? Like my wife works in the business but doesn't own any shares. She's not an owner at all, so she should be fully covered and we pay UI on her wages, right?

0 coins

Spouses and family members who actually work in the business and are on payroll with W-2s are generally covered employees if they don't meet the ownership exclusion threshold. So yes, if your wife is a genuine W-2 employee with 0% ownership, the S corp should be paying UI contributions on her wages.

0 coins

Got it - and she'd be able to file a claim if for some reason we had to close or lay her off? Even though she's married to the owner?

0 coins

Family relationship alone doesn't disqualify her from UI coverage as long as she's a legitimate W-2 employee and the relationship doesn't create an ownership stake. There can be other eligibility questions around family businesses but the UI contribution obligation should still apply.

0 coins

Does this question change at all if the S corp has like 20 shareholders? I'm in a professional practice - law firm - structured as an S corp and we have 18 equity partners all with varying percentages. Some are above 25% some are below.

0 coins

The analysis is per person in that case. Each equity partner's ownership stake is evaluated individually. Partners with more than 25% are excluded, those at 25% or below are covered employees for UI purposes. So your firm might have some partners paying into UI and some not, depending on their individual ownership percentages.

0 coins

That's what I thought but our payroll company was treating ALL partners as excluded regardless of percentage. I need to go back and check individual stakes.

0 coins

Yeah that's a potential issue worth cleaning up. If you have partners at say 15% or 20% ownership, the firm should technically be paying UI contributions on their W-2 wages. Getting it corrected proactively is the right move.

0 coins

ok slightly off topic but can we talk about what happens if an S corp owner does somehow manage to file for unemployment - like they're the sole owner, business goes bankrupt, they had no idea they were excluded. do they just get denied or is there some process?

0 coins

They'd get denied at the monetary determination stage most likely - NYSDOL would see the wages are from an S corp where the person is the majority owner and issue a disqualification. There's an appeal process but unless the ownership percentage is actually under 25%, an appeal wouldn't change the outcome.

0 coins

that's pretty brutal honestly. like you run a small business for 10 years, it fails, and you can't get any help from the system you've been adjacent to the whole time

0 coins

It's one of the tradeoffs of business ownership - you have control and potential upside but you don't have the safety net. The voluntary coverage election exists partly for this reason but very few owners bother to set it up in advance.

0 coins

I always assumed S corps were completely outside the whole unemployment system and I ran mine for 4 years without thinking about it once. Turns out I WAS paying UI on my employees' wages properly through my payroll service but just hadn't thought about whether I myself was included. Good reminder to actually understand what payroll is doing.

0 coins

Same situation here basically. My payroll company handles the quarterly filings and I honestly just trusted that it was all correct. This thread made me pull up my actual filings to check.

0 coins

What did you find when you looked?

0 coins

I found that my wages as 100% owner were correctly excluded and my two employees' wages were correctly covered. So payroll company got it right, I just had no idea what they were doing or why.

0 coins

My situation is a bit different - I'm a part owner at 15% and I was told by HR that I might not be covered for unemployment. They seemed confused about the rule. After this thread I'm pretty confident they were wrong and I AM covered since I'm under 25%.

0 coins

You're reading the rule correctly. At 15% you should be treated as a covered employee. I'd verify with NYSDOL directly just to have it confirmed, especially if your employer is telling you otherwise - it matters for whether contributions are being paid on your wages.

0 coins

How do I verify it on my end - is there a way to check whether my employer is actually paying UI contributions on my wages without asking them directly?

0 coins

You can contact NYSDOL's employer accounts division and ask whether UI contributions have been paid on your wages. You'd need to provide your employer's information. It's not commonly done but you have every right to ask.

0 coins

The original question about whether s corp owners have to pay unemployment tax has a pretty clean answer in NY and I'm glad this thread worked through it. The 25% threshold, the ability to voluntarily elect coverage, the fact that non-owner employees are covered regardless - all of this is stuff that every S corp owner should know and almost none of them do.

0 coins

Honestly agreed - I went into this thread knowing nothing and I'm coming out of it understanding my situation pretty clearly. 100% owner, correctly excluded, no contributions on my wages, no ability to collect if things go south unless I proactively elect voluntary coverage.

0 coins

And the voluntary coverage angle is worth at least exploring if your industry has real downside risk. Locking it in before things go wrong is the only time it makes sense.

0 coins

I'm actually going to look into the voluntary coverage election for my own S corp. Never knew it was an option before this thread.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure