Back to New York Unemployment

Connor O'Brien

Can you file for unemployment if you get fired? My NYSDOL situation explained

So I got let go from my job at a distribution warehouse last Tuesday and I'm honestly not sure where to stand with unemployment. My supervisor said I was being terminated for 'performance issues' but I never received any written warnings, no formal documentation, nothing. I showed up every shift, did my job, and then out of nowhere HR called me in and that was it. I'm now trying to figure out if I can even collect UI benefits after getting fired or if that automatically disqualifies me. I've heard conflicting things from people - some say you can file no matter what, others say getting fired means you get nothing. I have a mortgage and bills due in three weeks so this isn't a hypothetical for me, it's urgent. Filed my initial claim on the NYSDOL portal two days ago and it's just sitting there saying 'pending.' Anyone been through this?

Week two of my own adjudication right now, so I've been deep in this research. To answer your main question - yes, you absolutely can file for unemployment if you fired, and in New York the bar for disqualifying someone who was terminated is actually pretty high. NYSDOL has to find that you were let go for 'misconduct' - not just poor performance or not being a good fit. No written warnings, no documented discipline? That works in your favor big time. Now the reason I'm jumping in early is because I had a brutal time actually getting anyone at NYSDOL on the phone to ask questions like yours. Spent three days redialing and getting cut off. Someone in another thread mentioned Claimyr - claimyr.com - and there's a video walkthrough at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. What it does is wait on hold with NYSDOL so you don't have to, and I ended up speaking directly with a live agent who walked me through my adjudication status. If your claim stays in 'pending' more than a few days, that might be worth trying.

0 coins

Thanks, that's reassuring about the misconduct standard. Did your adjudication get resolved yet or are you still waiting?

0 coins

The misconduct definition in NY is actually narrower than most people realize. I went through a termination appeal last year - my employer claimed attendance issues but I had FMLA-protected absences. NYSDOL sided with me because the employer couldn't prove willful disregard of company rules. OP your situation with zero written warnings sounds similar.

0 coins

Okay so they have to prove I deliberately did something wrong, not just that my numbers were off or whatever?

0 coins

Exactly. There's a difference between being bad at your job and intentionally breaking rules. NYSDOL adjudicators know this distinction and your employer will have to show evidence of the second kind.

0 coins

My termination letter said 'position elimination' but then my employer told NYSDOL I quit voluntarily - almost cost me everything. The thing that saved me was keeping every single text, email, and voicemail from my employer before I was let go. If you have anything in writing from HR or your supervisor even casually mentioning your performance being an issue, hold onto it. NYSDOL adjudicators request documentation from both sides and you'll want your own paper trail.

0 coins

I do have a few texts from my supervisor that might be relevant. Should I upload those to my Unemployment Services account portal or wait until NYSDOL asks?

0 coins

Upload what you can now and document everything with dates. When adjudication starts they'll send you a questionnaire asking for your version of events - that's your main chance to lay it all out clearly.

0 coins

This is solid advice. The initial claimant questionnaire during adjudication is where most people either win or lose their case. Take your time on it, be specific, and don't leave anything out.

0 coins

I got fired back in March from a retail management job - my company said it was for 'policy violations' but it was actually because I reported a safety issue to HR and then suddenly I was on a performance plan that materialized out of nowhere. Filed my UI claim, went into adjudication, and I'll be real with you - the process is stressful. What helped me was understanding that NYSDOL sends a fact-finding questionnaire to both you and your former employer separately. Your employer has to actually substantiate whatever reason they gave for firing you. If they can't back it up with documentation, that weighs heavily in your favor. My claim was approved about five weeks after filing.

0 coins

Five weeks is a long wait - were you able to get any updates during that time or just sitting in the dark?

0 coins

Mostly sitting in the dark honestly. My Unemployment Services account just showed 'adjudication in progress' the whole time. I tried calling probably a dozen times over those five weeks.

0 coins

The lack of communication during adjudication is one of the most maddening parts of the whole process. You're just supposed to keep filing your weekly claims and hope for the best apparently.

0 coins

You should absolutely keep filing weekly certifications even while in adjudication - if your claim is approved the payments go back and cover all those weeks you certified. Missing a week can create a gap in your payment history that's a headache to fix.

0 coins

got fired last year didnt even bother filing bc i thought u couldnt get unemployment after being fired lol. a coworker told me later i probably wouldve been approved. so yeah definitely file, dont make my mistake

0 coins

This is so common - there's a huge misconception that any termination automatically disqualifies you. The state has to find actual misconduct on your part, not just that your boss decided they didn't want you anymore.

0 coins

yeah i was let go for 'not meeting expectations' which apparently is not the same thing as misconduct at all. lesson learned the hard way lol

0 coins

Filing my weekly cert this morning and saw this thread. The fired vs. quit distinction matters so much in NY. When you quit, you have to prove you had good cause to leave. When you're fired, the burden shifts - your employer has to prove you committed disqualifying misconduct. That's a meaningful legal difference that most people don't know walking in. Performance issues, personality conflicts, restructuring - none of those automatically count as misconduct under NYSDOL's definition.

0 coins

My HR person actually used the phrase 'this isn't working out' in the meeting. Does vague language like that help my case?

0 coins

It can. Vague termination language often signals that the employer doesn't have a specific, documented misconduct reason. NYSDOL adjudicators look for concrete evidence of rule violations and vague language doesn't provide that.

0 coins

My termination meeting used similar language and I was approved after adjudication. The employer submitted basically nothing to NYSDOL to justify the termination and that was pretty much that.

0 coins

The HR department at my old job tried to pressure me into signing a resignation letter instead of accepting a termination. If you're in that situation right now, do NOT sign anything saying you resigned voluntarily if you're actually being let go.

0 coins

Three weeks into adjudication when I found this thread, so this is timely. My situation is similar - terminated, employer claimed misconduct, I have zero disciplinary history. What finally helped me move things along was actually getting to speak to an adjudicator directly. Used Claimyr to get through since I kept hitting the busy signal or automated system. Ended up on the phone with a real NYSDOL agent who confirmed they had received my employer's response and that my questionnaire was under review. At least I knew where things stood.

0 coins

Good to know there's a way to actually reach someone. Did the agent give you any sense of timing?

0 coins

They said adjudication timelines vary based on caseload but mine had everything they needed. That was more information than I'd gotten from staring at the portal for three weeks.

0 coins

I've had the same experience - you can go weeks with the portal showing nothing and then find out from an agent that your case has actually been progressing fine the whole time.

0 coins

My agent also told me which week the payment would process when my adjudication was resolved. That was such a relief to have actual intel instead of just guessing.

0 coins

My employer fought my UI claim hard - submitted a whole packet of documentation to NYSDOL claiming I had been repeatedly counseled about performance. Problem was, I'd never signed anything or received anything in writing. NYSDOL requested I respond to the employer's submission with my own statement. I wrote a detailed, factual account of my employment, noted that I had never received written warnings, and listed the dates I was actually at work. Got approved. The process works if you engage with it seriously.

0 coins

How detailed did your written statement need to be? Like bullet points or more of a narrative?

0 coins

I did a mix - short introduction, then bullet points with specific dates and facts, then a brief closing. Clear and organized seemed to work better than a long emotional explanation.

0 coins

Agreed on being factual rather than emotional. The adjudicator is looking for facts that match or contradict what your employer submitted, not how upset you were.

0 coins

Employer here - I know that might make some people dismiss this but hear me out. In my experience with NYSDOL claims when we've had to terminate employees, the department really does investigate carefully. If we don't have documentation - written warnings, performance improvement plans with signatures, incident reports - our submission to NYSDOL is basically empty and the claimant typically wins. I've seen terminated employees receive benefits in cases where management knew the right answer but hadn't done the paperwork. The system does have some logic to it.

0 coins

Honestly this is a helpful perspective. It confirms that the burden really is on the employer to show documented misconduct, not just assert it.

0 coins

This matches what I know from the claimant side. Employer documentation (or lack of it) is often the deciding factor. No paper trail = no misconduct finding.

0 coins

I really appreciate you sharing this. Knowing my employer likely has nothing documented makes me feel more confident about my claim.

0 coins

My husband was fired last spring over what his employer called 'insubordination' - turned out to be a disagreement he had with a manager that the manager then exaggerated into a formal complaint after the fact. NYSDOL sent both sides questionnaires, the employer's account had obvious inconsistencies, and my husband was approved. He'd been worried sick that the word 'insubordination' on his termination paperwork would automatically sink him. It didn't, because NYSDOL looked at what actually happened, not just what the employer called it.

0 coins

Labels on termination paperwork don't automatically determine eligibility - what matters is whether the actual conduct behind the label meets the legal definition of misconduct.

0 coins

Exactly - his HR paperwork said insubordination but when NYSDOL asked for specifics the employer couldn't provide a concrete account of what he actually did that violated which specific rule.

0 coins

Mine just says 'performance-related separation' which is vague. I guess that works in my favor based on what everyone's saying here.

0 coins

week 1 of my claim and i was also fired so this thread is exactly what i needed. does anyone know if they contact your old employer right away or does that happen later in the adjudication

0 coins

NYSDOL typically reaches out to the employer after the initial claim is processed and flagged for adjudication - usually within the first couple of weeks. Your employer then has a window to respond, and after that NYSDOL sends you a fact-finding questionnaire.

0 coins

okay so there's like a whole back and forth process. i didn't realize it was that involved

0 coins

The timing can vary but that's roughly the sequence. Some claims move faster, some slower - depends on NYSDOL's caseload and how quickly your former employer responds.

0 coins

My adjudication dragged into week six and I was completely losing my mind not knowing what was going on. My portal hadn't updated and I was running out of savings. A friend suggested Claimyr and I figured I had nothing to lose. Ended up talking to an NYSDOL agent who told me my claim was actually in final review - it resolved four days later and I got all my back payments for the weeks I'd been certifying. The frustrating part was the information was available, I just had no way to get to it without reaching an actual human at NYSDOL.

0 coins

Six weeks sounds awful. I'm already anxious at day two. Glad it resolved for you though.

0 coins

Keep filing your weekly certifications no matter what - that's the main thing. All those weeks count once you're approved.

0 coins

The back payments piece is so important for people to understand. Those aren't lost just because your claim is in adjudication - as long as you kept certifying.

0 coins

wait so even if ur in adjudication u keep certifying every week and those weeks get paid when u get approved? i didn't know that

0 coins

My former employer flat out lied on their NYSDOL questionnaire response - said I had received three verbal warnings when I'd never been spoken to about my performance once in four years. I disputed every point in my response with dates, records, and a list of coworkers who witnessed my actual performance. NYSDOL took about two and a half weeks after I submitted my response before they ruled in my favor. It's infuriating that the employer can say whatever they want but at least NYSDOL gives you a chance to refute it.

0 coins

This is a really good point - the fact-finding questionnaire is YOUR chance to tell your side clearly. Don't just answer questions minimally, give full context.

0 coins

I wrote probably four pages responding to their claims. Every point they made I addressed directly with what I could document or at least describe specifically.

0 coins

NYSDOL adjudicators are reading a lot of these cases - clear, organized responses that directly counter specific employer claims tend to land better than general statements.

0 coins

My claim went into adjudication after I was fired from a food distribution job - employer claimed I violated safety protocols. I had to track down my own incident records and get a written statement from a coworker who was present. NYSDOL approved me after I submitted that additional documentation. The lesson I took away: gather every piece of documentation you can before NYSDOL even asks for it, so when they do ask you're ready to respond quickly.

0 coins

How do you submit additional documentation? Through the portal or by mail?

0 coins

Both options exist but the portal is faster. When you receive the fact-finding questionnaire there's usually an upload function in your Unemployment Services account.

0 coins

Mail works too but add significant time to your timeline. Portal upload is definitely the way to go if you can.

0 coins

I'm a week past my initial filing and genuinely panicking reading this. Mine also says pending and I was fired for what they called 'violations of company policy' - but the policy they're referencing was something in the handbook I genuinely didn't know was a rule. Does not knowing a rule count against you in adjudication?

0 coins

Genuinely not knowing a rule - especially if you were never trained on it, never told about it, and no one had flagged it before - is actually part of the analysis. NYSDOL considers whether the employee had reasonable notice that their conduct was prohibited.

0 coins

There's a difference in how NYSDOL looks at willful misconduct versus a mistake or misunderstanding. If you can show you weren't aware of the rule and no one told you, that weakens the misconduct finding.

0 coins

okay this helps a lot. the policy was buried in a 90 page handbook and was never covered in my training.

0 coins

Document that - note that you were never trained on that specific policy and never received communication about it. Include it in your fact-finding response.

0 coins

My termination was two months ago and I've been through the whole adjudication process now. I want to come back and share what I learned for people just starting out like OP: the fact-finding questionnaire is everything. Write it like you're explaining what happened to someone who knows nothing about your job or your workplace. Be specific about dates, what was or wasn't said, and what documentation does or does not exist. Don't assume the adjudicator knows your industry. My claim was approved and I genuinely believe it came down to how thoroughly I filled out that questionnaire.

0 coins

This is really helpful, thank you. I'm going to take my time with the questionnaire when it comes.

0 coins

Also - and I cannot stress this enough - keep filing your weekly certifications every single week without fail. Even if your claim is stuck, even if you have no idea what's happening. Those weeks are what gets paid out if you're approved.

0 coins

The questionnaire advice is spot on. I rushed mine the first time because I was panicking and I think it hurt my initial response. Took more time on the follow-up and that's when things turned around.

0 coins

Treating it like you're explaining to someone with no background knowledge is excellent framing. Adjudicators handle cases across dozens of industries - they don't know what your specific job or workplace is like unless you tell them.

0 coins

My whole experience with getting fired and filing UI was a wake-up call about documentation in general. I had been at my job three years and never kept any personal records of anything - no copies of my own performance reviews, no saved messages, nothing. When adjudication happened I was scrambling. Now I keep a personal folder with any work communications, performance reviews, anything relevant. If you're in a job right now and reading this, start keeping your own records even if everything seems fine.

0 coins

This is such underrated advice. So many people are caught off guard because they assumed their employer's records were also their records.

0 coins

I had to request my own personnel file through HR after I was already fired just to know what documentation even existed about me. That's not a position you want to be in during adjudication.

0 coins

I actually did this - requested my file within days of termination. Found out there was essentially nothing in it related to the supposed policy violation they fired me for.

0 coins

My sister went through this whole thing - fired, adjudication, the works - and she kept asking me whether she should just take whatever part-time work she could find while waiting or whether that would mess up her claim. For anyone in that situation: you can work while your UI claim is being processed, you just have to report any earnings honestly when you certify each week. NYSDOL adjusts your benefit amount based on what you earned that week. Working a little doesn't disqualify you, hiding earnings does.

0 coins

This is accurate and really important. You can earn up to a certain amount without losing your full week's benefit, and earnings above that reduce your benefit dollar for dollar. Report everything honestly.

0 coins

She was so worried that any income would just cancel her UI entirely. The reality is so much more nuanced than people assume.

0 coins

Good to know - I've been considering doing some gig work while waiting and wasn't sure if that was okay.

0 coins

Gig work counts as earnings and needs to be reported, but it doesn't disqualify you from UI. Just make sure you log it accurately on your weekly certification.

0 coins

My claim finally resolved after all that adjudication stress and I was approved. For anyone just starting this process: the whole thing genuinely does feel like you're just stuck waiting with no information. What I'd suggest is keep filing each week, keep any documentation you have ready to submit, respond to NYSDOL questionnaires quickly and thoroughly, and if you need to actually talk to someone about your claim status don't hesitate to find a way to reach a live agent. The portal alone will drive you crazy.

0 coins

Appreciate the update and the encouragement. Still early in my claim but feeling more prepared after reading through all of this.

0 coins

You've got the basics down - no written warnings, vague termination language, documentation gathering. That's already more than a lot of people know going in.

0 coins

Ending on that note - yes to everything said here. File weekly, respond thoroughly, document everything. The process is slow and stressful but it does work if you engage with it.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure