Back to New York Unemployment

NebulaNomad

Can you draw unemployment if you quit a job? My NYSDOL situation explained

So I left my job at a distribution warehouse last month and I'm trying to figure out where I stand with unemployment. My hours had been getting slashed for about three months straight — went from 40 hours down to 22, then 18, then some weeks barely 14. I finally told them I couldn't keep going because I had rent and bills that weren't getting any smaller. HR said I 'voluntarily resigned' on the paperwork but I honestly felt like I had no real choice at that point. Now I'm looking at this NYSDOL claim I filed and it says it's under review. I've heard people say you can't get anything if you quit but I've also heard there are exceptions. Can you draw unemployment if you quit a job in New York, or am I completely out of luck here? My claim has been sitting for almost two weeks with no movement and I genuinely don't know what to expect.

Your situation with the reduced hours is actually a recognized exception under New York's unemployment rules. What NYSDOL calls 'good cause' for leaving a job covers cases where your employer significantly cut your hours — going from 40 down to 14 is a massive reduction and that's exactly the kind of thing that can qualify. The key phrase you want to research is 'constructive discharge' or leaving for good cause attributable to the employer. When you're in adjudication, a claims examiner is basically reviewing whether your reason for leaving fits one of these exceptions. You'll probably need to explain the hour reductions clearly, so write down the timeline you mentioned — the dates, the hour counts, anything in writing from your employer about schedule changes.

0 coins

My paystubs actually show the drop really clearly week by week. Should I upload those somewhere in my Unemployment Services account or wait until they ask?

0 coins

Your account should have a document upload option under your claim details. Getting those paystubs in there now is a good move, don't wait for them to ask — it shows you're on top of it and gives the examiner something concrete to work with.

0 coins

Agreed, the paystub trail is huge in these situations. Hour reductions are easier to prove than a lot of other good cause claims because the numbers speak for themselves.

0 coins

Two weeks in adjudication with no updates and no way to get anyone on the phone — I know exactly what that feels like. When I was dealing with a similar review situation last year I eventually tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) after getting nowhere with NYSDOL's phone line. What it does is wait on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up talking directly to a live agent. There's a demo video at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE if you want to see how it works before you try it. I was actually able to ask the agent what documentation they needed for my adjudication and that made a huge difference in getting things resolved faster.

0 coins

Two weeks of trying to get through myself and not once did I reach a real person, so this is worth a look. Did the agent actually give you useful information or were they just generic about it?

0 coins

My agent was genuinely helpful — told me exactly which fields in my claim had flags on them and what the examiner was looking for. Way more specific than anything you'd get from the website.

0 coins

Sounds interesting but I'm always skeptical of third party services for government stuff. Did you have to give them a ton of personal information?

0 coins

My experience was pretty straightforward, nothing unusual about what it needed. The main thing is you're getting to an actual NYSDOL agent who can look at your actual file.

0 coins

Worth pointing out that 'quitting' and 'being constructively discharged' are treated very differently by NYSDOL even if they look the same on paper. When an employer slashes your hours that severely over a sustained period, New York unemployment law has a concept where you're essentially forced out without being formally terminated. The burden in adjudication is on you to show the reduction was substantial, involuntary from your side, and that you tried to address it with the employer before leaving. Did you ever raise the hours issue with a manager or HR in writing? Even a text message or an email saying something like 'I need my hours back' works better than nothing.

0 coins

There are a few texts between me and my supervisor where I asked about getting back to full time and he kept saying 'we're figuring it out.' Nothing definitive but it shows I tried.

0 coins

Those texts are gold for your adjudication. Screenshot them and upload them along with your paystubs. The examiner needs to see that you didn't just walk out impulsively — you tried to make it work first.

0 coins

This is accurate. My adjudication last year involved leaving a job and the examiner specifically asked me whether I had raised the issue with management. I had an email and that was the thing that pushed my claim through.

0 coins

i quit a job once and got denied immediately so I assumed it was always a no. didnt realize there were exceptions to that. does the reason you give on the initial application matter a lot or do they mostly figure it out during adjudication

0 coins

Your initial application answer matters more than people realize — it sets the stage for what the adjudicator reviews. If you wrote 'quit' without explaining the circumstances, they might just see a voluntary separation and flag it for denial. The more detail you give upfront about why you left (the hours, the attempts to fix it), the better positioned you are even before adjudication starts.

0 coins

oh man I literally just wrote 'personal reasons' on mine from two years ago lol no wonder I got denied. good to know for the future

0 coins

Yeah that's basically the worst thing you can write. 'Personal reasons' tells them nothing and gives them no basis to find good cause. Always explain the employer-side factors.

0 coins

My claim went through something similar about eight months ago — I left a retail job after they cut my shifts from full time to basically nothing over six weeks. NYSDOL adjudication took 19 days and I was absolutely losing my mind waiting. What eventually happened was they sent a questionnaire to my Unemployment Services inbox asking me to describe the circumstances. I answered it really thoroughly, referenced specific dates, and within four days of submitting that I had an approval. The questionnaire is actually a good sign — it means they're actively working it, not just letting it sit.

0 coins

Haven't gotten any questionnaire yet but now I'm watching my inbox more carefully. How specific did you get in your answers — like did you give exact dates and hour counts?

0 coins

My answers were very specific. Week of this date, hours were X. Week after, hours were Y. I basically wrote it like a timeline. The examiner even mentioned in a later notice that the documentation I provided was sufficient — so the detail definitely helped.

0 coins

My questionnaire experience was similar. The more concrete you are the less back and forth there is. Vague answers lead to follow-up requests and that stretches the whole thing out.

0 coins

Let me push back slightly on something — the 'good cause' exception is real but it's not automatic just because hours went down. NYSDOL looks at how much they dropped, over how long, and whether a reasonable person would have stayed or left. A drop from 40 to 14 hours over three months is pretty strong, but I've seen claims get denied where hours dropped to 20 and the examiner decided that was still substantial enough employment. It really comes down to the examiner assigned and how well you document things. I'm not saying OP is out of luck — just that going in thinking approval is guaranteed could leave you caught off guard if there's a denial.

0 coins

That's fair. I'm trying to prepare for both outcomes honestly. If I get denied, is there a window to appeal and does that restart the whole process?

0 coins

Your appeal window is 30 days from the date on the determination letter. The appeal doesn't restart from scratch — it goes to a Board of Review hearing where you can present additional evidence. If you get denied, file the appeal on day one, don't wait.

0 coins

Appeals are actually where a lot of people succeed even after denials. The hearing gives you a chance to explain your situation out loud to a referee, not just fill out a form. Many people find that more effective.

0 coins

My wife went through almost this exact scenario two years ago — she left a nursing home job after her hours kept getting cut and they kept changing her shifts around with no notice. First she got denied at adjudication, then she appealed, and at the Board of Review hearing she brought her paystubs, her texts with the scheduler, and a written statement about how the income reduction was making it impossible to cover basic expenses. The referee sided with her and she got approved for the full period she'd filed for. The process took about three months total but she did get the benefits. The important thing was she kept her weekly certifications going the whole time even while the appeal was pending.

0 coins

Keeping weekly certifications going during the appeal — does that mean I should still be filing each week even though the claim is in adjudication right now?

0 coins

Yes, file every single week no matter what. If you get approved down the line, those weeks you filed will be backdated and you'll receive payment for all of them. If you stop filing during adjudication or during an appeal, you lose those weeks and can't get them back.

0 coins

wait this is SO important. i had no idea you had to keep filing during adjudication. i stopped filing after like week two because i thought i had to wait for a determination first

0 coins

THE NYSDOL WEBSITE IS NO HELP AT ALL for this question. I tried to find a clear answer about quitting vs good cause on their FAQ page and it just goes in circles. called the main number six times over three days and never got through, just got cut off or put on hold forever. the system is designed to make you give up

0 coins

My experience with the phone lines was identical — hours of hold time and nothing to show for it. That's exactly why I ended up using Claimyr when I needed to reach an actual agent. Got to speak with someone who could look at my claim specifics rather than reading me the same FAQ info.

0 coins

is claimyr actually reliable or is it one of those things that sounds good and then doesnt work

0 coins

My claim review situation got genuinely resolved faster after I spoke with the agent through it. I'd been getting nowhere for weeks before that.

0 coins

Just had this whole situation play out with a friend of mine. He left a food service job after his employer cut his pay rate and his hours at the same time, and he was worried he'd get nothing because he technically quit. We looked into it together and I told him to try Claimyr because I knew he'd never get through to an agent on his own — he ended up talking to a live NYSDOL agent who walked him through exactly what he needed to submit for the good cause review. The agent apparently told him that partial constructive discharge cases like his are reviewed pretty carefully but they do get approved when the documentation is there. He got approved about two weeks after that call.

0 coins

Two weeks after talking to the agent — that's pretty encouraging. Did your friend know going into that call what he was going to ask, or did the agent just take the lead?

0 coins

He had a list of questions ready. The agent pulled up his file, saw the adjudication flag, and explained what the examiner had noted. Having specific questions definitely helped him get more out of the conversation.

0 coins

Preparation matters so much on those calls. I've had good and bad agent experiences and the difference is usually whether I went in knowing exactly what I needed to ask.

0 coins

Your friend's experience matches mine — agents can actually see your claim notes in a way that's way more useful than anything on the claimant-facing portal.

0 coins

OK so here's a question that I think a lot of people wonder — if you quit because your boss was just terrible, like hostile work environment type stuff, does that count as good cause too? Or is it really only for stuff like hours cuts and pay cuts?

0 coins

Hostile work environment can qualify as good cause in New York but it's one of the harder ones to prove. NYSDOL generally wants to see that you reported the situation to HR or management, that the employer failed to address it, and that the conditions were objectively intolerable — not just that your boss was difficult. Hours and pay cuts are easier because they're documented in your wage records. Harassment claims need incident documentation, HR correspondence, etc.

0 coins

That makes sense. I was asking partly for my own situation from about a year ago where I left over a hostile manager and got denied. I didn't have any documentation at all because I just fled the situation basically.

0 coins

Documentation is everything with those cases. If you're in a bad workplace situation and thinking about leaving, the advice is always to start building that paper trail before you quit — HR emails, incident reports, anything in writing.

0 coins

i just wanna say reading this thread has me feeling less panicked about my own situation. i quit a bartending job two months ago because they kept stiffing me on tip pools and cutting my nights and my claim has been in adjudication for 24 days. i was convinced i was going to get nothing

0 coins

Your tip pool situation might actually be part of your good cause argument — wage theft or improper pay practices can support a good cause finding. Document everything you can about how the tip pool was handled and how much income you lost because of it compared to what you were told when hired.

0 coins

My paystubs show the difference clearly because I know what my cut of the pool should have been based on the percentage we were told. I've been keeping notes on my phone about which nights were short and by how much.

0 coins

Those notes and paystubs together are solid evidence. The more you can show that your income was materially affected by the employer's actions, the stronger the good cause argument becomes.

0 coins

My former coworker got approved after quitting and I remember her saying the key phrase she used in her adjudication questionnaire was something like 'the reduction in hours made continued employment financially untenable.' She said she'd read that somewhere and figured using precise language would help. I don't know if the phrasing itself matters or if it was just the substance, but she did get approved.

0 coins

Phrasing matters somewhat — using terms the examiner recognizes signals that you understand what the standard is. But the substance is what actually drives the decision. 'My hours went from 40 to 14 over 12 weeks and I raised this with management twice with no resolution' is better than fancy phrasing with no facts behind it.

0 coins

That's a fair distinction. The language probably helped frame it but the documentation is what closed it.

0 coins

My plan is to be very factual and specific in everything I submit — exact dates, exact hours, exact conversations. Reading this thread has convinced me that precision matters more than anything else.

0 coins

does anyone know if the job search requirements kick in right away when you file or do they wait until adjudication is resolved? I've been applying to jobs because i thought i had to but my friend told me to hold off until my claim is approved

0 coins

Your weekly job search activity is required from the moment you're eligible to certify, adjudication or not. In New York you need three work search activities per week when filing. If you're approved and they audit your job search log, you need to have activity logged for every week you claimed. Stopping because you're in adjudication could result in denials for specific weeks even if the main claim gets approved.

0 coins

oh no. I've been doing the searches but not logging them anywhere. I just emailed resumes and didn't keep track. is that going to be a problem

0 coins

Start a simple log right now — employer name, position, date, and how you applied. Work backward if you can remember the applications you've already sent. NYSDOL doesn't usually audit every week but if they do ask, you need something to show them.

0 coins

I keep a Google Sheet for mine. Date, company, job title, application method. Takes about two minutes per application to log and it's saved me stress twice when I had to certify about my activities.

0 coins

Went through the whole quitting-for-good-cause process last spring and I want to share what actually worked for me in case it helps anyone. My situation was an employer who kept changing my schedule with zero notice — sometimes I'd find out my shift changed the day before. I uploaded a week-by-week hour log I made in a spreadsheet, screenshots of texts where I tried to address it, and a one-page written statement explaining why the conditions made continued employment unrealistic. During adjudication I actually got to speak with a NYSDOL rep through Claimyr — the agent confirmed my documents were received and told me which part of my statement the examiner had flagged for follow-up. I addressed that in a supplemental note and got my approval letter about ten days later.

0 coins

The supplemental note idea is interesting — can you just upload that into your claim account or do you have to send it a different way?

0 coins

My supplemental note went through the document upload in my Unemployment Services account. I titled it clearly so the examiner would know what it was addressing. The agent I'd spoken with actually suggested I do it that way.

0 coins

This whole sequence is really helpful to read. The fact that you could add more information mid-adjudication is something I didn't know was possible.

0 coins

Agreed. I always thought adjudication was just this black box where they made a decision and you either got it or didn't. The idea that you can be proactive with documentation during the review changes things.

0 coins

Has anyone dealt with NYSDOL sending you a questionnaire and then going completely silent for weeks after you submit it? That's where I am right now. Submitted my adjudication questionnaire 11 days ago and my account just shows 'pending determination' with no movement.

0 coins

My determination after submitting a questionnaire took 15 days. The 'pending determination' status basically just means they haven't finished reviewing your answers yet. It's frustrating but it usually does move eventually.

0 coins

Eleven days felt like forever already. At what point should I actually do something versus just waiting?

0 coins

My threshold would be around three weeks post-questionnaire before taking action. At that point getting to an agent by phone and asking for a status update is totally reasonable — I used Claimyr for exactly that kind of status check and it saved me a lot of guessing about whether my case was actually being worked.

0 coins

Three weeks is a reasonable benchmark. NYSDOL's adjudication target is typically 21 days from when they have all needed information, so if you're past that mark it's worth following up proactively.

0 coins

My biggest regret from my own adjudication was not knowing I could check the status of specific documents in my Unemployment Services account. Under your claim details there's a section that shows uploaded documents and whether they've been reviewed. I uploaded things and assumed they were seen but it turned out one of my key documents was still marked 'received but not reviewed' three weeks after I submitted it. When I finally got an agent on the phone they were able to flag it for the examiner directly.

0 coins

My account actually shows a document section — going to check right now if my paystubs are showing as reviewed or still pending.

0 coins

Worth checking regularly. If something has been sitting as 'received' for more than a week without moving to 'reviewed,' that might be worth asking about if you can get an agent.

0 coins

This is such a useful detail. I had no idea that document review status was visible in the portal. Going to look at mine right now for my current claim.

0 coins

For what it's worth — my experience as someone who had a good cause claim approved about 14 months ago — the whole process from filing to approval took 31 days total. First 18 days were adjudication silence, then the questionnaire, then 13 more days after I submitted my answers. I never spoke to an agent, everything came through my Unemployment Services inbox. I know that's not everyone's experience but it does happen without needing to escalate sometimes.

0 coins

31 days sounds brutal but honestly not as bad as some of the stories I've heard. good to know it CAN resolve without having to fight for it

0 coins

My case probably moved relatively smoothly because I'd been very detailed in my original application. Set yourself up well at the start and adjudication is less chaotic.

0 coins

That's reassuring to hear. My original application was fairly detailed and I've now added paystubs and texts to my document folder. Hoping the process goes similarly for me.

0 coins

My understanding from talking to people who've been through this multiple times — NYSDOL adjudicators are looking for a specific thing when they review quit cases. They want to see that your employer's actions caused the problem, that you tried to address it with them, and that leaving was your last reasonable option not your first instinct. The more your documentation tells that story in sequence, the more you're matching what they're actually checking for.

0 coins

That sequence — employer action, claimant response, employer failure to fix, then departure — is basically the template. When your facts map onto that timeline cleanly, you're making the examiner's job easier and that tends to work in your favor.

0 coins

My situation maps onto that pretty well actually. Hours dropped, I asked about it repeatedly, nothing changed, eventually became unsustainable. I'll make sure my documentation tells that story in that order.

0 coins

Presenting facts in that sequence is probably the single most useful piece of advice in this whole thread for people dealing with good cause adjudications.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure