Back to New York Unemployment

Val Rossi

Can you collect unemployment while on workers comp in NY? NYSDOL question

My situation is a little complicated and I can't find a straight answer anywhere so hoping someone here has actually dealt with this. I got hurt on the job back in February - warehouse work, strained my back pretty badly. Workers comp approved my claim and I've been getting weekly payments from the insurance carrier while I'm out of work recovering. The thing is, my doctor just cleared me for light duty starting next week but my employer says they have no light duty positions available right now and basically told me to stay home until I'm fully released. So now I'm sitting here with reduced workers comp payments (they cut it because I got partial clearance) and no actual paycheck coming in. Someone at my physical therapy place mentioned that I might be able to file for NYSDOL unemployment on top of the workers comp, but I honestly have no idea if that's even legal or how it would work. The two systems seem completely separate and I've never filed for UI benefits before. Can you collect unemployment while on workers comp in New York, or is receiving workers comp payments an automatic disqualification? And if I CAN collect both, does the workers comp amount get deducted from whatever UI benefits I'd receive? I really need to understand this before I do anything that could mess up either claim.

$504 a week is the max WC rate most people hit, and that number matters a lot here. NY allows you to file for UI while getting workers comp BUT - and this is a big but - your weekly WC payment gets deducted dollar for dollar from your UI benefit amount. So if your WC payment is higher than your UI benefit rate, you'd get zero UI. If your WC is lower than your UI benefit, you'd get the difference. The other catch is you still have to meet the 'able and available' requirement for unemployment, which is tricky on workers comp because you're supposed to be unable to work. The partial release your doctor gave you helps your case since you're technically able to work light duty but your employer won't accommodate it.

0 coins

Val Rossi

Author

My WC payment right now is around $380/week since they adjusted it after the partial clearance. So theoretically I could get UI benefits minus that $380? Or does even $1 of WC disqualify me entirely?

0 coins

The $380 would be deducted from your weekly UI benefit amount, not a full disqualification. Your UI benefit is calculated based on your previous wages, so if NYSDOL determines you'd get say $450/week in UI, you'd actually receive $450 minus $380 = $70. It's not much but it's something, and more importantly you'd be in the system building your benefit period.

0 coins

This is accurate. The able and available piece is really what trips people up. OP, when you certify weekly for UI you have to confirm you were able to work, available for work, and actively looking. With a partial release, technically yes. With full restrictions, that's where it gets complicated.

0 coins

Went through almost this exact scenario in 2023 and the hardest part was actually getting someone at NYSDOL on the phone to explain how they handle the WC offset calculation for my specific situation. Phone lines were impossible - spent days redialing and getting disconnected. Eventually used Claimyr (claimyr.com) - it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up talking directly to a live agent without sitting on hold yourself. There's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. The agent I spoke with walked me through exactly how they'd calculate my UI benefit with the WC deduction and whether my partial work release satisfied the able and available requirement. Knowing the actual numbers before I filed saved me a lot of stress.

0 coins

Val Rossi

Author

Had no idea something like that existed - the NYSDOL phone situation is already stressing me out before I've even tried calling. Bookmar- wait no I'll just check that site out. Did the agent seem knowledgeable about the WC overlap specifically or was it kind of generic advice?

0 coins

The agent I got was actually really specific about it. She pulled up the WC offset rules and told me my options clearly. I think it depends who you get but the people handling these calls are trained on the intersection between WC and UI, it's a common enough situation.

0 coins

NYSDOL phone wait times on this topic are brutal because it's a complicated question that gets routed to specialists. Good tip on the alternative approach.

0 coins

Few things to flag from someone who went through partial WC clearance last year. First, your employer's refusal to offer light duty is actually documented - get that in writing if you can, even just an email saying 'we have no light duty available.' That documentation matters if NYSDOL questions your availability. Second, the job search requirement for UI normally means 3 job search activities per week in NY, but when you're on WC with restrictions you need to be realistic - you should only be applying to jobs within your physical limitations. Applying for jobs you can't actually do just to satisfy the requirement creates its own problems.

0 coins

Val Rossi

Author

Getting something in writing from my employer is actually a great idea, hadn't thought of that. They've only told me verbally so far that there's no light duty.

0 coins

Agreed on the documentation. Also worth noting - when you file your initial UI claim, there's a section where you explain why you're no longer working. 'Employer has no light duty work available following partial medical release' is a legitimate separation reason that NYSDOL recognizes. Don't just put 'laid off' or leave it vague.

0 coins

Exactly what profile 14 said. How you describe your separation on the initial claim sets the tone for whether you get sent to adjudication or approved straightforwardly. Being precise and accurate from the start is worth the extra time it takes.

0 coins

ok but wait can someone clarify something bc im confused - if hes on workers comp doesnt that mean he was injured AT work? so wouldnt that make him ineligible for unemployment because he didnt lose his job he just cant do it?? i thought UI was for people who got laid off not injured

0 coins

UI eligibility isn't only for layoffs - it covers situations where you're out of work through no fault of your own, which includes when your employer can't accommodate a medical restriction. OP's employer told him to stay home because there's no light duty. That's constructively a separation from active employment even if he's technically still employed.

0 coins

oh okay that makes more sense. so hes not 'fired' but hes also not getting paid to work so NYSDOL treats it kind of like a layoff situation?

0 coins

More or less, yes. The key phrase NYSDOL cares about is 'able and available' and 'through no fault of your own.' If your employer won't bring you back because they have nothing suitable for your restrictions, that's their decision, not yours.

0 coins

My cousin went through this in 2022 - wait, let me just share what actually happened since it's similar. His WC payments were higher than his UI benefit rate would have been, so after the deduction he got zero UI. He filed anyway and his case sat in adjudication for 6 weeks before NYSDOL confirmed the math and denied benefits for that reason. The lesson there was that he should have done the rough calculation FIRST before filing, so he didn't waste weeks waiting for a denial he could have predicted. OP, do you have any way to estimate what your UI benefit rate would be based on your wages?

0 coins

Val Rossi

Author

My wages before the injury were around $58,000 annually. I've been trying to use the NYSDOL benefit calculator online but honestly I'm not 100% sure I'm entering the base period correctly.

0 coins

With $58k annual wages you'd likely be near or at the maximum UI benefit rate which is around $504/week in NY currently. Since your WC is $380 right now, you'd probably net around $124/week if the numbers work out. Not life-changing but definitely worth filing.

0 coins

The base period for a claim filed now in 2025 would generally look at wages from the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters. The NYSDOL website has a calculator - plug in your quarterly wages and it'll give you an estimated weekly benefit amount before any deductions.

0 coins

Used Claimyr when I was fighting a similar dual-benefit situation and finally got an agent to explain the actual adjudication trigger. What I learned: NYSDOL automatically sends WC-related UI claims to adjudication when the system flags a workers comp involvement - it's not a denial, it's just them verifying the offset calculation. Standard stuff, apparently. Plan for 2-4 weeks in adjudication even if everything is correct.

0 coins

Val Rossi

Author

This is really helpful to know - I'd been worried that adjudication meant something was wrong with my claim.

0 coins

Adjudication just means a human is reviewing it rather than it being auto-approved. For anything involving WC overlap it's almost automatic that it goes to review. Keep filing your weekly certifications the whole time though - don't stop just because you're in adjudication.

0 coins

THIS. So many people stop filing their weekly claims when they see adjudication status and then they lose those weeks even after approval. File every week no matter what.

0 coins

Honestly the system is designed to confuse people in exactly this situation. You're hurt, you're stressed, and then you have to navigate two completely separate bureaucracies that barely communicate with each other. Workers comp insurer on one side, NYSDOL on the other, and YOU are the one who has to report to both and make sure the numbers match up. If you get UI approved, you have to report those UI payments to your WC carrier too - it can affect their offset calculations from their end.

0 coins

Val Rossi

Author

Wait - so I'd have to report UI payments to the WC carrier AND report WC payments to NYSDOL? Both directions?

0 coins

Correct. NYSDOL needs to know your WC amount to calculate the deduction. Your WC carrier needs to know about any other income including UI benefits because WC is supposed to cover lost wages, and if you're getting UI it affects their wage replacement calculation. Talk to whoever handles your WC claim about this.

0 coins

The WC carrier notification is real but how it affects your WC payments depends on the carrier and your specific WC benefit type. Definitely ask both sides before assuming. Some carriers offset, some don't, depends on the nature of the WC benefit classification.

0 coins

filed for UI while getting WC partial payments back in fall 2024 - took about 3 weeks in adjudication then got approved. my WC was $310/week and my UI benefit rate came out to $467 so i got $157/week from NYSDOL after the deduction. not huge money but helped a lot when i had no other income. the key thing my adjudicator noted was that i had documentation from my employer that they couldnt accommodate my restrictions

0 coins

Val Rossi

Author

That's really encouraging to hear from someone who actually did this successfully. Did you file your UI claim online or did you call in?

0 coins

Filed online through the NYSDOL portal, the initial claim at least. Weekly certifications also online. Only called when i needed to explain the WC situation in more detail and even then it took multiple tries to reach someone.

0 coins

Oh and when you do the weekly certification and it asks if you received any other income that week, that's where you report the WC payment amount. Don't skip that field.

0 coins

My situation was a little different - I was fully on WC with no work clearance at all and NYSDOL denied me because I couldn't satisfy 'able and available.' The partial clearance OP has is actually the key distinction here. With zero work clearance, UI is basically off the table because you can't honestly say you're able and available for any work. OP has an advantage in that the doctor cleared them for light duty, so the 'able and available' box can legitimately be checked.

0 coins

Val Rossi

Author

That's a good point - my doctor's note specifically says 'cleared for sedentary and light duty work, no lifting over 15 lbs, no prolonged standing.' That's actually pretty specific documentation of what I CAN do.

0 coins

Keep a copy of that note and potentially reference it if your claim goes to adjudication and they question the able and available piece. The more specific the medical documentation, the cleaner it is.

0 coins

Right, that specificity in the doctor's clearance is exactly what NYSDOL adjudicators want to see. Vague language causes delays. 'Light duty' defined with actual physical parameters is much cleaner than just 'can return to modified work.

0 coins

WAIT does anyone know if you have to pay taxes on BOTH the workers comp AND the unemployment?? i feel like this is gonna be a tax nightmare for op on top of everything else

0 coins

Workers comp benefits in NY are generally not taxable at the federal or state level. UI benefits ARE taxable as ordinary income - you'll get a 1099-G at year end from NYSDOL. You can elect to have taxes withheld from your UI payments when you set up the claim or you can pay estimated taxes quarterly. Worth knowing upfront.

0 coins

ok good to know the WC part isnt taxed at least. still sounds complicated to track both

0 coins

NYSDOL gives you the option to withhold 10% federal and 2.5% state from your UI payments. If you're only getting a small UI amount after the WC deduction, the withholding takes a small portion but saves you from an unexpected bill in April.

0 coins

Tried to navigate this exact thing two years ago and got three different answers from three different NYSDOL reps about whether partial WC disqualified me completely or just reduced my benefit. Super frustrating. Eventually the fourth rep I reached gave me a clear answer with the actual regulation cited. The inconsistency in information from different agents is real, so if you get an answer that doesn't feel right, it's worth asking again.

0 coins

Val Rossi

Author

That is kind of alarming to hear. How do I know which answer is correct if agents are giving different information?

0 coins

Ask them to point you to the specific NYSDOL rule or section they're referencing. Agents who actually know the answer can usually cite where it comes from. The ones guessing tend to give vague explanations.

0 coins

You can also look up NY Labor Law Section 600 and following sections which govern UI eligibility. The WC offset rules specifically are pretty clearly stated there. Useful to have that background before calling so you can follow what the agent is saying.

0 coins

My claim had a workers comp question attached to it and after three weeks of getting no information through the online portal, Claimyr finally got me to an actual NYSDOL agent who could look at the adjudication notes and tell me what was holding things up. Turned out it was just a form they needed that nobody had told me about. Got it sorted in a day once I knew what they needed.

0 coins

Val Rossi

Author

A form they didn't tell you about - that is exactly the kind of thing I'm afraid of. How would you even know to send something they never asked for?

0 coins

You wouldn't, that's the whole problem. The adjudication notice just says 'pending review' with no detail. The only way to find out the specific holdup is to reach a human who can actually read the notes on your file.

0 coins

This is a really common adjudication trap. The online portal status almost never tells you WHY something is pending, just that it is. Phone is the only way to get specifics.

0 coins

The job search log piece of this - when you're on WC with physical restrictions and filing UI - is something people overlook. NY requires 3 job search activities per week. For someone with lifting restrictions and injury limitations, that means you need to be documenting searches for jobs you can ACTUALLY do. Sedentary office work, remote positions, light assembly, customer service work. Don't just log random applications to jobs outside your restrictions.

0 coins

Val Rossi

Author

So for the weekly certification I should be able to demonstrate I was genuinely searching within my physical limitations? Not that I need to 'prove' anything but keeping a detailed log?

0 coins

Exactly - keep dates, company names, position titles, and how you applied. NYSDOL can audit job search records and ask for them at any point. With a WC-involved claim that's already in adjudication, having a clean detailed log gives you nothing to worry about.

0 coins

Also worth noting: attending medical appointments, physical therapy, vocational rehab - those count as job search activities in some cases under NYSDOL rules. Check the weekly certification guidance for exactly what qualifies because it's broader than just submitting applications.

0 coins

Used Claimyr after my fourth failed attempt to reach NYSDOL about my WC-adjusted UI claim - ended up speaking with an agent who specialized in exactly this type of case and got the adjustment calculation explained clearly. The peace of mind from actually understanding what NYSDOL was doing with my numbers was worth it.

0 coins

Val Rossi

Author

Peace of mind is genuinely what I'm after here - I don't want to file and then not understand what's happening with my claim. That uncertainty would stress me out more than just waiting.

0 coins

Filing without understanding the WC interaction is how people make mistakes - like not reporting WC income on the weekly certification or applying for the wrong benefit amount. Talking to an agent first really does help you do it right from the start.

0 coins

Partial work release situations get complicated quickly when it comes to UI because the able and available standard was really designed with someone who's fully ready to work in mind. With medical restrictions, you're 'able' in a limited sense and 'available' for a subset of jobs. NYSDOL adjudicators handle this case type regularly but the initial automated system wasn't built for it, which is why these claims almost always require human review.

0 coins

Val Rossi

Author

Makes sense that the automated system flags it - it probably just sees 'workers comp' in the file and routes it out for review.

0 coins

The flag is essentially automatic, yes. 'Workers comp involvement' triggers adjudication regardless of your specific situation. But adjudication isn't a wall, it's just a gate. With the right documentation - employer letter, doctor's clearance, honest WC reporting - most people in your situation get through it.

0 coins

This is why the documentation advice in this thread is so important. Your file going to adjudication is basically guaranteed. What determines how long you're stuck there is whether the adjudicator can find everything they need in your file or has to send requests and wait.

0 coins

My experience with the WC offset was that NYSDOL underestimated my WC payment amount initially because I hadn't entered it correctly on the weekly certification. The deduction was calculated wrong for two weeks before an agent caught it. When they corrected it they adjusted the payments going forward - didn't create an overpayment issue because it was their calculation, not me hiding income. But it was confusing to track on paper.

0 coins

Val Rossi

Author

How exactly do you enter the WC amount on the weekly certification? Is it a dollar figure for that week or something else?

0 coins

The weekly certification asks for income received during that certification week. Enter the actual dollar amount of WC you received in that specific week, not an annualized number or the total to date. If WC pays you $380 that week, enter $380.

0 coins

And if your WC payment amount changes week to week because of partial release adjustments, enter the actual amount received each individual week. Consistency matters less than accuracy here.

0 coins

NYSDOL has a specific unit that handles workers comp involved UI claims - at least that's what an agent told me when I finally got through. They said those claims are reviewed by people who understand the offset rules versus general adjudicators. Couldn't verify that independently but the agent who handled mine definitely knew the WC offset rules cold.

0 coins

Val Rossi

Author

Knowing there are specialized people handling these cases is actually reassuring - better than a generic adjudicator who's never seen a WC-involved UI claim before.

0 coins

The agent told me the WC-UI overlap cases are more common than people think, especially in jobs with physical demands. Warehouse, construction, manufacturing - they see these regularly.

0 coins

OP's warehouse background is actually kind of ideal for this claim type because NYSDOL has seen a lot of them. The adjudicator who reviews the file will likely recognize the pattern and know exactly what to look for.

0 coins

Wrapping up what I've seen across this whole thread - the answer to OP's question is yes, you can collect UI while on workers comp in NY, with these conditions: your WC payment gets deducted from your UI benefit, you must meet able and available requirements (OP's partial release helps), you report WC income every week on your certification, and you need 3 documented job search activities weekly within your physical limitations. The claim will likely go to adjudication but that's standard for WC-involved claims, not a red flag.

0 coins

Val Rossi

Author

This thread has been incredibly helpful. Going to get the employer letter in writing, gather my WC payment records, pull the doctor's clearance documentation, and then file the initial UI claim online. Then I'll try to reach NYSDOL to confirm the offset calculation before my first weekly certification is due.

0 coins

That's the right sequence. File first, then follow up by phone to confirm numbers. Waiting to file while trying to reach someone by phone first just delays your benefit start date - in NY your claim date is when you filed, not when you got approved.

0 coins

Good luck OP. The first couple weeks feel chaotic but once you're in the system and understand the weekly certification process, it becomes routine. Document everything, report honestly, and don't stop filing weekly even when status shows adjudication pending.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure