Back to New York Unemployment

Sophia Bennett

Can you collect unemployment while on FMLA in New York?

My employer approved me for FMLA leave starting about six weeks ago due to a serious health condition. I've been out of work the whole time, obviously not getting paid, and my savings are draining fast. A coworker mentioned I might be able to file for unemployment benefits through NYSDOL while I'm on leave since I'm technically not receiving any income. I went ahead and filed a claim but now I'm second-guessing whether I even qualify. The claim is sitting there and I honestly don't know if NYSDOL is going to approve it or flag it as an issue. My job is protected under FMLA so I still have a position to return to — does that disqualify me from UI benefits? Has anyone actually been through this situation and know what NYSDOL looks like at a leave-of-absence claim?

Claimyr is worth trying if you need to actually speak with someone at NYSDOL about this — it waits on hold for you so you end up on the phone with a live agent rather than sitting there for hours yourself. claimyr.com has the info and there's a video demo at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE that shows how it works. I'd strongly suggest talking to an actual NYSDOL rep before your adjudication goes sideways, because the FMLA + UI question is not something their website answers clearly.

0 coins

My situation is kind of urgent at this point so I'll check that out tonight, thanks. Did you use it for a leave situation specifically or something else?

0 coins

Used it for an adjudication issue myself and had a live agent within the same morning I tried it. Way better than the endless hold music.

0 coins

Appreciate the tip — been trying to reach NYSDOL for two weeks on a totally different matter and getting nowhere fast.

0 coins

$0 in wages while on approved leave is exactly the scenario NYSDOL scrutinizes closely. The core problem is that unemployment insurance is designed for people who are unemployed through no fault of their own AND who are able to work, available for work, and actively looking. FMLA leave specifically means you have a health condition serious enough to need protected time off — which directly conflicts with the 'able and available' test NYSDOL applies every week you certify.

0 coins

My doctor cleared me for light duty about two weeks into the leave but my employer said there's no light duty available. Does that change anything about the able and available question?

0 coins

That detail actually matters a lot. If you have written documentation that you're medically cleared for some form of work, even restricted, and your employer can't accommodate that, NYSDOL may view you differently than someone who is completely unable to work. Keep that doctor's note — submit it if adjudication asks for anything.

0 coins

30 days is roughly how long my adjudication dragged on when I had a leave situation, so brace yourself for a wait no matter what the outcome is.

0 coins

FMLA and unemployment don't mix the way most people think they do. My HR department actually told me I could file when I was on leave last year and I did — got disqualified pretty fast. The adjudication letter said I wasn't considered 'able and available' because my own medical paperwork said I couldn't perform my regular duties. Filed an appeal but it didn't go anywhere because I couldn't prove I was seeking any other kind of work during that period.

0 coins

That's what I was afraid of. Did you at least get any weeks approved before the disqualification hit?

0 coins

Two weeks got paid out before the flag showed up in the system, then everything got put on hold during adjudication. Eventually I had to pay those two weeks back as an overpayment once the disqualification was finalized. So keep that in mind — even if money comes in early it might not be yours to keep.

0 coins

Overpayment notices are brutal, went through that myself for a totally different reason but the stress is the same regardless of why they hit you.

0 coins

There's a distinction worth understanding here between being on leave voluntarily versus being forced out. If your employer placed you on unpaid FMLA and you would work if they let you — meaning you're actually medically able to do some job somewhere — NYSDOL's able and available standard might technically be met depending on how the claim gets evaluated. The problem is that most people on FMLA are on it precisely because they can't work, which is why these claims get flagged so often.

0 coins

Does NYSDOL ask the employer for the reason behind the leave during adjudication? I'd worry about what gets reported.

0 coins

Your employer typically gets a notice when you file a UI claim and they can respond with separation information. If they report that you're on approved medical leave, that's what triggers the adjudication review. They're not required to fight your claim, but the nature of FMLA leave itself raises the able-and-available question automatically.

0 coins

Mine already responded to the initial claim notice, I saw the update in my Unemployment Services account. It just says 'employer response received' — no other detail showing yet.

0 coins

My neighbor went through almost this exact situation and ended up getting benefits approved — but only because she was on intermittent FMLA, not continuous leave. She worked some days, was off on others, and NYSDOL apparently treated the days she wasn't working differently than a continuous leave situation. She wasn't filing for full weeks either, just partial weeks on the days she missed. That nuance might matter depending on what type of FMLA you're on.

0 coins

Mine is continuous, full weeks out. So that probably doesn't apply to my situation unfortunately.

0 coins

Yeah continuous is the harder case for sure. Intermittent gives you more of an argument that you're still in the workforce and available on other days.

0 coins

Intermittent FMLA is a whole other headache administratively but if you can swing partial weeks of UI it might be worth the paperwork. Didn't know that was even possible until reading this.

0 coins

ABLE AND AVAILABLE is literally the biggest thing that kills these claims and nobody explains it properly before people file. You have to certify every single week that you were physically able to work and available to accept a job if one was offered. If you're on FMLA for a serious condition you can't just say 'yes' to that question because if your own doctor's paperwork says otherwise, you've got a potential fraud issue on top of a disqualification. I watched someone get an overpayment demand AND a fraud flag from exactly this scenario.

0 coins

Wait, fraud? Even if I genuinely didn't understand the rules when I filed?

0 coins

Intent matters in how they handle it, but when weekly certifications say 'able and available' and medical records say 'on leave for serious health condition,' that contradiction is what they flag. If you're uncertain about your answers when you certify, that's worth a conversation with an actual NYSDOL rep before you submit another week.

0 coins

This is why I always say call before filing in gray-area situations — the website does not give you enough information for these edge cases.

0 coins

Two scenarios where people on FMLA have actually gotten UI approved from what I've seen in these threads: first, the employer ends the job during the FMLA leave (fires you while on leave, which is illegal but happens), and second, the person exhausts their FMLA period, their job no longer exists when they return, and they're then genuinely separated from employment. Those are legitimate UI situations. Active FMLA with a job waiting for you is the hard case.

0 coins

What if the employer offers a different position when you come back from FMLA and the new role pays less? Does refusing that count as a voluntary quit?

0 coins

That's a gray area but NYSDOL generally looks at whether the offered position is 'suitable work' — pay, commute, your skills, what you were making before. If they cut your pay substantially, refusing might not disqualify you, but you'd need adjudication to work that out. Document everything either way.

0 coins

My job is supposed to be held as-is so hopefully that specific scenario doesn't come up for me.

0 coins

Filed and had my claim reviewed in a similar situation about eight months ago. The adjudication examiner actually phoned me and asked a series of questions about whether I was looking for other work during the leave period and whether my doctor had placed any restrictions on me. I hadn't been searching for other jobs at all — I expected to return to my same position — and that answer essentially ended my claim. If you haven't been doing job searches because you plan to go back, that's going to be an issue on its own separate from the able-and-available question.

0 coins

Every week I certify it asks about job search activities and I've been putting in the three contacts but honestly I was just going through the motions because I figured I'd be back at my job soon.

0 coins

Three contacts per week is the requirement and at least you're logging them, that's something. But the nature of those contacts matters — if the adjudication examiner calls, they may ask for specifics about those employers and what happened with each application.

0 coins

Keeping your actual job search log with employer names, dates, positions and contact methods is important. NYSDOL can request it and 'I emailed a few places' is not sufficient documentation.

0 coins

Used Claimyr when my own FMLA-adjacent situation got complicated and I genuinely couldn't get through on the NYSDOL line after trying for days. Ended up speaking with an agent who clarified exactly what my adjudication status meant and what documentation they needed from me. The difference between having that conversation and just waiting around for a letter was significant — the agent told me things the website never would have.

0 coins

How specific were they able to get about your actual file when you got them on the phone?

0 coins

My adjudication status, what triggered the review, what documents they still needed — pretty detailed. The agent pulled up my claim while we talked. Way more useful than any of the generic information on the NYSDOL website.

0 coins

An actual agent pulling up your file in real time is so much better than getting a form letter two weeks after you needed the information.

0 coins

Three weeks into FMLA and filing UI simultaneously is exactly the situation that tends to generate a request for additional information from NYSDOL. They're going to want to understand why you're applying, what your medical situation is, and whether you're truly available for other work. Having your documentation ready — FMLA approval letter, any doctor notes about your capacity, your job search log — is going to matter when they reach out.

0 coins

They haven't asked for anything yet, claim just shows as pending. Should I proactively submit documents or wait until they request them?

0 coins

Waiting for a request is usually fine — submitting things they haven't asked for can sometimes create more confusion. But know exactly where your documents are so you can respond fast when they do ask.

0 coins

Response time on adjudication document requests matters a lot. Missing their deadline can turn a potentially approvable claim into an automatic denial.

0 coins

What your employer puts in the response to NYSDOL shapes a lot of this. Some employers just confirm dates of employment and don't volunteer extra information. Others write paragraphs about the nature of the leave. The employer's response combined with your weekly certifications is usually what triggers or clears the adjudication flag in the first place.

0 coins

Is there any way to see what your employer actually submitted to NYSDOL?

0 coins

Not directly through the Unemployment Services portal, at least not in my experience. The adjudication examiner might reference it when they contact you, or you could potentially find out through a FOIL request but that takes forever and isn't practical for an active claim.

0 coins

Mine just submitted something generic I think — the system only showed 'employer response received' without any detail. Guess I won't know what they said until someone contacts me.

0 coins

Genuinely didn't know any of this before reading this thread. I always assumed unpaid leave of any kind meant you could get UI, that seemed logical to me. The able-and-available requirement makes the whole thing way more complicated than I expected. What about short-term disability — is that the thing that's supposed to cover FMLA situations instead of UI?

0 coins

New York's Paid Family Leave and New York State disability benefits are what most people use during leave — PFL for bonding or family care reasons, DBL for your own medical condition. Those programs are specifically designed for leave situations in a way that UI is not. If you have an employer-provided short-term disability policy, that might also apply.

0 coins

So people go through the whole UI process when they should have been filing for disability benefits instead? That seems like a system design problem.

0 coins

They serve completely different purposes and the eligibility rules don't overlap much. UI is for people who are unemployed and ready to work. NY Paid Family Leave and DBL are specifically for periods of leave. Many people don't know the difference until they're already in the middle of an issue.

0 coins

Applied for NY State disability through my employer's carrier when I was on medical leave and that covered a portion of my lost wages — not everything, but something. The NYSDOL UI route was a dead end for me in that same period for exactly the reasons people are describing here. If you haven't looked at whether NYS DBL applies to your situation that might be worth checking in parallel with whatever happens with the UI claim.

0 coins

My employer does have a disability plan, I actually forgot about that completely. Would filing a DBL claim hurt my UI case or are they totally separate?

0 coins

They're administered through completely different systems so filing DBL doesn't automatically hurt your UI claim. But if DBL pays you something during the same period, that income could affect your UI benefit calculation or eligibility for those weeks. Worth mentioning to whatever adjudication examiner contacts you.

0 coins

The coordination of benefits stuff between DBL and UI is genuinely confusing and I don't think even some of the NYSDOL reps fully understand how they interact. Getting it in writing from them is smarter than relying on a verbal explanation.

0 coins

Claimyr got me a live NYSDOL agent when I was dealing with a leave-related claim review last spring. Had tried the phone line multiple times over several days and couldn't get past the hold. The agent I finally spoke with told me my specific situation — medical leave with a return-to-work date already set — was going to result in a disqualification because NYSDOL treats a predetermined return date as evidence you weren't truly available for other employment. That was something I never would have figured out from the website alone.

0 coins

A predetermined return date being a problem is something nobody warned me about — I do have a return date set with my employer.

0 coins

That detail came up pretty fast in my conversation with the agent. If you have a fixed return date to the same job, NYSDOL sees that as evidence your availability for other work was always conditional. It's worth asking an agent directly how that affects your specific claim.

0 coins

Makes sense in a frustrating way. If you already know you're going back to your job on a specific date, you're not really 'available' for indefinite employment somewhere else the way UI is supposed to require.

0 coins

My adjudication on a leave situation took 11 weeks from start to finish before I got a determination letter. 11 weeks. Filed a claim in January, got a letter in late March. By that point I was already back at work. The determination was a disqualification anyway, so at least I didn't miss out on money I was actually counting on, but the timeline was brutal and I had no visibility into where things stood during that entire period.

0 coins

11 weeks with no information — that's my nightmare scenario right now. How often were you checking your Unemployment Services account during that time?

0 coins

Every single day, sometimes twice. Nothing updated for weeks at a stretch. The only thing that changed was eventually a letter showed up in my physical mailbox with the determination. The online account showed nothing new until after the letter arrived.

0 coins

NYSDOL's communication during adjudication is genuinely poor. The account portal shows almost nothing about where the review stands or what's needed. You're basically just waiting with no information.

0 coins

The job search requirement trips people up during FMLA situations in a specific way. You certify each week that you did your three job search activities, but if your employer and your FMLA paperwork both show you're on leave expecting to return, an adjudication examiner is going to look at those job search certifications and your leave documentation as contradictory. Were you genuinely looking for other work while planning to go back to your current job?

0 coins

Honestly, not really — I went through the motions because the certification requires it, but I wasn't seriously looking. My plan has always been to return to my current position.

0 coins

That's the bind. Certifying job search activities you weren't genuinely doing is exactly what NYSDOL considers a problem during adjudication. I'm not saying don't file, but being honest with an examiner if they reach out is important — the alternative has worse consequences.

0 coins

Adjudication examiners ask about specific job contacts in a lot of cases, names and dates and positions. If those contacts weren't real the inconsistency shows up fast.

0 coins

Returned here because a friend asked me basically the same question last week. Told him what this thread already covers: active FMLA with your job protected and a return date set is almost certainly going to result in a disqualification because you're not truly separated from employment and probably can't honestly certify you're available for work elsewhere. His situation ended up being better handled by filing for NYS disability benefits through his employer, not UI. He got partial income replacement that way within a couple weeks.

0 coins

Every response in this thread is pushing me toward the same conclusion — this UI claim probably isn't going to work out the way I hoped. Really glad I found this discussion before the adjudication determination comes through.

0 coins

Understanding where your claim likely stands is better than being blindsided by the disqualification letter. At least now you can explore the DBL route and not count on UI money that might not come.

0 coins

For what it's worth, the specific fact pattern here — continuous FMLA, predetermined return date, same employer job waiting — is about as difficult a UI case as NYSDOL sees. Doesn't mean fight the claim necessarily, but go in with realistic expectations and talk to an agent about your specific documentation.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure