Can you collect unemployment while college classes are going on? NYSDOL question
So I'm in a bit of a weird situation and hoping someone here has actually dealt with this before. I enrolled in a community college program back in January - it's an evening and weekend schedule, about 12 credits this semester. I was working full-time at a distribution warehouse until they laid off our entire shift three weeks ago. Filed my UI claim right away and got through the initial steps fine, but now I'm second-guessing myself on something pretty important. When I did the weekly certification, there's that section about whether you're able and available to work. I answered yes because honestly my class schedule is nights and weekends and I can absolutely work a full Monday-Friday daytime shift. But then my coworker (also laid off, also going to school) told me that NYSDOL automatically disqualifies you if you're in school. I have no idea if that's true or not. I've been certifying every week and showing my job search contacts but now I'm stressed that I'm going to get some letter saying I owe everything back. Has anyone actually been in this situation? Can you collect unemployment while college courses are running? I really need this income while I'm transitioning careers and I don't want to mess anything up.
79 comments

Olivia Clark
Your coworker isn't totally right on this one. What's the actual rule NYSDOL cares about? Ask yourself whether you'd drop those classes tomorrow if a full-time job came through - because that's essentially what they want to know. The department looks at whether your school schedule genuinely limits your availability for work. Evening and weekend classes that leave your weekdays completely open? That's a much stronger position than someone in full-time day classes who can only work around a rigid schedule. You're certifying that you're able and available, and if that's genuinely true given your schedule, you're on solid ground. The disqualification your coworker mentioned usually applies to people whose classes prevent them from accepting full-time work during normal business hours.
0 coins
Yara Assad
AuthorOkay that makes me feel a lot better. My classes are literally Tuesday and Thursday evenings plus Saturday mornings - I could start a 9-to-5 job Monday with zero conflict. I just want to make sure I'm not accidentally lying on my certification.
0 coins
Javier Morales
This is basically correct. The 'able and available' standard is what trips people up. If you can genuinely accept full-time work, the school enrollment itself isn't disqualifying.
0 coins
Natasha Petrov
wait does nysdol actually check what your class schedule is?? like do they verify with the school or something
0 coins
Connor O'Brien
Had almost this exact situation two years ago - I got laid off from a hotel job and was halfway through an associate degree. The question I kept asking myself was whether my enrollment would stop me from taking work if it was offered. My courses were all online and self-paced so it was pretty clear-cut. But I did get a letter from NYSDOL at one point asking about my school status. What helped me was just being thorough when I responded - I spelled out exactly what my schedule looked like and confirmed I was restricting my job search only to jobs that were genuinely unsuitable, not to protect my class times. Never had a problem after that.
0 coins
Yara Assad
AuthorDid they ever call you in for an interview about it or was it just the written letter?
0 coins
Connor O'Brien
Mine stayed entirely on paper - got the letter, sent back my response with the schedule details, and that was the end of it. No phone interview, just a written determination that came maybe two weeks later saying I remained eligible.
0 coins
Amina Diallo
ugh i got one of those letters and panicked so hard. ended up being fine but the waiting is brutal
0 coins
GamerGirl99
Hang on - are you having any trouble actually reaching NYSDOL to ask them directly about your situation? Because I went through something similar and spent three full days trying to get a live person on the phone, never got through once. A friend told me about Claimyr (claimyr.com) - there's also a demo video at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE that shows how it works. Basically it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up on the phone with a live agent. I was skeptical but it actually worked and I got to speak with someone who could look at my actual claim file and answer questions specific to my case. For something like the school enrollment question where the answer really depends on YOUR schedule and situation, talking to an actual agent is so much more useful than guessing.
0 coins
Yara Assad
AuthorTried calling twice yesterday, got the 'high call volume' message and then nothing. Might actually look into this.
0 coins
Hiroshi Nakamura
I've been hitting the same wall with their phone lines. How long did it end up taking before you got through to someone?
0 coins
GamerGirl99
Claimyr handled the hold time - I just did other things while it waited and eventually I was talking to an agent. The whole hold period was something like two hours but I wasn't sitting there the whole time.
0 coins
Isabella Costa
the nysdol phone system is genuinely one of the worst experiences i've ever had with a government office and i've dealt with a lot of them
0 coins
Malik Jenkins
There's some confusion in this thread worth clearing up. Can you think about what 'restricting your availability' actually means in practice? Here's why it matters: if you told an employer 'I can't work Saturdays because of class' during an interview, NYSDOL could argue you're imposing conditions on your availability. The rule isn't just about whether hours technically exist in your week - it's about whether you'd accept any legitimate offer or whether school creates conditions you won't budge on. For evening and weekend classes, the question is whether you'd rearrange or drop them for the right job. If the honest answer is yes, you're fine. If the honest answer is 'I need to finish this semester no matter what,' that's where it gets more complicated.
0 coins
Yara Assad
AuthorHonestly that's the part I keep going back and forth on. I WOULD drop the classes if I had to but I'd really prefer not to. Is preferring not to enough to cause an issue?
0 coins
Malik Jenkins
Preference isn't the problem - it's about what you'd actually do if a job required it. Most adjudicators understand people have preferences. The key phrase is whether you'd accept suitable work, not whether you have zero preferences about anything.
0 coins
Freya Andersen
i mean everyone has preferences, they cant expect you to be a robot about it
0 coins
Eduardo Silva
The 'willing to accept suitable work' standard is correct. NYSDOL isn't looking for someone with zero personal circumstances, just someone who won't artificially limit what jobs they'll take.
0 coins
Leila Haddad
My situation was actually the opposite of what everyone's describing - I was doing full-time day classes and tried to claim UI. Got flagged almost immediately. The adjudicator who reviewed my case was actually pretty direct about it: daytime full-time coursework during regular work hours is exactly the kind of thing that raises the availability question. Mine went into adjudication for about six weeks before I got a determination, and I did end up partially disqualified for the weeks where I couldn't demonstrate I was genuinely available for daytime work. So the schedule really does matter, and your evening/weekend setup sounds way better than what I had.
0 coins
Yara Assad
AuthorSix weeks in adjudication sounds awful. Did you at least get some of the weeks approved?
0 coins
Leila Haddad
Yeah the weeks after my semester ended were all approved without any issue. The ones during the semester were the problem - I got about half of them approved once I could show job search activity during daytime hours. It was frustrating but not a total loss.
0 coins
Emma Johnson
six weeks!! i would've lost my mind
0 coins
Ravi Patel
What does your weekly certification actually show for job search contacts? That's something a lot of people overlook when they're in school. If your job search log only shows applications to evening-shift or weekend jobs, that actually signals to NYSDOL that you're limiting your search around your class schedule - even if you never said so explicitly. You want your job search contacts to show a mix that includes standard Monday-Friday daytime positions. That consistency between what you're certifying about availability and what your actual search activity looks like is what keeps you out of trouble.
0 coins
Yara Assad
AuthorMine actually do include daytime jobs - I've been applying to warehouse supervisor and logistics coordinator roles that are all standard business hours. That's good to hear.
0 coins
Ravi Patel
Then you're in really good shape. The job search log that reflects genuine daytime availability is exactly the kind of documentation that holds up if anyone ever reviews your claim.
0 coins
Astrid Bergström
oh this is such a good point that nobody told me when i was going through mine. my search log was all over the place and i think that's part of why i got flagged
0 coins
Javier Morales
Is anyone else noticing how much this varies by adjudicator? I've seen people in basically identical situations get totally different outcomes. My friend was doing the exact same thing - night school, laid off, applied for UI - and she had zero issues throughout her whole claim. Meanwhile someone in our old workplace study group got flagged and had to appeal. Same city, same type of program, similar schedules. The human element in how these cases get reviewed is real.
0 coins
Olivia Clark
That inconsistency is genuinely frustrating but it's also why documentation matters so much. When the outcome is partly about which adjudicator sees your file, you want your paperwork to be bulletproof regardless of who's reviewing it.
0 coins
Javier Morales
Agreed. You can't control who looks at your case but you can control how clearly you've documented everything.
0 coins
Yara Assad
AuthorOkay so the takeaway is: keep the job search log clean and accurate, make sure I'm not limiting myself to school-friendly hours, and document that I'd accept daytime work. That's what I'm hearing.
0 coins
PixelPrincess
Had to jump in here because I went through almost this exact scenario last spring. Got laid off from my office admin job while doing two evening courses toward my business degree. I was nervous about the school question too but my claim went through fine. What I did was keep a note in my files of exactly what my class schedule was, in case I ever needed to prove my availability wasn't limited. I never actually had to submit it but having it ready made me feel better about every weekly certification. The peace of mind from being prepared is worth something.
0 coins
Yara Assad
AuthorThat's smart. I'm going to write out my full schedule and keep it with my claim documents.
0 coins
PixelPrincess
Exactly. If NYSDOL ever sends an availability inquiry, you want to be able to respond immediately with something clear and specific rather than scrambling.
0 coins
Hiroshi Nakamura
wait they can send those randomly? like just out of nowhere you get an inquiry letter?
0 coins
Omar Farouk
Trying to reach NYSDOL directly with questions like this is genuinely worth doing before your situation escalates. When I had an availability question about my own claim I tried calling for almost a week straight and couldn't get through. Someone here recommended Claimyr and it's the only reason I actually spoke to a live agent. The agent pulled up my claim on the spot and told me exactly what my account showed and what, if anything, was flagged. That kind of real-time account review is impossible to get any other way - their message portal takes forever and phone lines are brutal.
0 coins
Hiroshi Nakamura
Does it work even during like peak times like Monday morning?
0 coins
Omar Farouk
My experience was that it didn't matter what time it was - the hold situation is what it is, and Claimyr just handled it so I didn't have to sit there. I ended up talking to someone eventually regardless.
0 coins
Eduardo Silva
The Monday morning thing is real - I've heard their call volume is highest right after the weekend and right after any major news about benefits. Calling mid-week apparently helps somewhat.
0 coins
Natasha Petrov
okay so i have a dumb related question. if you START school while already on a claim - like you filed before you enrolled - does that change anything? because my situation is kind of different where i enrolled after i filed.
0 coins
Olivia Clark
What you should ask NYSDOL is whether anything about your situation changed since you filed - because starting school is considered a change in circumstances and you're technically supposed to report changes that could affect your availability. That's the case because failing to report changes can create overpayment issues later even if you were actually still eligible the whole time. Report it proactively and explain your schedule.
0 coins
Natasha Petrov
omg i didn't know that. I've been certified for three weeks since i enrolled and didn't say anything
0 coins
Malik Jenkins
You should contact NYSDOL as soon as possible and report the enrollment. Coming forward yourself is always better than having them discover it. Document when you made contact and what they said.
0 coins
Natasha Petrov
okay yeah reaching out today. this thread kind of scared me into action lol
0 coins
Chloe Martin
Claimyr actually saved me when I was dealing with an availability dispute on my claim - I'd been trying for weeks to reach someone and kept getting nowhere. The agent I spoke to was able to see notes on my file that the online portal doesn't show at all. For something like a school enrollment question where the details of your specific situation really matter, getting an agent on the phone is so much more useful than trying to decode form letters. If you're hitting walls with the phone lines, Claimyr is worth trying.
0 coins
Yara Assad
AuthorAre the agents able to actually update things on your claim during the call or is it more of an informational thing?
0 coins
Chloe Martin
In my experience the agent could both give me information AND flag notes for follow-up on my case. It wasn't just informational - they could actually see the full picture of what was going on.
0 coins
Diego Fernández
i asked about this once and was told agents have different levels of access depending on what department picks up. so it can vary.
0 coins
Freya Andersen
Honestly my two cents: just be straight with them. I know that sounds obvious but I've seen people tie themselves in knots trying to game the system and it usually makes things worse. If you're genuinely available for work, say so and mean it. If you're not really going to take a daytime job because of school, don't certify that you are. The overpayment letters that come later are way worse than dealing with it honestly upfront.
0 coins
Yara Assad
AuthorNo, I genuinely am available. That's what makes this stressful - I'm not trying to get away with anything, I just want to make sure I'm doing it correctly.
0 coins
Freya Andersen
Then you've got nothing to worry about. Seriously. People who get in trouble are usually either certifying while genuinely unable to work or not reporting income. Your situation sounds clean.
0 coins
Emma Johnson
Does anyone know if NYSDOL can see your school enrollment automatically? Like through some state database? I've always wondered if they just KNOW or if they only find out if you tell them or if something flags.
0 coins
Eduardo Silva
They can get information through various channels but how exactly the data flows isn't something that's publicly documented. What matters practically is that if your enrollment status is ever relevant to a determination, they will find out. The much safer path is always to be upfront about it.
0 coins
Javier Morales
This is exactly why proactive disclosure is the move. You don't know what they can and can't see, so you're better off not having anything to hide.
0 coins
Emma Johnson
yeah okay that makes sense. flying under the radar is definitely not worth the risk of a big overpayment demand
0 coins
Astrid Bergström
My experience was rough and I want to share it so other people don't go through what I did. I was taking classes and on UI and everything was fine for about six weeks, then out of nowhere my payments stopped and I got a determination that I was not 'able and available.' I had to appeal and it took almost four months to get resolved. The thing that saved me was documentation - I had emails from employers I'd interviewed with during business hours, my class schedule showing I was free during the day, and a letter from my program advisor confirming the schedule. Without all of that I think I would have lost the appeal.
0 coins
Yara Assad
AuthorFour months is terrifying. Did your payments restart while the appeal was pending or did you have to wait until it was resolved?
0 coins
Astrid Bergström
I had to wait for the resolution unfortunately. That was a really hard stretch financially. The one thing I'll say is that filing the appeal quickly mattered - there's a time limit and if you miss it you lose the right entirely.
0 coins
Amina Diallo
the appeal deadline thing is SO important. 30 days from the determination date and not a day more.
0 coins
Astrid Bergström
Exactly 30 days. Mark it on your calendar the day the letter arrives.
0 coins
Diego Fernández
Can we talk about the job search requirements for a second because I think there's another layer here for people in school. The requirement is usually 3 job search activities per week in New York. If your class schedule is eating into your time and you end up doing fewer than 3 activities some weeks, that's actually a separate problem from the availability question. Both things need to stay compliant.
0 coins
Yara Assad
AuthorMine have all been 3+ per week. I've actually been applying a lot because I really want to land something.
0 coins
Diego Fernández
Then you're doing it right. I just see people sometimes focus so hard on the availability question that they miss the job search activity requirement entirely.
0 coins
Ravi Patel
Good point. The job search log and the availability certification are two separate requirements that both need to stay in order. Letting either one slip creates problems.
0 coins
Amina Diallo
wait this is making me realize i never thought about this when i was on UI a couple years ago and in school. i just certified normally and never had any issues. wonder if i got lucky or if it just wasn't a problem.
0 coins
Olivia Clark
Were your classes affecting your daytime availability? If not, there probably wasn't anything to flag in the first place.
0 coins
Amina Diallo
no they were all evenings, so i guess that tracks. still kinda stressed reading all this retroactively lol
0 coins
Eduardo Silva
If your claim is closed and paid out, there's not much to stress about now. The look-back window for overpayments is real but usually only triggered by an audit or a tip, not routine review years later.
0 coins
Hiroshi Nakamura
Something I've been wondering about this whole thread: what happens if you get a job offer during the semester that conflicts with your class schedule? Like you got a great offer but it's a schedule that would require dropping classes - are you required to take it?
0 coins
Malik Jenkins
What would you say to the employer if you turned down that offer - that's the question NYSDOL effectively asks. If your reason for refusing is 'I'm in school,' that can count as refusing suitable work without good cause, which is a disqualifying event. This is why the theoretical willingness to drop classes matters: NYSDOL isn't just asking about your current schedule, they're asking whether work always comes first.
0 coins
Hiroshi Nakamura
So refusing a good job offer to protect your semester could actually end your benefits? That's wild, didn't realize it was that strict.
0 coins
Malik Jenkins
That's the standard, yes. 'Suitable work' that you refuse without good cause ends eligibility. 'I want to finish my degree' is generally not considered good cause under NYSDOL rules.
0 coins
Isabella Costa
Genuinely how is anyone supposed to know all of this without stumbling onto a forum thread or hiring a lawyer? The NYSDOL website has this information scattered across like fifteen different pages and none of it is written for a normal person to understand.
0 coins
Connor O'Brien
Agreed, it's genuinely hard to navigate. The best resource I found was actually calling and asking specific questions - which is its own nightmare given the hold times - but when you do reach someone they're usually willing to walk you through things.
0 coins
Isabella Costa
Tried calling four times last week. Gave up after the third time the line just went silent.
0 coins
Omar Farouk
Honestly that's exactly when Claimyr made sense for me - after I'd already burned several attempts on my own and needed to know I'd actually get through before my frustration made me give up entirely.
0 coins
Eduardo Silva
To bring this back around for anyone reading: the core principle is that UI benefits require you to be genuinely able and available for full-time work. School enrollment isn't automatically disqualifying - it depends entirely on whether the schedule genuinely limits your availability. Evening and weekend classes with open weekdays? Generally fine if you'd truly accept suitable daytime work. Full-time day classes that prevent you from working normal business hours? That's where problems arise. Document your schedule, keep your job search log reflecting genuine daytime availability, and if you ever get a letter asking about your school status, respond promptly and specifically.
0 coins
Yara Assad
AuthorThis is basically the clearest summary I've seen. Saving this whole thread honestly. My situation sounds like it falls clearly into the 'generally fine' category based on everything here.
0 coins
Javier Morales
Well put. The documentation point is key - even if you're in the clear, having clear records means a faster resolution if anything ever gets questioned.
0 coins
Eduardo Silva
Exactly. Claims that go smoothly don't generate paperwork, but when something does get reviewed, the people who've kept good records always come out better.
0 coins