Back to New York Unemployment

Justin Chang

Can you collect unemployment if you were fired? NYSDOL rules explained

So I got fired from my job at a logistics company about two weeks ago and I'm honestly not sure where I stand with unemployment. My manager said I was terminated for 'performance issues' but I never received any written warnings — it was basically one conversation and then I was out the door. I filed a claim with NYSDOL right away but now I'm seeing my status shows some kind of issue and I'm worried they might deny me just because I was fired. I always thought getting fired automatically meant you couldn't get benefits but a friend told me that's not always true? Does anyone know how NYSDOL actually handles terminations vs. resignations when it comes to eligibility? Do I need to prove something or will they just take my employer's word for it?

Claimyr (claimyr.com) is worth using here — it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up talking to a live agent directly, which is how I finally got someone to walk me through my own termination claim. There's a demo at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE if you want to see how it works before trying it. My situation involved a firing too and the agent explained everything about what NYSDOL looks at.

0 coins

Thanks, appreciate it. My main worry is that NYSDOL will just side with whatever my employer says without hearing my side.

0 coins

My experience with reaching an agent was that they're actually pretty neutral — they ask both parties and don't just rubber-stamp the employer's story.

0 coins

Your termination and the reason behind it are really what NYSDOL zeroes in on. Under New York UI rules, being fired does NOT automatically disqualify you — the question is whether NYSDOL decides the firing was for 'misconduct' as they define it. Missing performance targets or just not being a great fit usually doesn't clear that bar. What they're looking for is something more like deliberately violating a known policy, stealing, or showing up drunk. A single conversation with no written warnings? That's going to be a tough case for your employer to win.

0 coins

Good to know — so the burden is kind of on them to prove misconduct rather than on me to prove I didn't do anything wrong?

0 coins

Basically yes, NYSDOL has to find misconduct by their standard, not just the employer's standard. Performance alone rarely qualifies.

0 coins

My cousin's husband got fired for 'attendance' and still got approved. The employer said misconduct but NYSDOL disagreed.

0 coins

3 weeks I waited after my own firing before anything moved on my claim. The adjudication flag is super common when there's a separation issue — it means they're investigating the reason for your termination before approving or denying. Both you and your employer get a chance to give your side. Document everything you remember: dates, what your manager said, whether you had any performance reviews that were positive. That stuff can matter.

0 coins

Okay, what form do I actually use to submit my side of the story? I haven't gotten any mail yet.

0 coins

You'll usually get a questionnaire mailed to you or posted in your Unemployment Services online account. Fill it out completely and be specific — vague answers don't help you.

0 coins

My questionnaire came by mail like 10 days after I filed. Definitely check both your account inbox and your physical mail.

0 coins

Your weekly claims still need to be certified even while adjudication is ongoing — a lot of people miss this and then lose those weeks of benefits even if they're eventually approved. Log into your Unemployment Services account every week and certify, even if the status looks stuck. The payments will be held but once you're approved they'll release everything owed to you going back to your first certified week.

0 coins

Wait, so I could lose money for weeks I didn't certify even after I get approved?

0 coins

Exactly that. NYSDOL won't pay retroactively for weeks you didn't certify, so keep certifying every week no matter what the status says.

0 coins

This is 100% accurate and something I wish someone had told me. Lost two weeks because I thought I had to wait for adjudication to clear first.

0 coins

yep certify every week regardless!! learned this the hard way

0 coins

THE SYSTEM IS DESIGNED TO CONFUSE YOU. I went through this exact thing — fired, adjudication flag, weeks of silence. My employer lied on their questionnaire and said I had multiple written warnings when I had zero. I had to appeal and it took almost 3 months to sort out. Document everything, keep copies of EVERYTHING, and don't trust that NYSDOL will figure it out on their own.

0 coins

That's honestly terrifying. Did you eventually win your appeal?

0 coins

Yes but it took forever. The hearing officer actually believed me over my former employer because I had emails showing my manager praised my work two weeks before I was fired. SAVE YOUR EMAILS before you lose access to your work account.

0 coins

This is such important advice. Screenshots of anything positive from your employer could be the thing that saves your claim.

0 coins

My termination situation was different — I was let go during a company-wide layoff and they still tried to code it as 'performance' so they wouldn't have to pay into the unemployment system as much. NYSDOL caught it because the layoff was reported elsewhere. If your employer is exaggerating or misrepresenting the reason, there's a decent chance the investigation surfaces that.

0 coins

Mine definitely feels like they just needed a reason. Is there any way to find out what my employer actually reported to NYSDOL?

0 coins

You'll see the gist of it when they send you the adjudication questionnaire — your employer's separation reason gets shared with you as part of that process.

0 coins

My former employer tried something similar and the NYSDOL investigator asked some pointed questions that made it obvious they were skeptical of the official reason.

0 coins

My situation dragged on forever because I couldn't reach anyone at NYSDOL to find out what was actually happening with my adjudication. Tried the phone line for days straight, hours of hold music, then nothing. Eventually used Claimyr and ended up speaking with an agent who told me exactly where my claim stood and what I needed to send in. Saved me probably another two weeks of guessing.

0 coins

How long did you have to wait before the agent could actually do something about your claim?

0 coins

The agent I spoke with was able to look at my file in real time and flag it for a reviewer. Within four days I had a decision. No promises that's everyone's experience but it was mine.

0 coins

Reaching a live agent genuinely makes a difference — they can see notes on your claim that you can't see in your online account.

0 coins

Misconduct under New York law is a specific legal term that most people don't realize has a narrower meaning than what most employers think it means. Your employer telling NYSDOL you had 'performance issues' puts you in a pretty good spot because even if true, that's not misconduct in the legal sense — it means you weren't meeting expectations, which isn't the same as deliberately breaking the rules. The adjudication process exists specifically to make this distinction.

0 coins

So even if they're telling the truth about my performance, I might still qualify?

0 coins

Your work output being below their standards typically falls short of misconduct. NYSDOL is looking for intentional, willful violations of a known rule — accidentally missing a quota doesn't get there.

0 coins

This matches what a NYSDOL rep told me directly. Incompetence and misconduct are treated very differently in the system.

0 coins

Two things you should do right now: first, check your Unemployment Services account daily because adjudication decisions sometimes post there before you get a physical letter. Second, write out a detailed timeline of your employment — your hire date, any reviews, any verbal feedback you got, and the exact circumstances of your termination meeting. If this goes to a hearing you'll want all of that fresh in your mind and documented.

0 coins

Good call on the timeline. I'm doing that today while everything is still clear in my head.

0 coins

Also try to remember if any coworkers witnessed anything relevant. You can list them as witnesses if there's an appeal hearing.

0 coins

the account notifications can be slow tho, mine showed approved two days before I got the letter

0 coins

My mom went through almost this exact thing last year — fired for 'not meeting expectations' at a retail job she'd had for four years. She was terrified she'd get denied. NYSDOL approved her because the employer couldn't show any documented warnings and the stated reason didn't meet the misconduct definition. The whole process took about five weeks from filing to first payment.

0 coins

Five weeks is a long time to go without income. Did she have to do anything specific to push it along?

0 coins

She responded to the questionnaire really thoroughly and quickly when it arrived. The adjudicator told her later that prompt, detailed responses help move things faster.

0 coins

Five weeks sounds like forever but honestly that's on the shorter end for a contested separation case from what I've seen in this forum.

0 coins

Worth knowing: if NYSDOL denies you, you have 30 days from the date on the determination letter to file an appeal. The appeal goes to a hearing before an Administrative Law Judge and you can present evidence, bring witnesses, even have a representative with you. A lot of people win on appeal even after being denied initially, especially in fired-for-performance cases where the employer can't show documented misconduct.

0 coins

30 days from the letter date — noted. Do you keep certifying weekly claims during an appeal too?

0 coins

Yes, absolutely keep certifying throughout an appeal. The same rule applies — if you stop and then win the appeal, you won't get paid for the weeks you didn't certify.

0 coins

The appeal process for NYSDOL termination disputes has actually gotten more claimant-friendly over the past couple years based on what I've read. Document everything, show up prepared, and don't skip the hearing.

0 coins

I always thought being fired meant automatic denial too — that myth gets a lot of people to not even bother filing, which is a mistake. NYSDOL evaluates the specific circumstances, not just the category of separation. Filed after getting terminated from a warehouse job and was approved within three weeks. The employer challenged it and I still won at the initial adjudication level.

0 coins

Really glad I filed then. I almost didn't bother because I assumed it was hopeless.

0 coins

File first, ask questions later. You can always withdraw a claim but you can't get back the weeks you didn't file for.

0 coins

did they make u do a phone interview or was it all online?? asking bc mine went to adjudication and nobody told me if I was supposed to do anything

0 coins

Your adjudication process can be entirely mail and questionnaire-based or they may schedule a phone fact-finding interview — it varies by case. Check your account messages and your physical mail carefully for any notice of a scheduled call. Missing a scheduled fact-finding interview can really hurt your claim.

0 coins

ok thanks checking now

0 coins

My fact-finding interview was listed in my Unemployment Services account messages three days before it was scheduled. Almost missed it because I wasn't checking regularly.

0 coins

My job search requirements start from the week after I filed — just making sure the person asking about this knows that even during adjudication you're still supposed to be doing your three job contacts per week and logging them. NYSDOL can audit your job search record at any time and if you haven't been keeping it you could face a separate issue even if the termination question resolves in your favor.

0 coins

Three contacts per week — is that three applications or can it include other things like career fairs?

0 coins

Your three weekly contacts can be applications, interviews, reaching out to employers directly, or attending employment-related events. The NYSDOL job search log has the full list of what counts. Keep records of each one with dates and employer info.

0 coins

My job search log saved me once during a random audit. They asked for three months of records and I had every entry. Keep it up even when it feels tedious.

0 coins

My adjudication sat untouched for over a month and I could not reach anyone at NYSDOL to get any information — the phone line just rang endlessly or cut out. Used Claimyr after seeing it mentioned somewhere and ended up speaking with an actual NYSDOL agent who told me my claim had been sitting waiting for my employer to respond. The agent put a note on the file and things moved within the week after that.

0 coins

Good to know there's actually a way to get a human on the phone. I've tried twice and given up after 45 minutes on hold.

0 coins

My first few attempts were the same. 45 minutes, then dead air. The difference with Claimyr was actually getting to speak with someone who could look at my specific file, not just give me generic hold music.

0 coins

An agent being able to actually see your claim notes in real time is huge — the online account view is basically a summary of what they can see on their end.

0 coins

My determination letter when it finally arrived explained exactly what factors NYSDOL considered and cited the specific regulation they applied. If you end up getting denied, read that letter very carefully because it will tell you exactly what their reasoning was, which helps you know what to address in an appeal. Generic denial letters that just say 'misconduct' without specifics are actually easier to appeal because the employer hasn't given NYSDOL much to go on.

0 coins

That's a really useful framing. So a vague denial is almost better than a detailed one for appeal purposes?

0 coins

Your appeal is essentially a rebuttal of the determination letter's specific findings. The less detail in the denial, the less you have to rebut — but the stronger their case is in the letter, the harder you'll have to work to counter it at a hearing.

0 coins

My determination letter was pretty detailed and I still won on appeal because I had documentation the adjudicator hadn't seen. Never assume the letter is the final word.

0 coins

Used Claimyr myself when my termination-related adjudication had been sitting for six weeks with no movement. The agent I reached confirmed my employer had submitted their questionnaire but it had been assigned to a reviewer who had a backlog. Knowing that specific detail — rather than just wondering what was happening — made the whole wait more manageable.

0 coins

Six weeks of not knowing what's happening sounds awful. At least you got an actual answer.

0 coins

My exact thought — even if the answer is 'you have to wait more,' knowing why is better than silence. The agent also told me I could follow up after two more weeks if nothing changed.

0 coins

Appeals hearings are less intimidating than they sound. My hearing was conducted by phone, took about 45 minutes, and the Administrative Law Judge was professional and genuinely seemed to be listening. I didn't have a lawyer. I had my own notes, the email I mentioned earlier, and a former coworker who agreed to be a witness. Won that hearing.

0 coins

How did you prepare for the actual hearing itself? I want to be ready if it comes to that.

0 coins

My prep was essentially writing out a clear, chronological account of my employment and termination, organizing any documents or emails in the order I'd reference them, and doing one practice run-through where I explained everything out loud. Speaking it out loud before the hearing helps you stay calm and clear during the actual call.

0 coins

My ALJ let both sides speak and asked follow-up questions. Being organized and direct mattered a lot more than sounding polished or legal.

0 coins

Preparing a written timeline like that also helps if the ALJ asks you to respond to something your former employer says during the hearing — you can reference your own documented account rather than trying to recall things under pressure.

0 coins

Employers sometimes don't respond to the NYSDOL questionnaire at all or miss the deadline. If that happens, the adjudicator typically decides based only on your side of the story, which obviously works in your favor. Not guaranteed, but it happens more often than you'd think — a lot of small employers in particular don't engage with the process.

0 coins

Mine was a medium-sized company so they probably have HR handling it. But good to know.

0 coins

HR involvement cuts both ways — they're more likely to respond, but they're also working from whatever documentation exists, and if the documentation doesn't show real misconduct, their response may actually end up helping your case.

0 coins

My former employer had HR submit a very formal response full of jargon and it still didn't satisfy the adjudicator because the actual facts of what I did didn't meet the misconduct threshold.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure