Can you collect unemployment if you quit? What NYSDOL told me
So I left my job about six weeks ago and I'm honestly still not sure I made the right call, but I had to get out. The situation had become genuinely unbearable — my manager was creating a hostile work environment, HR kept brushing me off, and I was commuting 90 minutes each way to a job that had completely changed from what I was hired to do. I figured there was zero chance of getting unemployment since I quit, so I didn't even file right away. Then a friend told me New York actually has provisions for people who quit under certain conditions, so I went ahead and filed. Now my claim is sitting in adjudication and I have no idea what's going to happen. Has anyone actually been approved for UI benefits after quitting in New York? What reasons does NYSDOL actually accept? I'm terrified I'm going to get disqualified and then owe money somehow if I already certified for a week.
86 comments

Marcus Marsh
Went through almost this exact situation two years ago, so let me tell you what I found out. New York does allow unemployment benefits after quitting, but the bar is pretty high — NYSDOL calls it "good cause" and it basically means your working conditions were so bad that a reasonable person would have felt they had no real choice but to leave. Things like a genuinely hostile work environment, significant changes to your job duties or pay, unsafe conditions, medical reasons tied to the job — those can all qualify. The key thing that tripped me up at first: you usually have to show you tried to fix the problem before quitting. Did you report the hostile environment to HR? Do you have emails or documentation? That stuff matters a lot when adjudication reviewers look at your case.
0 coins
Katherine Shultz
AuthorYes, I emailed HR twice and have those emails saved. My manager also changed my shift from days to overnight with basically no notice, which I couldn't do because of my kids' school schedule. Would that count as a substantial change?
0 coins
Marcus Marsh
The shift change to overnight with no notice is actually really strong. NYSDOL generally treats a major schedule change — especially one that conflicts with a family obligation you couldn't reasonably work around — as a legitimate reason to quit. Make sure you document exactly when they told you about the change versus when it was supposed to start. The shorter that window, the better your case.
0 coins
Hailey O'Leary
I heard you have to have worked at least 6 months before they'll even consider a voluntary quit claim, is that right?
0 coins
Marcus Marsh
That's not quite right actually — there's no specific minimum tenure rule that blocks you from filing after a voluntary quit. What matters is whether you meet the base period earnings requirements for UI eligibility and whether your reason for quitting qualifies as good cause. Tenure might come up as context but it's not a cutoff rule on its own.
0 coins
Cedric Chung
Adjudication when you quit is really stressful because you don't know how long it'll drag on. First thing I'd do in your position is log into your Unemployment Services account every day and check if they've posted any requests for additional information. Sometimes they send a questionnaire about your separation and if you miss the deadline to respond it can hurt your claim badly. Keep certifying for your weekly claims while this is pending too — stopping early can mess things up.
0 coins
Katherine Shultz
AuthorChecked my account this morning and there's nothing new posted, just the same 'adjudication in progress' status. How long does this usually take for a voluntary quit situation?
0 coins
Cedric Chung
Voluntary quit adjudications tend to run longer than layoff claims because a reviewer has to actually evaluate the circumstances. I've seen people wait anywhere from three weeks to two months. It really depends on how backed up they are and whether they need to contact your former employer for their side of the story.
0 coins
Talia Klein
Two months is brutal if you have bills due now. Have you tried calling NYSDOL to at least find out where in the process your case is?
0 coins
Katherine Shultz
AuthorTried calling four times already. Either I sit on hold for over an hour and get disconnected, or I get a message saying high call volume and the line drops. It's infuriating.
0 coins
Maxwell St. Laurent
Okay so the phone situation with NYSDOL is a whole other nightmare. After spending basically three full days trying to get through, I found something called Claimyr — what it does is wait on hold with NYSDOL for you, so you end up actually on the phone with a live agent at NYSDOL without you having to sit there for hours. I was skeptical but it genuinely worked, I spoke to a real person at NYSDOL who could actually see my claim and tell me what was happening with it. Their site is claimyr.com and there's a demo video at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE if you want to see how it works before trying it. For a voluntary quit adjudication specifically, talking to an agent was the only way I got any real information beyond the generic status screen.
0 coins
Katherine Shultz
AuthorWatched the video just now — honestly this looks worth trying. The hold situation has been making me crazy. Did the agent you spoke to actually have details about your specific case or was it just general info?
0 coins
Maxwell St. Laurent
My agent pulled up my actual claim file and walked me through exactly what stage the adjudication was in and what documentation they still needed from me. Way more useful than staring at the status page.
0 coins
PaulineW
Tried Claimyr last month when my claim went into adjudication after I reported a job refusal incorrectly. Ended up talking to an agent who corrected the issue on the spot — took maybe 20 minutes once I was actually on with someone. Total game changer compared to redialing for days.
0 coins
Annabel Kimball
Does this work for voluntary quit cases specifically or only for regular layoff claims?
0 coins
Maxwell St. Laurent
Works for any claim type — the tool just gets you to an NYSDOL agent, what you discuss once you're there is entirely up to you and your situation.
0 coins
Chris Elmeda
My experience with voluntary quit UI might be useful here. I quit a retail job because my employer kept cutting my hours below what I needed to survive — went from 38 hours a week down to 11 hours over about two months. NYSDOL adjudication took about five weeks but I was approved. The investigator said the reduction in hours constituted a material change in my employment terms. So 'quitting' isn't automatically disqualifying, the circumstances really do matter.
0 coins
Katherine Shultz
AuthorThat's genuinely encouraging to hear. My situation has the overnight shift change plus the hostile environment documentation. I'm hoping that combination is enough.
0 coins
Chris Elmeda
Both of those together is a solid case honestly. The HR emails especially — having a paper trail showing you tried to resolve it before leaving is exactly what NYSDOL wants to see for a 'good cause' determination.
0 coins
Jean Claude
What if the employer lies to NYSDOL about the reason you left? Mine claimed I quit without giving any reason and I had to basically fight to prove I had documentation.
0 coins
Chris Elmeda
Your employer's version gets weighed against yours and your evidence. That's actually why documentation is so important — if you have emails, texts, or written complaints on file, those carry a lot more weight than a he-said-she-said situation.
0 coins
Charity Cohan
Wait so people actually get approved after quitting?? I always thought that was an automatic no. I quit my last job like eight months ago and never even filed because I assumed I was ineligible. Did I miss my window?
0 coins
Marcus Marsh
Your base period for UI eligibility looks at wages earned in roughly the 12-18 months before you file, so depending on when exactly you quit and whether you've worked at all since, you might still have a valid base period. I'd file anyway and let NYSDOL make the determination — worst case is they deny you, but you won't know unless you try.
0 coins
Charity Cohan
Logged into Unemployment Services just now and it looks like I might still have wages in the base period from my previous employer before the one I quit. Going to file today, thank you.
0 coins
Cedric Chung
File as soon as possible because even if you're eligible, benefits only start from your filing date — they don't go back to when you actually quit. Every week you wait is a week you can't recover.
0 coins
Josef Tearle
I work in HR and see the other side of these claims. When an employee quits and files for UI, we receive a separation notice from NYSDOL asking for our version of events. We're supposed to report the reason for separation accurately. If your employer misrepresents the reason, they can face penalties and increased unemployment insurance tax rates. I'm not saying all employers play fair, but there's real incentive for honesty. What helps claimants most is having their own documentation that lines up with a consistent story.
0 coins
Katherine Shultz
AuthorMy former employer is a pretty large company with an HR department, so I'm hoping they're at least consistent about what actually happened. The overnight shift change is documented in a written email from my manager, so there's no way they can deny that happened.
0 coins
Josef Tearle
An email from your manager confirming the shift change is excellent evidence. If that email shows the timeframe between notification and when the change was supposed to take effect, even better. That kind of concrete documentation is exactly what makes voluntary quit cases winnable.
0 coins
Talia Klein
Does the employer actually know what you told NYSDOL about why you quit, or do they just submit their own account separately?
0 coins
Josef Tearle
They submit their account separately based on the separation notice NYSDOL sends them. They generally see the nature of the claim but the specific written statements you gave to NYSDOL aren't shared verbatim with the employer during adjudication.
0 coins
Shelby Bauman
FOUR TIMES calling and kept getting disconnected?? That's insane. I had the same thing happen when I had a question about my job search requirements and by the time I finally got through I had already missed a deadline they never told me about properly. NYSDOL's phone system is honestly one of the most frustrating things I've ever dealt with. You have an urgent situation with money on the line and they just... make it impossible to reach anyone.
0 coins
Katherine Shultz
AuthorExactly, it feels like the system is designed to make you give up. And my situation isn't something I can just resolve through the online portal — I actually need to talk to someone who can look at my specific claim.
0 coins
Shelby Bauman
My neighbor mentioned Claimyr for getting through to NYSDOL when regular calling kept failing her. She said she ended up talking to an actual agent who answered her questions about her disqualification — might be worth looking into given how hard you're finding it to get through.
0 coins
Quinn Herbert
I used Claimyr specifically for a voluntary quit adjudication question and it worked — waited on hold so I didn't have to, and I ended up speaking directly with an NYSDOL agent who could see my case details. Honestly was the only way I got real answers on my claim.
0 coins
Shelby Bauman
The job search requirements thing they never explained to me properly is still making me paranoid. I'm doing my four contacts a week but I'm not sure I'm documenting them the right way in my log.
0 coins
Salim Nasir
My voluntary quit claim took almost seven weeks in adjudication and I want to tell you what finally moved it along. I sent a written request to the adjudication unit via the message center in my Unemployment Services account, specifically asking for a status update and noting the financial hardship the delay was causing. Within about a week of that message I got a determination letter. I don't know if the message actually triggered anything or if the timing was coincidence, but it's worth trying if you're stuck waiting.
0 coins
Katherine Shultz
AuthorFound the message center in my account — hadn't thought to use that. Sending a message now. Did you write anything specific about your circumstances or just ask for a status update?
0 coins
Salim Nasir
I kept it factual — mentioned my separation date, the nature of my claim, how many weeks it had been in adjudication, and that I was experiencing financial hardship. Polite but direct. I didn't re-litigate my whole case, just asked them to prioritize a determination.
0 coins
Jean Claude
The message center actually works? I've been leaving voicemails on their general line that I'm pretty sure nobody listens to.
0 coins
Salim Nasir
In my experience the message center in the actual Unemployment Services account portal got a faster response than any phone message I ever left. At least there's a record of it and it goes somewhere specific.
0 coins
Talia Klein
While you're waiting on adjudication, make sure you're staying current on your job search requirements. Even if your claim is pending, NYSDOL expects you to be doing your three job search activities per week (it went up from two) and keeping a log. If you get approved and they audit your job search records, any weeks where you didn't do the required activities could be disqualified even after the fact.
0 coins
Katherine Shultz
AuthorAlready doing the job search activities and keeping the log in a spreadsheet. I actually wasn't sure if I needed to do them while adjudication is pending so this is good to confirm.
0 coins
Charity Cohan
Wait the requirement is three per week now? I thought it was still two. I might have been doing this wrong for the past month.
0 coins
Talia Klein
It changed — it's three job search activities per week for most claimants. Check your Unemployment Services account under your claim details because sometimes the requirement is noted there. If you've been only doing two, start doing three immediately going forward and keep your documentation thorough.
0 coins
Hailey O'Leary
Does applying on job boards like Indeed count as one activity? I always assumed only direct company applications counted.
0 coins
Talia Klein
Yes, applying through job boards counts. The acceptable activities include things like submitting applications, attending job fairs, working with a recruiter, completing certain career training — NYSDOL has a list in the job search requirements section of your account. The key is you need to log the employer name, contact info, date, and what type of activity it was.
0 coins
Annabel Kimball
My situation was different from yours but maybe useful context. I was laid off last year and the whole adjudication thing took three weeks even for a simple layoff. When NYSDOL finally made their determination they backdated my benefits to my filing date, not to when the adjudication ended. So all those weeks of certifying while waiting weren't lost — I got paid for all of them once approved. If you've been certifying consistently, you should get all those weeks paid out if the determination goes in your favor.
0 coins
Katherine Shultz
AuthorThis is really reassuring actually. I've been certifying every week even though it feels kind of pointless right now not knowing the outcome. Good to know those weeks won't just disappear.
0 coins
Annabel Kimball
Keep certifying no matter what. Missing a week of certification is one of the few things that can actually cost you those benefits later. Even if the status hasn't changed, certify on schedule every week.
0 coins
Chris Elmeda
This is correct — your weekly certifications establish your ongoing eligibility week by week. The determination unlocks payment for all the pending certified weeks at once.
0 coins
Hazel Garcia
Two weeks ago I was in almost the same position — voluntary quit in adjudication, unable to get anyone on the phone, panicking about money. Used Claimyr to get past the hold situation, spent about 20 minutes with a live NYSDOL agent who actually walked through my case with me. The agent told me exactly what documentation the adjudicator still needed and I uploaded it that same day through the portal. Got my determination four days later. I know that turnaround probably isn't typical but I genuinely think uploading what they needed sped things up.
0 coins
Katherine Shultz
AuthorFour days after uploading documents is wild. I'm going to try to actually get through to someone to find out if there's anything they're still waiting on from me — that's the part that's most frustrating, not knowing if I'm missing something.
0 coins
Hazel Garcia
That was my biggest thing too — I kept assuming no news was good news but actually they were waiting on a document I didn't know I was supposed to submit. Getting to an agent who could check was the only way to find out.
0 coins
Jean Claude
How did you upload documents? I never knew there was a way to do that in the portal.
0 coins
Hazel Garcia
In the Unemployment Services account there's a section for uploading documents related to your claim — it might be under a 'correspondence' or 'document upload' section depending on your claim type. Worth exploring the portal menus carefully if you haven't.
0 coins
PaulineW
I was really skeptical about voluntary quit claims being approved at all until I read through NYSDOL's own guidance on 'good cause' separations. The list of reasons they consider is actually broader than most people think. Medical conditions that your employer wouldn't accommodate, domestic violence situations, significant pay cuts, following a spouse who had to relocate for work — there's a lot on that list. The hostile work environment you're describing combined with the schedule change is genuinely in the range of what gets approved. NYSDOL isn't looking to automatically deny voluntary quits, they're looking for whether a reasonable person would have felt forced to leave.
0 coins
Katherine Shultz
AuthorThe 'reasonable person' standard is interesting because I keep second-guessing myself about whether my situation was 'bad enough.' But I did genuinely try to fix it through HR before leaving.
0 coins
PaulineW
The fact that you went to HR and have that documented is exactly what shows you behaved like a reasonable person who tried to resolve it first. That's the part adjudicators are really looking for — evidence that quitting wasn't a first-resort reaction but a last resort after you tried.
0 coins
Marcus Marsh
This is the thing most people miss when they assume voluntary quit means automatic disqualification. The 'good cause' standard exists specifically because the law recognizes some situations leave you no real choice.
0 coins
Hailey O'Leary
Okay so my mom quit her job three months ago because her employer kept asking her to do stuff that wasn't in her job description and she never filed because she thought she couldn't. After reading all this I'm going to tell her to file. Is it too late?
0 coins
Cedric Chung
Filing after three months is definitely possible but the timing matters for which wages count in her base period. She should file as soon as possible — NYSDOL won't pay benefits for weeks before the filing date, so every week she waits is a week she can't get paid for even if approved. File today if possible.
0 coins
Hailey O'Leary
Telling her to log in and start the application right now. Thank you.
0 coins
Marcus Marsh
The duties expansion situation your mom had can qualify as good cause too — when an employer significantly changes the scope of your job beyond what you were hired to do, that can be considered a unilateral material change in employment terms. It's worth filing and letting NYSDOL make the call.
0 coins
Jean Claude
My voluntary quit adjudication actually came back as a disqualification and I want to share what I did. I appealed it. The appeals process through NYSDOL gives you a hearing before an Administrative Law Judge and I got to present all my documentation including the emails and a written statement. The ALJ reversed the disqualification and I ended up getting paid. I'm not trying to scare anyone but if your adjudication comes back denied, it's not over — appeal within 30 days of the determination.
0 coins
Katherine Shultz
AuthorHow long did the appeal take from filing to getting the ALJ decision?
0 coins
Jean Claude
My hearing was scheduled about six weeks after I filed the appeal and I got the written decision maybe three weeks after the hearing. So roughly two months total from appeal to resolution. Not fast, but it worked.
0 coins
Chris Elmeda
This is really valuable to share. A lot of people assume a denial is final and walk away without knowing they can appeal. The ALJ appeal process exists specifically to give claimants a fair review beyond the initial adjudication.
0 coins
Katherine Shultz
AuthorKnowing there's an appeal option makes me feel a lot less like everything rides on this one adjudication outcome. Still hoping for approval but good to have the roadmap if it goes the other way.
0 coins
Quinn Herbert
I want to circle back on the whole 'can't reach NYSDOL' problem specifically. For anyone with a voluntary quit claim in adjudication, speaking to an agent isn't just nice to have — it can actually change your outcome. I found out about Claimyr from someone else dealing with an adjudication issue, tried it, and ended up talking to a real NYSDOL agent within the same day. The agent flagged that my file had been sitting in a secondary review queue that the online portal doesn't show you. That's not information I would have ever gotten from just refreshing the status page.
0 coins
Katherine Shultz
AuthorSecondary review queue?? I had no idea there were stages that don't show up in the portal status. This is making me think I definitely need to actually speak to someone about my claim.
0 coins
Quinn Herbert
The portal status is basically just a simplified summary. The actual adjudication process has multiple stages that don't get reflected in the display you see. An agent can tell you exactly where your file is within that process.
0 coins
Salim Nasir
This makes me wonder if my claim is stuck somewhere in the process that I can't see either. The status has been showing the same thing for over three weeks.
0 coins
Quinn Herbert
Three weeks with no visible movement is exactly when you want to actually talk to someone who can look at the full case record, not just the status screen.
0 coins
Cedric Chung
While we're on the documentation topic — if your voluntary quit claim gets approved and your former employer appeals the determination (employers do sometimes appeal UI approvals), you'll want to be prepared for a hearing even after winning adjudication. Employers appeal when they want to avoid the UI tax rate increase that comes with former employees collecting on their account. It's annoying but knowing it could happen means you should keep all your documentation organized well past the approval date.
0 coins
Katherine Shultz
AuthorHadn't even thought about the employer potentially appealing an approval. I'm going to keep everything — every email, every HR communication, the shift change notice — organized in a folder just in case.
0 coins
Josef Tearle
From the HR side, employer appeals of UI determinations are genuinely time-consuming and costly for us too, so a lot of companies only appeal when the dollar amount involved is significant or when they think the determination was clearly wrong. A well-documented case where the employee has strong evidence tends to discourage appeals.
0 coins
Jean Claude
My former employer did appeal my ALJ reversal and lost again. It was exhausting but the documentation I had was airtight. Keep everything.
0 coins
Talia Klein
Practical thing that helped me understand my own adjudication status better: check your correspondence section in Unemployment Services for any questionnaires or information requests that might not have triggered an obvious alert. I had a questionnaire sitting there unread for ten days before I noticed it because the notification got buried. Responding to those quickly can really speed up how long adjudication takes.
0 coins
Katherine Shultz
AuthorJust checked every section of my account including the correspondence tab — nothing sitting there unanswered as far as I can tell. At least that's not what's causing the delay.
0 coins
Talia Klein
Good that you checked. The other thing is sometimes they contact your previous employer and are waiting on that response, which is entirely out of your control. That's often what causes the longer waits in voluntary quit adjudications.
0 coins
Charity Cohan
Why does NYSDOL have to contact the employer at all? Can't they just go off what the claimant says?
0 coins
Talia Klein
Employers are parties to the UI system and their account gets charged when former employees collect benefits. So they have a legal right to provide their account of the separation. NYSDOL is supposed to gather both sides before making a determination, especially in voluntary quit cases where there's a factual dispute about the circumstances.
0 coins
Shelby Bauman
Update from earlier in this thread — I sent that message through the portal message center like someone suggested and actually got a response in my account within four days. They confirmed my job search documentation is fine and explained exactly what format they want the log entries in going forward. Genuinely did not expect that to work so sharing it here in case it helps others.
0 coins
Katherine Shultz
AuthorReally glad you updated — this is making me feel better about the message I sent earlier this week. Hoping to get some kind of response soon.
0 coins
Salim Nasir
The message center being responsive is honestly the most underused feature in the whole Unemployment Services system. Most people don't even know it exists.
0 coins
Marcus Marsh
Agreed. Direct written communication through the portal creates a paper trail on both sides and seems to actually go to people who can respond, unlike the general phone queue situation.
0 coins