Back to New York Unemployment

Avery Saint

Can you attend school while on unemployment in NY? NYSDOL rules explained

So I got laid off from my warehouse job about six weeks ago and I've been collecting UI benefits while job searching. Here's my situation though - I've been thinking about enrolling in a welding certification program at a local community college. It's a 10-week course, meets Tuesday and Thursday mornings from 8am to noon. My cousin keeps telling me I need to 'pick one or the other' but that doesn't sound right to me. I've been certifying every week saying I'm able and available for work, and I genuinely am - I'd take a job immediately if one came through. Does going to school automatically disqualify you from collecting? I don't want to mess up my claim but I want to use this time productively. Has anyone actually navigated this with NYSDOL?

Your cousin's not entirely wrong but it's more complicated than 'pick one.' The piece that actually matters for your specific situation is whether that Tuesday/Thursday 8-to-noon schedule would stop you from accepting a job offer if one came in. NYSDOL looks at whether school attendance restricts your availability for full-time work. If you'd turn down a job because of class, that's when claims get denied. If you'd drop the course the moment you got hired, you're in much better shape than you think.

0 coins

That framing actually makes sense to me. I would absolutely quit the course for a full-time job, no question. So theoretically I should be okay as long as I'm still doing my job search activities and can demonstrate I'm available?

0 coins

This is the part that trips people up. NYSDOL can ask you directly whether your school schedule limits when you can work, and your answer to that question is what determines your eligibility, not just whether you enrolled.

0 coins

Exactly right. And document everything - keep records of your job applications even more carefully than usual during this period, because if your claim ever gets reviewed, you want a solid paper trail showing you were actively searching despite being in school.

0 coins

Spent three weeks trying to get a straight answer from NYSDOL on this exact question after I enrolled in an EMT course while collecting. Phone lines were a nightmare - kept getting dropped after 45 minutes on hold. Eventually used Claimyr (claimyr.com) - it waits on hold with NYSDOL so you end up on the phone with a live agent yourself. There's a video at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE that shows how it works. The agent I reached confirmed that short-term vocational or certification programs don't automatically disqualify you, but they flagged my account with a note that I was attending and doing a continuing availability review.

0 coins

Three weeks of trying to get through - that sounds exhausting. Did the agent seem surprised you were in school, or is this something they deal with regularly?

0 coins

Interesting that they actually flagged your account proactively. I'd want to know if that created any delays or adjudication issues down the line, or if it actually helped because everything was documented upfront.

0 coins

Helped, honestly. The flag meant my weekly certifications processed without getting kicked into adjudication. The agent basically set an expectation in the system so it didn't look suspicious when I kept certifying.

0 coins

Wait so you just... told them? That was an option? I've been terrified to mention my night classes to anyone at NYSDOL because I assumed it would automatically trigger a denial.

0 coins

Your welding program timing is actually the detail that makes this tricky or easy depending on your job market. Morning courses on two days a week - that's not a full schedule lockout. The NYSDOL standard is basically: would a reasonable employer expect you available during normal business hours, and would you actually show up? For most warehouse or skilled trades work, shifts don't all run 8am Tuesday. You're not locked out of evenings, weekends, or non-class hours at all.

0 coins

That's reassuring. The welding certification specifically would actually make me MORE employable in my field, so it feels counterproductive that it might hurt my claim.

0 coins

That's the irony of the system honestly. Trying to improve your skills during unemployment is exactly what they claim they want you to do, but then the availability rules can penalize you for it. NYSDOL's approved training programs get around this but those have their own hoops.

0 coins

NYSDOL-approved training under the TAA or similar programs is a whole different category - if your program qualifies, your availability requirement basically gets waived entirely. Worth looking into whether your welding cert is eligible for that designation before you just wing it on regular UI.

0 coins

went through this last year with a coding bootcamp. 4 days a week 9-5 and i was still collecting. never told nysdol specifically about the schedule, just kept certifying that i was available. got approved every week. not saying its the right move but it worked for me

0 coins

That approach carries real risk though. If NYSDOL audits your claim and finds you were in a 9-5 program without disclosing it, you're looking at an overpayment determination and potentially fraud charges. The few hundred dollars saved by not flagging it isn't worth that exposure.

0 coins

fair point i didn't think about audits. i just figured if i was willing to drop the program for a job it was fine

0 coins

Willingness to drop it matters, but NYSDOL can't verify your intent unless it's on record somewhere. The agent recommendation upthread - actually documenting your situation with them - protects you in ways that just hoping for the best doesn't.

0 coins

My situation was different but similar enough - I was doing a part-time paralegal certificate program when I got laid off from my admin job. What I learned was that NYSDOL categorizes school attendance as either 'customarily engaged in full-time study' or not, and that distinction determines almost everything. A Tuesday-Thursday morning cert program almost certainly doesn't put you in the full-time student category.

0 coins

Where did you find that specific language? I've been digging through the NYSDOL site and it's not super clear.

0 coins

It was actually in the determination letter I got after my claim was initially questioned. Someone reviewed my schedule and that was the phrasing they used. Full-time students face a much higher bar to prove availability.

0 coins

This matches what I've read too. Part-time or vocational programs are treated very differently from, say, enrolling as a full-time college student. The 'customarily engaged' standard is what full-time students have to fight against.

0 coins

okay but what about the weekly certification questions themselves? when it asks if you were able and available for work do you say yes even if you had classes those days? because that's where i always get confused and worried I'm going to accidentally commit UI fraud just by answering wrong

0 coins

Classes don't make you unavailable in the legal sense unless they prevent you from accepting or starting a job. You can honestly certify that you were able and available even on days you had class, as long as you would have skipped class for a job. That's the key - your genuine willingness and ability to work is what the question is actually asking.

0 coins

okay that makes way more sense. i was reading 'available' as literally 'free every hour' but it's more about whether you'd actually take the work

0 coins

Exactly. 'Available for work' in UI terms means you weren't placing conditions on employment that would prevent you from accepting a suitable offer. Having a part-time class schedule that you'd abandon for work doesn't create that condition.

0 coins

Tried figuring this out through the NYSDOL website FAQ and honestly came away more confused than when I started. The language on there about 'able and available' is super vague and seems designed to make you uncertain. I ended up just calling and spending literally an hour and forty minutes on hold before getting disconnected. At that point I just decided to trust the advice I'd read in forums like this.

0 coins

That phone situation is brutal. I had the same experience when I needed to ask about my own schedule conflict - tried three times and kept getting disconnected after long waits. A friend told me about Claimyr and I finally got through to an actual agent who could look at my account and give me an answer specific to my claim. Sometimes you just need a human who can see your file.

0 coins

Is that actually reliable? Because my concern is I'll use something like that, still not get through, and have wasted time I could've spent trying the regular line.

0 coins

Worked for me first try honestly. Got to talk to someone real who knew my specific situation instead of generic website answers.

0 coins

I might actually need to do this. The vague answers online are making me more anxious, not less - I want someone who can look at my actual claim.

0 coins

There's also the NYSDOL-approved training program angle worth exploring more. If your welding cert is through an accredited institution and you qualify for certain workforce development programs, you can actually have your job search requirements suspended while you complete the training. You'd still receive benefits but without the weekly job search activity requirement.

0 coins

How do I find out if my program qualifies? Is that something I'd look up online or does it have to go through a Career Center?

0 coins

Your local Career Center is the starting point. They assess whether your training fits the criteria - it generally has to be in an in-demand occupation and from an approved provider. Welding legitimately might qualify given current labor market demand for skilled trades.

0 coins

I went through the approved training route for a CDL program. The Career Center referral took about two weeks to process but once it was in, my UI continued without interruption and I didn't have to log job search activities during the training period.

0 coins

sort of jumping in here - does any of this change if its an online program vs in person? like if the classes are recorded and i watch them at 2am does that even count as 'attending school' in nysdols eyes

0 coins

Asynchronous online coursework is about as low-risk as it gets for UI availability purposes. If your 'schedule' is entirely self-directed with no required attendance at specific times, there's genuinely very little that conflicts with the availability standard. You're not locked into any windows that would prevent you from working.

0 coins

ok good because i signed up for some online courses at community college and was freaking out for nothing then

0 coins

Worth noting that even live online classes with set meeting times are treated similarly to in-person classes - it's the time commitment that matters, not the location. The fact that it's on Zoom doesn't make it less of a schedule restriction if it's real-time.

0 coins

This thread has been super helpful to find. I've been in almost this exact situation - got laid off in January and I'm trying to decide if I should take a phlebotomy training course. The Tuesday/Thursday schedule thing the original poster mentioned is basically what I'm looking at too. Really nervous about accidentally losing my benefits when I need them most.

0 coins

Your nervousness makes sense but the situation you're describing is genuinely one of the more workable ones. Short vocational programs with limited weekly hours are very different from full-time enrollment. Document your continued job search activity carefully and you're in a much better position than you're imagining.

0 coins

Does 'documenting job search activity' mean the NYSDOL portal log specifically or can it be my own spreadsheet?

0 coins

Both, really. The NYSDOL Unemployment Services portal where you certify your weekly claims has the job search log built in - you're supposed to enter at least three contacts per week there. Keep your own backup records too, but the portal entries are what NYSDOL actually reviews if your claim is audited.

0 coins

Went through adjudication specifically because of a school enrollment issue and it was not fun. NYSDOL sent me a questionnaire asking about my class schedule, whether attendance was mandatory, what I'd do if a job conflicted with class - really specific stuff. Took about three weeks to resolve and I didn't receive benefits during that period. Eventually got approved with back payment but the gap was stressful.

0 coins

Three weeks without payment during adjudication - that's rough. What did you end up doing for income during that period?

0 coins

Honestly just burned through savings. The back payment came eventually but the timing was terrible. That's partly why I'd say being upfront with NYSDOL from the start is worth it - my adjudication happened because they found out about my enrollment after the fact.

0 coins

This is exactly what I was afraid of. The uncertainty of adjudication while waiting for money sounds awful.

0 coins

see this is why i'm nervous to say anything. but also why i'm nervous NOT to say anything. there's no good option that feels safe

0 coins

The 'approved training' vs 'self-initiated training' distinction matters a lot here and nobody talks about it enough. If NYSDOL refers you to or approves your training program, you get completely different treatment under the law than if you just decide to take a class on your own. The former preserves your benefits and waives the job search requirement. The latter requires you to still meet the available-for-work standard on top of the school schedule.

0 coins

So theoretically the best path would be to go to a Career Center first and see if they'd actually refer me to the welding program, rather than just enrolling myself?

0 coins

That's exactly the ideal sequence if you have time. Enrollment first doesn't disqualify you from getting the approval later but starting the Career Center conversation before you enroll gives you the cleanest paper trail.

0 coins

Agreed. The Career Center referral process exists specifically for this scenario - someone collecting UI who wants to use that period to build skills. Getting the referral is the system working as intended, not gaming it.

0 coins

My experience is that how you answer the initial claim questions matters more than people realize for this down the road. When I first filed, there was a question about whether I was enrolled or planning to enroll in school. I said yes because I was taking one night class. That triggered additional questions but ultimately I was approved. Someone at the office told me that flagging it yourself upfront is treated much better than them discovering it later.

0 coins

That tracks with what someone else said earlier about proactive disclosure. I think my instinct to be upfront was right, I just wanted to make sure being honest wouldn't automatically disqualify me.

0 coins

It really doesn't, in my experience. NYSDOL seems to care much more about whether you're genuinely available for work than about the fact of school attendance itself. The honest answer to both gets handled; the hidden one becomes a problem if found.

0 coins

This is the right read. The fraud risk isn't from going to school - it's from certifying you were available for work if your school schedule genuinely prevented you from accepting employment. As long as that's not the case, disclosure is always better.

0 coins

i have a question that's kinda related - what if the school has a mandatory attendance policy and they'd drop you for missing class? does that count against you even if YOU'RE willing to skip for a job?

0 coins

That's where it gets complicated. If your school's mandatory attendance policy effectively means you'd have to choose between keeping your enrollment and taking a job, NYSDOL can interpret that as a restriction on your availability - even if your personal intention is to take the job. The external constraint matters, not just your subjective willingness.

0 coins

ugh. so for programs with strict attendance rules you're kind of stuck either way

0 coins

Practically speaking, if the program is short enough, some people calculate that they can complete it and then immediately be fully available. But during the program, you'd need to be ready to honestly answer that your attendance requirement could prevent you from starting a job immediately.

0 coins

Spent a long time going back and forth on this question when I was debating an HVAC certification while collecting UI. What finally resolved it was actually getting a specific answer from NYSDOL rather than interpreting vague guidelines. Used Claimyr to get through to an agent after my own solo attempts failed repeatedly - the hold times were genuinely hours long. The agent confirmed my specific program schedule wouldn't affect my availability determination given the number of hours and my job field.

0 coins

Getting program-specific confirmation seems like the safest move. Were they able to put that determination in writing anywhere or was it just a verbal confirmation on the phone?

0 coins

Verbal only, but the agent noted the conversation in my account. When I checked my Unemployment Services account afterward there was a note reflecting that an availability review had been conducted. That documentation ended up being useful.

0 coins

This is making me think I need to actually talk to someone at NYSDOL rather than just hoping my situation falls into the 'fine' category based on what I've read online.

0 coins

The legal standard NYSDOL uses comes from Labor Law Section 591 - you have to be ready, willing, and able to work. Schools trips people up on the 'available' prong specifically. Availability doesn't mean you have zero schedule obligations - it means you're not imposing conditions that restrict you to only certain types or hours of work. A two-morning-per-week welding cert doesn't come close to that threshold for most job types.

0 coins

Hearing that it's specifically about whether I'm imposing conditions on what work I'll accept makes this much clearer. I'd take any warehouse or trades job regardless of the class schedule.

0 coins

Then document that posture as clearly as you can in your records. If your claim is ever reviewed, the question will essentially be: would this person have turned down suitable work because of class? If the answer is no, the school attendance doesn't matter.

0 coins

Does NYSDOL ever ask this question on the weekly certification? Like is there a field where you'd indicate you're in school or is it only if they reach out separately?

0 coins

Weekly certifications don't have a school-specific field, but the questions about whether you were able and available and whether anything prevented you from accepting work are the operative ones. If you're in school and it genuinely didn't prevent you from accepting work that week, you answer yes to availability. The school fact itself only becomes relevant if NYSDOL audits or sends a questionnaire.

0 coins

Makes sense. I'm going to log the welding cert in my own records and be ready to explain it if asked, but not volunteer it on every weekly certification where it's not specifically asked.

0 coins

That's a reasonable approach. You're not hiding anything - if they ask, you answer honestly. The certification question is about your actual availability during that week, not about every activity you engaged in.

0 coins

This is how I handled my night class situation and it was fine. The key is that your honest answer to 'were you available for work' was yes, and that's what you're certifying.

0 coins

Went through almost this exact scenario with a nursing assistant certification program and was nervous enough about it that I tried to reach NYSDOL for three days straight before anything got through. Eventually someone in my support group mentioned Claimyr. Got through to an agent who told me that my CNA program, which met Monday Wednesday Friday mornings, was fine for my claim because my work history was in healthcare where evening and weekend shifts are extremely common - availability for my field didn't require daytime weekday openness specifically.

0 coins

That field-specific analysis is interesting - so it's not just about whether you're free during 'normal business hours' but whether you're available for work in YOUR field specifically?

0 coins

That's exactly what the agent said. For healthcare, food service, retail, trades - lots of fields where shift work is normal, daytime class hours don't restrict availability the way they would for a 9-to-5 office job search.

0 coins

This is an underappreciated point. 'Available for work' has to be evaluated against suitable work for that person's skills and history, not some abstract standard. A nurse's aide being free nights and weekends IS available for nursing aide work.

0 coins

Alright, pulling together everything from this thread - I'm going to take the following steps before enrolling in the welding program: check with my local Career Center about whether the cert qualifies for the approved training referral route, and if not, give NYSDOL a direct call to get my specific schedule reviewed and noted on my account. I feel a lot more confident that my situation isn't automatically disqualifying. Thanks everyone - this was incredibly useful.

0 coins

Sounds like exactly the right sequence. Career Center first, then NYSDOL call if needed. Good luck with the welding cert - it's a smart skill to pick up.

0 coins

Keep us posted on how the Career Center conversation goes. The approved training route is underutilized and your situation sounds like it could genuinely qualify.

0 coins

Good luck - and document everything as you go. Future you will thank present you if anything gets questioned later.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure