Back to New York Unemployment

Lydia Santiago

Can seasonal workers collect unemployment when the season ends?

My situation might be kind of niche but I feel like there have to be other people dealing with this. I've worked at the same outdoor recreation company for the past four summers — same employer, same role, same deal every year where they bring me on around late April and lay me off when things slow down in October. This year when the season wrapped up I went ahead and filed for UI through NYSDOL like I normally would between gigs, but now I'm seeing some kind of issue flag on my Unemployment Services account and I genuinely don't know if that's because of the seasonal nature of my work or something else entirely. The thing is, I've always reported my job search activities, I've always been available for work — I'm not in school, I don't have anything blocking me from taking a full-time position. But I'm starting to wonder whether NYSDOL treats seasonal workers differently than year-round employees when it comes to eligibility. Do we even qualify? Is there some special process or status I'm supposed to request? I didn't get any paperwork from my employer indicating I'd be rehired next spring, which I've heard can sometimes matter. Anyone who's been through this with seasonal work specifically, I'd really appreciate knowing what to expect.

My fourth season ending like this taught me more about UI rules than I ever wanted to know. The short answer is yes, seasonal workers in New York can collect unemployment between seasons — NYSDOL doesn't automatically disqualify you just because your layoff was predictable or tied to the time of year. What actually matters is whether you earned enough wages during your base period to meet the monetary eligibility threshold, and whether you're genuinely available and actively looking for work during the weeks you're claiming. The flag on your account could be a few different things. Sometimes NYSDOL opens an adjudication issue if your employer contests the claim or if something in your work history triggers a review. It doesn't necessarily mean you're disqualified — it just means someone at NYSDOL needs to look at your specific situation before they can release payments.

0 coins

My employer has never contested a claim before, so that part surprised me. Is there any way to find out what the flag is actually about without waiting for a letter in the mail? The account just says there's an issue under review and doesn't give me any details.

0 coins

Mine said the same vague thing for two and a half weeks before anything changed. The letters take forever but they do eventually show up.

0 coins

Your best move is to keep certifying every week even while the adjudication is open — missing a weekly claim during that window can create a bigger mess than the original flag.

0 coins

The base period calculation tripped me up my first year filing after a seasonal job. NYSDOL looks at your wages from roughly 12-18 months before you filed, depending on which base period they use. If your seasons run April through October, you might have a gap quarter in there that reduces your countable wages. Worth pulling your wage history from your Unemployment Services account to see what they're actually working with.

0 coins

Hadn't thought about that at all. My hours were solid during the season but obviously zero in the off-months, so I can see how the quarterly math might work against me.

0 coins

There's also an alternate base period NYSDOL can use if the standard one comes up short. My sister — wait, I mean when this happened to me a few years ago the alternate period saved my claim because it captured more recent wages. Worth asking about if your standard base period looks thin.

0 coins

Yeah the alternate base period is a real option, not just something people say. NYSDOL will apply it if the standard calculation doesn't meet the monetary threshold.

0 coins

Two weeks of busy signals and disconnected calls trying to get through to NYSDOL about a nearly identical situation — I finally used Claimyr (claimyr.com) and it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up actually speaking with a live agent. There's a video walkthrough at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE if you want to see how it works before you try it. The agent I reached was able to tell me exactly what the issue on my account was and what documents I needed to send in, all in one phone call. Saved me a lot of guessing.

0 coins

Two weeks of that sounds absolutely exhausting. I've been trying to get through since Monday and already feel like I'm losing my mind. Going to look at that video tonight.

0 coins

Every single time I've tried calling NYSDOL I get put on hold for forty minutes and then it just drops. Nice to know there's another way.

0 coins

Tried the NYSDOL main line about six times over three days before giving up. Ended up getting my adjudication info from a letter finally but by that point I'd already missed a weekly certification window.

0 coins

Standby status is something a lot of seasonal workers don't know about and it changed everything for my claim. If you have a definite return-to-work date from your employer — even an approximate season start in spring — you can request standby status with NYSDOL, which exempts you from the full three-job-search-per-week requirement. Without that status, NYSDOL expects you to be actively applying for work every week you certify, and if they audit your job search log and it looks thin you can end up with a disqualification even after your claim was approved.

0 coins

My employer never gave me anything in writing about next spring. If I don't have a confirmed return date, does that mean I can't get standby?

0 coins

Without a written confirmation of rehire, standby is tough to get approved. You'd need your employer to submit something to NYSDOL — even a letter on company letterhead saying you're expected back for the next season. It's worth asking them directly.

0 coins

My employer was willing to write a letter like that when I asked, but it took them three weeks to actually send it in. During that time I had to keep logging full job search activities to stay compliant.

0 coins

NYSDOL can be really strict about the standby documentation. My claim got flagged specifically because my employer submitted the letter too late and there was a certification gap in between.

0 coins

Honestly the job search requirement is where seasonal workers tend to get tripped up more than anywhere else. You need three separate work search activities per week — that means three distinct actions like submitting an application, attending a job fair, registering with an employment agency, or similar. A lot of people assume browsing job boards counts but it usually doesn't unless you actually apply or make a contact. NYSDOL can and does audit these logs.

0 coins

That part I've been keeping up with at least. I've been applying to full-time roles in a related field since I know I won't hear anything about next season for months.

0 coins

wait does uploading your resume to indeed count as one of the three or no

0 coins

Posting or updating your resume on a job board generally does count as one work search activity. But doing it again the next week on the same site usually doesn't count a second time — it needs to be a new and distinct action.

0 coins

This is the thing that stressed me out most when I first filed. Keep records of everything with dates, employer names, and what action you took. NYSDOL wants specifics if they ever ask.

0 coins

The issue flag on your account might also just be an identity verification hold. NYSDOL has been running more of those since they tightened up fraud prevention, and seasonal workers sometimes trigger them because the earning pattern looks unusual to their system — high wages for part of the year and nothing for months. It's not a reflection of anything you did wrong, it just means they want to confirm you are who you say you are before releasing funds.

0 coins

Hadn't even considered that possibility. How does the identity verification process work — do they contact me or do I have to initiate something?

0 coins

NYSDOL typically sends a letter with instructions, or sometimes they flag your Unemployment Services account with a prompt to verify through ID.me. Check your account messages section, not just the main dashboard — the prompt can be easy to miss.

0 coins

My identity verification issue sat unresolved for weeks because I didn't see the ID.me prompt buried in the messages tab. Once I completed it the payments released within a few days.

0 coins

Four different seasons working outdoor tourism, four rounds of filing UI claims between them. The thing that helped me most was treating each off-season filing like its own independent claim and not assuming anything carried over from the previous year. Your base period resets, your benefit rate recalculates, and if your wages went up during the most recent season your weekly benefit amount might actually be higher than what you got the year before.

0 coins

Mine should actually be higher this year since I picked up more hours. I just didn't expect the flag situation, that's new for me.

0 coins

The flag being new could genuinely be a fraud-prevention thing or it could be your employer responding to the claim in a way they haven't before. Either way it usually resolves — it just takes longer than anyone wants it to.

0 coins

My fourth claim also had a flag that my first three didn't. It was an adjudication that cleared after about three weeks with no action needed from me at all. Sometimes NYSDOL just reviews things.

0 coins

THE EMPLOYER RESPONSE WINDOW is what gets people. When you file a UI claim, NYSDOL notifies your employer and gives them a window to respond. If they indicate the separation wasn't a standard seasonal layoff — like if they put in something about misconduct or you quitting voluntarily — that opens an adjudication automatically. Had this happen to me and I had NO IDEA my employer even said anything until I got the determination letter two months later saying I was disqualified and owed money back. Fight everything in writing from day one.

0 coins

That's genuinely alarming. I have no reason to think my employer would do that but now I'm not so sure I shouldn't double-check somehow.

0 coins

You can call NYSDOL and specifically ask whether your employer responded to your separation claim and what they said. That's public information as part of your claim.

0 coins

Employer responses are part of your claim record and you have a right to see them. When I appealed a disqualification, getting the employer's written response was actually what helped me win the appeal because they mischaracterized the reason for my layoff.

0 coins

This is why documenting everything about your layoff at the time it happens matters. Any text, email, or message where your employer confirms the seasonal nature of your separation can be really useful later.

0 coins

Honestly tried for three days to get anyone at NYSDOL on the phone before my coworker mentioned Claimyr. Used it and ended up talking to an actual agent who walked me through what was on my claim and confirmed it was just a routine review, nothing I'd done wrong. Would have spent another week panicking without that call.

0 coins

Three days is about where I'm at right now. The not-knowing is way harder than whatever the actual answer turns out to be.

0 coins

Got that same coworker-tip energy when someone in my household mentioned it after I'd already been trying for a week on my own. Wish I'd known sooner.

0 coins

Weekly certifications need to happen every week without exception, even when your claim is flagged. Missing one doesn't pause the clock — it just means you forfeit that week's payment and you can't reclaim it later. NYSDOL's system doesn't give backdated credit for weeks you skipped, even when the skip was because you assumed things were on hold.

0 coins

Learned this the hard way my first year. Skipped two weeks assuming I'd get to them once the adjudication cleared and those two weeks were just gone.

0 coins

Certifying every week regardless — noted. I did my most recent one on Sunday so I'm current, but good to have this confirmed explicitly.

0 coins

wait the weekly claims and the adjudication are separate things?? i thought you had to wait until adjudication was done

0 coins

Completely separate processes. Adjudication is NYSDOL deciding whether you're eligible. Weekly certifications are you reporting each week that you were available and looking for work. Keep doing both simultaneously.

0 coins

My appeal two years ago taught me that NYSDOL's initial determination is not the final word. If the adjudication comes back as a disqualification and you believe it's wrong, you have 30 days from the date on the determination letter to file a formal appeal. The appeal goes to an Administrative Law Judge and it's a real hearing where you can present evidence and testimony. Win rate for well-prepared claimants is actually reasonable — the system is bureaucratic but it's not stacked entirely against you.

0 coins

30 days from the letter date — that's the window I need to remember. Hopefully it doesn't come to that but good to know.

0 coins

My ALJ hearing was done by phone and took maybe 25 minutes. Bring your documentation, speak clearly about the facts, and don't speculate. The judges are generally professional even if the whole thing feels intimidating.

0 coins

DOCUMENT EVERYTHING before the hearing. I mean everything. Texts from your employer, your offer letter, your termination notice, your work schedule. The more concrete evidence you bring the better your position.

0 coins

Something nobody mentioned yet — your weekly benefit amount for seasonal work is calculated the same way as for any other worker. NYSDOL takes your highest-earning quarter from the base period and uses a formula based on that. If your peak season wages were strong, your WBA could actually be pretty decent. Worth running the estimate on NYSDOL's website before you assume the worst about what you'd actually receive.

0 coins

My highest quarter last year was pretty solid, so I'm hoping that calculation works in my favor. I just need the account flag resolved first.

0 coins

The NYSDOL benefit estimator on labor.ny.gov is actually pretty accurate for figuring out what your WBA will be before the official determination comes through.

0 coins

My claim had an ID verification flag and an employer-response adjudication at the same time, which was a special kind of chaos. What finally helped me was actually reaching an agent through Claimyr — waited on hold so I didn't have to, and I got to speak directly with a rep who could see both issues in my account simultaneously and tell me which one was holding up payments and which one was just informational. Knowing the actual priority issue made it so much easier to focus my energy.

0 coins

Having two overlapping issues explained at once by someone who can actually see your account sounds incredibly useful. At this point I'm just trying to understand what's even happening.

0 coins

An agent who can pull up your full account view is genuinely the fastest path to understanding what's going on. The letters and account messages often don't give you the full picture.

0 coins

Partial weeks matter too if you pick up any work during your off-season claim period. NYSDOL has an earnings disregard formula — you can earn up to a certain amount per week without losing your full benefit, but once you go over that threshold your benefit gets reduced dollar for dollar. Report everything accurately though because misreporting earned wages is treated as fraud and the consequences are way worse than just having a reduced check.

0 coins

Good point — I've picked up some odd jobs in past off-seasons and always reported them. Didn't want to mess with that.

0 coins

Accurate reporting every week keeps your claim clean. NYSDOL cross-references wage data with the state tax system so unreported earnings tend to surface eventually.

0 coins

The earnings disregard in New York is based on your WBA so it varies by person. The formula is in NYSDOL's handbook but the simplest way to understand it is that some earnings reduce your benefit but don't eliminate it entirely unless you earn above your WBA for that week.

0 coins

do you have to register with the career center when you file? i got told you do but then when i asked someone else they said only sometimes

0 coins

NYSDOL requires most claimants to register with the NY Career Center system, but whether you have to physically report to one depends on your specific claim type and sometimes your geographic area. The registration itself is handled online through Unemployment Services — look for the career center section in your account. If you have standby status it may be waived.

0 coins

My claim required career center registration but not in-person reporting. Just had to complete the online profile and list it as one of my work search activities. Worth checking your determination letter for what specifically is required in your case.

0 coins

Five months into a seasonal layoff claim once and the worst part was the uncertainty early on. The system does work for seasonal workers — just takes some patience and knowing which specific requirements apply to you. Once my adjudication cleared and my standby status was confirmed I didn't have to do much besides certify weekly and wait.

0 coins

Patience is not my strong suit when bills are due, but I appreciate hearing it does eventually work out. This thread has helped a lot honestly.

0 coins

The first claim is always the worst because you don't know what's normal. By the second or third time you kind of know what to expect and when to actually worry.

0 coins

Knowing what 'normal' looks like for a NYSDOL adjudication timeline changes everything. First time I thought 3 weeks meant my claim was doomed. By the second time I knew it was just standard processing.

0 coins

Monetary vs non-monetary eligibility is a distinction that trips people up constantly. Monetary eligibility means you earned enough wages in your base period to qualify at all — NYSDOL handles this automatically and you'll see it in your determination. Non-monetary eligibility is everything else: your reason for separation, your availability for work, your job search activities. The flag on your account is almost certainly a non-monetary issue being reviewed.

0 coins

That breakdown actually clarifies a lot. So even if my monetary eligibility is fine, there could still be a separate review happening on the availability or separation side.

0 coins

Exactly right. And the two are resolved on different timelines. Monetary gets determined pretty quickly — it's the non-monetary side that can sit in adjudication for weeks.

0 coins

This is a genuinely important distinction and worth reading up on in the NYSDOL claimant handbook. The handbook is on labor.ny.gov and it explains both paths to disqualification separately.

0 coins

Representation at an ALJ hearing is allowed and sometimes changes outcomes significantly. If your adjudication comes back as a disqualification, you can represent yourself but you're also allowed to bring someone who knows the process. Some legal aid organizations in New York specifically handle unemployment appeals at no cost to the claimant. Worth knowing before you're in that situation.

0 coins

Legal aid for unemployment appeals is something I had no idea existed. Filing away just in case.

0 coins

LEGAL AID IS REAL AND AVAILABLE. When I went through my appeal I found a nonprofit that helped me prepare my case at no charge. Made a massive difference in how organized my documents were going in.

0 coins

Community legal services offices in most larger New York cities have specific staff for unemployment cases. The wait for help can be a few weeks so contact them early if your adjudication goes sideways.

0 coins

Recalling seasonal workers is different from rehiring them in NYSDOL's view, and that distinction can actually help your claim. If your employer laid you off with a reasonable expectation that you'd be brought back for next season, that's treated more favorably than a permanent separation. The burden falls partly on them to characterize the separation accurately when they respond to your claim.

0 coins

My understanding has always been that it's a seasonal recall situation, but I never got that in writing. Hoping my employer characterized it correctly when they responded.

0 coins

You can request to see your employer's response through NYSDOL — just ask the agent specifically for the separation documentation they submitted. That tells you what you're working with.

0 coins

The distinction between a recall layoff and a permanent separation is real and NYSDOL does treat them differently when evaluating your non-monetary eligibility. Getting clarity on how your employer filed that response is worth a phone call.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure