Back to New York Unemployment

Levi Parker

Can a landlord apply for unemployment? NYSDOL rules explained

My situation is a bit unusual and I'm having trouble finding a straight answer online. I've been a self-employed landlord managing a small portfolio of rental properties for the past six years — it was my primary income source, not just a side hustle. Recently I had to sell off two of my three properties due to a prolonged legal dispute with a contractor that drained my savings, and the remaining property is sitting vacant while I deal with permit issues. My rental income has essentially collapsed to zero. A friend told me I might be eligible for unemployment benefits through NYSDOL since I no longer have income, but I'm skeptical because I've always thought unemployment was only for people who lost a traditional W-2 job. Has anyone dealt with this or know whether a landlord can actually file a UI claim? I don't want to waste time applying if it's going to get denied immediately.

My experience with this exact question sent me down a rabbit hole last spring. Before I get into what I found out, though — if you do end up needing to reach NYSDOL directly to discuss your eligibility, their phone lines are genuinely brutal. Claimyr (claimyr.com) waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so that you end up talking to a live agent — there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. Saved me hours. Anyway, to your actual question: the core issue is whether you paid into the unemployment insurance system through wages. Rental income from being a landlord is not considered covered wages under New York's UI rules, so if your only income was from rents, there wouldn't be a base period of covered employment to draw benefits from. That's the fundamental problem with landlord situations.

0 coins

My concern exactly — I never had wages in the traditional sense, it was always rental income. So does that completely rule me out, or are there edge cases?

0 coins

Covered wages are really the whole ballgame here. No covered employment in your base period, no UI benefits — that's pretty much how it works across the board.

0 coins

My brother-in-law tried something similar after his rental business dried up and NYSDOL denied him immediately at the claims level. Never got past the initial filing.

0 coins

Technically there's a distinction worth making here. If you at some point in the last 18 months held a regular job — even part-time — alongside your landlord work, those wages might appear in your base period and give you enough covered employment to file. The base period NYSDOL uses is typically the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters. So if you had any W-2 income during that window, the picture changes.

0 coins

For the past six years it's been exclusively landlord income, no W-2 work at all. So I think that closes that door for me.

0 coins

Your timeline matters a lot here. Six years of pure self-employment with no payroll wages means your base period would show zero covered earnings. NYSDOL won't have anything to calculate a benefit rate from.

0 coins

This is what trips people up — they assume income is income. But NYSDOL only counts wages where unemployment taxes were paid by an employer, not rental income, investment income, or self-employment income.

0 coins

yeah pretty much this. my landlord neighbor asked me the same thing last year and I told him the same thing lol

0 coins

My first instinct when I saw this post was to wonder if you'd ever operated your rental business as an LLC or S-corp and paid yourself a salary through it. That's actually the scenario where landlords sometimes do have covered wages — if you formally employed yourself and ran payroll with FUTA/SUTA taxes withheld, those wages would count. It's not common but it does happen.

0 coins

Operated as a sole proprietor the whole time, never set up payroll. Sounds like that matters more than I realized.

0 coins

Payroll through an S-corp is the only real path I've seen work for landlords, and even then NYSDOL sometimes pushes back on whether the work was bona fide employment. It's complicated.

0 coins

My accountant mentioned this setup once as a tax strategy. Had no idea it also had unemployment implications. Really wish someone had explained this earlier.

0 coins

WAIT. so are you telling me that people who own rentals literally can never get unemployment no matter what?? I feel like this is something nobody explains when you become a landlord. I've been managing two units for 3 years and never thought about this once

0 coins

Your assumption isn't wrong in most cases — passive landlords without payroll wages fall outside the UI system entirely. It's not that there's a rule against landlords, it's that the system only covers people whose employers paid unemployment taxes on their behalf.

0 coins

okay that actually makes sense when you put it that way. so its really about whether taxes were paid into the system not about what KIND of job you had

0 coins

Exactly right. The UI system is essentially an insurance pool funded by employer payroll taxes. No employer, no contributions, no benefits — landlords who self-manage and never ran payroll are simply outside that pool.

0 coins

Went through something adjacent to this after I sold my only rental and tried to file. The rep at NYSDOL was actually pretty helpful once I got through to someone — she explained that my situation would require covered wages in the base period and without that the system basically has nothing to work with. Filed anyway just to see what would happen, got denied in about two weeks, and the denial letter was actually pretty clear about the reason.

0 coins

How long did it take you to actually get through to someone at NYSDOL? I've been trying for days and keep getting disconnected.

0 coins

Took me most of a morning the first time. Tried again later in the week and had slightly better luck calling right when they opened. Even then it was about 90 minutes on hold before anyone picked up.

0 coins

My situation with reaching NYSDOL was just as frustrating. Ended up using Claimyr, honestly it was the first time I actually got to speak to a live agent without spending my entire day on the phone. Would definitely try it if the hold times are killing you.

0 coins

There's a path that sometimes surprises people in situations like this. If your rental activity collapsed AND you're now actively looking for regular employment, you technically might qualify for UI once you find a new job and get laid off — but that doesn't help you right now obviously. The other thing to look into is whether your state has any assistance programs for self-employed individuals who've had income loss. Those aren't unemployment insurance per se but they're sometimes available through workforce development agencies.

0 coins

Worth knowing for the future I guess. Right now I just need to understand what I'm eligible for given where things stand today.

0 coins

Your point about workforce programs is a good one. NYSDOL Career Centers can sometimes connect people to emergency assistance or retraining programs even when they don't qualify for regular UI.

0 coins

Workforce NY has some resources that don't require covered employment. Worth visiting a local career center in person if you can.

0 coins

My cousin went through something similar and her situation ended up being different than she expected because she had done some freelance bookkeeping years ago for a company that actually put her on payroll. That showed up in her base period and gave her just enough covered wages to establish a UI claim. The lesson I took from watching her go through it — always check your earnings history in your NYSDOL account before assuming you have zero covered wages.

0 coins

That's a good point actually. I did do some consulting for a small firm back in 2020 — though that's probably too far back to matter for the base period now.

0 coins

2020 wages would definitely be outside the standard base period by now, unfortunately. NYSDOL's base period goes back roughly 15-18 months from when you file, so 2020 is too old.

0 coins

There's also an alternate base period NYSDOL can use if you don't qualify under the standard one, which looks at the most recent four completed quarters instead. Still probably wouldn't capture 2020 wages but worth knowing the option exists.

0 coins

My brother went through the whole landlord-to-unemployed situation last year and was equally confused. He ended up using Claimyr to get through to a NYSDOL agent because the regular phone line was a dead end for him — just hold music and disconnections for days. Once he was actually on the phone with someone, the agent walked him through exactly why his rental income didn't count and pointed him toward some workforce development resources instead. Saved him from filing a doomed claim and wasting weeks waiting for a denial.

0 coins

hold music and disconnections describes my experience with every government phone line ever

0 coins

Knowing before filing whether it's even worth it would save so much time. That's really what I need — just a clear answer from someone at NYSDOL before I spend weeks on a doomed application.

0 coins

Your brother's approach was smart. Getting clarification before filing is way underrated. So many people submit first and ask questions later, then spend months waiting for a denial they could've seen coming.

0 coins

ok kind of a dumb thing to ask but can landlords who do like property management for OTHER peoples properties get unemployment? like if youre employed by a property management company and they let you go? asking because my roommate is in that situation

0 coins

Your roommate's situation is completely different and much more straightforward. Working for a property management company as an employee means the company paid unemployment taxes on those wages — so yes, if they were let go, they can file for regular UI benefits just like anyone else who lost a W-2 job.

0 coins

ok yeah that makes sense. she was definitely a W-2 employee so sounds like shes good to file. thanks

0 coins

W-2 employment at a property management firm is fully covered by UI. The confusion usually comes from mixing up the employer (the management company) with property owners like the OP who are essentially their own business.

0 coins

My take after reading everything here: the OP's situation is unfortunately pretty clear-cut. No covered wages in the base period means no UI benefit rate can be calculated. What might be worth exploring instead is whether there are small business programs, housing assistance, or community development grants that could bridge the gap while they figure out the next step income-wise. NYSDOL's main phone line can also refer you to partner agencies if you explain your situation.

0 coins

Had not really considered the partner agency angle. If I eventually get through to NYSDOL maybe I'll ask specifically about what other programs they can point me toward.

0 coins

Your instinct to call rather than just rely on the website is good — NYSDOL agents seem to have more information about referral resources than what's posted online.

0 coins

HUD has some assistance programs too that people overlook when they're thinking only about unemployment. Might be worth a parallel search while you're sorting out the NYSDOL question.

0 coins

There's something I got wrong for a long time that actually applies here. My old belief was that anyone who lost income involuntarily could get UI — I genuinely thought it was about the loss, not the source. What I learned the hard way is that NYSDOL looks at whether you were part of the covered employment system, not whether your income dropped. Landlords, freelancers, sole proprietors — if no one was paying FUTA and SUTA taxes on your earnings, you're outside the system regardless of how significant the income loss was.

0 coins

this is such an important thing to understand and I had no idea either until reading this thread. the government really needs to explain this better

0 coins

The tricky part is that there IS a system for self-employed people — New York had the PUA program during the pandemic — but that was pandemic-specific and ended. Right now there's no standing program for self-employed income loss in New York.

0 coins

PUA is long gone and there's nothing equivalent active right now in NY. That gap is real and it leaves a lot of people confused about their options.

0 coins

My filing experience was different from the standard case people describe here, so maybe it adds something. After my rental income dried up I tried to file thinking maybe the system would at least process it and tell me whether anything existed. Got to the weekly certification step before it flagged my account for adjudication specifically because I couldn't document 'separation from employment' — there was no employer to separate from. The adjudicator was actually quite clear in their notes that rental income doesn't constitute covered employment.

0 coins

Adjudication just because you filed? That's a whole extra delay I'd like to avoid if possible.

0 coins

Your concern about the delay is valid. In my case the whole thing took about six weeks from initial filing to denial letter. If I'd known upfront I wasn't eligible, I'd have saved that time entirely.

0 coins

The adjudication flag in cases like this is pretty automatic — NYSDOL's system sees an unusual employment situation and routes it for a human review. Getting clarification before filing is genuinely the better move.

0 coins

Adjudication timelines have been running longer lately from what I've seen on this forum. Some people waiting 8-10 weeks for cases that probably shouldn't have been filed in the first place.

0 coins

something about this whole thread is making me appreciate having an employer way more than i used to lol. never really thought about how being your own boss means you're completely outside the safety net in most cases

0 coins

Your reaction is a pretty common one when people first realize how the UI system is structured. The tradeoff for being self-employed is freedom but no employer-funded safety net — that's why a lot of financial advisors push self-employed folks to build bigger emergency funds.

0 coins

yeah i always assumed there was some version of unemployment for everyone. learning something new today fr

0 coins

There's a nuance about S-corp situations that hasn't been fully explained here. My understanding — and I'd verify this with NYSDOL directly — is that if a landlord set up an S-corporation, paid themselves a reasonable salary, and that payroll was reported with appropriate state unemployment taxes, those wages would appear in their base period like any other employee's wages. The S-corp itself would be the 'employer' for UI purposes. Some CPAs actually set this up deliberately for exactly this reason. But if you're already in a situation where it wasn't done, there's no retroactive fix.

0 coins

Retroactive is exactly what I'd need and you're confirming that's not an option. This is useful context for whatever I set up next though.

0 coins

Your point about the S-corp-as-employer setup is accurate. The key is that the S-corp must have actually run proper payroll with state unemployment insurance taxes withheld — a lot of small S-corps skip that or minimize salary to reduce payroll taxes, which then backfires in a situation exactly like this.

0 coins

An S-corp owner who minimized salary to cut taxes and then tried to file for UI is in a tough spot. NYSDOL will look at covered wages only, so if the official payroll was low, the benefit rate would be low even if distributions were high.

0 coins

My situation reading this — I'm a freelancer not a landlord, but the principle sounds identical. Income without covered wages means no UI safety net. I've been meaning to look into whether setting up as an S-corp and paying myself properly would change that for me.

0 coins

Your instinct is right and it's worth talking to a CPA about. The setup has to be done correctly and maintained over time — it's not a quick fix but it is a legitimate path for self-employed people to build UI eligibility going forward.

0 coins

Makes sense to plan ahead rather than scramble when income drops. I'll bring it up with my accountant.

0 coins

Freelancers and landlords are in the same boat structurally. No covered employment, no UI. The S-corp salary route is the main legitimate workaround available, and it has to be in place before you need it.

0 coins

Tried calling NYSDOL myself today about a different question and gave up after 2 hours on hold. How is anyone actually getting through to these people

0 coins

My experience was exactly the same until I tried Claimyr. Got on the phone with an actual NYSDOL agent without the endless hold — honestly couldn't believe it worked the first time I tried it.

0 coins

wait seriously? because I've literally tried calling every day this week and cannot get through to a single person

0 coins

Calling right when they open at 8am used to work better, but lately even that isn't reliable. The volume they're dealing with is just enormous.

0 coins

Mid-week mornings have been slightly better in my experience but it's still a gamble. Some days you get through in 45 minutes, other days never.

0 coins

My perspective having watched several people go through unusual UI situations: NYSDOL agents are actually more helpful than the website suggests when you get a real person. The website makes everything sound black-and-white but agents can often point you toward resources or programs that aren't prominently advertised online. For anyone in a gray area situation — landlord, freelancer, S-corp owner — a direct conversation with an agent is worth pursuing even if the answer ends up being no.

0 coins

This is actually reassuring. Even if the answer is no, hearing it directly from an agent and getting pointed toward alternatives is better than just getting a denial letter weeks from now.

0 coins

Exactly. The denial letter just says you're ineligible. An agent can explain why and what else might be available. Those are very different experiences.

0 coins

Agents also sometimes catch things the online system misses — like an alternate base period that might apply, or a previous job you forgot about that's still within the window. Worth the call even when the situation seems clear-cut.

0 coins

update question from the OP — has anyone actually tried filing in a situation like this and been approved? I keep seeing posts about why landlords can't qualify but wondering if anyone found an exception

0 coins

Your question is worth asking but approval cases for pure landlords with no payroll wages are extremely rare. The ones I've seen discussed online almost always involve some W-2 wages in the mix — even from years ago — that people had forgotten about.

0 coins

My denial was pretty fast and came with a clear reason. I haven't personally seen a landlord case with zero covered wages get approved in New York. If anyone has, I'd genuinely be curious what their situation was.

0 coins

There's no carve-out in New York law for landlords to access UI without covered wages. If an approval happened it would likely be an error that could get reversed on audit. Not something to bank on.

0 coins

Thanks everyone — this has been really clarifying. My takeaways: (1) my rental income never counted as covered wages, (2) without base period wages there's nothing to calculate a benefit from, (3) filing would likely result in adjudication and eventual denial, and (4) my best move is probably to contact NYSDOL directly to ask about any other programs or resources, then explore S-corp setup for the future. Going to try to reach an agent and ask specifically about workforce development referrals.

0 coins

Your plan sounds right. Claimyr might be worth trying if the phone line keeps frustrating you — getting to an actual agent to ask about those referral programs is the step that could open doors here.

0 coins

Workforce NY career centers are also walk-in friendly in most areas. Sometimes easier to just go in person and talk to someone who can look at your full situation and point you in the right direction.

0 coins

Your framing of the S-corp question for future planning is exactly right. It won't help today but could make a real difference the next time income gets disrupted.

0 coins

Wishing you luck — situations like this really highlight the gap in the safety net for self-employed people. Hope the workforce resources open something up for you.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure