Can a 17 year old file for unemployment in NY? NYSDOL age rules explained
My daughter just turned 17 and was working part-time at a grocery store for about 8 months before they cut her hours down to basically nothing last week. She was making around $340 a week and was a legitimate W-2 employee the whole time, taxes withheld, the whole deal. I'm trying to figure out if she even qualifies to file a UI claim with NYSDOL given her age. I looked at the NYSDOL website and it doesn't specifically mention anything about minimum age requirements for unemployment benefits - it just talks about being 'able and available' to work and having enough base period wages. Does being 17 affect her eligibility? Has anyone dealt with this situation before?
81 comments

Paloma Clark
Your daughter's W-2 status is actually the key detail here, not her age. NYSDOL doesn't list a minimum age for unemployment - what matters is whether she earned enough wages during the base period to meet the monetary eligibility threshold. If her employer paid into the UI system on her behalf (which they should have if taxes were withheld), she built up a wage record that NYSDOL can look at. The question she should ask NYSDOL directly is whether her base period wages hit the minimum weekly benefit threshold, because that determines whether a claim can even be established. At roughly $340/week for 8 months, she might be close to the edge depending on how those wages fall across quarters. The bigger potential issue is the 'able and available' requirement - at 17 she might have school schedule restrictions that complicate things, so NYSDOL will want to know if she's genuinely available for full-time work or limited by school hours.
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
AuthorHer school schedule is definitely a concern I hadn't fully thought through. She goes Monday through Friday obviously, so her 'available' hours are pretty limited during the day. Does that automatically disqualify her or is there a part-time worker exception?
0 coins
Paloma Clark
Part-time worker history matters a lot here - your question for NYSDOL should be whether her prior employer only scheduled her part-time, because if she was hired as a part-time worker the standard is that she be available for work similar to what she had, not necessarily full-time. This comes down to her work history with that employer specifically.
0 coins
Heather Tyson
My nephew had a similar situation at 16 and they actually denied him initially because of school hours but then he appealed and won. So it's not automatic disqualification at all.
0 coins
Raul Neal
Honestly the fastest way to get a straight answer on the age and availability question is to actually talk to a NYSDOL agent directly, because the online info is super vague about edge cases like this. My situation was different but I had a complicated eligibility question and spent two weeks trying to get through on the phone. A friend told me about Claimyr - it basically waits on hold with NYSDOL so you end up talking to a live agent without sitting there for hours yourself. You can check it out at claimyr.com and there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. For something like a minor filing a claim it's honestly worth getting an agent on the phone because the rules aren't posted clearly anywhere.
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
AuthorTwo weeks trying to get through sounds about right - I tried calling yesterday and gave up after 90 minutes on hold. I'll look into Claimyr, thanks for the tip.
0 coins
Jenna Sloan
Does that actually work? I've tried calling NYSDOL like 6 times in the past month and either get the busy signal right away or sit forever and nothing happens.
0 coins
Raul Neal
My situation was exactly that - busy signal or eternal hold - and Claimyr sorted it out. Ended up speaking with an agent that same day, which shocked me honestly.
0 coins
Christian Burns
Tried phoning NYSDOL myself this morning and got disconnected twice. Might have to look into this.
0 coins
Sasha Reese
Base period wages are really what this comes down to for a 17-year-old, same as any claimant. NYSDOL looks at the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before the claim date - so if your daughter was working the past 8 months, some of those wages may actually fall into an earlier quarter than you'd expect. At $340 a week she was earning roughly $1,360 a month. NYSDOL requires a minimum amount in the highest base period quarter plus wages in at least two quarters to establish a claim monetarily. The specific minimums change periodically but her wages at that rate for 8 months should put her in a reasonable position IF the wages fall across multiple quarters the way they need to. Worth running the numbers before even worrying about the age question.
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
AuthorShe started working last March, so that would put wages in Q1 and Q2 of last year and then Q4 of this year I think. Does the base period calculation ever use an alternate base period if the regular one doesn't work in her favor?
0 coins
Sasha Reese
Your question about the alternate base period is exactly the right one to ask - NYSDOL does have an alternate base period that uses the most recent four completed quarters, which sometimes captures more wages for people who started working recently. She should ask NYSDOL to check eligibility under both.
0 coins
Muhammad Hobbs
Didn't know about the alternate base period thing. Wish someone had told me that when I filed last year, might have changed my benefit amount.
0 coins
Noland Curtis
Age 17 and filing for unemployment - I want to flag something that might actually matter more than the eligibility question itself. In New York, 17-year-olds are legally minors, and there's a question about whether a minor can enter into a legally binding agreement with the state for benefits purposes without a parent or guardian involved. This isn't something that comes up often but NYSDOL might require a parent to be involved in some capacity when a minor is filing a claim. I don't know this for certain but it's the kind of thing worth asking an agent specifically, because the standard online filing process just assumes adult filers.
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
AuthorParent involvement requirement - that's something I hadn't even thought to look up. Would I be filing on her behalf or would she file and I just provide information?
0 coins
Noland Curtis
Your role in this would likely be as a responsible party or representative if NYSDOL requires it - worth asking that agent specifically because I've seen conflicting information about this online and an agent would know the current procedure.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
My kid had a part-time job at 16 and when their hours got cut to zero we looked into this. We ended up talking to an agent through Claimyr because the NYSDOL website gave us nothing useful on the minor question. The agent told us that the minor still files in their own name but a parent can assist with the account setup. That was our experience anyway.
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
AuthorProfile 8's experience helps - so it sounds like she files herself but I can help with the account. Good to know.
0 coins
Vanessa Figueroa
WORKED AT A GROCERY STORE AND GOT HOURS CUT TO ZERO - this is literally a qualifying reason for unemployment (substantial reduction in hours). The age thing gets too much attention in this thread honestly. The real issue is whether her wages clear the monetary requirement. If NYSDOL has a wage record for her under her SSN showing those 8 months of work, she has a legitimate claim to file regardless of being 17. The system doesn't have an age filter that rejects minors automatically - I know people assume it does but it doesn't. FILE THE CLAIM and let NYSDOL tell her she's ineligible if she is. Don't self-disqualify before even trying.
0 coins
Abby Marshall
Hours cut to zero - does that count the same as a layoff for unemployment purposes? I always assumed you had to be fully let go.
0 coins
Vanessa Figueroa
Reduction in hours is absolutely a qualifying reason - you don't have to be fully fired. If your hours drop significantly enough that your weekly earnings fall below your weekly benefit amount, you can file. It's one of the more misunderstood parts of UI eligibility.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
This is true. My hours got cut from 40 to 8 a week and I was able to collect partial unemployment. NYSDOL has a whole partial benefit calculation for it.
0 coins
Heather Tyson
Partial UI is actually underused because people don't realize they qualify. Worth looking into for sure.
0 coins
Drew Hathaway
School enrollment complicates the able and available requirement more than age does, honestly. NYSDOL's standard is that a claimant be ready, willing, and able to accept suitable work immediately. If your daughter is enrolled in school full time, she needs to be able to show that she's available for work during hours that are consistent with what employers in her field offer. Since she was working part-time around school before, the question she should bring to NYSDOL is whether being available only for part-time hours around her school schedule satisfies the availability requirement given her prior work pattern. Some adjudicators are flexible on this for students who have an established part-time work history, others are not. It's genuinely inconsistent.
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
AuthorInconsistent adjudicator decisions are frustrating to hear about - so her outcome might literally depend on who reviews her claim?
0 coins
Drew Hathaway
Your frustration is completely valid. Adjudication outcomes for student claimants aren't always uniform, which is why getting an appeal on record quickly matters if she gets denied. The appeal window is 30 days from the determination and you should never miss it.
0 coins
Laila Prince
Appeals are really underused. I got denied initially for something similar and appealed and won at the hearing. Don't take the first denial as final.
0 coins
Isabel Vega
okay so random but i work at a grocery store too and ive seen like 3 coworkers under 18 get their hours slashed this year alone. none of them knew they could even try filing. does nysdol send you anything automatically if your hours drop or do you just have to know to file yourself
0 coins
Paloma Clark
Filing is entirely on the claimant - NYSDOL doesn't proactively reach out when someone's hours drop. The employer reports wages but doesn't trigger a claim. Your coworkers would each need to go to labor.ny.gov and file themselves.
0 coins
Isabel Vega
that is wild to me. so people just never collect because they dont know? seems like a lot of people leave money on the table
0 coins
Vanessa Figueroa
Millions of dollars in unclaimed UI benefits every year because people don't know they qualify or don't know how to file. It's a real problem.
0 coins
Christian Burns
My daughter went through something similar at 17 - part-time job, hours got cut, we didn't know what to do. What actually helped us was getting an agent on the phone who walked us through the whole thing. We spent almost a week trying to reach NYSDOL on our own, finally got through on a Tuesday morning around 8am right when they open. The agent confirmed that her age didn't disqualify her and explained exactly what the monetary threshold was for her base period wages. Sometimes you just need a human on the phone to clear up five different questions at once.
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
AuthorTuesday morning at 8am - is that genuinely the best time to call? I've been trying midday and getting nowhere.
0 coins
Christian Burns
Early morning on a Tuesday or Wednesday has worked best for me personally. Mondays are always slammed because of weekend backlog. Fridays are hit or miss. Try as early as possible right when the lines open.
0 coins
Jenna Sloan
I've tried 8am and still sat on hold for over an hour before giving up. The wait times seem totally random to me.
0 coins
Dominique Adams
My experience with NYSDOL phone waits went from unbearable to actually manageable once I used Claimyr. Ended up with an agent on the line and got my questions answered the same day I tried. For something like this where you need actual answers about a specific situation, it made a real difference.
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
Something worth knowing - the job search requirements for weekly certification are also going to apply to her if she's collecting. NYSDOL requires three work search activities per week, documented in a job search log. For a 17-year-old student this might actually be harder to satisfy than the initial eligibility question. She can't just list 'applied to grocery store' every week - she needs three distinct activities per week from the approved list (applying, attending a job fair, completing a resume workshop, etc.). This catches people off guard when they start certifying and think they just have to answer yes to the weekly questions.
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
AuthorThree activities per week - does applying to jobs online count as one activity per application or does she need to do three separate types of activities?
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
Each job application counts as one activity - so three separate applications to three different employers in a week would satisfy the requirement. They don't have to be three different types. But she should keep records with dates, employer names, positions, and how she applied, because NYSDOL can audit.
0 coins
Abby Marshall
Keeping detailed records saved me during an audit last year. NYSDOL asked for documentation going back several weeks and I had everything logged. Don't skip the records even if it feels tedious.
0 coins
Louisa Ramirez
Can she even set up a NY.gov ID account at 17? That's the login system for Unemployment Services online and I genuinely don't know if there's an age minimum for creating the account. This might be a practical barrier before you even get to the eligibility question.
0 coins
Sasha Reese
NY.gov ID creation - the terms technically say users must be adults in some contexts, but in practice minors often create accounts without issue. The more cautious path is to call NYSDOL and ask about filing over the phone or whether a parent-assisted account setup is possible. Don't let the account question stop you from at least asking.
0 coins
Louisa Ramirez
Phoning first sounds like the right move here. If the online system rejects the account setup you don't want that to create some flag on her SSN before the claim is even filed.
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
AuthorParent-assisted setup sounds like the safest path based on this whole thread. I'll call with her and ask the agent how to do it properly.
0 coins
TommyKapitz
Went through almost this exact situation last spring with my own kid - 17, part-time retail, hours went to zero. We got completely contradictory information from two different sources and finally used Claimyr to get an agent who gave us a definitive answer. The whole thing took maybe 20 minutes once we were actually speaking with someone at NYSDOL. Turned out she was eligible, filed the claim, got approved. The age thing was not the barrier we thought it would be.
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
AuthorYour outcome is really encouraging - what was the agent's specific explanation about why age wasn't a barrier?
0 coins
TommyKapitz
My kid's agent basically said New York doesn't set a minimum age in the UI statute and that the eligibility criteria apply uniformly - wages, availability, work separation reason. That was it. No special minor review process, just the same evaluation anyone gets.
0 coins
Muhammad Hobbs
That's really helpful to hear from someone who actually went through it. The speculation in these forums is useful but firsthand agent confirmation is what you actually need.
0 coins
Heather Tyson
Agreed - the agent's answer cuts through so much back and forth. Getting on the phone is the move here.
0 coins
Laila Prince
Monetary eligibility is worth calculating before filing so you're not going in blind. For New York, the weekly benefit amount is roughly 1/26 of the wages in the highest base period quarter, capped at the state maximum. If your daughter earned around $340/week and worked most of Q2 last year, her highest quarter wages might be around $4,400. One twenty-sixth of that is about $169/week in benefits. That's above zero, which means she'd have a monetary entitlement - but just barely. The minimum to actually get paid anything is higher than zero so you'd want to run the actual numbers on NYSDOL's benefit calculator on their site before filing.
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
Author$169 per week - that would actually cover a meaningful chunk of what she needs for transportation and her phone bill while she looks for another job. Worth pursuing even if it's not a huge amount.
0 coins
Laila Prince
Even modest benefit amounts matter when you're 17 and those are your personal expenses. The filing process is also worth doing because if she establishes a claim, her benefit year stays open for 52 weeks and she can collect whenever she has weeks with reduced or zero earnings during that period.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
Benefit year staying open for 52 weeks is something a lot of people don't use strategically. Good point to raise.
0 coins
Abby Marshall
What nobody tells you upfront about filing for the first time - there's a one-week waiting period in New York where you file a claim but don't get paid for that first week. It's called the waiting week. So whenever she files, week one of claiming is essentially a wash. After that she certifies weekly and gets paid for each week she meets the eligibility requirements. Just want her to know so she doesn't panic when the first week shows no payment.
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
AuthorWaiting week policy - that's annoying but good to know in advance. So she should file as soon as possible to get the waiting week out of the way?
0 coins
Abby Marshall
Filing sooner is always better in unemployment - you can't collect for weeks before you filed, and your benefit year starts from your filing date. Every week you wait to file is a week you can't get back.
0 coins
Jenna Sloan
I waited three weeks to file because I thought my employer might give my hours back. Lost those three weeks forever. File immediately people.
0 coins
Heather Tyson
Employer might push back on approving a minor's claim just because they can - some employers contest UI claims routinely regardless of the reason for separation. If her hours were cut rather than her being fired, the employer might argue she voluntarily reduced her hours or was still employed. Make sure she can document that the reduction came from the employer side (manager communications, schedule texts, anything showing the employer cut her, not that she asked for fewer hours).
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
AuthorDocumentation from the employer side - she actually has text messages from her manager about the schedule change. Should she gather those now before filing?
0 coins
Heather Tyson
Gathering that documentation right now is the right move - before filing so you have everything ready if adjudication opens. Screenshots of texts with dates showing the employer's decision are exactly the kind of evidence that resolves contested claims quickly.
0 coins
Vanessa Figueroa
Employer contests are really common for part-time workers. Having documentation ready upfront means you're not scrambling to find proof weeks into adjudication.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
Want to add one thing about the weekly certification process specifically for a 17-year-old who's still in school: the certification question asks whether you were able and available for work during the week, and you have to answer yes to get paid. Technically being in school limits availability, but NYSDOL's interpretation for someone with an established part-time work history is generally that availability for part-time work is sufficient. The key is that she has to genuinely be willing to take another part-time job if one is offered - she can't be collecting while refusing every job offer because school is in the way.
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
AuthorRefusing job offers being a disqualifier - what counts as a 'suitable' job she'd have to accept? Can she turn down a full-time shift because of school?
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
Suitable work for her purposes would be work similar to what she was doing - part-time, around school hours. She could reasonably decline a full-time overnight position, for example, as it doesn't match her prior work pattern. But she can't reject every offer.
0 coins
Drew Hathaway
This is actually one of the more nuanced areas of UI law and it really does come down to individual adjudicator judgment in marginal cases. Getting it documented from an agent that her availability standard is part-time would help protect her if it's ever questioned.
0 coins
Jenna Sloan
im reading all this and my head is spinning. is there like a simple checklist somewhere on the nysdol website for first time filers? because the main website is so confusing i never know what page im supposed to be on
0 coins
Sasha Reese
labor.ny.gov/unemploymentinsurance has the main portal and there's a 'how to file' guide linked from the main unemployment page. It's not a checklist exactly but it walks through the steps. For a first-time filer the online guide is decent - the gaps are in the edge cases like this thread is discussing.
0 coins
Jenna Sloan
Okay the portal I can find. It's the specific questions about my situation that the website never answers. I always end up back at square one trying to get a person on the phone.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
For situations where the website gives you nothing, Claimyr got me to an agent to ask exactly the questions the website doesn't cover. Much better than trying to decode the FAQ pages.
0 coins
Muhammad Hobbs
Adjudication is what I'd prepare for mentally - even straightforward claims sometimes go into adjudication where NYSDOL reviews the claim before paying anything. This can take 2-6 weeks sometimes. During adjudication she should still be filing her weekly certifications every week without skipping, because if she's found eligible, back payments for those weeks will process automatically. Missing a week means missing that payment permanently.
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
AuthorFiling weekly certifications even during adjudication - does she log in every week and certify even though she can't see any payment coming?
0 coins
Muhammad Hobbs
Yes, every single week without exception. The UI account will show certifications as pending during adjudication and then release them all at once when the claim is approved. Missing even one week creates a gap you can't fill later.
0 coins
Abby Marshall
Learned this the hard way - missed two weeks during my adjudication thinking I didn't need to certify until it was resolved. Those two weeks were just gone when my claim was approved.
0 coins
Louisa Ramirez
Parent here with a slightly different angle: I went through helping my son file at 18 last year and even at 18 there was confusion about whether his school enrollment affected his claim. NYSDOL ended up asking him several clarifying questions during adjudication about his school schedule and his availability. It didn't disqualify him but it added almost three weeks to the process. At 17 I'd just expect the adjudication to take longer than average and not read anything into the delay.
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
AuthorThree weeks of extra adjudication time just for school schedule questions - should she be proactive about disclosing her school schedule when she files, or wait to be asked?
0 coins
Louisa Ramirez
Proactive disclosure in the additional information section of the application actually worked in my son's favor - the adjudicator's notes showed they appreciated the upfront explanation of his availability. I'd recommend doing the same.
0 coins
Laila Prince
Proactive disclosure is almost always better in unemployment. Trying to hide or understate complications usually creates more problems than addressing them upfront.
0 coins
Christian Burns
Wrapping up what I've seen in this thread as someone who's been through it: file the claim, don't self-disqualify based on age, document the employer's decision to cut hours, certify weekly without skipping, and get an agent on the phone to answer the specific questions about her situation that the website doesn't cover. That's really the whole playbook for a situation like this.
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
AuthorThank you for summarizing all of that. Getting an agent on the phone is clearly the step I need to take first. Going to try tomorrow morning and use Claimyr if I can't get through on my own.
0 coins
Paloma Clark
Your plan is solid. Early call attempt first, and if the lines are jammed, Claimyr is a reasonable tool to have in your back pocket for getting through. Good luck to your daughter - her situation sounds like a genuinely valid UI claim.
0 coins
Isabel Vega
hope she gets it!! the system is confusing for adults let alone a teenager trying to figure it out for the first time
0 coins