Back to New York Unemployment

Amara Okafor

Can I receive unemployment if I was fired? NYSDOL situation

So I got let go from my job at a distribution warehouse last month and I'm trying to figure out where I stand with unemployment. My supervisor called me into the office on a Thursday morning and said they were 'ending my employment' due to what they called 'repeated performance issues' - but honestly I never received any written warnings and there was nothing documented that I ever signed off on. I filed my UI claim with NYSDOL about a week after getting fired and now my account just shows 'adjudication in progress' with zero other details. I keep trying to call NYSDOL to find out what's happening but I can't get a human being on the line no matter what time I try. Meanwhile my bills are stacking up and I have no idea if I'm even going to get approved. Can anyone who's been fired tell me what actually happens with these claims? Does NYSDOL automatically deny you if your employer says you were fired for cause?

Two weeks into my own adjudication right now so I feel this deeply. Mine's also a termination situation. What I can tell you from reading everything I could find is that being fired doesn't automatically mean you're disqualified - NYSDOL looks at WHY you were fired. If they determine it was 'misconduct' under their definition, that's when you get denied. But a lot of firings don't actually meet that legal threshold.

0 coins

What counts as misconduct in their eyes though? Like is 'performance issues' automatically going to be considered that?

0 coins

Performance problems alone usually aren't misconduct. Misconduct under unemployment law is more like intentional rule violations, not just being bad at your job. That said your employer can still contest the claim and slow things way down.

0 coins

Exactly what that person said. My situation was similar - no written warnings, nothing signed - and I was told that actually helps your case since there's no documentation trail showing you were repeatedly warned.

0 coins

My adjudication dragged on for almost six weeks before I heard anything and I was losing my mind trying to get through on the phone. Every time I called the NYSDOL line I'd either get a busy signal or sit on hold for two hours and get disconnected. A friend told me about Claimyr - claimyr.com - and there's a video showing what it does here: https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. Basically it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up actually talking to a live agent instead of burning your whole afternoon. I ended up speaking with an agent who explained exactly where my claim was in the process and what the adjudicator was still waiting on. For a termination case that's huge because you need to know if they're waiting on your side or the employer's side.

0 coins

Are there situations where calling actually changes anything or is it just informational?

0 coins

In my case it was more than just informational - the agent told me my employer had submitted a response with some details I could counter. I didn't know I could send in additional documentation until that call. So yeah, it can be genuinely useful especially for fired cases where the employer is probably contesting.

0 coins

Six weeks sounds brutal. My adjudication wrapped up in about three weeks but mine wasn't a termination so probably apples and oranges.

0 coins

I had a termination claim adjudication take nearly two months last year. The wait is different for every single case and it's maddening.

0 coins

I used to think getting fired meant automatic disqualification and I went through a whole mess believing that until someone corrected me. The actual rule is about whether you were fired for 'misconduct connected with your employment' - and NYSDOL's definition of misconduct is narrower than most people assume. Things like not meeting a quota, struggling with job duties, even attendance issues that weren't willful can all potentially still qualify you. What they're really looking for is whether you deliberately disregarded your employer's interests.

0 coins

My employer never gave me anything in writing, not one warning ever. Does that factor into the adjudicator's decision?

0 coins

Documentation matters a lot actually. If your employer claims they warned you repeatedly but can't show any written record of that, their account is a lot harder to substantiate. Keep any emails, texts, or anything from your time there that shows what actually went on.

0 coins

This matches what an appeals officer told my neighbor - the burden is on the employer to prove misconduct, not on you to prove you weren't guilty of it. Really important distinction.

0 coins

My first week of filing after getting terminated I was absolutely convinced I'd be denied and I didn't even tell my family I filed because I thought it was pointless. Turned out I was approved after adjudication. The distribution and warehouse industry fires people for 'performance' all the time and a lot of those don't meet the misconduct bar.

0 coins

How long did your adjudication take from the time you filed?

0 coins

About four and a half weeks from filing to the determination letter showing up in my account. The wait was miserable but the outcome was fine.

0 coins

My warehouse termination took five weeks of adjudication before approval. It really does vary but don't give up on it.

0 coins

THREE HOURS on hold yesterday, got to what sounded like someone picking up and then dead silence followed by a disconnect. I cannot explain how infuriating this is. I'm also dealing with a termination adjudication and I genuinely have no idea if my employer responded or not, if the adjudicator needs something from me, nothing. The NYSDOL phone system is an absolute disaster.

0 coins

What number were you dialing when that happened? The main claims line or the adjudication specific one?

0 coins

The main 888 number. Is there a separate adjudication line I should be using??

0 coins

There's supposed to be a way to reach the adjudication unit more directly but honestly I've never gotten through that way either. I ended up using Claimyr to finally get an agent - it handles the hold time for you and you end up with an actual person at NYSDOL on the line. For a termination claim where you need real answers about what your employer submitted, talking to a live agent is the only way to actually find out what's happening.

0 coins

That is genuinely the most useful thing I've seen in this thread. Going to look into it today.

0 coins

Eight days after my determination letter came in I want to give some hope to people in adjudication - mine was a termination and I got approved. What seemed to matter most was the written statement I submitted during adjudication explaining my side. Did you get a letter or message asking you to give your account of what happened?

0 coins

What did that statement request look like when it came in - was it through the Unemployment Services online account or by mail?

0 coins

Mine came as a message in my Unemployment Services account. It asked specific questions about the circumstances of my separation and gave me a deadline to respond. I'd check there constantly if I were you.

0 coins

I got the same kind of questionnaire in my account. The questions are pretty direct - date of termination, reason employer gave, whether you received prior warnings, that kind of thing. Answer everything as specifically as you can.

0 coins

My employer told NYSDOL I was fired for insubordination when I was terminated and I still got approved after adjudication because I was able to show the incident they called insubordination was actually me raising a safety concern. The point being - whatever reason your employer gives, you have the right to tell your side completely. NYSDOL adjudicators are supposed to look at both accounts.

0 coins

How do you actually submit your version if nobody has contacted you yet?

0 coins

You may need to wait for NYSDOL to send you the fact-finding questionnaire. But you can also try reaching someone by phone to ask if additional information is needed. Some people submit a voluntary written statement through their account messages even before being asked - it doesn't hurt.

0 coins

My adjudicator actually told me when I finally reached her that proactive documentation is never turned away. She said it goes into the file either way.

0 coins

My claim was initially denied after a termination adjudication and I want people to know that isn't the end. I appealed and won at the Board of Review hearing. The whole process took about four extra months but I got all my back benefits eventually. So even a denial isn't necessarily final.

0 coins

Were you representing yourself at that appeal hearing or did you have someone helping you?

0 coins

Completely on my own. The hearing was over the phone with an Administrative Law Judge and it was much less intimidating than I expected. I just explained what happened at my job and answered questions honestly.

0 coins

Appeals are genuinely worth pursuing if you believe the decision was wrong. The reversal rate at hearings isn't terrible, especially for cases where there's no documented prior discipline.

0 coins

My appeal took about three months but I also ended up winning. Don't let the timeline discourage you from filing one if you need to.

0 coins

The thing people don't realize going into these termination adjudications - your employer is also being contacted and given a chance to explain why they fired you. You're not the only one being asked questions. So if your employer says 'performance issues' but has no documentation to back that up, their case to NYSDOL is pretty weak.

0 coins

Do you know if employers typically bother responding to NYSDOL or do a lot of them just ignore it?

0 coins

Bigger companies almost always respond because they have HR departments set up for exactly this. Smaller employers are more variable. Either way NYSDOL gives them a deadline and if they miss it, the adjudicator typically moves forward with what they have.

0 coins

The employer non-response situation actually helped me. My ex-employer apparently didn't reply in time and my claim moved forward based solely on my statement.

0 coins

My situation going into week three of adjudication after being terminated - I keep checking my Unemployment Services account every morning hoping to see a determination. The waiting is genuinely the worst part. I know nothing has changed from yesterday but I still look.

0 coins

What week did they fire you in? I mean what time of year, because I've heard adjudications move faster or slower based on caseload at different times.

0 coins

Got fired in February, filed that same week. Adjudication started around mid-February. I'm told winter into spring is a heavier period for NYSDOL but who knows.

0 coins

Mine started in late January so we might be in similar queues. This is reassuring that someone else is also just waiting it out.

0 coins

My HR department fired me and cited a 'code of conduct violation' and I honestly wasn't sure if that phrasing alone would doom my claim. It didn't. The adjudicator found that the specific behavior they cited didn't rise to the level of intentional misconduct. I think people get scared by official-sounding termination language but the actual legal standard is what matters.

0 coins

How specific did the adjudicator's determination letter get about why they made the decision they did?

0 coins

Pretty specific actually. Mine listed the reason the employer gave, my response, and then explained why under New York unemployment law the conduct described wasn't disqualifying misconduct. It was actually useful to read even though I was just relieved to be approved.

0 coins

The determination letters can be surprisingly detailed. Mine referenced specific sections of unemployment law which I then looked up to fully understand what the adjudicator was applying.

0 coins

My first real breakthrough in my termination claim came after I actually got to talk to someone at NYSDOL instead of just staring at my online account. I used Claimyr and ended up on the phone with a live agent who told me my employer had submitted a statement but that I still had a window to add documentation to my file. That window would have closed without me knowing about it if I hadn't made that call.

0 coins

How long into your adjudication was that when you found out there was still a window to submit stuff?

0 coins

About week two and a half. The adjudicator hadn't issued a determination yet so I still had time. I sent in a detailed timeline of events along with some emails I'd saved. I genuinely believe that changed the outcome.

0 coins

This is exactly the kind of thing I'm worried about missing while I'm stuck being unable to get through on the phone. The fact that there are undisclosed deadlines that you can only find out about by talking to someone is insane.

0 coins

Your point about the window is so important. My adjudication also had a submission deadline that I only found out about through a message in my account - but not everyone notices those messages right away.

0 coins

My determination came through after six weeks and reading it I realized the adjudicator had weighed the fact that I had no prior discipline on file against me - wait no, I mean IN MY FAVOR. The employer claimed this was 'ongoing performance problems' but couldn't show any paperwork. Adjudicator sided with me.

0 coins

Your situation sounds really close to mine - no written warnings, employer claiming ongoing issues. That's encouraging to hear.

0 coins

Fight it out through the process. Gather anything you have from your time there - even mundane work emails can establish context. And respond thoroughly to any questionnaire they send you.

0 coins

The absence of documentation hurts employers in these cases more than a lot of people know. It's hard to claim 'repeated performance issues' with nothing on paper to back it up.

0 coins

My termination adjudication was complicated by the fact that my manager and I had a genuinely contentious relationship and I was worried that personal history would color how NYSDOL saw the firing. What I found out is that adjudicators are mostly looking at the documented facts and the legal standard, not personal dynamics that aren't in the record.

0 coins

Were you worried about how much of that history to include in your statement to NYSDOL?

0 coins

Honestly yes. I ended up sticking to factual specifics rather than characterizing our relationship. I described specific incidents without editorializing too much. I think that helped me come across as credible.

0 coins

Sticking to verifiable specifics is good advice for any fact-finding questionnaire. Adjudicators deal with a lot of he-said-she-said and clear factual accounts stand out.

0 coins

My whole view on this changed once I understood that NYSDOL adjudication for termination cases is basically a mini-investigation. They contact you, they contact your former employer, they compare the accounts. If your employer is claiming misconduct, they have to actually establish what that misconduct was. And Claimyr ended up being how I finally managed to have a real conversation with someone at NYSDOL about where my mini-investigation stood - I'd been trying for weeks to reach someone and finally ended up talking to an agent who gave me specifics I couldn't get from my online account alone.

0 coins

When you talked to that agent, were they able to tell you which direction the adjudicator was leaning?

0 coins

They didn't say which way it was going to go but they confirmed my employer had submitted something and told me I could respond to it. That response opportunity is what I'd been missing without knowing it. The agent walked me through how to submit additional documentation through my Unemployment Services account.

0 coins

This is actually so helpful because I didn't know responding to the employer's submission was something you could do. I thought it was just NYSDOL deciding based on two separate statements.

0 coins

The fact-finding process is more interactive than the online account makes it seem. The portal really doesn't surface a lot of this procedurally.

0 coins

Five days after getting my determination letter and I'm still a little in shock that I was approved after a termination. My employer submitted a detailed statement claiming I violated policy and I was convinced that would be enough to sink my claim. It wasn't, because I was able to demonstrate it was a first-time incident with no prior warnings and no written policy that had been clearly communicated to employees.

0 coins

How did you demonstrate the policy hadn't been clearly communicated - what did you submit for that?

0 coins

I requested my own personnel file from HR before they had a chance to redact anything and there was literally no signed acknowledgment of the policy they claimed I violated. That was the key piece.

0 coins

Requesting your personnel file is a great move that more people should know about. You're entitled to it in New York and it often reveals what documentation actually exists versus what employers claim exists.

0 coins

My mom lost her job last year for supposedly violating a workplace policy and went through three months of this whole process before finally being approved at the appeal level. What she told me after going through all of it was that the people who gave up after a denial were the ones who lost - the process only works for you if you stay in it.

0 coins

Three months is a really long road. Did she have to keep filing weekly claims through that whole period even though she hadn't been approved yet?

0 coins

She kept filing every single week and those benefits were backdated once she was approved. That is crucial - you have to keep certifying every week regardless of adjudication status or you lose those weeks permanently.

0 coins

This cannot be stressed enough. Keep filing weekly claims no matter what. Missing a week during adjudication is not recoverable.

0 coins

My adjudicator even confirmed this - no exceptions, no workarounds for missed weeks during adjudication. File every Sunday no matter what.

0 coins

My first instinct when I got fired was to assume I had no case and not even bother filing. A friend talked me into it and I was approved with no issue. If I'd trusted my instinct I would have just walked away from money I was owed. The system isn't perfect but for termination cases without true misconduct, it often does work.

0 coins

How fast did your determination come through compared to other people sharing here?

0 coins

Mine was actually pretty fast, only about seventeen days from filing to determination. I think caseload timing had a lot to do with it.

0 coins

Seventeen days is wild compared to some of these six and eight week situations. The variance in wait times is confusing.

0 coins

Coming at this from where I started in total panic, reading through everything here has genuinely helped me understand what I'm actually dealing with. I checked my Unemployment Services account again this morning and there's now a questionnaire I need to fill out about my separation - which I completely would have missed if people here hadn't told me to check for it. Going to respond to it today with as much specific detail as I can and keep filing my weekly claims no matter what. Thank you all for this.

0 coins

Your questionnaire showing up means the adjudication is actively moving on your case. That's a good sign.

0 coins

Fill it out as completely as possible and submit it before the deadline shown on the form. Good luck - termination cases with no documented prior discipline have a solid track record.

0 coins

You're doing everything right. Document everything, respond thoroughly, keep certifying. That's the whole playbook.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure