Back to New York Unemployment

GalacticGladiator

Can I claim unemployment if I get fired? NYSDOL rules explained

So I got let go from my warehouse job last Friday and I'm trying to figure out where I stand. My manager said it was because of 'performance issues' but honestly the whole situation felt really off — I'd never received a formal write-up, no documented warnings, nothing in writing. HR just called me into the office and that was it. I've been working there for almost two years, full-time, so I should have enough work history. My question is can I claim unemployment if I get fired or does getting fired automatically disqualify you? I always thought only layoffs counted but a coworker told me that's not necessarily true in New York. I filed online through Unemployment Services already but I'm not expecting to just sail through — I figure they'll probably flag it for adjudication since the separation reason is termination. Anyone been through something like this? Do I stand a chance?

Two years of full-time work is solid — you're definitely in the right ballpark for base period wages. The thing people don't realize is that NYSDOL doesn't automatically deny fired workers. The key question they look at is whether you were terminated for 'misconduct' as defined under New York unemployment law. Regular performance issues, not meeting quotas, stuff like that — those usually don't rise to the level of disqualifying misconduct. Misconduct in the NYSDOL sense is more like intentional rule-breaking, theft, insubordination, that kind of thing. No write-ups or formal warnings in your file actually works in your favor here.

0 coins

My supervisor's whole reason was just 'not meeting expectations' — there was never anything specific put in writing. Does NYSDOL ask my former employer to submit documentation?

0 coins

Your employer gets a Notice of Potential Charges mailed to them and they have to respond. They can contest it, but if all they have is vague 'performance' language with nothing documented, that's hard for them to prove rises to misconduct. NYSDOL will look at both sides.

0 coins

yeah same thing happened to my buddy, fired for 'attitude' with zero writeups and he got approved no problem

0 coins

Went through almost the exact same thing nine months ago — terminated from a retail management job, no documentation, just told it 'wasn't working out.' I was terrified I'd be denied because I was fired, not laid off. Filed the claim, it went into adjudication for about three weeks, then I got a letter saying approved. So yes, fired people absolutely can get benefits in New York. Don't let anyone tell you getting fired is an automatic disqualifier.

0 coins

Three weeks in adjudication — did you have to do anything during that time or just wait?

0 coins

My weekly certifications kept going the whole time and I kept logging my job searches. When the approval came through, the payments for those weeks hit all at once. Don't stop certifying.

0 coins

this is the part people mess up, they stop filing their weekly claims while waiting and then lose those weeks entirely

0 coins

Adjudication when you're fired can drag on and sometimes you need to actually talk to someone at NYSDOL to find out what's happening with your case. I spent two weeks hitting redial with nothing. Eventually used Claimyr — the way it works is it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you, so you end up speaking directly with a live agent — claimyr.com, there's a demo video at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. Got actual answers about where my adjudication stood and what documentation I needed to submit. Way better than the hold music loop.

0 coins

my hold times have been ridiculous, like 2+ hours and then the line just drops. might actually look into this

0 coins

My claim just moved to adjudication status this morning so I'm already bracing for the wait. I'll keep this in mind if things stall.

0 coins

Tried phoning NYSDOL four times over two days, never got past the automated system. Claimyr actually got me to a real person and I finally found out my claim had a question attached that I didn't even know about.

0 coins

30 days is the window people miss — if NYSDOL sends you a determination letter and you disagree with it, you've got 30 days from the mailing date to file an appeal. Miss that and you're basically starting over. Keep checking your Unemployment Services account daily and open every piece of mail the day it arrives. For a termination case especially, the first determination isn't always the final word.

0 coins

My account shows 'pending' still. When a determination letter comes, does it show up in the online account or only by mail?

0 coins

Both, usually — the account gets updated and a letter goes out. But the official appeal deadline runs from the mailing date on the letter, not when you see it online, so check your mailbox too.

0 coins

found this out the hard way, the online status updated two days after the letter was supposedly mailed and i almost missed counting my 30 days right

0 coins

WAIT does this mean if ur employer says u were fired for being late a bunch does that count as misconduct?? im freaking out about my own situation now reading this. i was late maybe like 5 times over 8 months and they let me go last week

0 coins

Five late arrivals over 8 months is probably not going to meet the misconduct bar unless you had written warnings and kept repeating it after being warned. NYSDOL looks at whether the behavior was willful and repeated after formal notice. File and let them adjudicate it.

0 coins

ok i didnt have ANY written warnings, like nothing at all in my file. should i still apply??

0 coins

yes always apply regardless, worst they can do is deny you and then you can appeal. never assume you dont qualify

0 coins

The job search requirement kicks in from day one — a lot of people don't realize that while their claim is in adjudication, the job search requirements are still active. In New York you need to record at least three job search activities per week. If you get approved and NYSDOL audits your log, missing weeks can cause problems. Use your Unemployment Services account to log each one.

0 coins

Already started logging mine. I wasn't sure if I needed to while adjudication was pending but I figured better safe than sorry.

0 coins

Smart move. My approval letter specifically referenced that my job search records were on file. Keep every confirmation email from applications too.

0 coins

wait do online applications count?? i thought u had to like go in person somewhere

0 coins

Honestly the NYSDOL phone situation is a nightmare and i feel for anyone trying to get answers about a termination case. called 11 times in one week trying to find out if my employer had responded to my adjudication. ELEVEN. got through twice and both times got disconnected before I even finished explaining my situation. the system is broken

0 coins

My experience with Claimyr actually got me talking to a real agent after all those failed attempts. Used it when my own adjudication stalled and finally got a straight answer about what documents NYSDOL needed from me.

0 coins

Does it actually work during the busy morning hours? thats when I've had the worst luck

0 coins

My situation — I tried on a Tuesday morning — and yeah it still worked, just took a bit. Got through to someone eventually and they were actually helpful once I was on the line.

0 coins

Former HR person here, now on the other side of the table unfortunately. When a company terminates someone for 'performance' without documentation, they're in a weak position to contest unemployment. NYSDOL adjudicators know the difference between documented disciplinary processes and vague post-hoc justifications. If your employer can't show a progressive discipline trail — written warnings, performance improvement plans, that kind of thing — their contest is probably going to fail.

0 coins

That's genuinely reassuring to hear from someone who's been on the HR side. My file is completely clean as far as I know.

0 coins

Your clean file is actually evidence in your favor in adjudication. NYSDOL can and does request employment records. No documentation of discipline makes 'misconduct' nearly impossible to prove.

0 coins

wish someone had told me this before i just accepted my denial without appealing last year. i had no writeups either

0 coins

Can someone explain what adjudication actually means?? i see it everywhere in this thread. is it the same as being denied? my claim says 'pending adjudication' and i'm panicking

0 coins

Pending adjudication just means NYSDOL is reviewing your claim — it hasn't been decided yet, not denied. When a claim has a question attached (like a termination reason that needs investigation), they put it in adjudication before making a determination. It's normal, especially for fired claimants.

0 coins

oh thank god. i thought adjudication meant i failed or something. so i just keep filing weekly certifications and wait?

0 coins

Exactly that — keep certifying every week no matter what your status shows. Those weeks get paid out once a decision is made.

0 coins

just want to say i got fired for supposedly 'stealing time' (i was 10 min late from lunch twice) and still got unemployment approved after appeal. don't give up even if the first answer is no

0 coins

Stealing time is a serious-sounding charge — how did you handle the appeal?

0 coins

wrote out the full timeline, showed my actual punch records which contradicted what my manager claimed, and submitted it all with my appeal form. the hearing officer sided with me

0 coins

punch records and time logs are really underrated as appeal evidence, good call bringing those

0 coins

my situation is a little different — i was fired but then my employer told NYSDOL it was a 'mutual agreement to part ways.' that is NOT what happened lol. does it matter what label they put on it if the facts are that i was let go involuntarily?

0 coins

The label matters less than the actual facts of the separation. NYSDOL adjudicators are trained to cut through framing. If you were told your employment was ending and you didn't truly have a choice in the matter, that's a discharge regardless of what the employer calls it. Explain the actual sequence of events.

0 coins

ok so i should just describe exactly what happened in the adjudication interview if they contact me?

0 coins

Yes — be specific, factual, and chronological. 'I was called into the HR office on [date], told my position was being eliminated/that I was being let go, and given a final paycheck.' The more specific you are, the harder it is to spin.

0 coins

Claimyr is worth mentioning for anyone stuck in a termination adjudication who needs to know what their employer actually submitted. That was my situation and I'd been trying to reach NYSDOL for over a week. Used Claimyr and ended up on the phone with an actual NYSDOL agent who read me exactly what my former employer had filed. Turned out they'd called it a 'voluntary resignation' which was completely false and I was able to dispute it right then.

0 coins

My employer might try to pull something similar given how the conversation ended. Knowing what they submitted seems really important.

0 coins

Seriously, it changed everything for my case. The agent was able to flag my dispute on the spot so it was noted before the adjudicator made a final call.

0 coins

wait how would you even know what ur employer said if u cant get anyone on the phone. this is actually useful info

0 coins

Base period wages are the other piece of this puzzle — even if NYSDOL finds you eligible based on the separation, you still need to have earned enough in your base period to qualify for a benefit amount. For most claimants the base period is the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters. With two years of full-time work you should be fine, but it's worth checking your wage record on file through your Unemployment Services account.

0 coins

Checked mine and it looks like my wages are on there from both years. Does NYSDOL use the highest quarter to calculate the weekly benefit amount?

0 coins

New York uses a formula based on your highest quarter wages — roughly your highest quarter divided by 26, with a maximum benefit amount that changes each year. Your weekly benefit shows up in your account once they calculate it.

0 coins

is there a minimum amount u have to have earned to even qualify?? im worried my part time hours might not be enough

0 coins

Also keep in mind — if NYSDOL denies your claim and you appeal, you have a right to a hearing before an Administrative Law Judge. That's a formal but claimant-friendly process. You can present your own evidence, bring documentation, and the ALJ is supposed to be neutral. A lot of people win at that level who lost the initial determination.

0 coins

my friend got denied initially and won his ALJ hearing, said the judge actually read all his documents carefully unlike the first reviewer

0 coins

Good to know there's a formal appeal path. At what point in the process does the ALJ hearing happen?

0 coins

After your first determination comes out, if you appeal within 30 days, it goes to an ALJ hearing. They schedule it and you get a notice — hearings can be done by phone which is a lot easier than going in person.

0 coins

The employer's side of this matters a lot and people underestimate it. Former employers in New York pay more into the unemployment insurance system when their ex-employees collect benefits — something called experience rating. Some employers fight claims aggressively just to protect their rate. If yours is a bigger company they might have a third-party company that handles UI claims just to contest them. Know that going in.

0 coins

The experience rating piece is exactly right. I dealt with this — a large regional employer I'd worked for had an outside vendor whose only job was contesting UI claims. They submitted a detailed response with HR notes that I'd never even seen. I had to respond carefully.

0 coins

Mine is a mid-size company, maybe 200 employees. Should I assume they'll contest?

0 coins

Worth assuming yes for any company that size. Prepare your own documentation now — texts, emails, anything that shows the circumstances of your termination from your perspective — before memories fade.

0 coins

anyone else notice that the NYSDOL website's FAQ on termination vs. misconduct is like incredibly vague?? i read it three times and still wasn't sure if my situation counted. called the number, waited forever, the line went dead. tried again, same thing. this is not how a government service should work in 2025

0 coins

The phone situation is genuinely awful. Claimyr was how I finally got past it — waited on hold for me and I ended up talking to an actual agent who answered my specific question about misconduct definition in like two minutes.

0 coins

Two minutes to get an actual answer vs. hours of trying and getting cut off — yeah that's hard to argue with

0 coins

the vagueness in official materials is real. the actual decisions come down to adjudicator discretion and each case gets reviewed individually which the website doesn't really make clear

0 coins

Documentation checklist for anyone in a termination adjudication: gather your offer letter or employment contract, any performance reviews (especially positive ones), all emails from supervisors about your work, your final paycheck stub, the termination notice if they gave you one in writing, and any texts or messages about the circumstances. Even if you weren't given formal documentation of discipline, you might have informal messages that establish the actual context.

0 coins

My manager did send me an email last month saying I was doing 'great work adapting to new processes' — that seems like it could be relevant given they're claiming performance issues?

0 coins

That email is relevant — save it in multiple places. A supervisor praising your work shortly before termination undermines a 'performance misconduct' argument considerably.

0 coins

Screenshots of positive feedback are gold in these cases, seriously. Adjudicators and ALJs notice when employer claims don't line up with their own written record.

0 coins

ok update on my situation from earlier in this thread — i filed my claim yesterday and it immediately went to 'pending adjudication.' is that normal for fired claimants or does it mean something is already wrong??

0 coins

Pending adjudication on a termination claim is completely standard — almost every fired claimant gets flagged for review because NYSDOL has to verify the separation reason. It doesn't signal anything negative about your chances.

0 coins

ok phew. how long does adjudication usually take? trying to figure out if i can make rent

0 coins

Ranges a lot — could be two weeks, could be six or more depending on how backed up they are and whether your employer responds quickly. Keep filing your weekly certifications every single week so you don't lose those benefit weeks.

0 coins

got my determination letter today — APPROVED. filed as a fired claimant, adjudication took 19 days, and they found that my employer did not establish misconduct under NYSDOL guidelines. for anyone reading this scared like i was: it is possible to get approved when you're fired

0 coins

Genuinely needed to see this today. Congrats and thanks for coming back to update.

0 coins

My first weekly payment hits in a few days based on the letter. All those certifications I filed during adjudication are queued up. Huge relief.

0 coins

This is the update this thread needed. 19 days adjudication, clean determination. Gives me hope for mine.

0 coins

Final thing worth knowing for anyone reading later — 'at-will employment' and unemployment eligibility are separate legal concepts. New York is an at-will state, meaning your employer can fire you for almost any reason or no reason. But that has nothing to do with whether you can collect unemployment. NYSDOL eligibility turns on whether the termination involved disqualifying misconduct, not on whether the firing was legally justified. Your employer had every legal right to let you go AND you can still qualify for benefits.

0 coins

This is exactly the confusion I had when I first filed. I kept thinking 'they can fire me for anything so I probably can't claim' — didn't realize those are two completely separate questions.

0 coins

More people need to know this honestly. The at-will thing throws so many people off and they don't even bother filing.

0 coins

yeah my coworker literally told me not to bother applying because NY is at will. glad i looked it up myself

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure