Back to New York Unemployment

DeShawn Washington

Are seasonal employees eligible for unemployment in NY? NYSDOL rules explained

I've been doing landscaping and grounds maintenance work for the same company for the past four years. Every year it's the same cycle - they hire me around late March or April, I work solid through October, and then I get laid off when the season ends. The company always tells me they 'expect' to bring me back next season but there's nothing in writing and no guarantee. This year I figured I'd finally look into whether I can actually collect unemployment during the winter months instead of just burning through my savings. I went on the NYSDOL site and started reading but honestly the language is pretty confusing when it comes to seasonal work. I know I definitely have enough wages in my base period from working all those months but I keep second-guessing myself about whether a seasonal employee counts as someone who was 'laid off through no fault of their own' or whether NYSDOL sees it differently when the layoff is predictable and happens every year. Anyone who's done seasonal work and gone through this - are seasonal employees eligible for unemployment between seasons? Would really appreciate hearing from people who've actually dealt with NYSDOL on this.

The layoff happens the same way every October and you're wondering if that pattern works against you - I had the exact same worry my first year trying to claim. Turned out for me that NYSDOL cares more about why you lost the work than whether the timing was predictable. If the company ended your work because the season was over, that counts as a layoff through no fault of yours. The fact that it happens on a schedule every year doesn't disqualify you. You still have to meet the base period wage requirements and be available for work during the weeks you're certifying, but seasonal employees absolutely can and do collect UI between seasons here in New York.

0 coins

That's genuinely reassuring to hear. I think I was confusing predictability with somehow being my fault, which doesn't even make sense when I think about it. Did you have any issues with NYSDOL questioning the nature of your layoff when you filed?

0 coins

Same experience here, did tree trimming work for years and filed every winter without problems. The employer might get a notice about the claim but that doesn't mean they can easily contest it just because the season ended the same way it always does.

0 coins

Wait so the employer can contest it even for seasonal layoffs?? I thought if you got laid off that was automatically fine

0 coins

Reaching NYSDOL by phone to ask about your specific situation was the part that nearly broke me when I first filed seasonal. I kept getting dropped after 40 minutes on hold, over and over. A friend told me to try Claimyr - what it does is wait on hold with NYSDOL for you, so you end up actually on the phone with a live agent instead of sitting there redailing for hours. The site is claimyr.com and there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE - it genuinely saved me a full day of frustration. The agent I finally spoke with clarified everything about my seasonal claim status in like ten minutes.

0 coins

Hours of redialing is exactly what I've been dreading. I'll check out that video, thank you.

0 coins

My situation was identical - tried NYSDOL's phone line maybe a dozen times over three days and never got through. Claimyr got me to an agent the same afternoon and I had my questions about the base period sorted out pretty quickly after that.

0 coins

Is Claimyr legitimate? Like does it actually work or is it one of those things that sounds good but just wastes more time

0 coins

Went into it skeptical myself but I ended up talking to an actual NYSDOL agent within a couple hours of using it. Legit for me at least.

0 coins

Your base period wages are really the foundation here and it's worth understanding how NYSDOL calculates them before you file. The standard base period covers the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before you file. For someone working April through October every year, that usually means your earnings from those months count across the relevant quarters. You need at least $2,900 in wages in your base period and your high quarter earnings have to be at least $1,600. Most full-season landscape workers clear those thresholds easily after a few years on the job.

0 coins

My hours were pretty solid all season so wages shouldn't be the issue. Good to have the actual numbers though - I hadn't found those specific thresholds spelled out clearly on the NYSDOL site.

0 coins

Is there an alternate base period if someone doesn't meet the standard one? I work seasonal retail and my hours are all over the place

0 coins

There is - if you don't qualify under the standard base period, NYSDOL can use the last four completed calendar quarters instead. You'd have to request that evaluation when you file or during the claims process.

0 coins

i had no idea about any of this when i filed my first claim, i just submitted it and hoped for the best lol

0 coins

My employer told me point blank that seasonal workers can't collect unemployment and I almost believed him. Filed anyway on the advice of a coworker who'd been through it, and got approved without any issue. Employers sometimes say stuff like that either because they genuinely don't know or because they don't want their unemployment tax rate going up. Don't let what your employer says about eligibility stop you from filing a claim.

0 coins

Mine hasn't said anything about it but I could see that happening. Good to know the employer's opinion isn't the final word here.

0 coins

The UI tax rate angle is real - employers do pay more when former employees claim, so some of them discourage it. Doesn't change your legal right to file at all.

0 coins

My old boss literally told me I was ineligible and I didn't file and later found out I probably would have gotten it. Lost out on months of benefits because of bad info from him. So annoying.

0 coins

That's unfortunately common and it's infuriating. The rule is straightforward: NYSDOL decides eligibility, not your employer.

0 coins

There's one thing that tripped me up my first winter filing that nobody warned me about. When you're certifying weekly for UI benefits between seasons, NYSDOL requires you to list your job search activities - usually three contacts per week. For seasonal workers in landscaping or other trades, this can feel weird because you're planning to return to the same employer next spring, but you still have to do the job search and document it properly or your weekly payments can get held up.

0 coins

Three contacts per week - okay that's something I need to get organized about before I file. Is there a specific format NYSDOL wants for recording those?

0 coins

They want employer name, contact date, how you applied or made contact, and position applied for. You enter it online through your Unemployment Services account when you certify each week. Keep your own records too in case anything gets questioned later.

0 coins

The job search part caught me off guard too my first year. I ended up talking to a NYSDOL agent through Claimyr after my payment got flagged, and the agent explained exactly what counts as a valid contact. Turns out applying on Indeed, reaching out to temp agencies, and contacting employers directly all qualify - you just have to log each one properly when you certify.

0 coins

wait does it have to be three DIFFERENT employers or can you apply to the same one multiple times in a week

0 coins

Applying to the same company multiple times in one week to fill your three contacts is not something NYSDOL considers valid - each contact needs to be a different employer. That came straight from an agent I spoke with. The good news is in a week you don't do any contacts because of a holiday, NYSDOL usually adjusts the requirement down proportionally.

0 coins

The holiday adjustment is good to know. My first time filing I was panicking over Christmas week trying to figure out if I'd have enough contacts.

0 coins

ok that makes sense, three different employers per week got it. what about if you're applying for jobs that are kind of seasonal themselves, like do those count

0 coins

They count as long as you're genuinely able and willing to accept that work if offered. NYSDOL's requirement is just that you're making real efforts to find employment, not that you're applying to permanent year-round jobs specifically.

0 coins

Something my adjudication notice never explained was that there's a difference between being on standby status and filing as a standard seasonal claimant. If your employer formally puts you on standby with NYSDOL - meaning they certify they expect to recall you within 45 days - you can collect without having to do the weekly job search. But the employer has to initiate the standby designation, you can't just request it yourself. For most seasonal workers the employer never does this so you end up in regular filing with job search requirements.

0 coins

My employer has never mentioned anything like a formal standby designation to me. So it sounds like I'll be doing the standard job search requirement route. Is standby something I should ask the company about?

0 coins

You could ask, but honestly most small landscaping companies don't even know standby status exists as an option. If they're open to it and genuinely expect to bring you back within 45 days, it could save you the job search hassle. If they're not familiar with it or the recall date is uncertain, just file normally and do your weekly contacts.

0 coins

Learned about standby status from a coworker at my seasonal job - the company had no idea they could file it on our behalf. Some employers actually appreciate knowing because it streamlines the process for everyone when rehiring starts.

0 coins

This is wild, I did four winters of seasonal unemployment and never heard of standby. Filed the regular way each time and it worked fine but good to know that option exists

0 coins

Filing that first claim after my season ended was the most nerve-wracking thing. I kept expecting some letter saying I was disqualified because I 'knew' the job would end. The letter that came said approved and I actually had to read it three times to believe it. The system works if you meet the requirements - wages, laid off through no fault of your own, able and available to work. Seasonal ending is a layoff. That's it.

0 coins

Reading this thread is making me feel a lot more confident about actually filing. The language on the NYSDOL site made me feel like there might be some gotcha for seasonal workers but it sounds like it's pretty clear-cut if your situation fits the criteria.

0 coins

The website language is confusing for everyone, not just seasonal workers. File the claim, answer everything honestly, and let NYSDOL make the determination. Most straightforward seasonal layoffs get through fine.

0 coins

The 'able and available' part is worth paying attention to. NYSDOL can flag your claim if you're not actually available for other work during the weeks you certify - like if you're doing side jobs off the books or traveling. Just be honest on your weekly certifications.

0 coins

What nobody really spells out is how the weekly certification actually plays out in practice. Every week you're claiming benefits, you log into your Unemployment Services account and answer a series of questions - did you work, how much did you earn, did you look for work, were you able and available. If you worked any hours in a given week, you have to report that income and NYSDOL will reduce your benefit by a calculated amount for that week. It doesn't necessarily disqualify you from getting something, but you have to report it.

0 coins

What about odd small jobs during the off-season? Like if I do a one-time snow removal job for a neighbor for $80, does that need to go on my certification?

0 coins

Yes, any earnings in a certification week need to be reported, even cash work for neighbors. NYSDOL audits exist and unreported earnings can lead to overpayment notices that you'll have to repay - sometimes with penalties. It's not worth the risk.

0 coins

ugh this is complicated. so you can still work a little bit and collect? I thought it was all or nothing

0 coins

Not all or nothing - if you earn less than your weekly benefit amount plus a small disregard, NYSDOL still pays you a reduced amount. Once your weekly earnings get high enough they stop paying for that week but it doesn't end your whole claim.

0 coins

This partial benefit calculation trips a lot of people up. Worth looking it up specifically on the NYSDOL site because the formula isn't super intuitive but it's not as harsh as people assume.

0 coins

My claim got held in adjudication for three weeks after I filed my seasonal claim because my employer contested it. I had no idea what was happening, the online portal just said pending review. I was totally in the dark until I got a questionnaire in the mail asking me to describe the circumstances of my separation. Filled it out explaining the season ended and the company had no work until spring. Approved about two weeks after I returned the form. If your claim goes into adjudication don't panic - it doesn't mean you're denied, it means they're reviewing details.

0 coins

Three weeks in limbo sounds stressful. Did NYSDOL notify you that the employer had contested, or did you only find out when the questionnaire arrived?

0 coins

Only found out when the questionnaire showed up. The portal never said anything about an employer objection specifically. I'd check your Unemployment Services account message center frequently if you file - NYSDOL posts correspondence there too, not just mailed letters.

0 coins

Adjudication gets used as a scary word but it's really just NYSDOL's process for resolving any open question about a claim. For seasonal separations where the employer doesn't contest, claims often skip adjudication entirely.

0 coins

My fourth winter claiming was the year I actually had to appeal a denial, which was a whole different experience from the normal process. Got denied because my employer submitted information saying I had quit voluntarily - which was completely wrong, the season ended and they laid me off like every other year. Used Claimyr to reach NYSDOL before the appeal deadline and got an agent who told me exactly what documentation to gather and where to submit my appeal. Ultimately won the appeal but it took about six weeks from filing to hearing.

0 coins

An employer submitting incorrect information and getting someone denied - that's genuinely concerning. Did you have anything in writing from the company that helped your case?

0 coins

My pay stubs showing the same seasonal pattern across four years were the most useful thing I had. Also my work history records from NYSDOL's own system showed wages only during the season each year, which supported my account of how the employment worked.

0 coins

Appeals for seasonal workers where the employer claims voluntary quit are more common than people realize. Keeping your own records of each season - hire dates, layoff notices if any, final pay stubs - is really worth doing.

0 coins

This is making me think I should start keeping better records for my seasonal job. I've never saved any of that stuff

0 coins

Went through three rounds of phone hold hell trying to figure out why my seasonal claim from last year was showing a different base period than I expected. Someone in another thread mentioned Claimyr and I tried it - ended up talking to an actual NYSDOL agent who walked me through how my quarters were being counted and why one of my seasons fell into a different calculation year than I thought. Turned out my benefit amount was actually slightly higher than my own estimate because of how the quarters lined up.

0 coins

The base period calculation being different from what you expect is something I ran into too. It's worth having an agent confirm how they're counting your quarters, especially if your work history spans multiple years.

0 coins

Higher than expected is a nice surprise at least. I've been trying to estimate my benefit amount using the NYSDOL calculator but I'm not fully confident I'm entering the right quarter earnings.

0 coins

The online calculator is a decent starting point but it only works right if you know exactly which quarters to include. An agent can pull your actual wage records from the state system and give you a precise number.

0 coins

Filing the actual claim online is pretty smooth once you decide to do it. The NYSDOL Unemployment Insurance application walks you through section by section and asks clear questions about your employment. The separation reason options include seasonal/temporary layoff which is exactly what you'd select for this situation. You'll need your employer's official name and address, your start and end dates, and your Social Security number. The whole application takes maybe 30 minutes if you have everything ready.

0 coins

30 minutes is manageable. I've been building it up in my head as this enormous complicated thing. Is there anything that commonly trips people up in the application itself?

0 coins

The base period wage section can be confusing because it asks about past employers across multiple quarters and people sometimes aren't sure which jobs to include. Include everything you earned wages from during the base period even if it's from a different employer than your most recent one.

0 coins

Also make sure the employer information is accurate - wrong EIN or company name can slow things down because NYSDOL has to verify employer records.

0 coins

i messed up my employer address on my initial application and had to call to get it corrected which was annoying. double check everything before you hit submit

0 coins

The timing of when you file actually matters more than people think. Your benefit year starts the Sunday of the week you file, and you can't get paid for weeks before that date even if you were already unemployed. I waited three weeks after my last day at work to file my first seasonal claim because I was nervous about whether I qualified, and those three weeks of potential benefits were just gone. File as soon as your last day of work is done.

0 coins

Filing immediately after the last day - noted. I definitely don't want to lose weeks of benefits to procrastination like you did. How quickly does NYSDOL process new claims and start paying?

0 coins

There's a one-week unpaid waiting period for everyone, so your first full week of claimed benefits doesn't pay out. After that it's usually a couple of weeks before the first payment comes through, assuming no adjudication holds. Set up direct deposit when you file - it's faster than paper checks.

0 coins

The one week waiting period is waived sometimes for disaster situations but for a standard seasonal claim it always applies. Factor that into your budget planning for the first month.

0 coins

Direct deposit is definitely the move. My first claim I did paper check by mistake and it took almost two weeks longer to arrive. Never again.

0 coins

Spent two seasons being too intimidated to file and then when I finally did I got approved for $487 a week. That's real money I just left on the table because I was scared of some bureaucratic process I didn't understand. If you've been laid off at the end of your season and you have wages in the base period, you owe it to yourself to at least file and find out. The worst that happens is NYSDOL denies it and you can appeal.

0 coins

$487 a week is nothing to leave sitting there. I think I've been in a similar headspace of assuming it probably won't work out so why bother, but this thread has pushed me to actually file.

0 coins

The fear is so common with seasonal workers because we've internalized the idea that we're somehow different from regular employees. You pay into the UI system through your wages same as anyone else. You're entitled to draw on it when you need it.

0 coins

I lost my first season's worth of benefits to this exact mindset. By my second year I filed immediately and got everything I was owed. Don't be me from year one.

0 coins

There's one scenario that can complicate things worth mentioning. If your seasonal employer offers you work in a different capacity during the off-season - like offering you warehouse work or snow removal on their property - and you turn it down without a solid reason, NYSDOL can view that as a voluntary refusal of suitable work and reduce or deny benefits for that period. This is different from your employer just saying they 'expect' to recall you in spring.

0 coins

My employer has never offered me anything off-season, it's always a clean layoff when the season ends. But good to know this distinction exists.

0 coins

Clean seasonal layoff with no offer of alternative work is the clearest path to qualifying. The complication I described tends to happen at larger operations that have multiple lines of business year-round.

0 coins

There's also a question of what counts as 'suitable' work if something is offered. An offer of work at significantly lower pay or in a completely different field isn't automatically something you have to accept to maintain UI eligibility. The guidelines around suitable work are detailed but they do give you some protection there.

0 coins

This suitable work question came up in my appeal case. The agent explained that NYSDOL looks at your prior wages, your occupation, and the offered work's terms before deciding if a refusal was justified. It's not just 'any job is a suitable job.

0 coins

Worth understanding what happens to your claim when spring comes and your employer wants to bring you back. If you're collecting UI benefits and your employer makes a bona fide offer to rehire you for the new season, you're expected to accept it - that's work you're able to do, it's your trade. If you refuse a genuine rehire offer to stay on benefits a bit longer, you'd lose your UI eligibility going forward. Most people filing seasonal claims don't have that issue because they want to go back to their seasonal work anyway.

0 coins

Makes total sense - the whole point is to bridge the gap between seasons, not to avoid working. When I go back I'd just stop certifying weekly?

0 coins

Exactly - when you start work again you stop certifying. You'd report any earnings in the last week before you go back (since most people work a partial week to start), and then you don't certify after that. If the new season ends and you get laid off again, you'd file a new claim at that point.

0 coins

The cycle of filing new claims each year is totally normal for seasonal workers. After a couple of times through the system it becomes pretty routine - file at layoff, certify weekly through the winter, go back when the season starts.

0 coins

I look at it as just part of the annual rhythm at this point. File in November, collect through March or April, go back to work. The UI system exists for exactly this kind of situation.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure