


Ask the community...
The whole unemployment system is so messed up. They make it impossible to reach anyone and then wonder why people are frustrated. At least if you do get fired for performance you have a decent shot at getting benefits approved.
I went through something similar last year - got fired for not meeting sales quotas despite really trying my best. NYS Department of Labor approved my benefits because they determined it wasn't misconduct, just a poor fit for the role. The key thing is to document everything now while you're still employed - save any emails about performance expectations, feedback from your supervisor, evidence that you're making efforts to improve, etc. This documentation can be really helpful if your employer contests your claim later. Also, even if the worst happens, remember that getting fired for performance issues is different from getting fired for breaking rules or policy violations. You've got a good chance of qualifying for benefits.
Just to add some clarity on what happens at the BYE date: 1. Your benefit rate stays exactly the same until your BYE date 2. You can collect all remaining effective days at that same rate 3. After your BYE date, you must file a new claim even if you had days remaining 4. Your new claim will have a new benefit calculation based on your base period wages 5. There will typically be a 2-3 week gap between claims while your new application processes The NY DOL should send you a notification about 2-3 weeks before your BYE date reminding you to file a new claim if you're still unemployed.
I went through this exact situation last year! My BYE was in March 2024 and I had 8 effective days left. You'll definitely get your full weekly benefit rate for all remaining days - they don't reduce it at all. Just make sure you're prepared for the processing time on your new claim. I started my new application about a week before my BYE date and it still took almost 3 weeks to get approved. The hardest part was gathering all the wage documentation from different employers during my base period. Start collecting those W-2s and pay stubs now so you're not scrambling later!
Thanks for sharing your experience! That's really helpful to know about the timing. Quick question - when you gathered your wage documentation, did you need pay stubs from ALL employers during the base period, or just the W-2s? I had a few different part-time jobs and I'm not sure I kept all those pay stubs.
My brother had this exact same issue last month and it turned out he accidentally answered one of the certification questions wrong. They never tell you which one! He had to call and straighten it out. Took forever to get through though. BTW my payment is showing up normal this week so maybe it's not affecting everyone?
Just wanted to follow up for anyone still checking this thread - I experienced the same delay last week and it resolved exactly as others described. My payment showed up Wednesday morning instead of the usual Tuesday. The key thing I learned is to check the desktop version of the NY.gov unemployment portal rather than just the mobile app, since system notifications are more visible there. Also, if this happens again in the future, don't panic immediately - give it 48 hours during system maintenance periods before calling. Thanks to everyone who shared their experiences here, it really helped calm my nerves!
Thanks for sharing this follow-up! I'm actually going through this exact situation right now - claimed Sunday and still nothing showing up. Your advice about checking the desktop version is really helpful, I've only been using the mobile app. It's reassuring to know this is a recurring issue during maintenance periods rather than something wrong with my specific claim. I'll wait until Wednesday morning before calling and check the desktop portal for any system notices I might have missed.
From my experience working in HR, I can confirm what others have said - employers really only get basic notification details. When someone files unemployment, we get a form showing the claim was filed, the employee's stated reason for leaving, and their work dates with us. We have to respond within 10 days if we want to contest it. The system doesn't show us benefit amounts, job search activities, or any ongoing claim details. It's designed to be pretty straightforward - we just confirm or dispute the basic facts about the employment separation. Filing for unemployment is a normal part of the process after layoffs, so don't worry about it affecting future opportunities with the company.
That's really helpful to hear from someone who's actually handled this from the employer side! The 10-day response window is good to know too. I was worried they might get ongoing updates about my claim status, but it sounds like it's really just that initial notification and response period. Thanks for the reassurance about it being routine after layoffs - that definitely makes me feel better about potentially reapplying there down the road.
I went through this exact situation a few months ago and was worried about the same thing! What really helped ease my mind was learning that the employer notification is handled through their payroll/HR department, not individual managers. So even if you do apply back there later, the person interviewing you probably won't have any knowledge of your unemployment claim unless they specifically went digging through HR records (which would be pretty unusual). The whole process is way more private than I initially thought. Just make sure you're honest about your reason for leaving when you file - that's the one thing they can see and respond to if it doesn't match their records.
That's such a good point about it going through HR/payroll rather than individual managers! I hadn't thought about that aspect. It makes total sense that the people doing the actual hiring wouldn't necessarily have access to or knowledge of unemployment filings unless they were specifically looking for it. Thanks for sharing your experience - it's really reassuring to hear from someone who went through the same worries and came out fine on the other side.
CosmosCaptain
I'm in literally the exact same situation! I just checked my transcript after seeing this post and I have the same 291 code with a negative amount from last month. I've been so confused about what it meant but reading everyone's experiences here is giving me hope that it's actually a refund coming. The whole unemployment tax situation has been such a mess - I paid extra taxes when I filed in early 2021 before they changed the rules. It's crazy that they're finally fixing this automatically instead of making us jump through more hoops. Definitely going to be checking my bank account daily now! Thanks for posting this, it's so helpful to hear from others going through the same thing.
0 coins
Chloe Green
•Same here! I've been stressing about this for weeks not knowing what those codes meant. It's such a relief to find this thread and see so many people confirming they actually got their money. The timing makes sense too - I filed early in 2021 before the law changed and paid taxes on all my unemployment. Been checking my account every day since I saw the 291 code show up. Fingers crossed we both see that deposit soon! 🤞
0 coins
Nia Davis
I'm going through the exact same thing right now! Just saw the 291 code with a negative amount on my transcript from a few weeks ago and had no clue what it meant until I found this thread. It's such a relief to see so many people confirming they actually received their refunds - I was worried it was some kind of mistake or that I'd have to jump through more hoops to get the money. The whole unemployment tax situation has been such a headache. I filed early in 2021 and paid taxes on all my unemployment benefits, then months later they changed the rules. At least they're fixing it automatically instead of making us amend our returns. Based on what everyone's saying here, sounds like I should expect the deposit in the next few weeks. Finally some good news after dealing with all the NY unemployment chaos! Thanks for posting this question - it's so helpful to hear from others in the same boat.
0 coins