Unemployment appeal misconduct NRS 612.385 what evidence to submit - Nevada DETR help
So I got hit with a disqualification last week and I'm scrambling to figure out how to fight it. My former employer told Nevada DETR I was fired for misconduct, which is completely false - I was let go because they said my performance didn't meet quota targets during a period when our entire team was struggling and they'd actually changed the quota metrics without telling anyone. Not exactly willful wrongdoing on my part. I've filed my appeal through the CSS portal and the hearing is scheduled for about five weeks out. The disqualification letter references the misconduct statute and I've been reading everything I can find online but I'm still confused about what I actually need to bring or submit as evidence. I've got some emails, my old performance reviews that were actually decent, and a text thread with my supervisor where she admitted the quota change happened without proper notice. What kinds of documents carry the most weight in these hearings? Do I submit them before or during? And does anyone know if witnesses can attend by phone or do they have to show up in person? I really need this appeal to work - I've got a mortgage payment due and my weekly UI claims are frozen while this adjudication mess sorts itself out.
78 comments

Romeo Quest
Before anything else - are you still able to get through to anyone at Nevada DETR by phone? Because I burned three weeks trying to reach an agent to ask basic questions about my own appeal and kept hitting busy signals or getting disconnected. Someone in another thread pointed me to Claimyr (claimyr.com) and there's a video walkthrough at https://youtu.be/Mc9FNfOF_yY - basically it works the queue for you and calls you back when an agent picks up. I used it before my misconduct hearing to confirm my hearing date and ask whether my employer had submitted anything yet. Huge difference from just dialing and praying. Anyway, once you do get through, specifically ask them to confirm your employer's submitted position statement, because that document tells you exactly what you're arguing against.
0 coins
Lydia Santiago
AuthorThe employer submitted a position statement? I didn't know that was even a thing - nobody told me they'd file something separately. So I should be asking DETR to send me a copy of whatever my employer submitted?
0 coins
Romeo Quest
Yes, exactly. They should provide it to you as part of the hearing packet but sometimes it doesn't come until close to the date. Getting it early gives you time to prepare counter-evidence for each specific claim they make.
0 coins
Val Rossi
Claimyr worked for me too when I was prepping for my appeal hearing. I called three times on my own and gave up each time. Used Claimyr once and had an agent in about 40 minutes who answered every question I had about submitting documents before the deadline.
0 coins
Eve Freeman
Those quota emails you mentioned - when exactly did management send out the revised quota numbers relative to your termination date? That timing is what your whole case turns on, actually. The legal concept here is basically that misconduct has to involve something you chose to do wrong, knowing it was against the rules. If the rule itself changed without notice and you hadn't even worked a full review cycle under the new numbers before they fired you, that's a really strong argument that there was nothing intentional or deliberate about missing target. Pull out every email with a date stamp showing when the new metrics were announced versus when your termination letter is dated. That gap is your argument.
0 coins
Lydia Santiago
AuthorThe quota change email came out roughly six weeks before I was let go, but the cycle they measured me on was only three weeks long. Does that short measurement window matter?
0 coins
Eve Freeman
Three weeks against a changed metric is actually meaningful. Performance management periods are usually 30, 60, or 90 days at minimum. Your employer essentially set you up to fail inside a window too short to demonstrate improvement even if you'd tried. Document that timeline explicitly on a simple one-page chronology you bring to the hearing.
0 coins
Clarissa Flair
wait so they changed the quota AND only gave you 3 weeks before firing? that seems really unfair honestly
0 coins
Caden Turner
Unfair doesn't necessarily win a UI appeal though. The question is whether the conduct was willful. That 3-week window is relevant precisely because willful means you chose to miss targets, not that you failed during an unreasonably short corrective period.
0 coins
McKenzie Shade
Your performance reviews being positive is actually bigger evidence than people think. My cousin went through a misconduct disqualification appeal two years ago for something completely different - attendance issues they claimed - and what ended up tipping the hearing officer was that she had three consecutive satisfactory annual reviews. The idea was basically: if someone is genuinely committing misconduct, why are the reviews good? Gather every formal review document, not just the most recent one. Patterns matter.
0 coins
Lydia Santiago
AuthorI have two full-year reviews and one mid-year check-in, all rated 'meets expectations' or above. I'll make sure to bring all three. Should I highlight specific sections or just bring the whole packet?
0 coins
McKenzie Shade
Bring the whole document but put a sticky note or paper clip on the pages with the overall rating. Hearing officers move fast and you want to make it easy for them to see the relevant parts immediately.
0 coins
Harmony Love
Also make sure they're the official copies from HR if possible, not just your personal saved versions. Official letterhead carries more weight than a PDF you printed yourself.
0 coins
Rudy Cenizo
ok genuine question - does anyone know if you have to pay anything to file the appeal or is it free? I'm dealing with something similar and have been too scared to start because I thought there were filing fees
0 coins
Eve Freeman
Free. Zero cost to file a UI appeal in Nevada. The hearing is also free. You don't need an attorney either, though you can bring one if you want.
0 coins
Rudy Cenizo
oh thank god. ok I'm filing today then. I've been sitting on this for two weeks thinking I'd have to pay something
0 coins
Natalie Khan
The text thread with your supervisor is potentially your strongest single piece of evidence - here's why it matters specifically for your situation. She admitted in writing that the quota change happened without proper notice. That's your former employer essentially conceding a key fact in your favor. Screenshot every message in that thread, include the contact name and phone number visible in the screenshots, and print them out. If the hearing officer asks how you can prove it's really her, that visible contact info helps. Some people also get a phone bill showing the number belongs to the supervisor, which is extra but can help if the employer challenges authenticity.
0 coins
Lydia Santiago
AuthorThe contact saved in my phone is her work number, not her personal cell. Would that still work as identification, or do I need something that ties it to her personally?
0 coins
Natalie Khan
Work number is actually better in some ways because it's verifiable through the company directory. If she denies it at the hearing, you can point out it came from the company's main line.
0 coins
Daryl Bright
Can the supervisor be called as a witness even if she still works at the company? That seems like it could get complicated for her
0 coins
Natalie Khan
Legally yes she can be subpoenaed but realistically most former employees don't go that route. The written texts themselves are the evidence - you don't necessarily need her to show up and testify.
0 coins
Sienna Gomez
I went through a misconduct appeal last year after getting fired from a warehouse job. The thing that surprised me most was how informal the actual hearing felt. I was terrified going in thinking it would be like court, but the hearing officer just went through the facts conversationally. That said, I was totally unprepared on the evidence side and lost even though I had a decent argument, just because I couldn't back it up with documents. So my advice: bring more than you think you need. Physical copies of everything, organized in the order you'd want to refer to them.
0 coins
Lydia Santiago
AuthorWhat ended up happening after you lost? Did you appeal again or just accept it?
0 coins
Sienna Gomez
I accepted it unfortunately. Didn't know there was a Board of Review appeal above the initial hearing. If I'd known, I might have pushed it further. So know that if you lose at the first hearing level, there's still a next step.
0 coins
Kirsuktow DarkBlade
This is true - the Board of Review appeal is a real option and it's also free. You have 11 days from the initial decision to file that second appeal, so don't wait around.
0 coins
Abigail bergen
NOBODY TELLS YOU THIS but your employer has a financial incentive to fight your claim because their unemployment tax rate goes up if you collect. So they will lie. They will submit stuff that sounds official but is completely one-sided. You need to come to that hearing treating it like a real legal fight, not a polite conversation. I lost my first appeal because I assumed the hearing officer would see through the employer's story on their own. They don't do your work for you.
0 coins
Clarissa Flair
is that actually true about the tax rates? I never knew employers were financially affected
0 coins
Abigail bergen
100% real. It's called experience rating. The more former employees collect UI benefits from your employer's account, the higher their unemployment tax rate gets. So yes, they have a direct dollar reason to contest claims and claim misconduct.
0 coins
Eve Freeman
This is accurate. It's worth keeping in mind when you're evaluating how aggressive your employer's response might be. Some employers fight everything automatically; some only push back on larger claims.
0 coins
Ahooker-Equator
Witness logistics question since you asked about that - for Nevada DETR appeal hearings witnesses can participate by phone. You don't need them physically present. The hearing notice itself will have a dial-in number and instructions. If you have a coworker who witnessed the quota announcement or can speak to your performance, they can literally call in from wherever they are. I confirmed this detail directly with a DETR agent I reached through Claimyr - I was skeptical about phone witnesses but the agent confirmed it's standard practice and actually common because employers and claimants are often in different cities.
0 coins
Lydia Santiago
AuthorA former coworker who was also affected by the quota change might be willing to call in. How much notice do I need to give to add a witness?
0 coins
Ahooker-Equator
You should notify the appeals office as early as possible, ideally at least a week before the hearing. The hearing notice will have contact information. Let them know the witness's name and that they'll be attending by phone.
0 coins
Harmony Love
Also brief your witness beforehand on what specifically they're being asked to speak to. Vague testimony like 'yeah it seemed unfair' doesn't help as much as 'I personally attended the meeting where the new quota was announced on this specific date.
0 coins
Anderson Prospero
something I haven't seen anyone mention yet - what's your termination paperwork actually say? Like the specific reason written on your separation notice. Because if your employer wrote something vague like 'failure to meet performance standards' rather than explicitly using the word misconduct, you can actually use that document against them at the hearing. If the termination letter says performance and they're now telling DETR it was misconduct, that's a direct inconsistency you can point out. Those inconsistencies hurt employers' credibility with hearing officers.
0 coins
Lydia Santiago
AuthorMy separation letter says 'terminated due to failure to achieve assigned performance targets' - nothing about misconduct, violation of policy, or anything like that. So they invented the misconduct framing when they responded to DETR?
0 coins
Anderson Prospero
That gap between what they told you in writing and what they told DETR is genuinely useful. Bring both documents side by side. The hearing officer can see exactly what changed between when they fired you and when they filed their claim contest.
0 coins
Caden Turner
This happens more than people realize. Employers sometimes escalate the stated reason when contesting UI claims because they know 'performance' doesn't disqualify you but 'misconduct' does. Pointing that out explicitly is a legitimate and effective tactic.
0 coins
Abigail bergen
And THIS is exactly why I said treat it like a legal fight. They changed the story to avoid paying. That's not a mistake, it's strategic.
0 coins
Clarissa Flair
wait I'm confused about something in this thread - is misconduct and disqualification the same thing? Or is misconduct just one reason you can get disqualified? I got disqualified too but my letter says something different
0 coins
Eve Freeman
Different things. Disqualification is the outcome - you don't get benefits. Misconduct is one specific reason that can lead to disqualification. There are other reasons too like quitting without good cause, refusing suitable work, etc. What does your disqualification letter cite as the reason?
0 coins
Clarissa Flair
it says 'voluntary quit without good cause attributable to the employer' which sounds different from misconduct
0 coins
Eve Freeman
Completely different legal path. You'd want to look into what qualifies as good cause for leaving, which is its own whole area. The evidence strategies in this thread are specific to misconduct cases so some of it won't apply to yours.
0 coins
Clarissa Flair
oh okay. I'll start a separate thread I guess. thanks for clarifying
0 coins
Val Rossi
One thing I want to flag about the weekly claims being frozen - are you still filing them every week even though you're disqualified? Because you absolutely should be. If you win your appeal, DETR will only pay out weeks where you actually filed a claim. Weeks where you didn't file are gone even if you win. I know it feels pointless to file when everything is frozen but you need that paper trail.
0 coins
Lydia Santiago
AuthorI filed the first two weeks after the disqualification but then stopped because it felt futile. Can I go back and file retroactively for the weeks I missed?
0 coins
Val Rossi
You can request backdating through DETR but it's not guaranteed and you have to give a good reason for missing the weeks. It's worth trying but not certain. Going forward, file every single week no matter what.
0 coins
Kirsuktow DarkBlade
This is super important advice. The CSS portal lets you file even when your claim is under appeal. The system just holds the payments pending the appeal outcome. Missing weeks is one of the most common and painful mistakes people make.
0 coins
Tyrone Hill
Has your hearing officer been assigned yet? Because once assigned, some people have had luck calling the appeals office directly to ask procedural questions specific to their hearing officer's preferences, like whether they prefer documents submitted in advance versus brought day-of. I found this out after I'd already submitted mine the wrong way. The process for submitting evidence ahead of a hearing isn't totally obvious from the standard instructions. I had a whole situation where I thought I'd submitted my documents but they weren't in the hearing packet and I had to scramble at the actual hearing. Used Claimyr to get through to someone at DETR who could actually confirm whether my documents showed up in the system before I walked into that room, which saved me from a nasty surprise.
0 coins
Lydia Santiago
AuthorThe assignment letter I got shows a hearing officer name and a direct number for the appeals unit. So I should call that specific number and ask about their document submission preferences?
0 coins
Tyrone Hill
Yes, that number goes to the appeals unit support staff who can answer procedural questions. It's different from the main DETR claims line. Much easier to reach.
0 coins
Harmony Love
Also ask specifically whether documents submitted by fax, email, or mail are all acceptable or if one method is preferred. Some officers want everything in one submission method for their records.
0 coins
Toot-n-Mighty
Coming back to the actual evidence question from the original post since I think we got a bit into the weeds - here's a practical list of what tends to be persuasive in a quota/performance misconduct appeal specifically: First, the communications showing when the new standards were announced. Second, any documentation of your actual performance numbers versus the new targets during that short window. Third, your historical performance reviews showing you weren't a problem employee. Fourth, the termination letter showing what the stated reason actually was. Fifth, anything showing other employees were also struggling with the new targets if you can get it - because if everyone was missing quota, it starts to look like a quota problem not a you problem. Organize these as numbered exhibits and reference them by number when you speak.
0 coins
Lydia Santiago
AuthorThe point about other employees is interesting - two colleagues were let go around the same time for similar reasons. Can I reference that without having them present?
0 coins
Toot-n-Mighty
You can reference it and it helps your argument even without them present, but their testimony would obviously be stronger. Even a written statement from them signed and dated could carry some weight. It's worth asking if either would be willing.
0 coins
Daryl Bright
Is there a risk that bringing up the coworkers makes it look like you're deflecting personal accountability? I'd worry the hearing officer might think you're trying to shift blame.
0 coins
Toot-n-Mighty
The purpose isn't deflection - it's establishing that the quota standard itself was unreasonable or unevenly applied. That's directly relevant to whether the failure was willful. It's not 'it's their fault' it's 'this standard was objectively failing everyone.
0 coins
Harmony Love
Formatting note that might sound minor but actually matters - when you bring physical documents to the hearing, number every page and have an index sheet at the front. Something as simple as 'Exhibit 1: Quota Change Email dated [date], Exhibit 2: Performance Review 2023,' etc. It makes you look organized and prepared, which genuinely does affect how hearing officers perceive your overall credibility. I work in HR and have sat in on these from the employer side - the claimants who come in with organized binders are taken more seriously.
0 coins
Lydia Santiago
AuthorYou've been on the employer side of these hearings - what's the most common mistake you've seen claimants make that ends up hurting them?
0 coins
Harmony Love
Getting emotional and going off-script. The hearing officer needs to hear facts in a logical sequence. When people get upset and start explaining how unfair everything was, it derails the factual record. Stick to dates, documents, and direct quotes.
0 coins
Sienna Gomez
This is exactly what I did wrong in my hearing. I got frustrated and started talking about how the company treated everyone badly and I could tell the hearing officer just wanted me to get back to the specific facts.
0 coins
Kirsuktow DarkBlade
One more thing on the NRS 612.385 side of this - the burden in a misconduct termination actually falls on the employer to prove the misconduct happened, not on you to disprove it. People don't realize this. You're not walking in as the accused who has to prove innocence. They have to affirmatively show what rule you violated, that you knew the rule existed, and that you deliberately broke it. If their evidence is thin or inconsistent, that benefits you even without you having to knock it down with counter-evidence.
0 coins
Lydia Santiago
AuthorSo the employer goes first in presenting their case? I wasn't sure about the order of proceedings.
0 coins
Kirsuktow DarkBlade
Generally yes - the party with the burden of proof typically goes first, so the employer presents their case and then you get to respond and present yours. The hearing officer may ask questions throughout. It varies a little by hearing officer but that's the general structure.
0 coins
Caden Turner
This is accurate and understanding it changes your mental preparation. You're responding to their case, not building an airtight case from scratch on your own.
0 coins
McKenzie Shade
I didn't know this when I had my hearing and I basically treated it like I had to prove everything myself from zero. Would have approached it completely differently.
0 coins
Daryl Bright
Does anyone know if you can request a continuance if you don't feel ready on the scheduled date? I'm asking for myself actually - my hearing got scheduled for two weeks out and I haven't even gotten my employer's statement yet
0 coins
Kirsuktow DarkBlade
You can request a continuance but do it quickly - contact the appeals unit as soon as possible and explain you haven't received the employer's response documents yet. That's actually a valid reason for a continuance request.
0 coins
Daryl Bright
ok calling tomorrow morning. does it hurt your case to ask for more time
0 coins
Kirsuktow DarkBlade
No. Procedural requests like continuances are neutral. The hearing officer evaluates your case on its merits, not on whether you asked for more time to prepare.
0 coins
Caden Turner
One scenario worth thinking through - what if the employer shows up with documents you've never seen before at the actual hearing? This catches people off guard. You have the right to ask the hearing officer for time to review new documents before responding to them. Don't just let the employer introduce something at the last second and immediately start arguing against it without reading it carefully first. Hearing officers are generally reasonable about giving you a few minutes to review unexpected submissions.
0 coins
Lydia Santiago
AuthorWhat if the new document is something that really undermines my case and I'm not prepared to respond to it on the spot?
0 coins
Caden Turner
You can ask for a recess to collect your thoughts, and in some cases if the new evidence is substantial enough to warrant it you can ask the hearing officer to allow written responses submitted after the hearing. It's not guaranteed but it's a legitimate request.
0 coins
Natalie Khan
This is why getting that employer position statement before the hearing is so valuable - it's supposed to prevent exactly this kind of ambush. If they submit something at the hearing that contradicts their earlier written statement, that inconsistency itself becomes evidence in your favor.
0 coins
Abigail bergen
Final thought from me - whatever happens at the initial hearing level, do NOT miss the 11-day appeal window to the Board of Review if you lose. I cannot stress this enough. The number of people who lose at the first level and just give up without knowing there's another shot is genuinely heartbreaking. The Board of Review has reversed initial decisions in cases where the hearing officer made procedural errors or misapplied the law. Set a calendar reminder for 11 days after your hearing date just in case.
0 coins
Lydia Santiago
Author11 days from the date of the decision or 11 days from when I receive the decision in the mail?
0 coins
Abigail bergen
From the date of the written decision - which is why you should check your CSS portal and email regularly after the hearing rather than waiting for the postal mail, which can add days.
0 coins
Kirsuktow DarkBlade
This is correct. And the decision date is printed on the decision document itself, so when you receive it, that's the date your 11 days start counting from, not the postmark date.
0 coins
Sienna Gomez
I wish I had known this. I got my decision letter 5 days after the decision date and thought I had 11 days from when I received it. I had actually already missed the window by the time I figured that out.
0 coins