Back to Nevada Unemployment

NebulaNinja

Can unemployment be denied for negligence mistake at work - Nevada DETR situation

So I got let go from my warehouse job about two weeks ago and I'm trying to figure out where I stand with my UI claim. My supervisor said I was terminated for 'negligent operation of equipment' - basically I bumped a forklift into a rack and caused some minor product damage. It wasn't intentional, I just misjudged the turn. I'd been there almost four years with zero incidents before this. Filed my claim with Nevada DETR right away and now I'm sitting here wondering if this whole negligence angle is going to sink me. My CSS account just shows 'adjudication in progress' and I have no clue which way this is going to go. Has anyone had their unemployment denied because of a workplace mistake? Like an actual accident, not something you did on purpose?

Two weeks into my own adjudication right now so this hits close to home - mine is for something similar. What I found out the hard way after my claim got flagged is that Nevada DETR doesn't automatically deny you just because your employer says the word 'negligence.' There's a pretty big difference between a one-time honest mistake and a pattern of careless behavior. The adjudicator is basically looking at whether you showed a deliberate disregard for your employer's rules or just messed up once. A four-year clean record is genuinely going to work in your favor here. Keep your documentation ready - incident reports, your employment history, any performance reviews showing you were a good worker before this.

0 coins

My termination letter said 'gross negligence' and I ended up getting approved after adjudication - the key detail in my case was that it was a first offense with no prior warnings. DETR wanted to see my whole disciplinary file before they made the call.

0 coins

Mine says 'negligent operation' on the termination paperwork - does the specific wording on that letter matter a lot to what DETR decides?

0 coins

The wording matters less than the actual facts of what happened. They're going to call your former employer and ask questions, so just be ready to tell your side clearly and factually.

0 coins

Just got my approval letter yesterday after a brutal three weeks of adjudication so I want to share what actually helped me. I had been calling Nevada DETR every single day for two weeks trying to get a status update and kept hitting busy signals or getting disconnected after waiting forever. Someone in a different thread mentioned Claimyr - claimyr.com - and I was skeptical but desperate enough to try it. They have a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Mc9FNfOF_yY. Basically it got me through to an actual DETR agent when nothing else was working. The agent I reached told me exactly what documentation to upload and what the adjudicator was looking at. That conversation probably saved my claim. For anyone stuck in adjudication limbo, especially for a termination dispute, being able to actually talk to someone makes a huge difference.

0 coins

Week five of my own adjudication and I've been trying to reach DETR for weeks - every number I try either rings forever or kicks me to a voicemail that's full. Going to look into this.

0 coins

Really glad your claim came through. Did the agent give you any sense of what the typical outcome is for first-time incidents versus repeat issues?

0 coins

She basically said first-time mistakes without prior write-ups are treated very differently from repeated rule violations. Couldn't promise me anything but she explained what factors the adjudicator weighs.

0 coins

Got approved last month after a termination dispute too and I had the same experience trying to reach anyone at DETR - the phone system is genuinely brutal.

0 coins

Three months back I went through almost exactly this situation - terminated from a logistics company for damaging equipment. I lost my first adjudication because I didn't understand the difference between what DETR considers 'misconduct' versus a simple mistake. Here's what I wish I'd known earlier: under Nevada UI rules, misconduct means you intentionally or repeatedly violated something you clearly knew was a rule. A single accident where there's no history of warnings doesn't usually meet that bar. The employer has to actually prove you were acting recklessly or in defiance of their policies, not just that you made an error. I ended up appealing and winning because I had my clean disciplinary record and witness statements from coworkers who saw it was just a misjudgment.

0 coins

Went back and read my termination letter again - there's no mention of prior warnings or any disciplinary history. Does that actually help my case or do they not care?

0 coins

That absence of prior discipline is probably the most important thing in your favor. The adjudicator looks at the whole picture and a clean four-year record speaks loudly.

0 coins

Seventh week waiting on mine and this thread is the first thing that's made me feel less panicked. My situation is similar - first offense, no write-ups - so hearing this helps.

0 coins

Got a question because I'm confused about something - is there a difference between being denied during adjudication and getting an actual disqualification letter? My claim for a termination dispute has been in adjudication for going on six weeks and I don't know if I should be preparing to appeal or just waiting.

0 coins

Filing weekly claims through week four myself, and yes those are two separate things. Adjudication is the investigation phase where they're still deciding. A disqualification is the actual decision against you. If you get disqualified you have 11 days to file your appeal.

0 coins

Eleven days feels really short - is that calendar days or business days because that changes everything for me.

0 coins

Got that exact question answered by a DETR agent - it's calendar days from the date on the determination letter, not business days. Don't sit on it.

0 coins

My claim sat in adjudication for eight weeks before any determination came out - the wait is awful but it doesn't mean bad news is coming.

0 coins

I work in HR and I've seen how these termination cases get reviewed from the employer side. The thing most claimants don't realize is that when DETR contacts your former employer, the employer has to actually demonstrate that you violated a known, established policy - not just that you caused an accident. If your company didn't have a documented forklift safety policy that you were trained on and acknowledged, their case gets a lot harder. Also worth knowing: employers often don't even bother responding to DETR's requests for information, and when they don't respond, claims tend to default toward approval.

0 coins

Had my forklift certification training about two years ago - is that going to count as proof I knew the rules even if I didn't have anything to sign recently?

0 coins

Certification training creates a record that you were trained, which could cut either way. It shows you knew how to operate the equipment, but it also shows the company invested in proper training. The key is whether the incident was a lapse versus a defiance of what you learned.

0 coins

Just received my adjudication questionnaire last week and this thread is making me realize I need to be way more careful about how I describe what happened.

0 coins

The employer non-response thing is real - my former company never sent anything back to DETR and my adjudication came out in my favor after about five weeks.

0 coins

Somewhere around week three of adjudication, I completely lost my mind trying to get through to DETR on the phone. Tried at 7:58am, tried at lunch, tried everything people recommended online. A friend who'd gone through a termination dispute told me to try Claimyr - said it cut through the hold time problem entirely. The site is claimyr.com and there's a demo video at https://youtu.be/Mc9FNfOF_yY that shows what it actually does. I finally reached a live DETR agent who told me my employer hadn't responded to their inquiry yet, which explained why everything was taking so long. Just having that piece of information took a huge weight off. For a negligence or misconduct termination case especially, knowing what stage your adjudication is actually at can help you figure out what to do next.

0 coins

Received my denial letter last Thursday and I wish I'd found this thread before it was too late to get more information during adjudication. Going to try this for the appeal stage.

0 coins

Appeals are absolutely a situation where reaching an agent matters - there are specific procedures and they can tell you exactly what to submit.

0 coins

Just hit my second week of adjudication and already feeling the wall of silence from DETR - appreciate the heads up on this.

0 coins

My claim got denied a few months ago for a termination they called misconduct and I want to share what I learned from the appeal hearing because it might help people here. The appeals referee asked very specific questions: had I been warned before, was there a written policy, did I receive training, was the damage intentional. For an equipment accident case those questions are really the whole ballgame. If you can answer no, no history of warnings, yes I was trained, no it wasn't intentional - you're in a good position. I lost the initial adjudication but won my appeal, so denial isn't the end of the road.

0 coins

Thinking about what I'd say at a hearing makes this feel very real - did you have to get a lawyer or was it manageable to represent yourself?

0 coins

Handled mine completely on my own - brought my clean employment record, the incident report, and a written statement explaining exactly what happened. The referee was pretty straightforward to deal with.

0 coins

Just wrapped up my own appeal hearing last week and wanted to add - I had a really hard time getting any information about what to expect during the whole appeal process. Tried calling DETR repeatedly and got nowhere. Used Claimyr at claimyr.com to finally reach someone and they walked me through the hearing procedures and what documentation to bring. Made a stressful process a lot less confusing.

0 coins

Got my appeal hearing scheduled for next month and I've been dreading it - hearing that someone represented themselves successfully is genuinely reassuring.

0 coins

About a month into this whole process now. One thing nobody told me until it was almost too late: you have to keep filing your weekly claims even while your claim is in adjudication. I almost stopped because I figured why bother if everything is on hold. But those weekly certifications establish your continued eligibility - if you get approved and you haven't been filing, you lose those weeks. File every single week no matter what.

0 coins

Just submitted week six of my weekly claim even though nothing has been decided yet - glad I kept going because I had no idea this was required.

0 coins

Nobody explained this to me either - I stopped for two weeks thinking it was pointless and had to call DETR to figure out if I could file retroactively. It's a mess to fix after the fact.

0 coins

Have been filing every Sunday since I submitted my initial claim - at least I did that part right.

0 coins

This is such an important point that gets buried. Weekly certification is not optional even during adjudication.

0 coins

Somewhere in month two of waiting here and I want to push back a little on the idea that negligence claims are usually fine. I know someone who got denied for a single incident - no prior write-ups - because the employer was able to show the specific safety rule that was violated was posted in the work area and covered in an annual training. DETR sided with the employer because there was documented evidence the rule was known. I'm not saying you're going to get denied, just that the employer's documentation matters a lot and you should be prepared for them to present whatever they have.

0 coins

That's a fair point - my earlier comment was about the typical outcome but documented prior knowledge of a specific rule does shift things. The key question is whether ignoring a known rule was intentional or still just a lapse.

0 coins

Exactly - there's a spectrum and the adjudicator has discretion. I just think people should go in prepared rather than assuming the outcome.

0 coins

This is accurate. The documentation the employer submits within their response window is the biggest variable. Some employers are very thorough, others send nothing at all.

0 coins

Just got past the adjudication questionnaire stage this week and have a small thing to add: be really careful how you describe the incident on that questionnaire. I described mine as 'I wasn't paying enough attention' and an adjudicator told me later that phrasing sounds like admitted recklessness. Better to describe it as a misjudgment or an error given the conditions - something that conveys it was an accident without language that sounds like you acknowledged a pattern of carelessness.

0 coins

Already submitted mine but I described it as a misjudgment of clearance while making a standard turn - hoping that reads the way it should.

0 coins

That phrasing sounds solid - it's specific, it describes a momentary error, and it doesn't suggest any pattern.

0 coins

Received my questionnaire yesterday and this advice is exactly what I needed before filling it out. The word choice really does seem like it matters a lot here.

0 coins

Wish this had been posted before I submitted mine - I definitely used some language I'd take back now. Still waiting to hear.

0 coins

Coming at this from week three of adjudication and I have to say the total radio silence from Nevada DETR while your whole financial situation hangs in the air is one of the most stressful experiences I've ever dealt with. No updates, no timeline, nothing. I keep logging into CSS hoping for some change and there's just the same 'adjudication in progress' message sitting there.

0 coins

Just past week four of the same silence - it really does just sit there with zero updates. The only way I ever got any real information was by actually reaching an agent on the phone.

0 coins

Have tried calling five times this week alone - I've never once gotten through to an actual person.

0 coins

Got through once after calling right at opening time and waiting 45 minutes - told me basically nothing except to wait. The system is really poorly designed for people who need actual answers.

0 coins

The CSS portal not updating is by design in a way - adjudication is an internal process and they don't push status updates until a determination is made. It feels cruel but that's how it works.

0 coins

My determination came in yesterday after six weeks and I want to share the actual language they used because it might help people understand what they're looking at. Mine said the evidence did not establish that my actions rose to the level of misconduct as defined under Nevada unemployment law. The key phrase was 'isolated incident' and 'no documented pattern of similar behavior.' If those phrases end up in your determination letter, you're approved. If it says 'deliberate disregard' or 'repeated violations' that's the denial language.

0 coins

Six weeks into this and finally seeing light at the end of the tunnel from your post - really appreciate you sharing the actual wording.

0 coins

Hang in there - clean record and a genuinely accidental incident are strong facts on your side.

0 coins

Just bookmarked this comment specifically so I know what I'm reading when my letter finally comes. Thank you for being this specific.

0 coins

My approval letter had almost identical language about 'isolated incident' - it's clearly the standard they apply in these cases.

0 coins

About five weeks into adjudication for a termination case myself and I had a really specific situation I wanted to share. My employer actually changed their story between what they told me when I was fired and what they submitted to DETR. The agent I spoke with - I finally got through using Claimyr after weeks of failed attempts, the site is claimyr.com - told me that inconsistencies in the employer's account actually work in the claimant's favor because DETR can't verify conflicting information. So if you feel like your employer might be misrepresenting what happened, document everything you remember about what they said at termination.

0 coins

Just finished my fourth week and my employer also told me something different when I was let go than what I think they'd tell DETR - didn't realize that inconsistency could actually matter.

0 coins

Write down everything you remember, timestamps if you can, any witnesses. Consistency in your account versus inconsistency in theirs makes a real difference.

0 coins

Got a question - what if you signed a separation agreement? Does that affect what DETR looks at during adjudication?

0 coins

Separation agreements generally don't prevent you from filing for UI - they might contain non-disparagement language but DETR evaluates the facts of the separation independently.

0 coins

Just came here to update anyone following along on a termination-for-misconduct case - my denial letter arrived after about seven weeks and I've now filed my appeal. The denial cited a specific safety protocol I supposedly violated. Here's the thing: I never received written notification of that protocol. My appeal is based entirely on the fact that you can't violate a rule you were never formally informed existed. Hearing is in three weeks.

0 coins

Just got my own appeal decision back last month - lack of documented notice of a specific rule was the central argument in my successful appeal too. That's a strong foundation.

0 coins

Really helps to hear that worked for someone else - I feel like the facts are on my side but the formal process is intimidating.

0 coins

Following your case with real interest because mine is likely going the same direction. Please come back and update after the hearing.

0 coins

The appeal process is slower than the initial adjudication but the hearings are genuinely fairer in my experience - you actually get to speak and be heard.

0 coins

Somewhere in week two of adjudication and reading this whole thread from start to finish has been incredibly useful. One question I haven't seen addressed: does it matter at all that I told my supervisor immediately after the incident and took full responsibility at the time? Like does honesty during the incident factor into what DETR decides?

0 coins

Reporting an incident immediately actually tends to work in your favor - it demonstrates you weren't trying to hide it or cover anything up, which counters any argument that you had a reckless attitude.

0 coins

My adjudicator mentioned this during my call - voluntary disclosure and taking responsibility shows the incident wasn't part of a pattern of trying to get away with things.

0 coins

That's a relief - I was worried it might be used as a kind of admission against me.

0 coins

There's a difference between admitting an accident happened and admitting you were reckless. The first is just honesty. The second is what DETR is actually looking for.

0 coins

Final update from me since I mentioned my appeal hearing earlier - walked out of that hearing this morning and I think it went well. I described everything factually, brought my four years of performance reviews, and the employer representative actually had a hard time answering basic questions about whether the safety policy was formally documented. The referee seemed to focus a lot on whether I had actual written notice of the specific rule. Won't know the result for a week or two but I feel cautiously optimistic.

0 coins

Following this thread since I posted the original question and hearing this feels like momentum - really rooting for you.

0 coins

The whole thing from initial termination to appeal hearing has been about two and a half months. Not easy but definitely survivable.

0 coins

My hearing is next week and your description of how the referee focuses on documented notice of the rule is exactly the frame I needed. Thank you.

0 coins

Performance reviews covering your full tenure are underutilized at these hearings - most people just bring incident-related paperwork. Good call bringing them.

0 coins

Nevada Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure