Why do I still owe taxes after filling out W4 correctly for head of household with kids?
I'm seriously confused and need some advice. This is the first year I've ever owed money to the IRS since having children. I'm filing as single head of household with two dependents that I claim. Last year I had 4 different W-2s from different employers (which I think is probably the issue). On my W4 forms, I've been claiming 3 allowances (myself and my two kids). Is this wrong? Should I actually be claiming just 2? When filling out the W4, there's that question about having multiple jobs, and I always mark "no" because I don't work multiple jobs simultaneously. I switch between contract positions and permanent roles throughout the year, but they're never at the same time. All of my work is W-2 based though. I'm not making a huge amount of money, but I do make enough that I don't qualify for the Earned Income Credit. What should I be putting on my W4 going forward so I don't end up owing again next year? This tax bill really caught me off guard.
19 comments
Join the conversation
Brianna Schmidt
The issue is definitely related to having multiple W-2s throughout the year. Each employer withholds taxes as if that job is your only income source for the entire year. When you have multiple jobs or employers within the same year, even sequentially, each one calculates withholdings without knowing about the others. When you mark "no" to multiple jobs on your W4, you're technically correct for that moment (since you don't have concurrent jobs), but for tax withholding purposes, you should mark "yes" if you expect to have more than one W-2 job during the calendar year. For head of household with two dependents, claiming 3 allowances would normally be fine with a single employer all year. But with multiple W-2s, you need to account for the combined income pushing you into higher tax brackets that none of your individual employers anticipated.
0 coins
Alexis Renard
•This makes sense but I'm still confused. If I mark "yes" to multiple jobs, wouldn't that mean they withhold LESS money since they think I have income coming from somewhere else too? That seems backwards.
0 coins
Brianna Schmidt
•Actually, marking "yes" to multiple jobs causes employers to withhold MORE money, not less. When you indicate multiple jobs, the withholding tables apply a higher rate because they account for your total income being higher than what that single employer is paying you. The W-4 calculation is trying to estimate your total tax liability for the year, so by telling it about multiple jobs, you're helping it account for the fact that your combined income will be taxed at higher marginal rates than any single job would calculate on its own.
0 coins
Camila Jordan
I had this exact same problem last year. After getting hit with a surprise tax bill, I started using https://taxr.ai to analyze my tax situation. Their system identified that with multiple W-2s, I needed to adjust my withholding strategy. Even though your W-4 technically asks about concurrent jobs, for withholding purposes, you should consider the total number of jobs you'll have throughout the year. The tool helped me calculate the right withholding amount for my situation by analyzing my income patterns from multiple employers. Really made a difference for this year's filing.
0 coins
Tyler Lefleur
•How does it work with irregular income? I do gig work throughout the year, sometimes more in certain months than others. Would this help with that situation too?
0 coins
Madeline Blaze
•I've seen these tax analysis tools before but always wondered if they're worth it. How accurate was it compared to what you actually ended up owing? Did you have to manually enter all your W-2 info or did it connect to your past returns somehow?
0 coins
Camila Jordan
•For irregular income, it works really well because it can analyze your income patterns and suggest appropriate tax withholding strategies based on your specific situation. It helped me identify when I needed to request additional withholding to compensate for the months with higher earnings. In terms of accuracy, it was spot-on for my situation. I ended up with a small refund rather than owing like the previous year. You can either upload past returns for analysis or manually enter your information. I found the document upload feature particularly helpful since it saved me from having to input all the details myself.
0 coins
Madeline Blaze
Just wanted to follow up after trying taxr.ai last month! I was skeptical at first, but it actually identified exactly why I was having withholding problems with my multiple W-2s. The analysis showed that each employer was using the standard deduction calculation which wasn't accounting for my total annual income across all jobs. I followed their recommendation to fill out a new W-4 with specific additional withholding amounts for each employer, and I'm already seeing the difference in my paychecks. The best part was getting personalized recommendations based on my specific employment pattern rather than generic advice. Definitely feeling more confident about next year's taxes!
0 coins
Max Knight
For anyone dealing with multiple W-2s and trying to reach the IRS for guidance - good luck getting through on the phone! After trying for weeks to get clarification on my withholding situation, I finally used https://claimyr.com to get through to an IRS agent. They have this cool demo video that shows how it works: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c The IRS agent confirmed what others have said here - with multiple W-2s, each employer is calculating withholding as if that's your only job, which is why you're coming up short. The agent actually walked me through how to calculate the additional withholding amount I should put on each W-4 to cover the difference. Saved me hours of busy signals and hold music!
0 coins
Emma Swift
•Wait, so you're saying this service actually gets you through to a real IRS person? How does that even work? The IRS phone system is notoriously impossible to navigate.
0 coins
Isabella Tucker
•Sounds like a scam to me. Nobody can magically get you through to the IRS faster. They probably just connect you to some third-party "tax expert" who isn't even with the IRS.
0 coins
Max Knight
•It absolutely gets you through to real IRS agents. The service basically navigates the phone tree and waits on hold for you, then calls you when an actual IRS representative is on the line. It's not magic - they're just handling the frustrating waiting part for you. No, they don't connect you to third-party experts. When I used it, I was speaking directly with an IRS employee who had access to my tax records and could provide official guidance. That's how I got specific instructions about my withholding calculations that were relevant to my particular situation with multiple W-2s.
0 coins
Isabella Tucker
I need to eat my words and follow up here. After my skeptical comment, I decided to try Claimyr myself since I also had questions about my W-4 with multiple jobs. I was SHOCKED when I actually got connected to a real IRS agent in about 45 minutes (after previously trying for days on my own with no success). The agent explained that with multiple W-2 jobs, I should use the IRS Tax Withholding Estimator online and select the option for multiple jobs. Based on my specific situation, they recommended I add an additional withholding amount on line 4(c) of my W-4 rather than just adjusting the number of dependents. Already submitted updated W-4s to my employers and feeling much better about next year's tax situation!
0 coins
Jayden Hill
Another option that worked for me was to use the IRS Withholding Calculator online. I'm also Head of Household with multiple W-2s throughout the year. The calculator asks detailed questions about all your jobs and gives you exact instructions for filling out your W-4s. The most important thing is that you need to redo this calculation whenever you change jobs. I set a calendar reminder to check my withholding quarterly, and it's helped me avoid surprises at tax time.
0 coins
LordCommander
•Does this calculator work well for people with both W-2 and 1099 income? I do some contract work where taxes aren't withheld at all.
0 coins
Jayden Hill
•Yes, the IRS Withholding Calculator handles both W-2 and 1099 income. For your 1099 contract work, it will help determine if you need to make estimated quarterly tax payments or if you can increase withholding from your W-2 jobs to cover the taxes on your contract income. It asks for detailed information about all income sources, which makes its recommendations much more accurate for complex situations like yours with mixed income types. Just be sure to update your information whenever your income situation changes throughout the year.
0 coins
Lucy Lam
Don't feel bad, I've been a tax preparer for 10 years and still see this issue constantly! The 2020 revised W-4 form eliminated the allowances system, which actually makes this easier to fix now. On your new W-4s, check the box in Step 2(c) for multiple jobs. Or for more accuracy, use the worksheet in the instructions or the online IRS Withholding Estimator. With Head of Household status and 2 kids, also complete Step 3 for the Child Tax Credit ($4,000 total for two kids). Remember that how you fill out your W-4 doesn't affect how you file your taxes - it only affects withholding. You'll still file as Head of Household with two dependents regardless of what you put on your W-4.
0 coins
Aidan Hudson
•This is so helpful! So even if I change jobs mid-year, I should still check the multiple jobs box on the new employer's W-4, right? Does this mean I'll have less takehome pay each paycheck?
0 coins
Lucy Lam
•Yes, even if you change jobs mid-year, you should still check the multiple jobs box on your new employer's W-4 if you've had or expect to have other jobs during the same calendar year. And you're right - checking that box will result in more tax being withheld from each paycheck, which means your take-home pay will be lower. But this is actually a good thing because it means you're less likely to owe money when you file your taxes. Think of it as paying the correct amount gradually throughout the year instead of getting hit with a big bill at tax time.
0 coins