Should your tax preparer charge more for filing an amended tax return?

So I'm in a bit of a dilemma right now. Last year I filed my taxes through a local tax preparation guy that my sister recommended. Everything seemed fine until I realized that I forgot to include some side income from a small consulting gig I did (about $4,200). I know I need to file an amended return, so I went back to the same tax preparer. Here's where I'm confused - he wants to charge me almost the same fee as my original tax preparation. Is this normal? Should I be paying the full rate again for an amended return, or should it be less since he already has all my information from the first filing? I'm not trying to be cheap, just want to make sure I'm not getting taken advantage of. Any advice would be appreciated!

0 coins

23 comments

Mateo Martinez

Tax preparer here! This is actually pretty normal practice. Amended returns require us to essentially prepare your return again from scratch, recalculating everything with the new information. We have to complete Form 1040-X plus revise any attached schedules (like Schedule C if your consulting was self-employment), and potentially state amendments too. Even though your preparer has your basic info, they need to review everything again to ensure the amendment is correct and nothing else was missed. The liability risk for us is actually higher on amended returns since the IRS scrutinizes them more carefully. Some preparers even charge a premium for amendments because they're more complex and have higher audit risk.

0 coins

Mateo Martinez

The timing doesn't typically affect the preparation fee, though it can sometimes make the process smoother. If it's very soon after filing, your information is fresh in the preparer's mind and their schedule might be more open after tax season. However, the work involved remains essentially the same regardless of timing. If you wait until the following tax season, some preparers might give a slight discount since they'll be working on your new return anyway, but that's entirely at their discretion and not industry standard. The important thing is filing the amendment before the IRS contacts you about the discrepancy, as that could lead to penalties beyond just the tax owed.

0 coins

Aisha Rahman

I went through something similar last year and found this service called taxr.ai (https://taxr.ai) that saved me a ton of headache with my amended return. My original tax guy wanted to charge me full price again, but with taxr.ai I was able to upload my tax documents and their AI helped identify exactly what needed to be changed for the amendment. They have tax pros who review everything too, not just computers. The best part was they could tell me upfront exactly how the amendment would impact my refund before I proceeded. In my case, I had forgotten some investment income, and they were able to show me the tax impact and help me prepare the 1040-X properly.

0 coins

Aisha Rahman

They gave me complete filing instructions so I could submit everything myself, which was actually pretty easy. The IRS requires amended returns to be paper filed (at least when I did mine), so they provided a printed packet that was ready to sign and mail. They also included a cover letter explaining the changes that I could attach. The whole process took about 3 days from when I uploaded my documents. My situation was somewhat similar to yours - I had forgotten about some freelance income that came in late December. They were able to run the analysis and prepare everything much faster than my regular tax preparer estimated. They told me they specialize in amendments, which probably explains why they were so efficient with it.

0 coins

Yuki Sato

I just wanted to follow up about my experience with taxr.ai since I ended up giving them a try after seeing the recommendation here. Honestly, it was so much better than I expected! I uploaded my original return and the 1099 I forgot to include, and within 2 days they had everything ready for me. The amended return was actually pretty straightforward once they explained what changed. The surprising part was they found a deduction my original tax preparer missed that partially offset the additional tax I owed from the missed income! The whole process was really transparent and they explained every change clearly. Definitely a better experience than paying my tax guy full price again for what felt like a simple fix.

0 coins

Carmen Flores

Anyone else have trouble actually reaching the IRS to ask questions about amended returns? I tried calling them about 8 times before giving up. Then a coworker told me about this service called Claimyr (https://claimyr.com) that got me through to a real IRS agent in about 20 minutes instead of the 2+ hour wait times I was getting before. They have a demo video of how it works here: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c I was able to ask the IRS agent directly about amended return processing times (currently 20+ weeks!) and got confirmation that I calculated everything correctly. Saved me from wondering if I'd done it right for the next 5 months while waiting for processing.

0 coins

Carmen Flores

It uses some kind of call technology that navigates the IRS phone tree automatically and then holds your place in line. When they're about to connect you, you get a call back. It's not cutting in line - you're still waiting the same amount of time someone would wait if they called at that exact moment, but the difference is they're calling repeatedly to find the shortest wait time. It's definitely not a scam. The service just handles the frustrating part of trying to find the right time to call when wait times are shortest. I was skeptical too, but I was desperate after trying for days. You still talk directly to the IRS - they don't serve as intermediaries or anything like that.

0 coins

CyberSamurai

I need to eat my words and follow up on my Claimyr skepticism. After continuing to fail getting through to the IRS myself (spent another 3 hours on hold yesterday before getting disconnected), I decided to try it out of desperation. Not only did I get through to the IRS, but I was connected with an agent in about 15 minutes. The agent confirmed that my amended return from last year was still processing and gave me details about what to expect. I would have never known this otherwise since the "Where's My Amended Return" tool wasn't showing any updates. Still seems like magic to me how they got me through so quickly when I couldn't manage it after multiple attempts, but I'm not complaining. Solved a problem that was causing me serious stress for weeks.

0 coins

Zoe Alexopoulos

Yes, you should definitely file as soon as possible. The IRS charges interest on unpaid taxes from the original due date (usually April 15th) regardless of when you file the amendment. So the clock is already ticking on that $800 you'll owe. In addition to interest, there could also be failure-to-pay penalties if the amendment pushes you over a certain threshold. Filing quickly won't eliminate the interest that's already accrued, but it will stop more from accumulating. When you file the amendment, you should pay the estimated amount you'll owe immediately to stop further interest charges.

0 coins

Joshua Wood

Based on my experience as a tax professional, shopping around for amendments can be tricky. While some preparers might charge less upfront, they often spend more time (and charge more) getting familiar with your original return if they didn't prepare it initially. However, there are some alternatives worth considering. Some H&R Block or Jackson Hewitt locations offer flat-rate amendment services that might be cheaper than your current preparer's full rate. Also, if your amendment is relatively straightforward (like adding a single 1099 or W-2), you might be able to handle it yourself using tax software - TurboTax and FreeTaxUSA both have amendment features that walk you through the process step by step. Just remember that with consulting income, you'll likely need to file Schedule C and potentially pay self-employment tax, so make sure whoever you choose (or if you do it yourself) understands the full implications of that additional income.

0 coins

Chloe Mitchell

I'm facing a similar situation right now! My tax preparer is also wanting to charge me almost the full fee again for an amended return. Reading through these responses has been really helpful - I didn't realize that amended returns require essentially preparing everything from scratch again. One question I have is about the self-employment tax aspect that was mentioned. If I forgot to include some freelance income (around $3,000), will I definitely owe self-employment tax on that, or does it depend on how much total self-employment income I had for the year? I'm trying to figure out the full financial impact before I decide whether to pay my current preparer or try one of the alternative services mentioned here. Also, has anyone had experience with amended returns that involve both adding income AND claiming additional deductions that were missed? I think I might have some business expenses related to that freelance work that I could deduct.

0 coins

Chloe Martin

Great question about self-employment tax! If your total self-employment income for the year is $400 or more, you'll owe self-employment tax on it (currently 15.3% - that's Social Security and Medicare taxes). So even if this $3,000 was your only freelance income, you'd owe SE tax on the full amount. Regarding business expenses - absolutely include those if you have them! Things like equipment, software, home office expenses, or supplies used for that freelance work can significantly reduce your taxable income. Just make sure you have documentation (receipts, bank statements, etc.) since business deductions on amended returns sometimes get extra scrutiny. I'd recommend calculating the full impact first: additional income tax + self-employment tax - any business deductions. This will help you decide if paying your preparer's fee is worth it versus trying a service like taxr.ai that others mentioned, or even doing it yourself if it's straightforward enough.

0 coins

GalacticGuardian

I'm in a very similar boat! My tax preparer is charging me $325 for an amendment when my original return was $375. I was initially frustrated about the cost, but after reading through all these responses, I'm starting to understand why amendments are priced similarly to original returns. One thing I'm curious about - has anyone dealt with amended returns where you're switching from standard deduction to itemized deductions? I realized after filing that I had enough medical expenses to itemize, but I'm not sure if that makes the amendment more complex or affects the cost. My preparer mentioned something about having to recalculate everything, but I want to understand what I'm paying for. Also, for those who used the alternative services mentioned here (like taxr.ai), did they provide any kind of guarantee or review process? I'm nervous about making a mistake on an amendment since I've heard the IRS scrutinizes them more carefully. The peace of mind might be worth paying my regular preparer, but I'm trying to weigh all my options.

0 coins

Alexis Renard

Switching from standard to itemized deduction can definitely make the amendment more complex, especially if you're doing it mid-year after filing. Your preparer will need to recalculate your entire tax liability using Schedule A, and depending on what deductions you're claiming (medical, state/local taxes, charitable contributions, etc.), they may need to verify you meet all the thresholds and requirements. Medical expenses are particularly tricky since they have to exceed 7.5% of your adjusted gross income to be deductible. Your preparer will need to recalculate this and make sure you have proper documentation for all the expenses you're claiming. Regarding guarantees - most reputable preparers (whether traditional or online services) will stand behind their work and help fix any errors they make. However, the responsibility for providing accurate information still falls on you as the taxpayer. When I've used services like the ones mentioned here, they typically have certified tax professionals review the work before finalizing, which does provide some additional peace of mind. Given the complexity of switching to itemized deductions, you might actually benefit from sticking with your regular preparer who already knows your situation, even if it costs a bit more. The amendment accuracy is crucial since the IRS does give these extra scrutiny.

0 coins