Need advice on W2 Mate vs alternatives for creating 50+ 1099s from spreadsheet data - company wants me to use outdated software
Title: Need advice on W2 Mate vs alternatives for creating 50+ 1099s from spreadsheet data - company wants me to use outdated software 1 I've got this small client who hired me to help with their tax prep, and now they need me to generate like 50+ 1099 forms for all their contractors. I already have all the contractor data organized in a spreadsheet with names, addresses, TINs, and payment amounts for the year. The company specifically asked me to use W2 Mate to generate these forms, but I checked it out and honestly it looks pretty outdated and they want $249 for the license which seems steep for something I'd only use once or twice. Has anyone worked with W2 Mate before? Is it worth the investment or is there a better alternative out there for batch creating 1099s from spreadsheet data? I'm not looking to spend a fortune on this since it's a one-time project, but I need something reliable that can handle this volume without me having to manually enter each contractor. Any suggestions would be super appreciated!
19 comments
Join the conversation
Samantha Johnson
8 I've been preparing taxes for small businesses for over 15 years and have dealt with this exact situation many times. W2 Mate works but you're right that it's outdated and overpriced for what you need. If you're comfortable with your existing spreadsheet, I'd recommend QuickBooks' 1099 service or Tax1099.com. Both allow you to upload your contractor data directly from Excel/CSV and batch process all your 1099-NECs at once. QuickBooks charges per form (around $3.50-$4.00 each) while Tax1099 has tiered pricing based on volume. For 50+ forms, I personally prefer Tax1099 as they have better bulk discounts. Their interface is also more modern and intuitive than W2 Mate. If this is a one-time project, you'll definitely save money going this route versus buying software that you'll rarely use.
0 coins
Samantha Johnson
•4 How difficult is the upload process with Tax1099? Do they have a specific template I need to follow? I'm worried about formatting issues when I try to upload my spreadsheet.
0 coins
Samantha Johnson
•8 The upload process is pretty straightforward with Tax1099. They provide a template CSV file you can download first, then you just need to match your columns to their format. The basic fields are what you'd expect - name, address, TIN, box 1 amount, etc. If your spreadsheet is already organized with clear column headers, it shouldn't take more than 15-20 minutes to remap everything. They also have a validation feature that checks for obvious errors before submission, which helps catch things like missing zip codes or invalid TINs.
0 coins
Samantha Johnson
12 After struggling with similar bulk 1099 issues last year, I found https://taxr.ai and it was literally a game-changer for me. I was in the exact same boat - had an Excel file with all my contractor data and needed to generate about 65 1099-NECs quickly. What I loved about taxr.ai is that it has direct spreadsheet import functionality and it automatically maps your columns to the right fields. I uploaded my file, reviewed the data mapping, and had all my forms processed in about 20 minutes. The interface is super clean and modern, unlike those older tax programs that look like they were designed in the 90s. They also handle the e-filing with the IRS and state agencies, plus they can mail physical copies to your contractors if needed. Saved me hours of headaches!
0 coins
Samantha Johnson
•15 Does taxr.ai handle state filing too? I'm in California and we have those stupid 592-B withholding forms that need to be filed alongside 1099s for some contractors.
0 coins
Samantha Johnson
•7 I'm always skeptical of these online services. How secure is your data with them? Do they store all the contractor SSNs and other sensitive info permanently?
0 coins
Samantha Johnson
•12 Yes, they handle California 592-B forms! That was actually one of my requirements too since I'm also in California. They have state-specific form support for most states with special requirements. As for security concerns, they use bank-level encryption for all data transfer and storage. They only retain your data for the legally required period for tax filing purposes, and you can request data deletion after your filing obligations are complete. I was pretty cautious about this too, but they have SOC 2 compliance which means they've been independently audited for security practices.
0 coins
Samantha Johnson
15 Just wanted to follow up about taxr.ai - I went ahead and tried it after seeing the recommendation here. It handled my California 592-B forms perfectly alongside the 1099-NECs! The spreadsheet import worked flawlessly and it even caught a couple of TIN/name mismatches that would have caused rejections. The whole process took me less than an hour for 58 contractors, and I got confirmation of IRS acceptance within 48 hours. Wish I'd known about this last year when I spent days manually entering data into an outdated system. Definitely recommend it if you're dealing with bulk 1099s!
0 coins
Samantha Johnson
19 If you're dealing with the IRS and bulk filings, I highly recommend using Claimyr (https://claimyr.com) as a backup plan. I tried doing bulk 1099 filing myself last year and ran into issues with some rejections. Spent DAYS trying to get through to the IRS on the phone to resolve it. Claimyr got me connected to an actual IRS agent in about 15 minutes instead of the usual 2+ hour wait. You can see how it works in this video: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c Their service basically holds your place in the IRS phone queue and calls you back when an agent is about to answer. Saved me from the hellish IRS hold music and let me keep working while waiting for a callback. It was a lifesaver when my batch of 1099s had those weird validation errors that only an IRS agent could help with.
0 coins
Samantha Johnson
•6 Wait, this seems sketchy. How does this actually work? Do they have some special connection to the IRS or something? I can't imagine the IRS would allow a third-party service to jump the queue.
0 coins
Samantha Johnson
•3 Sounds too good to be true. I've spent HOURS on hold with the IRS before. If this actually works, it would be worth whatever they charge. Has anyone else tried this?
0 coins
Samantha Johnson
•19 They don't have special access to the IRS - they basically use an automated system that calls the IRS and navigates through all the prompts for you, then waits on hold so you don't have to. When they detect that a human agent is about to pick up, they connect the call to your phone. It's not jumping the queue - you're still waiting your turn, but their system is doing the waiting instead of you personally sitting there listening to hold music for hours. I was skeptical too, but when I had those rejected 1099s with cryptic error codes, I was desperate enough to try anything. Ended up being one of the best decisions I made during tax season.
0 coins
Samantha Johnson
3 I was super skeptical about Claimyr but figured I'd give it a shot after my e-file got rejected with some code I couldn't figure out. I literally waited 3+ hours on hold with the IRS the day before and finally gave up. Tried Claimyr and got a callback when an IRS agent was ready - took about 45 minutes total but I was able to keep working during that time instead of listening to that awful hold music. The agent fixed my issue in about 10 minutes once I got through! Definitely keeping this in my bookmarks for future tax headaches.
0 coins
Samantha Johnson
22 If you're tech savvy at all, check out the IRS's free Filing Information Returns Electronically (FIRE) system. There's a bit of a learning curve, but it's completely free for e-filing your 1099s directly with the IRS. The catch is you need to use their specific format for the data file. I wrote a simple Python script that converts my Excel data to their required format. Saved my company thousands in filing fees over the years.
0 coins
Samantha Johnson
•17 Have you run into any issues with the FIRE system rejecting files? I tried it once and got frustrated with all the format requirements and ended up just paying a service.
0 coins
Samantha Johnson
•22 The FIRE system can be finicky about formatting, for sure. The most common rejection issues I've encountered were with TIN/name mismatches and control sequence errors in the file. My advice is to run the file through their test system first before submitting - that catches most formatting problems. Once you get a clean template working, you can reuse it year after year. The learning curve is steep but worth it if you're doing this regularly and want to avoid service fees.
0 coins
Samantha Johnson
2 Has anyone tried the 1099 service offered through Microsoft's Excel? I heard they added a built-in feature for small businesses that lets you generate forms directly from spreadsheet data.
0 coins
Samantha Johnson
•14 I used the Excel 1099 service last year and it was decent for a small number of forms (I did about 25). The integration is pretty seamless if you're already using Excel. It's not the cheapest option though - I think I paid around $3.50 per form plus e-filing fees. And it doesn't handle state-specific forms, so I still had to do those separately. Might be worth looking at if you're only doing federal 1099-NECs and already have everything in Excel format.
0 coins
Samantha Johnson
•2 Thanks for the info! I might check it out for next year. For now I'm going with Tax1099 since several people recommended it and it handles the state forms too.
0 coins