< Back to IRS

Giovanni Ricci

Managing Remote Workers Across Multiple States - Nexus and Tax Filing Requirements

I've been researching a situation we're facing next year with employees working remotely across 7 different states. Our actual business operations (medical device R&D) are only happening in one state, but from what I'm finding, having remote workers could create nexus in each of those states. Does having remote employees mean we need to register as a foreign entity in all these states? And the bigger question - would we have to pay state taxes on ALL our profits in EVERY state, or just on whatever portion is generated in each state? It seems absolutely crazy that having a remote worker would require all that administrative burden and tax complexity. I'm wondering how big companies handle this - there must be some reasonable approach? Is there any feasible workaround to avoid getting tangled in multi-state tax nightmares just because we have remote staff? Thanks for any insights you can share!

NeonNomad

•

Having remote workers across multiple states definitely creates some tax complexity, but it's manageable! When you have employees working in different states, you typically do create "nexus" (a tax presence) in those states, which generally means you need to register as a foreign entity in each state. The good news is you don't pay taxes on all your profits in every state - that would be double or triple taxation! Instead, most states require "apportionment" where you allocate your business income based on certain factors like payroll, property, and sales in each state. So you'd only pay tax on the portion of income attributable to each state. For the registration part, yes, you'll need to register as a foreign entity doing business in each state where you have employees. This usually involves filing with the Secretary of State and getting registered with the Department of Revenue.

0 coins

Thanks for the explanation! So basically we would need to figure out what portion of our business income came from activities in each state? How exactly do companies typically calculate this - is it based on the employee's salary as a percentage of overall payroll? And does this mean we'd need to file tax returns in all 7 states?

0 coins

NeonNomad

•

Yes, you'll need to apportion your income across the states. The calculation varies by state, but typically involves a formula using payroll, property, and sales factors. Many states now use a single-sales factor formula, but for states using multiple factors, you'd calculate the percentage of your total payroll that's in each state, same for property, then average those percentages to determine how much income is attributable there. And yes, you would need to file tax returns in all states where you have nexus. You might also need to register for unemployment insurance and workers' compensation in each state where you have employees. I'd recommend working with a CPA experienced in multi-state taxation to help set up a system for tracking these obligations.

0 coins

After dealing with something similar last year, I found this amazing online tool that saved me tons of headaches with multi-state tax compliance. Check out https://taxr.ai - it helped me figure out exactly which states I needed to register in based on my remote workforce and what tax obligations I had in each one. The system actually analyzes your specific situation and tells you where you have nexus and what your filing requirements are. For my business with 5 remote workers in different states, it saved me from overpaying in some states while making sure I was compliant everywhere I needed to be. Really helped me avoid some potential audit nightmares.

0 coins

That sounds interesting. Does it actually file the taxes for you in each state or just tell you where you need to file? And how does it determine the income allocation between states?

0 coins

I'm skeptical about these online tax tools. Most of them miss nuances in state tax laws. Like how some states have economic nexus thresholds that might exempt small businesses. Does this one account for those differences?

0 coins

It doesn't file the taxes for you, but it gives you a detailed report of where you need to register and file based on your specific situation. It provides guidance on income allocation methods for each state where you have nexus, showing which states use single-sales factor, which use three-factor formulas, and how to apply them. Yes, it absolutely accounts for economic nexus thresholds! That's one of its best features - it analyzes each state's specific rules, including minimum thresholds for both physical and economic nexus. It saved me from unnecessary filings in two states where I was actually below the economic nexus threshold despite having a small amount of sales there.

0 coins

I was super skeptical about online tax tools for multi-state issues, but I decided to try https://taxr.ai after seeing it mentioned here. Honestly, it was eye-opening! I discovered I was unnecessarily registered in 2 states where my activities were actually below their nexus thresholds, and I was missing a filing obligation in another state. The report it generated saved me so much research time and probably thousands in consulting fees. My accountant was actually impressed with the detailed analysis of our nexus situation and the state-specific breakdowns of apportionment formulas. For anyone dealing with the multi-state employee headache, this is definitely worth checking out.

0 coins

Dmitry Volkov

•

I've been dealing with multi-state tax issues for years with remote workers, and calling the state tax departments directly is absolutely maddening. After wasting days on hold trying to get answers about New York's rules, I tried https://claimyr.com to get through to an actual human at the tax department. You can see how it works here: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c They basically wait on hold with the state tax departments for you, then call you when they get a representative on the line. Saved me literally hours of hold time and I finally got clear answers about our filing requirements from an actual tax department employee. This plus a good multi-state tax accountant has made our compliance process so much more manageable.

0 coins

Ava Thompson

•

How does this actually work though? Like they just sit on hold instead of you? What's stopping the tax department from just hanging up when they transfer the call?

0 coins

CyberSiren

•

This sounds like total BS honestly. State tax departments barely answer their phones for anyone. And even if you do get through, the person who answers probably won't know the answer to complex nexus questions. You need a real tax attorney who specializes in multi-state taxation.

0 coins

Dmitry Volkov

•

They use a system that monitors the hold queue and then calls you when they've got a representative on the line. The tax department doesn't know the call is being transferred - it's seamless from their perspective, so there's no hanging up. You just suddenly have a tax rep on the phone ready to answer your questions. I completely understand the skepticism - I felt the same way! But most times, getting direct answers from the actual tax authority is valuable even for just confirming what your tax attorney advises. State departments won't give complex legal advice, but they will confirm filing requirements, deadlines, and basic nexus rules which is super helpful when you're trying to stay compliant across multiple states.

0 coins

CyberSiren

•

OK I need to eat my words from earlier. After my accountant recommended it, I reluctantly tried Claimyr to help get answers from California and New York tax departments about our nexus situation with remote workers. Instead of spending 2+ hours on hold (which I've done before), I got calls back within 45 minutes with actual tax department representatives on the line. Got clear confirmation about our filing obligations and registration requirements that matched what our accountant thought but wanted to verify. For California especially, getting that direct confirmation about our specific situation was invaluable since their rules are so complex. Not a replacement for good tax advice, but definitely a time-saving tool when you need to hear directly from the state.

0 coins

One workaround some companies use is contracting with a Professional Employer Organization (PEO) that acts as the employer of record. The PEO handles payroll, benefits, and employment tax filings across all states, and your workers become legally employed by the PEO while working for you. This can significantly reduce your multi-state compliance burden. Companies like TriNet, Insperity, and Justworks offer these services. It's not cheap, but it might be less expensive and less hassle than managing registrations and tax filings across 7 states yourself. Might be worth exploring depending on how many employees you have in each state.

0 coins

That's a really interesting solution I hadn't considered! Do you know roughly what the cost difference might be between using a PEO versus handling all the state registrations and filings ourselves? And does using a PEO completely eliminate our nexus in those states or just simplify the employment tax side?

0 coins

PEO costs typically run between $85-$150 per employee per month depending on the services included and how many employees you have. Compare that to the costs of state registrations (which can be $100-$500 per state initially), annual report fees, registered agent fees ($100-$300 annually per state), plus accounting costs for multiple state tax returns ($500-$2,000 per state). The PEO only addresses the employment side - it handles payroll taxes, unemployment, workers comp, and benefits administration across states. It doesn't completely eliminate nexus, as you'd still have business activity in those states. However, it does simplify the most complex part of multi-state operations (employment compliance) and eliminates the need to register for payroll taxes in each state.

0 coins

Zainab Yusuf

•

Don't forget about local taxes too! Some cities and counties have their own income taxes on top of state taxes (like NYC, Philadelphia, San Francisco). I got hit with penalties because I didn't realize my remote employee in Ohio was subject to municipal taxes. Make sure you're accounting for ALL tax jurisdictions when figuring out your compliance strategy.

0 coins

This is so true. We have an employee in Pennsylvania and got blindsided by the local tax requirements. Each municipality has different rates and filing requirements. It's insane how complicated this gets beyond just the state level.

0 coins

Freya Thomsen

•

This is such a common challenge for growing businesses! I've been through this exact situation with our company when we expanded to remote workers in 6 states. Here's what I learned: Yes, you'll likely need to register as a foreign entity in each state where you have employees, but the good news is that you won't pay full taxes on all profits in every state. Each state uses apportionment formulas to determine what portion of your income is taxable there - typically based on factors like payroll, property, and sales in that state. The key is getting organized early. I'd recommend: 1. Document exactly what business activities happen in each state (not just where employees live) 2. Understand each state's specific nexus thresholds - some have minimum requirements before you need to file 3. Consider whether your remote workers are just living in those states vs. actually conducting business there For a medical device R&D company, if your actual R&D activities and operations are centralized in one state, you might have less nexus exposure than you think. The remote workers might just create payroll tax obligations rather than full business income tax nexus in some states. Definitely worth consulting with a multi-state tax specialist to map out your specific situation before diving into registrations everywhere.

0 coins

This is exactly the kind of scenario that keeps business owners up at night! I went through something similar when we had remote employees in 4 states. One thing that really helped was creating a detailed matrix of each state's requirements - not just for income taxes, but also for sales tax, unemployment insurance, workers' compensation, and any professional licensing requirements. A few additional considerations that caught me off guard: - Some states have "throwback" rules that can affect your apportionment calculations - Certain states have different nexus thresholds for different types of taxes (income vs. sales vs. payroll) - If any of your remote workers are handling sales activities, that could create additional nexus considerations beyond just having employees For medical device R&D specifically, you'll want to pay close attention to where your intellectual property is being developed and used. Some states have specific rules about how IP income gets sourced and taxed. The administrative burden is real, but there are definitely strategies to streamline it. Consider implementing a centralized system for tracking employee work locations and activities from day one - it makes the apportionment calculations much easier come tax time. Would be happy to share more specifics about what worked for us if you're interested!

0 coins

Sofia Perez

•

This is incredibly helpful, thank you! The point about IP development location is something I hadn't even considered - that could definitely complicate things for our R&D operations. Would you mind sharing what that centralized tracking system looked like for your company? I'm trying to figure out the best way to document employee activities across states from the beginning rather than trying to reconstruct it later when tax time comes around. Also, when you mention "throwback" rules affecting apportionment - can you give an example of how that might work in practice? I want to make sure I understand all the potential complications before I start setting up our compliance framework.

0 coins

IRS AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
20,087 users helped today