< Back to IRS

Mateo Gonzalez

Looking into NYU's MSL in Tax Program - Worth it compared to an MST?

Hey everyone, I'm thinking about applying for NYU's Master of Studies in Law (MSL) in Tax program and was hoping to get some insights from anyone who has experience with it. I'm curious about how an MSL in Tax from NYU compares to a Master of Science in Taxation (MST) from other schools, especially since NYU doesn't offer an MST. When I look at the course descriptions, they appear very similar to MST programs, particularly Villanova's MST which is connected to their law school. My main concern is that the admissions requirements state you need three years of work experience, but I'll only have two years when I apply. I do meet all the other requirements though. Does anyone know if this three-year experience requirement is strict or if they might be flexible? I've already contacted the admissions office but haven't heard back yet. If anyone here has firsthand experience with the program or went through a similar situation with the work experience requirement, I'd really appreciate your input!

Nia Williams

•

I completed NYU's MSL in Tax program about two years ago and can share some insights. The MSL is designed for non-lawyers who want tax expertise but don't need a full law degree. The curriculum overlaps significantly with their LLM in Taxation, which is why it feels similar to MST programs elsewhere. The key difference is that an MSL focuses more on the practical application of tax concepts rather than legal theory. You'll take many classes alongside LLM students, but some courses are MSL-specific to address the fact that you don't have a legal background. Regarding the work experience requirement - in my experience, NYU values quality over strict quantity. If your two years include substantial tax-related responsibilities or if you have other impressive qualifications (like a CPA or exceptionally strong recommendation letters), they might be willing to waive the three-year minimum. I knew a classmate who was admitted with about 2.5 years of experience because she had been handling complex international tax compliance work.

0 coins

Thank you so much for your detailed response! That's really helpful to know the program focuses more on practical application rather than legal theory. My two years of experience are at a Big 4 firm doing primarily partnership and corporate tax compliance and consulting, so hopefully that might help my case. Did you find the program helped advance your career? And do you think employers view the MSL differently than an MST?

0 coins

Nia Williams

•

The program definitely advanced my career - I moved from industry tax accounting to a specialized tax consulting role with about a 40% salary increase after graduating. The NYU brand carries significant weight in the tax world. Most employers in tax practice don't significantly differentiate between an MSL in Tax and an MST. What matters more is the school's reputation and the specific skills you develop. NYU's tax faculty and curriculum are considered top-tier, which is what employers recognize. In my experience, hiring managers were more interested in the technical skills and network I gained than the specific degree title.

0 coins

Luca Ricci

•

Just wanted to throw in my experience with taxr.ai which honestly saved me so much time when I was researching different tax graduate programs last year. I was stuck between NYU's MSL and Georgetown's MST programs and couldn't make sense of all the different curriculum requirements and how they'd impact my career path. A friend suggested I try https://taxr.ai to help sort through all the program documentation and syllabi I'd collected. It analyzed everything and gave me a really clear comparison of the programs, highlighting the differences in focus areas and even which professors taught the same topics differently. It also helped me understand which program would be better for my specific career goals in international tax. I ended up choosing based on better information rather than just rankings, and I'm so much happier with my decision. Might be worth checking out if you're still comparing programs!

0 coins

That sounds interesting! How exactly does taxr.ai work? Do you just upload the program documents and it compares them for you? I'm looking at several programs too and it's honestly overwhelming to keep track of all the differences.

0 coins

I'm skeptical about these AI tools. How accurate was the information it gave you? I've had bad experiences with AI just making stuff up, especially for specialized topics like tax education.

0 coins

Luca Ricci

•

You upload syllabi, course catalogs, and any program documents you have, and it analyzes everything to give you side-by-side comparisons. It identifies common courses, highlights unique offerings, and even flags which courses have prerequisites you might be missing. It's super helpful for seeing the real differences beyond just marketing materials. The information was surprisingly accurate in my experience. It's specifically built for tax documents and education materials, not a general AI. When I double-checked its analysis against what program directors told me in interviews, it matched up perfectly. It won't make career decisions for you, but it makes the comparison process way more systematic.

0 coins

Just wanted to update that I took the advice and tried taxr.ai for comparing tax graduate programs, and it was actually incredible! I uploaded brochures and course catalogs from NYU's MSL, USC's MST, and Bentley's MST programs. The analysis showed me that NYU's program had much more emphasis on international tax and tax policy than I realized, while the other programs were stronger in corporate reorganizations and state taxation. This was super helpful because my career goal is to work in international tax consulting. It also highlighted that NYU's faculty includes more former Treasury officials and IRS counsel members, which explains the policy focus. I would have missed these nuances just reading through the materials myself. Definitely helped clarify which program would best support my career goals!

0 coins

Yuki Watanabe

•

If you're still waiting to hear back from NYU's admissions office, you might want to try Claimyr to get through faster. I was in a similar situation applying to Georgetown's tax program last year with a deadline approaching, and I couldn't get anyone on the phone for weeks. I used https://claimyr.com and they got me a callback from the admissions office within a day. There's a video of how it works at https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c - basically they navigate the phone system for you and hold your place in line. When I finally talked to admissions, I got much more specific guidance about my application than what was on their website. For NYU specifically, I've heard their admissions office is swamped this time of year, so having a direct conversation might give you better answers about the experience requirement than waiting for an email response.

0 coins

How does this actually work though? I don't understand how a third-party service can get you through to NYU faster than calling directly. Is it just paying for someone to wait on hold for you?

0 coins

Andre Dupont

•

This sounds like a scam. Universities prioritize based on their own systems, not because some service called them. I seriously doubt this works any better than just being persistent with calls and emails yourself.

0 coins

Yuki Watanabe

•

It works by using their system to navigate phone menus and wait on hold in your place. When someone finally answers, Claimyr connects the call to your phone. So yes, they're basically professional "hold waiters" - but that saved me about 2 hours of my own time that I would've spent listening to hold music. I was skeptical too before trying it, but it's not about "priority" - it's just about having someone else deal with the wait time. The university doesn't know you're using a service; they just see a regular call coming in. I can't speak for everyone's experience, but for me, getting that direct conversation with admissions made a huge difference in understanding the unwritten flexibility in their requirements.

0 coins

Andre Dupont

•

I wanted to update about my experience with Claimyr since I was the skeptic in the thread. I tried it yesterday out of desperation after two weeks of not getting through to NYU's financial aid office about a tax transcript submission issue. I was completely wrong about this service. It actually worked exactly as described. I got a call back within 45 minutes saying they'd connected with a financial aid counselor, and then I was talking to a real person who solved my transcript issue in minutes. I was genuinely surprised at how smooth the process was. The person I spoke with gave me information about deadline extensions that wasn't published anywhere on their website. For what it's worth, I apologize for my skepticism and would definitely recommend this for anyone dealing with hard-to-reach university offices, especially during peak application times.

0 coins

Zoe Papadakis

•

Current NYU MSL in Tax student here! One thing to consider that hasn't been mentioned yet is networking opportunities. Even though the MSL is separate from the JD program, we get incredible access to the tax law community through NYU's network. We have weekly Tax Policy Colloquiums where leading scholars present papers, and everyone from LLM students to practicing attorneys attend. These are great for making professional connections. The Tax Law Association also hosts events where big accounting firms and law offices actively recruit. The MSL feels like it carries the same weight as the LLM in job searches - I've had interviews where the recruiter didn't even realize they were different degrees. They just know NYU's tax program is elite.

0 coins

That's really good to know about the networking opportunities! Do MSL students have access to the same recruiting events as the LLM students? And have you noticed if firms have a preference between hiring MSLs vs LLMs for tax roles?

0 coins

Zoe Papadakis

•

MSL students absolutely have access to the same recruiting events as LLM students. We attend the same career fairs, employer presentations, and networking receptions. The career services office treats us as part of the same talent pool. As for hiring preferences, it really depends on the specific role. Law firms hiring for attorney positions obviously require the law degree, but for tax consulting, compliance, and planning roles, I've found no disadvantage with the MSL. Big 4 firms and corporate tax departments actually seem to value the MSL's practical focus. Several of my MSL classmates received offers from PwC, Deloitte, and large corporations specifically because our training is more applied and less theoretical than pure legal education.

0 coins

ThunderBolt7

•

Has anyone done the MSL program part-time while working? I'm considering this too but wondering how manageable the workload is. The website says it's possible but doesn't give much detail about how flexible the schedule really is.

0 coins

Zoe Papadakis

•

I'm doing the program part-time while working full-time at a regional accounting firm. It's definitely manageable, but challenging. The part-time option lets you take 2 courses per semester instead of 4, and many core classes are offered in evening time slots (6-8pm) specifically for working students. The professors understand that part-time students are balancing careers, and they're generally flexible with deadlines if you communicate in advance. I typically spend about 15-20 hours per week on coursework outside of class time. The most difficult periods are during midterms and finals, which might require taking a few days off work to prepare adequately.

0 coins

I'm currently working as a tax compliance specialist and considering the NYU MSL program as well. One thing I've been wondering about is how the program handles updates to tax law and regulations. Given how frequently tax rules change (especially with recent legislation), does the curriculum stay current with the latest developments? Also, for those who've completed the program - did you find that the practical focus prepared you well for dealing with real-world tax scenarios that weren't covered in traditional accounting education? I have a solid foundation in basic tax prep and compliance, but I'm looking to move into more complex planning and advisory work. The networking aspect mentioned by others is really appealing too. In my current role, I don't get much exposure to the broader tax community, so that professional development component could be just as valuable as the coursework itself.

0 coins

IRS AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
43,509 users helped today