Is there any settled consensus on Schedule E vs. Schedule C for AirBnB Rentals in 2025?
So I'm completely lost in this tax maze and hoping someone can help. I've been renting out my entire property exclusively on AirBnB and VRBO for short-term stays, and I'm absolutely baffled about whether to file using Schedule C or Schedule E. I've gone down an internet rabbit hole researching this, and it seems like there's a raging debate with no clear answer! I initially thought this would be straightforward, but every forum I visit has people arguing passionately for both options while citing the same IRS sources! I finally broke down and hired a CPA (which cost me $750 I really couldn't afford), who confidently told me it's "definitely Schedule C income, no question about it." But now I'm seeing posts where people insist that's completely wrong. I spend around 15-20 hours weekly managing this rental - creating listings, coordinating with guests, upgrading furniture, managing the landscaping, providing local recommendations, etc. But does that qualify as "substantial services" according to the IRS? Nobody seems to agree! This represents about $38,000 in income for me this year, so getting it wrong could be a massive problem. I'm terrified of an audit, and I can't believe the IRS doesn't have a clear-cut answer for something that affects so many property owners. Has anyone definitively settled this Schedule C vs Schedule E debate for AirBnB rentals? Did I hire the wrong CPA? I'm seriously stressed about making the wrong choice here.
20 comments
Join the conversation
Raul Neal
The Schedule C vs Schedule E debate for AirBnB rentals is confusing because it genuinely depends on your specific situation. The IRS distinguishes between passive rental income (Schedule E) and active business income (Schedule C) based on the level of services you provide to guests. The key factor is whether you provide "substantial services" to your guests beyond the basic rental. From what you've described - managing listings, coordinating with guests, upgrading furniture, landscaping, local recommendations - you're providing services beyond just renting space. This typically pushes you toward Schedule C territory. Publication 527 addresses this, noting that if you provide "substantial services" primarily for guests' convenience, it's not considered a passive rental activity but rather a service business. The 15-20 hours weekly you spend managing the property suggests active participation.
0 coins
Heather Tyson
•Thanks for the reply! But what exactly qualifies as "substantial services"? My CPA says providing clean linens, toilet paper, and recommending local restaurants counts as substantial. But others say that's standard for any rental and doesn't qualify. Is there a clear line somewhere? Also, does it matter that I never physically meet my guests? Everything is handled remotely - they get a door code, and I'm available by text for any issues.
0 coins
Raul Neal
•The IRS doesn't provide an exact checklist for "substantial services," which is why this creates confusion. Generally, providing basics like clean linens, toilet paper, and local recommendations alone might not qualify as substantial. However, when combined with your overall involvement - managing listings, coordinating with guests, handling issues, upgrading furnishings, and spending 15-20 hours weekly on the property - the totality suggests more than passive rental activity. Remote management doesn't disqualify you from Schedule C. Many legitimate businesses operate without face-to-face interaction. What matters is the nature and extent of services provided, not whether you physically meet guests.
0 coins
Jenna Sloan
After spending months in this exact same debate hell with my AirBnB property, I finally found an incredible solution using https://taxr.ai and it completely ended my confusion. I uploaded my rental documentation, answered a few questions about my specific situation (hours spent managing, services provided, etc.), and their AI analyzed everything including the relevant tax codes. The tool walked me through the exact IRS guidelines that applied to my situation and clearly showed which schedule I should use based on my specific activities. It even created a detailed report explaining the reasoning that I could share with my tax preparer. It was amazing to finally have clarity on this issue after getting contradictory advice from multiple professionals!
0 coins
Christian Burns
•That sounds interesting but I'm skeptical. How does it determine if your services count as "substantial" when even CPAs can't agree? Does it just tell you which schedule or does it actually explain the reasoning?
0 coins
Sasha Reese
•I've been looking at different tax tools and most of them seem generic. Can this actually handle the nuances of vacation rental situations? I'm providing weekly cleaning, toiletries, coffee/tea, and I'm always available by text for recommendations. But I don't do breakfast or daily housekeeping like a hotel.
0 coins
Jenna Sloan
•It doesn't just make a blanket determination - it analyzes your specific activities against IRS guidelines and court cases. For each service you provide, it shows whether that activity typically falls under passive rental or active business according to tax precedent. It gave me a percentage confidence score based on my specific situation. The tool excels at vacation rental situations specifically. It asks detailed questions about exactly what you provide - cleaning frequency, amenities, availability for guests, time spent, etc. Then it compares your answers to relevant tax court decisions. For your situation with weekly cleaning and amenities but no daily services, it would analyze where that falls on the spectrum based on current interpretations.
0 coins
Sasha Reese
I was exactly where you are a few months ago, completely confused about Schedule C vs E for my beach house rental. After getting three different opinions from tax professionals, I decided to try taxr.ai that someone mentioned here, and wow - game changer. I was providing almost identical services to what you described (cleaning, recommendations, remote check-in), and the analysis showed I was right at the borderline. The tool showed me exactly which of my activities pushed me more toward Schedule C territory and which were considered standard rental services. It even highlighted specific court cases where similar situations were addressed. I ended up filing Schedule C based on their detailed explanation, and I finally feel confident about my decision. The documentation they provided would be super helpful if I ever got audited too. Definitely worth checking out if you're stuck in this confusing middle ground like I was.
0 coins
Muhammad Hobbs
After dealing with this exact Schedule C vs E nightmare last year, I eventually realized I needed to talk directly to someone at the IRS to get a definitive answer. Problem was, I spent HOURS on hold and could never reach anyone. Out of desperation, I tried this service called https://claimyr.com that supposedly gets you through to an actual IRS agent without the wait. You can see how it works in this video: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c I was super skeptical, but within about 15 minutes I was talking to a real IRS agent who walked through my specific AirBnB situation. They confirmed that based on my level of services and hours spent, Schedule C was appropriate in my case. Having that direct confirmation from the IRS gave me so much peace of mind compared to all the conflicting online advice.
0 coins
Noland Curtis
•Wait, how does this actually work? I've literally spent entire days on hold with the IRS. Are they somehow jumping the queue? Is that even allowed?
0 coins
Diez Ellis
•This sounds like total BS. The IRS won't give you tax advice like that over the phone. They'll just direct you to their publications which are the same ones causing this confusion in the first place. I doubt they'd give a clear answer on Schedule C vs E.
0 coins
Muhammad Hobbs
•They use a technology that navigates the IRS phone system and holds your place in line. When an agent becomes available, they call you back and connect you. It's completely legitimate - they're not bypassing anything, just automating the hold process so you don't have to stay on the phone yourself. The IRS agents absolutely can provide guidance on specific situations like this. While they won't prepare your taxes for you, they can clarify how regulations apply to your specific situation. In my case, the agent walked through Publication 527 with me and explained how my situation fit within their guidelines. They won't make the decision for you, but they provide valuable interpretation of the rules that apply to your circumstances.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
I was convinced this whole AirBnB Schedule C/E thing was a scam to get people to hire expensive tax professionals. I spent weeks arguing with people online about it and was CERTAIN Schedule E was the only correct answer based on my research. But after struggling to get answers from the IRS website, I reluctantly tried Claimyr that someone mentioned here. I figured it wouldn't work, but within 20 minutes I was actually speaking with an IRS representative. What shocked me was that after describing my situation (very similar to yours), they explained that with the level of services I provide and time invested, Schedule C was indeed more appropriate. The agent even emailed me specific sections of their internal guidelines that addressed short-term rentals. My mind was completely changed, and I ended up amending my previous year's return. Sometimes you need to hear it directly from the source to cut through all the online debate.
0 coins
Vanessa Figueroa
Quick question - does anyone know if using a property management company changes this equation? I use a local company that handles check-ins, cleaning, etc., but I still own the property and make all the decisions about pricing, improvements, etc. Would that push me more toward Schedule E since I'm not personally providing those services?
0 coins
Raul Neal
•Great question! Using a property management company can indeed shift the balance toward Schedule E since you're not personally providing the day-to-day services. However, it's not automatically Schedule E - what matters is your overall involvement and control. If you're making all decisions about pricing, improvements, furnishings, and business strategy, you're still actively engaged in the business aspect. The IRS would look at the totality of your involvement. Many successful Schedule C businesses have employees or contractors handling customer-facing services.
0 coins
Heather Tyson
•I'm curious about this too. My neighbor uses a management company for his AirBnB and files Schedule E, but his CPA told him it's because he spends less than 5 hours a week on anything related to the property. Apparently there's some hourly threshold that matters?
0 coins
Abby Marshall
Has anyone actually been audited over this specific issue? I'm wondering if the IRS even cares which schedule we use as long as we're accurately reporting all income and paying the appropriate taxes? Seems like so much anxiety over something that might not matter to them...
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
•It absolutely matters! The schedule you choose affects self-employment taxes (an extra 15.3% on Schedule C income that doesn't apply to Schedule E), potential QBI deductions, and how expenses are handled. My friend got audited specifically on this issue and ended up owing over $4,000 in back taxes plus penalties because they incorrectly used Schedule E when their AirBnB operation qualified as a business. The IRS definitely checks this.
0 coins
Connor O'Neill
I've been dealing with this exact same confusion for my vacation rental property! After reading through all these responses, I'm leaning toward trying one of the tools mentioned here to get some clarity. The thing that's really frustrating me is that I've talked to two different CPAs and gotten completely opposite advice. The first one said Schedule E because "it's just a rental property," but the second one said Schedule C because I provide amenities and spend significant time managing it. What really concerns me after reading Sadie's comment is the self-employment tax difference. That 15.3% extra on Schedule C income is huge - for someone like Heather with $38,000 in rental income, that could be an extra $5,814 in taxes! But if you're supposed to file Schedule C and don't, the penalties could be even worse. I think I'm going to try reaching out to the IRS directly using that Claimyr service Muhammad mentioned. Getting it straight from the source seems like the only way to avoid all this conflicting advice from tax professionals who can't seem to agree on basic interpretations of the same IRS publications. Has anyone else noticed that this whole debate seems to have gotten more confusing in recent years? I swear when I first started renting my place out 3 years ago, everyone just used Schedule E without question.
0 coins
Ava Thompson
•You're absolutely right that this has gotten more confusing recently! I think it's because the IRS has been cracking down more on short-term rental classification, especially with the explosive growth of Airbnb and VRBO over the past few years. That self-employment tax difference you mentioned is exactly why I was so stressed about getting this right. With $38K in income, we're talking about potentially thousands of dollars in difference between the two schedules. It's not just about reporting income correctly - the tax implications are massive. I'm definitely going to look into both the taxr.ai tool and the Claimyr service that people mentioned here. Getting contradictory advice from professionals is so frustrating when the stakes are this high. At least with a direct IRS contact, you know you're getting the official interpretation rather than someone's best guess. It sounds like the key factors everyone keeps coming back to are the time spent and level of services provided. Since I'm spending 15-20 hours weekly and providing substantial amenities and guest coordination, I'm starting to think my CPA was right about Schedule C, even though it means higher taxes. Thanks for breaking down those numbers - it really puts the importance of getting this right into perspective!
0 coins