Back to IRS

Jibriel Kohn

How to transfer Roth IRA to another bank — IRS implications I didn't expect

Switched jobs earlier this year and finally got around to consolidating my retirement accounts. My Roth IRA has been sitting at one institution for about six years, and I want to move it to the bank where I already have everything else. The transfer itself seems straightforward from the financial side but I'm getting confused about the IRS piece. Does the IRS get notified when you do this? Do I need to report anything on my tax return? I've heard there's a difference between a direct transfer and a rollover and that one of them has a 60-day deadline and can only be done once a year — but I'm not sure which is which or whether that even applies when you're just moving between banks and not changing account types. Last thing I want is to accidentally trigger a taxable event or get a notice from the IRS saying I owe something. Anyone been through this?

Refund from my 2025 return took way longer than expected to show up after I filed on extension in October. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) so IRS would pick up the phone while I was at work — ended up on the line with a live agent who pulled up my account and confirmed the exact refund amount and the date it had been issued. The agent said the deposit date was already set, so I just had to wait for it to clear. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at the IRS: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c On your actual question: a direct trustee-to-trustee transfer between two IRA custodians isn't reported on your tax return and the IRS has no limit on how many you do per year. The 60-day rule and the once-per-year cap apply to the indirect rollover — where the old institution cuts you a check and you deposit it yourself at the new place. That's the one to avoid if you can. Tell both banks you want a direct transfer and get it in writing.

0 coins

Thank you — so if I ask both banks to handle it directly between themselves I never even touch the money and there's no 60-day clock ticking?

0 coins

Exactly right. When the check never comes to you personally, the once-per-year rollover rule doesn't apply. The institutions handle the paperwork.

0 coins

Worth noting: even with a direct transfer, you'll likely get a 1099-R from the old custodian at year-end. The code on it will show it was a non-taxable transfer, but you still see the form.

0 coins

Went through almost the same situation two years ago when I consolidated three Roth IRAs into one. The thing that confused me most was the 1099-R that showed up in January — it looked scary, like I'd made a taxable withdrawal. But the distribution code in box 7 indicated it was a direct rollover, so it didn't add to my taxable income. Your tax software or preparer will know what to do with it.

0 coins

So I'll see that form even if no money actually came to me — that's the part that had me worried. Good to know the code on it explains everything.

0 coins

You'll also receive a 5498 from the new institution confirming the funds arrived, though that one comes in May, after the April filing deadline. Keep it for your records.

0 coins

I panicked over a 1099-R the first time I did a rollover too. The distribution code is the key — once my preparer showed me which code meant non-taxable I stopped worrying.

0 coins

The difference between direct and indirect matters a lot more than most people realize. With indirect, the sending institution is required by law to withhold 20% of the amount for taxes — except that rule applies to traditional IRAs and employer plans, not Roth IRAs, so you may not face withholding on a Roth specifically. But the 60-day window and the once-per-year limit on indirect rollovers still apply regardless. If you miss the 60 days, the amount not deposited gets treated as a distribution. For a Roth the tax hit depends on whether the earnings portion comes out, but either way it's a mess you don't want.

0 coins

The 20% withholding piece I hadn't heard before — glad I asked. Even if it doesn't apply to Roth I would have been blindsided.

0 coins

Good clarification. A lot of people mix up the rules because they heard them for a 401k rollover and assumed Roth IRA works the same. The withholding obligation differs by account type.

0 coins

The once-per-year indirect rollover limit is per taxpayer across all IRAs combined, not per account. So if you've already done one indirect IRA rollover in the past 12 months, a second one would be a problem even if it's a different IRA.

0 coins

Something that tripped me up: the new bank's IRA application asked whether I was rolling over or transferring, and I didn't know which box to check. Turns out they meant the same distinction — direct transfer vs. indirect rollover. Checking the wrong box caused a delay because they set it up as a rollover contribution and had to redo the paperwork. Ask them specifically for a 'direct trustee-to-trustee transfer' and spell it out that way.

0 coins

That paperwork confusion is exactly the kind of thing I'd walk into. I'll use that exact phrase.

0 coins

Banks call it different things — 'in-kind transfer,' 'direct transfer,' 'trustee-to-trustee.' Getting both institutions on a three-way call to coordinate helped me avoid a week of back-and-forth.

0 coins

My new credit union asked for a 'transfer of assets' form from the sending institution. The names vary but the concept is the same — you're never taking possession of the funds.

0 coins

Curious whether there's any IRS deadline for when a Roth IRA transfer has to be completed. Like if I start the process in December is there a problem if the funds don't arrive until January of the new year?

0 coins

No IRS deadline on direct transfers — they can straddle calendar years without tax consequences. The 1099-R and 5498 will just reflect whichever year the transactions occurred in.

0 coins

The only deadline to watch for is whether you're making a contribution rather than a transfer. Annual IRA contribution limits and deadlines are separate from transfer rules, so make sure the new institution codes it as a transfer, not a new contribution.

0 coins

That distinction between a transfer and a new contribution hadn't occurred to me. I'll make sure to tell them upfront what I'm doing so they code it correctly.

0 coins

Had a CP14 land in my mailbox in September showing I owed a balance for tax year 2024 that I was pretty sure I'd paid. Claimyr handled the hold time on 800-829-1040 for me — an agent pulled up my account and read off the balance still showing for that year and confirmed which payment had posted and which one hadn't. Turned out a payment I thought cleared hadn't been applied to the right period. I sent in a copy of the payment confirmation and got a corrected notice a few weeks later.

0 coins

Balance discrepancies like that are so stressful. Good that the agent could actually see the payment history by tax year.

0 coins

The IRS Online Account at https://www.irs.gov/your-account shows payment history too if you want to check before calling. I could see the payments listed but couldn't tell from there why one wasn't applied — that's why I needed the phone.

0 coins

A payment applied to the wrong tax year is more common than people think. The confirmation number from the payment is the key piece to have when you call.

0 coins

My Roth transfer question is a little different — I inherited a Roth IRA from a family member and need to move it to a new custodian. Does the same direct transfer approach apply, or are inherited Roth IRAs handled differently?

0 coins

Inherited IRAs have different rules around distributions and beneficiary classifications that go beyond what most of us know from our own accounts. The IRS has guidance on inherited IRAs on irs.gov and the new custodian's IRA department should walk you through the options before you initiate anything.

0 coins

Agreed — don't assume the standard transfer rules apply to an inherited account. Talk to a tax professional before moving it, because the type of beneficiary you are (spouse vs. non-spouse, eligible designated vs. not) changes what's allowed and when distributions have to start.

0 coins

Didn't realize inherited accounts were a whole separate category. I'll talk to a CPA before I do anything.

0 coins

Filed my 2025 return on extension back in October and I'm still waiting on the refund. Where's My Refund has been showing 'your return is being processed' for about six weeks now with no update. How long is too long before I should be doing something about it?

0 coins

A paper return mailed to the IRS can take six weeks or more just for the IRS to open and log it, so six weeks of 'being processed' isn't unusual for an October extension filer. The IRS says to allow more time for mailed returns before expecting any movement in Where's My Refund.

0 coins

Mine was e-filed, though. Does that change the timeline?

0 coins

E-filed returns are usually faster — a few weeks from the acceptance date in normal cases. If yours has been six weeks with no movement and no notice from the IRS, it might be worth calling 800-829-1040 or checking your IRS Online Account to see if anything is pending on their end.

0 coins

The year I did my Roth transfer, I forgot to tell my new bank that the account should be classified as a Roth, not a traditional IRA. They set it up as traditional by default. Catching that before any transactions posted saved a lot of headaches — make sure you confirm the account type in writing when you open the receiving account.

0 coins

That would have been a nightmare to untangle. I'll confirm in writing that it's specifically a Roth IRA account before anything moves.

0 coins

That's a surprisingly common error. The 5498 the new custodian sends the IRS will show the account type, so if it's wrong there it needs to be corrected before the next tax year.

0 coins

My bank sent me a confirmation letter after setup that listed account type. I'd ask for one before initiating the transfer so you have something to point to if anything gets misfiled.

0 coins

The IRS does receive a 5498 from the new institution confirming the rollover or transfer, so they have visibility into it even though you don't report it yourself. That's how they'd know if someone exceeded the once-per-year indirect rollover limit — the forms would show two indirect rollovers in a 12-month window.

0 coins

So the IRS is in the loop even on direct transfers — just through the custodian's reporting, not through anything I file. That actually makes me feel better that there's a paper trail.

0 coins

Exactly. And if you ever get a question from the IRS about a rollover, the 5498 and the distribution code on the 1099-R together tell the whole story.

0 coins

Keeping both the 1099-R and the 5498 in your tax records for a few years is smart. If the IRS ever asks about a year's retirement account activity you'll have both sides of the transaction.

0 coins

Does the once-per-year rollover rule reset on January 1st each year, or is it a rolling 12-month window?

0 coins

Rolling 12-month window — not a calendar year. So if you did an indirect rollover in August, you'd have to wait until the following August before doing another indirect rollover from any IRA, not just that same account.

0 coins

That rolling window trips a lot of people up because they assume it resets in January. The IRS counts from the date of the distribution, not the tax year.

0 coins

Rolling 12 months is stricter than I thought. Good thing I asked before I tried to do two in the same year.

0 coins

My transfer took about three weeks from start to finish, which I thought was fast. The hold-up was the old institution wanting a signature guarantee on the transfer form — not a notary, specifically a Medallion signature guarantee from a bank officer. If your old custodian requires one, budget extra time.

0 coins

Three weeks is actually reassuring. The Medallion thing is new to me — is that common?

0 coins

It varies by institution and by the account balance. Some require it over a certain dollar threshold, others always do. Call your current IRA custodian and ask before you fill anything out so you know what to get in advance.

0 coins

My transfer didn't need one, but the old custodian did require a copy of the new account statement showing the Roth IRA was open and funded with at least a small amount first. Each institution has its own checklist.

0 coins

Set up an installment agreement with the IRS last spring for a balance from my 2023 return. By November the monthly amount in my IRS Online Account didn't match what the agreement letter showed, and I couldn't tell if the agreement had been modified or if I was looking at an updated figure after some penalties rolled in. Claimyr held the line on 800-829-1040 until an agent picked up — the agent confirmed the current monthly amount in the system and the next due date on the agreement. The figures matched the online account once the agent explained which line to look at.

0 coins

Monthly amount discrepancies in the online account versus the original letter are confusing. At least the agent could point to the right figure.

0 coins

The IRS Online Account lets you change a payment plan's monthly amount or due date yourself if you need to adjust, which is useful once you know what the actual current terms are.

0 coins

Knowing the agent confirmed the next due date helped me make sure that payment went out on time. Missing a payment puts a plan in default, which I really didn't want.

0 coins

Went to a Taxpayer Assistance Center appointment last month for an identity issue — totally unrelated to my Roth — and the agent there mentioned that IRA transfer questions sometimes come up during appointments too. If you have a complicated situation, like an inherited Roth or one that has both contributed and converted amounts, an in-person appointment at a TAC might be worth scheduling. You'd book through 844-545-5640 or use the office finder on irs.gov.

0 coins

That's useful — I hadn't thought of a TAC appointment for a Roth question, but mine is complicated enough that talking to someone in person might actually help.

0 coins

Mine is straightforward enough that I think I'm okay with the custodian handling it. But the TAC option is good to know for anyone with a messier situation.

0 coins

The TAC appointment line is busy this time of year, so if you need one, schedule it sooner rather than later.

0 coins

W-2 from my second job last year showed withholding that didn't match what I expected based on my pay stubs, so I had the IRS pull the wages and withholding they had on record for 2025. Claimyr kept me from spending my lunch break on hold — the agent confirmed the exact wages and federal withholding that employer had reported, which matched the W-2 amount I had. The discrepancy turned out to be a payroll rounding issue I'd have found on my own eventually, but it was good to verify what the IRS had on file.

0 coins

Verifying what the IRS actually received from an employer versus what your W-2 shows is something I didn't know you could do by phone. Good to know.

0 coins

You can also pull a wage and income transcript through the IRS Online Account to see the same thing without calling. The transcript shows what each employer reported for the year, including withholding.

0 coins

Wage and income transcripts come available later in the year after employers file — usually by late spring for the prior year. Useful when checking if everything was reported correctly.

0 coins

Had a question about whether a Roth IRA transfer would affect my ability to make a Roth IRA contribution for the same year. I was worried that moving funds counted as some kind of contribution that would push me over the annual limit.

0 coins

A direct transfer doesn't count as a contribution at all, so it has no effect on your annual contribution limit for the year. Those two things are completely separate — the limit applies only to new money you're adding from outside your IRAs, not to money moving between them.

0 coins

That's a relief. I contributed my full amount in January and then worried when I started the transfer process that I'd somehow exceeded something.

0 coins

Contributions and rollovers or transfers are tracked differently on IRS forms. Your annual contribution goes on the 5498 with one code, and a rollover or transfer goes with a separate code — they don't add together toward the limit.

0 coins

The Taxpayer Advocate Service is worth knowing about if a transfer somehow creates a tax issue that the IRS hasn't resolved after the normal timeframes. TAS is free and independent within the IRS. You'd reach them at 877-777-4778 or through the taxpayeradvocate site — https://www.taxpayeradvocate.irs.gov/ — if something went wrong and you couldn't get it resolved otherwise.

0 coins

Hopefully I won't need TAS but good to have that in my back pocket if something goes sideways.

0 coins

TAS helped a family member of mine when a rollover was incorrectly flagged as a taxable distribution and the IRS wasn't responding to written inquiries. It took months but TAS eventually got it resolved.

0 coins

TAS can't take every case — they generally focus on financial hardship situations or cases where the IRS has gone past its normal response time. But if you're stuck and can't get the IRS to respond, it's a real option.

0 coins

Worth clarifying something from earlier in this thread: someone mentioned the 20% withholding rule and said it doesn't apply to Roth IRAs. That's mostly accurate for direct rollovers, but if you take an indirect rollover from a Roth IRA, the withholding rules can still apply depending on the institution. Don't assume no withholding will happen just because it's a Roth — confirm with your custodian before they cut any check to you.

0 coins

Good addition. The safest answer is always to call your custodian and ask specifically what they'll withhold before you choose the method. 'Direct transfer' eliminates the question entirely.

0 coins

My old institution's IRA department told me they were required to withhold unless I signed a waiver. For a Roth the tax math is different from a traditional, but the withholding itself can still happen at the institution's end if you don't elect out of it.

0 coins

This is why direct transfer beats indirect rollover in almost every case — you remove the withholding question, the 60-day question, and the once-per-year question all at once.

0 coins

Filed on extension and my return for 2025 is still being processed. I checked the IRS Online Account and saw my return was received, which is reassuring, but no refund date yet. My question is whether the online account gives any more detail than Where's My Refund for an extension filer.

0 coins

The IRS Online Account shows your return as filed and any notices that have been issued digitally, but for refund timing, Where's My Refund is still the main tool. They can show slightly different things, so checking both isn't a bad idea.

0 coins

Same situation here — extension filer, return received, no refund date in either tool. My tax preparer said October extension filers should expect processing to take longer than spring filers simply because the IRS processes a high volume of paper and e-filed returns all at once after the extension deadline.

0 coins

Knowing both tools can show different information is helpful. I'll keep checking both.

0 coins

My employer switched payroll systems mid-year and the W-2 they issued showed combined figures from both systems. I wasn't sure if the IRS would see one W-2 or two for the same employer, so I pulled a wage and income transcript after the filing deadline to compare. The transcript showed both entries — the IRS received separate records from the two payroll periods. Everything matched my combined W-2 when added together, but I was glad I checked.

0 coins

Payroll system switches causing two records for one employer is more common than people expect. Pulling a wage and income transcript is the cleanest way to verify what the IRS actually received from your employer.

0 coins

Get Transcript through the IRS Online Account is the fastest way to pull that — available immediately once it's posted, versus waiting days for one by mail.

0 coins

Having the transcript handy before filing also helps catch any discrepancies early, before the IRS sends a CP2000 notice asking why your return doesn't match what the employer reported.

0 coins

Update from the original poster: I called both banks and used the phrase 'direct trustee-to-trustee transfer' as suggested here. Both institutions confirmed they handle it that way by default — I just needed to fill out a transfer form at the new bank with my current account details. No money will ever be in my hands. The representative at the new bank said I'd get a confirmation when the funds arrive, and they'd send the 5498 in May. I feel a lot better about the whole thing. Thanks everyone.

0 coins

That's the cleanest outcome. Keep the confirmation letter from the new bank and the 1099-R from the old one when it arrives in January — you'll want both if anything ever comes up.

0 coins

Great outcome. That phrase 'direct trustee-to-trustee transfer' really does cut through the confusion because both sides know exactly what you mean.

0 coins

Glad it worked out that simply. The hardest part really is just knowing the right words to say to the custodians.

0 coins

IRS AI

Expert Assistant
Secure