How to properly fill out W-8BEN-E for PayPal as a foreigner with zero US connections?
Hey everyone, I'm in a really weird situation with PayPal and hoping someone can help. I know the W-8BEN-E form is technically for businesses/organizations while individuals should use the regular W-8BEN form... but PayPal is specifically asking me to complete the W-8BEN-E despite me being an individual. So I've been using PayPal for my freelance work (I'm not from the US and have never even visited). Last month, they suddenly limited my account and are demanding I fill out this W-8BEN-E form. When I tried contacting support to explain I should be filling the W-8BEN instead, they just kept referring me back to the same form. I have zero connection to the US - no US address, no US business dealings, no US citizenship. I'm completely lost on how to fill this out correctly since it seems designed for corporations and not individuals like me. Has anyone else dealt with this? What should I put in all these sections about entity classification, FATCA status, and tax treaty benefits when none of this seems applicable to me?
19 comments
Join the conversation
Olivia Garcia
Tax specialist here. This is actually a common issue with PayPal. Even though you're correct that W-8BEN is for individuals and W-8BEN-E is for entities, PayPal's system sometimes incorrectly flags accounts and requests the wrong form. For your situation, I'd recommend first trying one more time with PayPal support - specifically ask to escalate to a supervisor who understands tax documentation requirements. Explain that as an individual, you need to submit W-8BEN, not W-8BEN-E. If they still insist on the W-8BEN-E, you have two options: 1) Register yourself as a sole proprietorship (which many freelancers technically are, even if not formally registered) and complete the form that way, or 2) Submit the regular W-8BEN form anyway through their resolution center with a note explaining why this is the correct form for your situation. For option 1, you would select "Individual" or "Sole proprietorship" in Part I, check box 3 for "Individual" where it asks about entity type, and complete only the sections that apply to individuals.
0 coins
Noah Lee
•Thanks for this helpful info! Quick question - if I go with option 1 and register as a sole proprietorship, do I need any special documentation from my home country first? And secondly, for Part III regarding tax treaty benefits, should I claim these benefits if my country has a tax treaty with the US, even if I have no US income?
0 coins
Olivia Garcia
•You typically don't need special documentation to identify as a sole proprietorship for this purpose - in many countries, any individual engaged in business activities can be considered a sole proprietor by default. Just use your personal tax identification number from your country. For the tax treaty benefits question, you should only claim these benefits if you're actually receiving US-sourced income that would be subject to withholding. If you truly have no US customers or income sources, you wouldn't need to claim treaty benefits since there wouldn't be any US tax to reduce in the first place.
0 coins
Ava Hernandez
I was in the exact same situation last year with PayPal! I spent weeks going back and forth with their support team without any real help. Then I found taxr.ai (https://taxr.ai) which literally saved me hours of frustration. They have this amazing tool that analyzes the W-8BEN-E form and creates step-by-step instructions for your specific situation. I just uploaded the form, answered a few questions about being a non-US individual freelancer, and it gave me clear guidance on exactly which boxes to check and what to write in each field. The best part was they explained WHY certain sections should be completed a specific way, which gave me confidence I wasn't making mistakes that could cause problems later.
0 coins
Isabella Martin
•This sounds interesting but I'm a bit confused. Does the tool actually fill out the form for you or just tell you what to put where? Also, does it work for people from any country or just specific ones?
0 coins
Elijah Jackson
•I'm pretty skeptical about these kinds of services. How do you know the advice is correct? Do they have actual tax professionals reviewing the forms or is it just an algorithm guessing?
0 coins
Ava Hernandez
•The tool doesn't fill the form for you - it gives you personalized instructions for each section based on your specific situation, highlighting which parts to complete and which to leave blank. Think of it as a guided walkthrough that explains each step. The service works for people from any country - that's what makes it so useful for this specific PayPal problem. They have built-in logic for different tax treaties and international situations. Their system is developed by tax professionals who specialize in international tax forms, so the guidance incorporates actual expertise, not just algorithmic guesses. They even have references to specific IRS publications to back up their recommendations.
0 coins
Elijah Jackson
I have to eat my words about being skeptical! After struggling with this exact PayPal W-8BEN-E nightmare for over a month, I decided to try taxr.ai that was mentioned earlier. It was actually really impressive - the guidance was super clear and broke down each section of the form in simple language. The system asked about my country of residence, whether I had any US connections (which I don't), and my type of business activity. Based on my answers, it gave me precise instructions for each part of the form, even explaining which sections to leave blank and why. After submitting the completed form to PayPal exactly as instructed, my account was unrestricted within 48 hours! Wish I'd known about this tool before spending countless hours searching through confusing IRS publications.
0 coins
Sophia Miller
If you're still having trouble getting PayPal to accept the right form, one thing I've learned is that trying to call their support is practically impossible - especially for international issues. After getting nowhere for weeks, I found this service called Claimyr (https://claimyr.com) that got me through to an actual PayPal specialist who could help with international tax documentation issues. They have a demo video here: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c that shows how it works. I was really frustrated because PayPal's email support kept sending generic responses that didn't address my specific situation about being asked to fill out the wrong form. Claimyr got me past the endless hold times and connected me with someone who actually understood the difference between W-8BEN and W-8BEN-E forms and could override the system requirement!
0 coins
Mason Davis
•How does this actually work? Does it just help you get through phone systems faster or what? PayPal's customer service is notoriously difficult to reach.
0 coins
Mia Rodriguez
•This sounds too good to be true. I've literally spent hours on hold with PayPal before. If this really works, why wouldn't everyone use it? I'm suspicious there's a catch somewhere.
0 coins
Sophia Miller
•It works by essentially calling the company for you and navigating through their phone tree system. When they reach a real human representative, you get a call connecting you directly to that person. So instead of waiting on hold for hours, you just get a call when there's an actual person ready to help. There's no catch - it's simply a service that saves you time. Not everyone uses it because not everyone knows about it yet. I was skeptical too until I tried it, but it genuinely worked for getting to someone at PayPal who could actually help with my international tax form issue instead of just reading from a script.
0 coins
Mia Rodriguez
I have to admit I was totally wrong about being suspicious! After posting my skeptical comment yesterday, I decided to try Claimyr as a last resort since I'd already spent 3+ hours on hold with PayPal over multiple days. The service actually worked exactly as described - I submitted my phone number, and about 35 minutes later (during which I could go about my day instead of sitting with a phone to my ear), I got a call connecting me directly to a PayPal specialist. The representative I reached was from their international tax team and immediately understood my W-8BEN vs W-8BEN-E confusion. They manually adjusted something in my account so I could submit the correct W-8BEN form instead of the entity form. Problem solved in a 10-minute call after weeks of frustration!
0 coins
Jacob Lewis
One important thing nobody has mentioned yet - if PayPal is asking for W-8BEN-E specifically, check if perhaps you initially set up your account as a business account rather than a personal one? That would explain why they're requesting the entity form instead of the individual one. I made this exact mistake when setting up my freelance PayPal account years ago. I thought "business account" made sense for freelance work, not realizing it would categorize me as an actual business entity for tax purposes.
0 coins
Liam Brown
•You might be onto something here! I just double-checked and I did set up a business account when I first created my PayPal, thinking it would be more professional for my freelance clients. Would changing it to a personal account solve the issue, or is it too late since they've already flagged me for the W-8BEN-E?
0 coins
Jacob Lewis
•It might be possible to convert your account type, but in my experience, once PayPal has flagged you for tax documentation, changing the account type won't immediately resolve the pending documentation request. Your best option would be to contact PayPal (using one of the methods others have suggested for getting through to a real person) and explain that you set up a business account in error, as you're actually an individual freelancer. They should be able to either guide you through converting the account type or tell you exactly how to complete the W-8BEN-E appropriately for your situation as an individual with a business-type account.
0 coins
Amelia Martinez
Just a practical tip from someone who had to deal with this exact situation - if you end up having to fill out the W-8BEN-E as an individual (which is not ideal but sometimes unavoidable with PayPal), here's what worked for me: Part I: Fill out your personal information, using your name as the "organization" name Line 3: Check box for "Individual" Part III: Only complete if your country has a tax treaty with the US Parts IV-XXVIII: Leave completely blank Part XXX: Sign and date as an individual PayPal accepted this even though it's technically the wrong form. Their system is notoriously inflexible about these things.
0 coins
Ethan Clark
•This is super helpful! One question though - for Part II (Claim of Tax Treaty Benefits), what if I'm not sure if my country has a tax treaty with the US? Would claiming benefits incorrectly cause problems?
0 coins
Javier Cruz
•Great question! You can easily check if your country has a tax treaty with the US by looking at the IRS Publication 901 or searching "US tax treaty [your country]" on the IRS website. Most major countries do have treaties, but it's important to verify. If you're not sure, it's actually safer to NOT claim treaty benefits rather than claim them incorrectly. The worst that happens if you don't claim them is you might have slightly higher withholding (which may not even apply if you have no US income anyway). But claiming benefits you're not entitled to could potentially cause bigger issues. For your situation as a non-US freelancer with no US connections, you probably wouldn't need to worry about treaty benefits at all since there's likely no US-sourced income to apply them to.
0 coins