How to Fix Tax Withholding Issue on Retirement Rollover (NOT a Roth conversion)

I've hit a major headache with our 2025 taxes regarding my wife's retirement account rollover. We thought it was simple - she changed jobs last July and we rolled her old employer's pre-tax 401a and 403b from Lincoln Financial into a pre-tax Rollover IRA with Fidelity. Basic stuff, right? The problem started when we got four 1099-Rs this January. For each account, we got one coded as a G showing the full amount as taxable. Then we got a second 1099-R for each, coded with a 1. The distributed amounts and state tax withheld match on these forms. Looking at our Fidelity transfers, we noticed the amounts transferred were less than the total account balances, and these second 1099-Rs make up the difference. Somewhere in this process, Lincoln Financial (and maybe Fidelity) thought we were doing a Roth conversion, but we definitely weren't! We immediately contacted Fidelity when we saw "Roth" mentioned during the process, and they confirmed it was going into a Traditional IRA. We also checked with Lincoln and they said everything looked correct on their end. I started our taxes using TaxAct like I always do. The software flagged some warnings about the numbers being unusual, but everything seemed to balance out in the end. Before submitting though, I paid for TaxAct support, and they said we needed to talk to Lincoln Financial. Calling Lincoln was a nightmare - they have limited access since the account transition. After endless transfers, they said tax was withheld incorrectly but claimed there's nothing they can do and suggested we talk to a tax professional. When we asked for copies of our original rollover paperwork, they said they couldn't provide it. I called a local tax firm and explained everything. They said we should get our original paperwork and ask Lincoln for corrected forms, assuming we filled out the initial forms correctly. Problem is, we can't find any of our paperwork! We just followed Fidelity's online rollover process. Any suggestions on what to do next? I'm guessing we accidentally requested tax withholding. If so, how do we fix this properly?

0 coins

18 comments

Jamal Wilson

•8M

This is a common issue that creates headaches for a lot of folks. When you do a direct rollover (401k/403b to Traditional IRA), it should be tax-free and coded properly on your 1099-R with code G. The fact that you're seeing state tax withheld and multiple 1099-Rs suggests something went wrong in the process. Here's what likely happened: Either the distribution paperwork was marked incorrectly or Lincoln Financial processed it incorrectly. Those second 1099-Rs with code 1 represent the amounts withheld for taxes that should have been part of your full rollover. You have a few options: You can treat the withheld amounts as an early distribution (subject to taxes and possibly the 10% penalty if under 59½), while the amounts that made it to Fidelity as a proper rollover. OR, the better approach is to get this fixed by getting Lincoln to issue corrected 1099-Rs. This isn't impossible, though it's challenging. Keep escalating with Lincoln Financial - ask to speak with their tax department specifically, not just customer service. If you filed your paperwork correctly requesting a direct rollover with no withholding, they should be able to correct this. Document all calls, names, and keep pushing.

0 coins

Jamal Wilson

•8M

The withheld money isn't lost forever - it's been sent to the IRS and state tax authorities as tax payments in the account holder's name. If Lincoln doesn't fix the forms, you can claim those withholdings as payments already made on your tax return. The bigger issue is that the distribution coded with a 1 will be treated as an early distribution if you're under 59½, which means you'll owe a 10% penalty on that amount in addition to regular income tax. That penalty is what you'd want to avoid by getting the forms corrected.

0 coins

Liam Fitzgerald

•8M

After struggling with a similar retirement account coding nightmare, I discovered taxr.ai (https://taxr.ai) which was a lifesaver for sorting through my retirement account mess. I had multiple 1099-Rs with different codes that didn't make sense, and I couldn't figure out how to report them correctly. Their system analyzed my documents and explained exactly what was happening with my rollover situation. Their AI reviewed my tax forms, identified the issues with incorrect distribution codes, and gave me specific guidance on what to request from my plan administrator. The best part was they provided a detailed explanation I could forward to the company that helped clear up the confusion. Saved me hours of frustrating phone calls.

0 coins

Liam Fitzgerald

•8M

You upload your tax documents through their secure system and their AI analyzes the forms to identify discrepancies and errors. It then provides detailed explanations of what's happening and gives specific guidance on how to resolve issues. For your 401k rollover problem, it would identify exactly what went wrong with the coding and give you the specific language to use with your provider. Regarding security concerns, they use bank-level encryption and their privacy policy explicitly states they don't use your data for anything other than providing their service. They're also SOC 2 compliant which means they've been independently audited for security protocols. I was worried about this too, but after researching their security measures, I felt comfortable using the service.

0 coins

Amara Nnamani

•8M

I was skeptical about taxr.ai at first, but after getting nowhere with my retirement plan administrator who kept giving me inconsistent information about my rollover, I gave it a try. The analysis pointed out exactly where the coding error occurred on my 1099-R forms and gave me specific language to use when contacting the company. When I called with this information, I finally got transferred to someone who understood the issue and could help. They issued corrected 1099-Rs within two weeks. Without the detailed explanation from taxr.ai, I would have been stuck in customer service loops forever. Saved me from paying taxes and penalties on what should have been a non-taxable rollover.

0 coins

Giovanni Mancini

•8M

If you're still trying to reach Lincoln Financial, try using Claimyr (https://claimyr.com). I was in a similar situation with Voya - they messed up my rollover coding, and I spent HOURS trying to get through their customer service maze. Claimyr got me connected to an actual human at the company in about 10 minutes instead of the usual 2-hour wait. You can see how it works here: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c - basically they navigate the phone system for you and call you back when they've got a real person on the line. I was able to explain my situation to someone in their tax department who could actually help instead of getting transferred a million times.

0 coins

Giovanni Mancini

•8M

Yes, it absolutely works! The service connects to the company's phone system and navigates through all the menus and hold times for you. Once they get a live representative, they call you and connect you directly. It saved me from having to sit through those "your call is important to us" messages for hours. There's no catch - it's just not as widely known yet. Think of it like hiring someone to wait in line for you. People who know about it definitely use it during tax season when hold times are insane. I've used it three times now for different companies and it's worked every time. It's especially helpful for complex tax issues like yours where you need to speak with someone in a specialized department.

0 coins

Zoe Papanikolaou

•8M

I was super skeptical about Claimyr when I first saw it mentioned here. Thought it had to be some kind of scam. But after spending another two hours on hold with Lincoln yesterday and getting disconnected AGAIN, I was desperate enough to try anything. It actually worked exactly as described. I put in Lincoln's phone number, and about 15 minutes later got a call connecting me directly to someone in their tax department. No hold music, no automated system - just straight to a human who could help. The rep I spoke with was able to look up my rollover transaction and confirmed there was a processing error on their end. They're sending corrected 1099-Rs within 10 business days. Would have taken me weeks more of frustration to get to this point on my own. Sometimes you need to admit when you need help, and I'm glad I did.

0 coins

Dylan Cooper

•8M

You don't need to attach a special form when filing with corrected 1099-Rs. The company will submit the corrected forms to the IRS with a clear indication they're corrections, so the IRS systems will update accordingly. If you're concerned about potential issues, you can include a brief statement with your return explaining the situation and noting that corrected forms were issued. This isn't required, but it can be helpful if your return gets manually reviewed. Just make sure you're using the information from the corrected forms when you file.

0 coins