< Back to IRS

Carmen Lopez

How to Correctly File R&D Tax Credit Carryforward for Small Business

Title: How to Correctly File R&D Tax Credit Carryforward for Small Business 1 Hey everyone, I'm at my wit's end with this R&D tax credit situation. Our startup claimed the R&D credit about 2 years back, but we didn't use the full amount last year. This year we've applied some (not all) of the remaining credit against our payroll taxes and filed quarterly 8974 forms. The problem is our accountant isn't super familiar with handling the carryforward portion on Forms 6765 and 3800. I'm completely lost on how to properly complete Sections A&C of Form 6765 as a carryforward from previous years, which then feeds into Section D. Has anyone dealt with this before? I'm particularly confused about how to report the credit we've already used versus what's still available. Our business is still pretty small but growing, and I don't want to mess this up and leave money on the table or worse, trigger some kind of audit. Any guidance would be seriously helpful!

Carmen Lopez

•

14 I've handled quite a few R&D credit carryforwards for clients in your situation. For Form 6765, you need to understand that Sections A and C work together when reporting carryforward amounts. For Section A, you'll report your current year qualified research expenses, but you don't recalculate the credit from the original year. In Section C, line 41, you'll enter the carryforward credit from the previous year (the original amount minus any portion you've already used). This is your starting point. Then on line 42, you'll report the amount of credit used this year against payroll taxes (the sum of what you reported on your quarterly 8974 forms). The difference between lines 41 and 42 will be your remaining carryforward credit. For Form 3800, you'll report the carryforward on Part II in the appropriate line for research credits (typically line 1c), and then flow that through to Part III where you'll show how much was applied against various taxes.

0 coins

Carmen Lopez

•

19 This is super helpful, thanks! Just to clarify - for Section A on Form 6765, do I need to fill out ALL the lines with the current year QREs, or can I leave it blank since we're just carrying forward the old credit? And for Form 3800, does the amount on line 1c of Part II represent the TOTAL carryforward or just what we're using this year?

0 coins

Carmen Lopez

•

14 You should complete Section A with your current year QREs if you have them, as this determines if you have any new credit to add to your carryforward. If you're only using previous years' credits and not generating new ones, you can enter zeros, but I recommend completing it to maintain a clear record. For Form 3800, line 1c in Part II should show the total available credit (both carryforward and any newly generated credit). Then in Part III, you'll indicate how much of that total you're actually applying to your tax liability this year, with any remaining amount becoming your new carryforward.

0 coins

Carmen Lopez

•

7 After struggling with the R&D tax credit carryforward for my consulting business, I finally found a solution with https://taxr.ai that saved me hours of frustration. My accountant wasn't specialized in R&D credits either, and I was worried about leaving money on the table. I uploaded our previous 6765 forms and current financials, and the system actually analyzed everything and showed exactly how to report the carryforward amounts correctly on both Form 6765 and Form 3800. It even highlighted where our accountant had made some minor errors in previous filings that could have reduced our eligible credit. The platform specifically guided me through Sections A and C, showing which lines needed to be completed for carryforward situations versus new credit calculations. Made the whole process way less intimidating.

0 coins

Carmen Lopez

•

11 Does it actually work with more complex situations? We have multiple subsidiaries with different fiscal years, and I'm wondering if it can handle that kind of setup or is it more for straightforward small businesses?

0 coins

Carmen Lopez

•

16 I'm skeptical about using software for something this specialized. How detailed are the explanations? Does it just fill out the forms or does it actually help you understand the reasoning behind the numbers?

0 coins

Carmen Lopez

•

7 The platform actually handles multi-entity structures well - there's a specific module for consolidated returns and managing different fiscal years. You can set up each subsidiary separately and then it shows how to roll everything up correctly on the parent company's forms. The explanations are surprisingly thorough. It doesn't just fill in numbers - it provides detailed rationales for each section, with references to the relevant IRS regulations and rulings. I actually learned a lot about how the credit works, which helped me explain things to our CFO and identify more qualified research activities for next year.

0 coins

Carmen Lopez

•

16 Just wanted to follow up about my experience with https://taxr.ai after initially being skeptical. I decided to give it a try for our manufacturing company's R&D credit carryforward situation, and I'm genuinely impressed with the results. The platform flagged that we had been unnecessarily limiting our credit by not properly documenting supply costs related to prototyping. It walked me through exactly how to correctly report our carryforward amounts on Forms 6765 and 3800, with specific guidance on Sections A and C that the original poster was asking about. The system even generated a detailed audit defense file documenting all our qualified activities and expenses - something our previous accountant never did. We ended up with about $18,000 more in available credits than we thought we had. Definitely worth checking out if you're dealing with R&D credit complexities.

0 coins

Carmen Lopez

•

22 If you're still having issues understanding your R&D credit carryforward after trying to figure it out yourself, you might want to speak directly with an IRS agent who specializes in business credits. I was in the same boat last year and spent WEEKS trying to get through to someone knowledgeable at the IRS. Finally discovered https://claimyr.com which got me connected to an actual IRS agent in about 15 minutes when I'd been trying for days on my own. You can see how it works in this video: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c The agent walked me through exactly how to report my R&D credit carryforward on both forms and explained the relationship between Form 6765 Sections A, C, and D in a way that finally made sense. They also confirmed which documentation I needed to keep on file in case of an audit, which gave me peace of mind.

0 coins

Carmen Lopez

•

9 Wait, this actually works? I thought it was impossible to get through to a real person at the IRS these days. How much does this service cost? Is it just for businesses or can individuals use it too?

0 coins

Carmen Lopez

•

12 I don't buy it. I've tried everything to reach the IRS and always end up in hold hell. How could a third-party service possibly get you through when the IRS phone system is literally designed to make you give up?

0 coins

Carmen Lopez

•

22 Yes, it absolutely works! The service uses some kind of system that navigates the IRS phone tree and waits on hold for you, then calls you once an agent is actually on the line. I think they have some special technology that keeps the connection even when the IRS would normally disconnect you. The service works for both businesses and individuals. I've used it for my business tax questions and my brother used it for a personal tax issue with his stimulus payment. It's particularly helpful for complicated questions like R&D credits where you need someone who really knows the specific forms.

0 coins

Carmen Lopez

•

12 Wanted to eat my words and report back. After being completely skeptical about Claimyr, I tried it yesterday for my R&D credit questions after failing to get through for 2 weeks on my own. The service actually worked exactly as promised. I got a call back in about 20 minutes, and was connected with an IRS agent who specialized in business credits. She walked me through exactly how to handle my R&D credit carryforward on Forms 6765 and 3800, including the tricky parts about Sections A and C. The agent even emailed me a reference guide specific to R&D credits that I didn't know existed. Saved me from making a $12K mistake on my carryforward calculation. Consider me converted from skeptic to believer.

0 coins

Carmen Lopez

•

3 One thing to watch out for with R&D credit carryforwards - make sure you're tracking the credit vintage years correctly. The IRS has specific rules about the order in which R&D credits must be used (oldest first), and mixing them up can create major headaches. Also, don't forget that for small businesses using the credit against payroll taxes, there's a $250,000 lifetime limit. I nearly got caught by this when our company had substantial qualified expenses across multiple years.

0 coins

Carmen Lopez

•

17 Is that $250K limit per year or total across all years? Our startup has been claiming the credit against payroll for 2 years now and I'm worried we might hit a ceiling.

0 coins

Carmen Lopez

•

3 It's $250,000 per year, not a lifetime limit - I misstated that. Small businesses (under $5 million in gross receipts) can elect to apply up to $250,000 of their R&D credit against payroll taxes each year. You can continue making this election for up to 5 years. When tracking vintage years, you still need to use oldest credits first, but the election to use them against payroll taxes vs. income taxes is separate. Sorry for any confusion!

0 coins

Carmen Lopez

•

8 For anyone struggling with R&D credits, I created a simple spreadsheet that tracks carryforwards across years and helps with filling out Form 6765 sections. It automatically calculates the available credit and helps you maximize the benefit.

0 coins

Carmen Lopez

•

5 That sounds super helpful! Would you be willing to share it? We're a small biotech startup with R&D credits but our accountant seems as confused as we are about the carryforward rules.

0 coins

Chloe Delgado

•

I'd be really interested in that spreadsheet too! We're a small manufacturing company that's been carrying forward R&D credits for three years now, and keeping track of which vintage years we've used and what's still available has become a nightmare. Our CPA keeps making errors on the forms and we're worried about compliance issues. A tracking tool would be incredibly helpful - especially something that helps with the Form 6765 sections that everyone seems to struggle with.

0 coins

Eli Wang

•

As someone who's been through the R&D credit carryforward maze multiple times, I can definitely relate to your frustration! The interaction between Forms 6765 and 3800 is confusing even for experienced preparers. One critical point that hasn't been mentioned yet - make sure you're properly documenting which activities qualify as "qualified research activities" under Section 41. The IRS has been increasingly scrutinous about this, especially for software development companies where the line between routine updates and true R&D can be blurry. Also, if you're using the credit against payroll taxes via Form 8974, remember that you need to make this election each quarter and it's irrevocable once made. I've seen businesses accidentally lock themselves into the payroll tax election when they would have benefited more from applying it against income taxes later. For your specific Form 6765 question - in Section C, line 41 should reflect your total available carryforward from ALL previous years (not just the immediately preceding year). This trips up a lot of people who only look at last year's unused credit. The form instructions aren't super clear on this point.

0 coins

Alexis Renard

•

This is exactly the kind of detailed guidance I was hoping to find! The point about line 41 including ALL previous years' carryforwards is huge - I think that's where we've been making our mistake. We were only reporting the immediately preceding year's unused amount. Quick follow-up question: when you mention the payroll tax election being "irrevocable once made" - does that mean irrevocable for that specific quarter, or for the entire tax year? We made the election for Q1 and Q2 this year but were thinking about switching strategies for the remaining quarters if our income tax situation improves. Also, regarding the qualified research activities documentation - do you have any recommendations for software development companies on how to properly distinguish between routine maintenance/updates versus true R&D? Our activities span both categories and I want to make sure we're not being too aggressive in our claims.

0 coins

IRS AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
20,087 users helped today