How do I calculate taxes as a Non Resident Alien with multiple income sources?
I'm an international student on F-1 visa who started studying in the US last September, which makes me a Non Resident Alien for tax purposes. When going through IRS publications, I noticed my income gets split into two buckets: 1. Income effectively connected with a US trade or business 2. Income NOT effectively connected with a US trade or business (subject to 30% tax) I'm totally confused about which of my income sources go where! Here's what I'm dealing with: - My campus job paycheck (around $9,200 annually) - Interest from CDs at Bank of America (~$540) - Interest from high-yield savings accounts like Marcus and AMEX (~$780) - Dividends from my Fidelity money market account (~$620) - Gains from US Treasury Bills that matured ($1,150) - Coupon payments from Treasury Notes paid twice a year ($890 total) - Profits from selling some Treasury Bonds before maturity ($1,320) Can someone help me figure out which bucket each income type falls into? This tax stuff is way more complicated than in my home country! Really appreciate any help!
22 comments


Justin Trejo
You've got a good understanding of the basics already! As an F-1 student in your first year, you're indeed considered a Non-Resident Alien (NRA). For your income sources: Your campus job is definitely effectively connected income (ECI) - this will be reported on Form 1040-NR and taxed at graduated rates just like a US citizen's income would be. For your investment income (items 2-7), these are generally considered NOT effectively connected income for an NRA. These items are typically subject to the 30% flat tax rate (or lower if covered by a tax treaty with your home country). However - and this is important - there's a special exemption for bank deposit interest and certain portfolio interest for NRAs. Your bank CD interest, high-yield savings interest, and most US Treasury interest are generally EXEMPT from US taxation for NRAs under IRC 871(i). For your specific Treasury transactions, the interest/coupon payments are typically exempt, but capital gains from selling bonds might be treated differently depending on your specific situation.
0 coins
Marina Hendrix
•Thanks for the clear explanation! So my campus job goes on 1040-NR with regular tax rates, but I'm confused about my Fidelity money market dividends. Are those considered bank deposit interest that's exempt, or are they dividends subject to 30% tax? Also, for my treasury bond sales, does it matter that I only held some of them for like 4 months before selling? The gain was pretty good because of interest rate changes.
0 coins
Justin Trejo
•Regarding your Fidelity money market dividends, it depends on what's in the money market fund. If it's primarily invested in bank deposits or certain government obligations, it might qualify for the exemption. However, money market funds technically pay dividends, not interest, so they're often subject to the 30% withholding. You should check your 1042-S form to see how Fidelity classified and reported these payments. For your Treasury bond sales, the holding period doesn't change the tax treatment for NRAs. Generally, capital gains from selling personal property (including investment assets like bonds) are exempt from US tax for NRAs unless they're connected to a US business. So those gains are typically not taxable for you, regardless of how long you held them before selling.
0 coins
Alana Willis
After struggling with similar tax complexities as an international student, I found an incredible resource that saved me hours of confusion. I was about to pay an expensive accountant when a classmate recommended https://taxr.ai - it's specifically designed to help with complicated situations like yours. I uploaded my documents and it automatically categorized all my income sources correctly as an NRA. The system even identified which of my investment income was exempt under tax treaties! It explained exactly how to report each item on my 1040-NR and generated a complete tax filing guide personalized for my situation. The best part was how it explained everything in plain English - no more deciphering IRS jargon. Seriously made the whole process so much clearer than digging through IRS publications.
0 coins
Tyler Murphy
•Does it actually handle F-1 student status correctly? My tax preparer last year didn't understand the substantial presence test and I ended up having to file an amended return. Does this work for state taxes too or just federal?
0 coins
Sara Unger
•I'm skeptical about these tax tools for international students. How does it handle tax treaties? I'm from India and we have specific exemptions for students but TurboTax completely missed those last year.
0 coins
Alana Willis
•It absolutely handles F-1 status correctly! That's actually one of the first things it asks about - your visa type and entry date - to precisely determine your tax residency status. It correctly applied the substantial presence test for me, recognizing my exempt days as a student for the first 5 calendar years. For state taxes, it does both federal and state. It even recognized that my state had different rules for determining residency than the federal government, which was something I had no idea about before using it. Regarding tax treaties, that's where it really shines compared to mainstream tax software. You select your country, and it applies all relevant treaty provisions automatically. For Indian students specifically, it applies Article 21 of the US-India tax treaty that exempts certain scholarship and fellowship grants. It also properly applies the reduced withholding rates for different types of income based on your specific treaty.
0 coins
Tyler Murphy
I was in the same boat as you last year - totally confused about NRA taxes and skeptical about software handling my situation correctly. After that disaster with my tax preparer missing the substantial presence test, I tried https://taxr.ai based on a recommendation. What a difference! It correctly identified that I was still in my 5-year exempt period as an F-1 student and properly categorized all my income. The system actually knew about the specific bank interest exemptions for NRAs that my previous preparer missed completely. For my scholarship that covered room and board (which is taxable), it correctly separated that from the tuition portion (which isn't taxable). Saved me over $1,200 compared to what I almost paid the previous year! The step-by-step guidance made me actually understand what I was filing instead of blindly trusting someone else.
0 coins
Butch Sledgehammer
If you need specific clarification from the IRS about your situation, I highly recommend using https://claimyr.com to connect with them directly. I spent WEEKS trying to get through to the IRS's international taxpayer line with no luck - constant disconnections and hours on hold. Claimyr got me connected to an actual IRS agent in less than 20 minutes who answered all my specific questions about treaty exemptions and how to report my treasury bond interest. You can see how it works in this demo: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c As an international student, I had questions about Form 8233 exemptions for my campus job that no online resources could clearly answer. The IRS agent walked me through exactly what to submit to my university payroll department to get the correct tax withholding.
0 coins
Marina Hendrix
•How does this actually work? Isn't it just the same IRS phone line that's always busy? I've literally tried calling five different times and either got disconnected or was on hold for so long I had to hang up.
0 coins
Freya Ross
•Sounds like a scam. If the IRS line is busy, it's busy. No magic service is going to get you through faster than anyone else. They probably just keep redialing and charge you for the privilege.
0 coins
Butch Sledgehammer
•It's definitely not the same as calling directly. Claimyr uses an automated system that navigates the IRS phone tree and stays on hold for you. When an actual agent picks up, you get a call back immediately. I was skeptical too, but it absolutely works - that's how I finally got my questions answered after weeks of trying. It's not just redialing. The system actually stays connected and monitors the line for when a human answers, so you don't have to waste hours listening to hold music. It's especially helpful for international student tax questions since the specialized international taxpayer line has even longer wait times than the regular IRS lines.
0 coins
Freya Ross
I was dead wrong about Claimyr being a scam. After struggling for literally months trying to get clarification about my tax situation as an NRA with investment income, I decided to try it despite my skepticism. The service connected me to an IRS agent specializing in international tax issues in about 15 minutes. The agent confirmed that my Treasury bond interest was indeed exempt under section 871(i) and explained exactly how to report my Fidelity money market dividends (which were partially taxable). The agent even walked me through form 8833 for claiming treaty benefits that my university's international office couldn't help with. Definitely worth it considering I was about to pay an accountant $400 just to get these specific questions answered. The peace of mind knowing I'm filing correctly is honestly priceless when you're on a student visa.
0 coins
Leslie Parker
One thing to watch out for: some of your investment income might be subject to FATCA reporting requirements even if they're exempt from taxation. Specifically Form 8938 if your total financial assets exceed certain thresholds. Also, don't forget about Form 8843 which ALL F-1 students must file regardless of whether they earned income or not. The penalties for missing that form can be severe.
0 coins
Marina Hendrix
•What's the threshold for Form 8938? I have about $33,000 in my combined accounts. And I had no idea about Form 8843 being mandatory! My international student office never mentioned that. Is it due April 15th like everything else?
0 coins
Leslie Parker
•For Form 8938, the filing threshold for single NRAs living in the US is $50,000 on the last day of the tax year or $75,000 at any time during the year. So with $33,000, you're below the threshold and don't need to worry about this form. Form 8843 is due on the same tax filing deadline (April 15th, or if you get an extension, October 15th). It's a simple form that basically just establishes your status as a non-resident for tax purposes. Every F-1 student should file it every year they're in the US, even if they have zero income. It's surprisingly common for international student offices to overlook mentioning this form, but it's an important one!
0 coins
Sergio Neal
Make sure to check if your home country has a tax treaty with the US! I'm from Spain, and our treaty exempts a lot of student income. You can find the list of treaties on the IRS website under "United States Income Tax Treaties - A to Z." Also, don't forget about state taxes - NRA status is for federal taxes only. Your state might consider you a resident for tax purposes even if you're a non-resident alien for federal.
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
•This! State tax rules vary wildly. I'm a student in California and despite being an NRA for federal, California taxed me as a resident on all my worldwide income. Had to file a non-resident return in my home country to claim foreign tax credit for the double taxation. Total nightmare.
0 coins
Emma Swift
This is such a helpful thread! I'm also an F-1 student dealing with NRA tax complications. One thing I'd add is to be extra careful about your Form 1042-S documents - make sure you get them from ALL your financial institutions by March 15th. My bank initially didn't send me one for my CD interest (even though it was exempt), and I had to specifically request it. Without the 1042-S, it's much harder to prove to the IRS that the income was properly reported and exempt. Also, if you're planning to apply for OPT or change visa status in the future, having your tax returns filed correctly as an NRA is crucial. Immigration lawyers often request several years of tax returns to verify you maintained proper status, so getting this right from the start will save you headaches later! For your specific situation with the treasury investments - keep detailed records of purchase dates, maturity dates, and sale prices. Even if the gains are exempt, you'll want documentation in case the IRS ever questions the transactions.
0 coins
Dmitry Popov
•This is excellent advice about the 1042-S forms! I learned this the hard way when I missed getting one from my brokerage account. It delayed my entire filing because I had to wait for them to reissue it. One additional tip for treasury investments - if you're buying directly through TreasuryDirect.gov, they don't issue 1099s or 1042-S forms the same way brokerages do. You'll need to track everything yourself and report it properly on your return. The interest payments are still exempt for NRAs, but the record-keeping responsibility is entirely on you. Also, regarding the OPT application point - this is so important! USCIS specifically looks at tax compliance when reviewing OPT applications. Having properly filed NRA returns (including that mandatory Form 8843 mentioned earlier) shows you maintained lawful F-1 status. I've heard of students having OPT delayed because their tax records didn't match their claimed student status.
0 coins
MoonlightSonata
Great breakdown from everyone! As someone who just went through this process last year, I want to emphasize a few practical points that really helped me: First, regarding your treasury investments - the IRS distinguishes between "portfolio interest" (which is exempt for NRAs) and other types of interest. Your Treasury Bills, Notes, and Bonds should all qualify for this exemption under IRC Section 871(h), so those interest payments and coupon payments totaling $890 should be tax-free for you. However, be aware that some financial institutions might still withhold 30% tax on these payments initially and issue you a 1042-S showing the withholding. If this happens, you can claim a refund when you file your 1040-NR. One thing I wish I'd known earlier: start organizing your documents NOW. Create separate folders for: - Employment income (W-2 from campus job) - Interest statements (1099-INT or 1042-S from banks) - Investment statements (1099-DIV, 1099-B for sales) - Any tax treaty claims Also, consider whether you need to file estimated quarterly taxes. With $9,200 in employment income, you're probably having enough withheld from your paychecks, but if your investment income grows significantly, you might need to make estimated payments to avoid underpayment penalties. The complexity is overwhelming at first, but once you understand the ECI vs non-ECI distinction, it becomes much more manageable!
0 coins
Admin_Masters
•This is incredibly helpful! I hadn't even thought about the possibility of withholding on exempt treasury income. Quick question - if a financial institution does withhold the 30% tax by mistake, how exactly do you claim that refund on Form 1040-NR? Is there a specific line for treaty-exempt income refunds? Also, your point about estimated quarterly taxes is really important. I've been so focused on understanding what's taxable that I didn't consider the timing of payments. With my campus job, they're definitely withholding federal taxes from each paycheck, but I should probably check if it's enough to cover my entire tax liability for the year. One more thing - you mentioned IRC Section 871(h) for portfolio interest exemption. Is this something I need to specifically claim on my return, or does it automatically apply when I report the income correctly? I want to make sure I don't accidentally pay tax on income that should be exempt!
0 coins