Back to IRS

Zoe Wang

Do I send a 1099 to a Canadian contractor? Confused about what the IRS actually requires

Hired a freelancer based in Canada to do some design work for my small business this year. Paid her just over $800 total across a few invoices. Now I'm trying to figure out end-of-year paperwork and I honestly don't know where I land on this. Do I send a 1099 to a Canadian contractor or is that whole requirement only for people inside the U.S.? A friend said I don't have to do anything because she's foreign, but another person in my business group said I still need to send something. I don't want to mess up my taxes or miss a filing deadline. Anyone dealt with this?

Figuring out where you stand here, I'd check whether your contractor gave you a W-8BEN before you paid her. That's the form a foreign individual fills out to certify they're not a U.S. person for tax purposes. If you have a signed W-8BEN on file, you generally don't file a 1099-NEC for that contractor — the 1099 rules are aimed at U.S. persons. Without one, you're in murkier territory and you'd want to ask a tax professional or the IRS directly about your specific situation. The IRS's site at https://www.irs.gov/ has the instructions for Form W-8BEN if you want to read what it covers.

0 coins

Zoe Wang

Author

She never sent me anything like that — I didn't even know to ask for it. So now what, do I go back and request it even though I already paid her?

0 coins

Asking for it now is still worth doing. Keep it with your records for the year. The form is about her status, so the date you received it doesn't have to match the date you paid — but get it in writing before you file.

0 coins

Didn't know that form existed. I've been hiring a couple of people in Mexico for my Etsy shop and nobody ever mentioned a W-8BEN to me. Going to look this up tonight.

0 coins

Amended 1040-X I filed back in the spring for tax year 2024 was what sent me down a rabbit hole of IRS phone calls. I ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) — it waits on hold with 800-829-1040 for you so you end up talking to a live IRS agent — and I want to share what the agent told me because it's relevant here. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at the IRS: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c. The agent pulled up my account and confirmed the amended return's received date, which was the piece I needed. The reason I bring it up: while I had the agent on the line I asked about foreign contractor paperwork and she said to look at the instructions for W-8BEN and the 1099-NEC, because whether a 1099 goes to a foreign person depends on where the services were actually performed. If the work was done entirely outside the U.S., the IRS generally treats the income as foreign-source and a 1099-NEC isn't required — but you still want that W-8BEN in your file.

0 coins

Zoe Wang

Author

Where the work was performed — that's something I hadn't even thought about. She's in Toronto and was working from there the whole time, so that sounds like it would apply to me.

0 coins

The agent said that? That's actually the clearest explanation I've seen on this whole thread. The 'where performed' piece is what trips people up.

0 coins

She was pretty direct about it. She said the instructions for the forms themselves spell it out, and that the IRS's site has the current versions. She didn't get into the specific rules for every scenario, just the general framework for my situation.

0 coins

Your friend is mostly right but it matters why. The 1099-NEC is for payments to U.S. persons — that's the basic rule. A foreign contractor who did the work outside the country isn't in that bucket. Where it gets people is when a foreign contractor is actually a U.S. person living abroad, or when the work was partly done inside the U.S. In those cases the analysis changes. Since your contractor is in Canada and worked from there, you're likely not filing a 1099-NEC, but get that W-8BEN.

0 coins

Zoe Wang

Author

What if I never get the W-8BEN from her? Like if she just doesn't respond?

0 coins

Document that you asked. Send an email, keep the reply or the lack of one. If you can't get it, that's something to bring to a tax professional before you file — you don't want to guess on that piece.

0 coins

The W-8BEN thing came up for me too with a contractor in the Philippines. I had no idea it was even a thing until an accountant mentioned it at the end of last year. Got it from him retroactively with no problem.

0 coins

Nobody explained this to me when I started hiring outside the U.S. either. I just assumed 1099 rules applied to everyone I paid over $600. Spent three years doing it wrong before a CPA set me straight. The IRS has never come after me for those earlier years but I still stress about it.

0 coins

Has the IRS ever sent you anything about those earlier filings, or has it just been quiet?

0 coins

Completely quiet so far. But I keep all the records just in case someone asks.

0 coins

Three years is a long time to do it differently than the rule says. I'd still keep everything documented. If you have W-8BENs from those contractors it probably helps your case if anything ever came up.

0 coins

I want to push back a little on something in this thread — someone said the $600 threshold is the trigger for the 1099 requirement. That's the threshold for U.S. persons, yes, but the whole question of whether a 1099 is even the right form for a foreign contractor is a separate step that comes before the dollar amount matters. If the contractor is a foreign person who did work outside the U.S., the threshold question doesn't even get to the starting line because a 1099-NEC isn't the form in play.

0 coins

Zoe Wang

Author

So the $600 number I keep seeing isn't the main question here — it's first whether a 1099 applies at all to a foreign contractor?

0 coins

Exactly. The sequence matters. First: is this a U.S. person or a foreign person? Second: where was the work performed? The $600 figure comes into play only once you've established a 1099-NEC is even the right form for the situation.

0 coins

I had this backwards for a long time. Thought $600 was the universal threshold for everyone I paid. Good to see it spelled out like this.

0 coins

My accountant told me the same thing as what people are saying here — W-8BEN is your protection as the payer. If you have it, you've done your due diligence. If the contractor later turns out to be a U.S. person who lied on the form, that's on them, not you. Keep the form with your business records for the year.

0 coins

Zoe Wang

Author

That's actually really reassuring. So the burden shifts if they gave me false information?

0 coins

That's the general understanding, yes — but I'm not a tax pro, so for your actual filing I'd confirm with one. The IRS's site has the instructions for W-8BEN that explain the payer's reliance rules in more detail.

0 coins

The 'reliance' piece is what I was missing. I always thought I was on the hook no matter what the contractor told me.

0 coins

Went through this exact situation earlier this year with a developer I hired in Germany. Asked three different people and got three different answers. Eventually I just called the IRS at 800-829-1040 myself and sat on hold for about 45 minutes before I got someone. The agent told me the same thing that's been said here — W-8BEN, confirm work location, and read the instructions for the forms. Worth the wait to hear it directly.

0 coins

Zoe Wang

Author

45 minutes is brutal but at least you got through. Did they give you a definitive answer or more of a 'read the instructions' response?

0 coins

Honestly a bit of both. They confirmed the core rule pretty clearly but kept directing me to the form instructions for the specifics. I think that's as far as they go on a general call.

0 coins

45 minutes on hold for that answer would have driven me up a wall. I've had calls where I waited that long and then got disconnected right before someone picked up.

0 coins

Canadian contractors specifically — there's also the U.S.-Canada tax treaty that sometimes comes up in this context. The treaty can affect withholding obligations for certain kinds of payments, but whether it changes your 1099 obligation depends on factors a tax professional really needs to look at. I'd mention to whoever you consult that she's specifically in Canada, not just 'outside the U.S.,' because the treaty makes it a slightly different question.

0 coins

Zoe Wang

Author

I had no idea a treaty was involved. Is that something I need to research on my own or would a CPA typically know about it?

0 coins

Any CPA or enrolled agent who works with small businesses should know the U.S.-Canada treaty basics. It comes up often enough that it's not obscure. When you call or meet with one, just lead with 'Canadian contractor, design work done in Toronto' and they'll know where to look.

0 coins

The treaty angle is real but for most small payments for work done entirely in Canada, you're unlikely to have a withholding obligation in the first place. Still worth mentioning when you consult someone.

0 coins

A letter showed up for my business last month asking me to verify my EIN registration — turned out to be related to some contractor payments from 2024 that the IRS wanted documentation on. I used Claimyr to reach someone at the business line and ended up talking to an agent who pulled up the notice. She confirmed the date it was issued and exactly what documentation they were asking for, which was just the contracts and payment records. Having that spelled out saved me a lot of guessing about what to send in.

0 coins

Zoe Wang

Author

Did they ask for W-8BENs specifically as part of the documentation, or just contracts and payment records?

0 coins

The agent said contracts and payment records for that particular notice. W-8BENs weren't specifically listed, but I had them and included them anyway just to show I'd collected the right forms.

0 coins

What line did you use for the business-related call? I've always just used the main individual line and it doesn't feel right for business questions.

0 coins

The business line is 800-829-4933 — same hours as the individual line, Monday through Friday, 7 to 7 local time. For anything EIN or business-account related that's the one to use.

0 coins

Does anyone know if this same logic — foreign person, work outside the U.S., no 1099 — applies to 1099-MISC as well, or just 1099-NEC? I pay a couple of foreign contractors for royalties on content they created and I've been filing 1099-MISCs for all of them.

0 coins

Royalties paid to foreign persons can actually trigger different rules than service payments — there can be withholding obligations under Chapter 3 of the tax code depending on the payment type and whether a treaty applies. I'd strongly recommend asking a tax professional or the IRS directly about royalty payments specifically, because that's a different analysis than what this thread is covering for service income.

0 coins

Okay that is a completely different situation than I thought I was in. I need to actually talk to someone about this before I file.

0 coins

Royalties versus services is a real distinction the IRS makes. The form instructions for W-8BEN also cover different income types — worth reading before you consult anyone so you can ask the right questions.

0 coins

Checked my own files after reading this and I realized I've been collecting W-9s from everyone — including two foreign contractors I paid this year. A W-9 is for U.S. persons. I should have been asking them for W-8BENs instead. Going to have to fix that before I file.

0 coins

Made that same mistake my first year in business. The confusion between W-9 and W-8BEN is so common. W-9 for U.S. persons, W-8BEN for foreign individuals — they look similar at a glance but serve totally different purposes.

0 coins

Can I just have them fill out a W-8BEN now even though I already paid them and collected the W-9?

0 coins

From what I understand, yes — you can collect the correct form now and keep both in your records with a note about when each was received. A tax professional can confirm how to handle the W-9 that's already in your file for a foreign contractor.

0 coins

Refund on my personal return this year was stuck with no movement in Where's My Refund for about ten weeks. I ended up reaching someone at 800-829-1040 through Claimyr and the agent confirmed the refund amount on my account and the date it was issued — it had actually been mailed but the address on file was an old one. Separately, that same call helped me realize I needed to update my address before any correspondence about my business filings went missing too. So now I'm paranoid about keeping the IRS's address for me current.

0 coins

Zoe Wang

Author

Mailed to an old address — that's exactly the kind of thing you don't find out about until it's too late. How do you update the address with the IRS?

0 coins

You can do it through the IRS Online Account at https://www.irs.gov/your-account, or file Form 8822 by mail. The IRS also updates the address when you file your next return, but that's the slowest option if you're waiting on something time-sensitive.

0 coins

The online account is so much faster for address updates than waiting for a return to process. I did mine in about two minutes.

0 coins

Read everything here and I'm realizing my situation might be different — I hired a Canadian contractor who also holds a U.S. green card. Does that change anything? A green card holder is usually treated as a U.S. person for tax purposes, right?

0 coins

Green card holders are generally treated as U.S. residents for federal tax purposes, yes. If your contractor has a green card, the foreign person analysis probably doesn't apply and you'd be back to the standard 1099-NEC rules — including collecting a W-9 instead of a W-8BEN. I'd confirm with a tax professional given the specifics, but that's the general framework.

0 coins

She actually mentioned her green card when we first started working together and I didn't think anything of it. Going to ask her directly whether she files U.S. taxes before I decide what form to use.

0 coins

That's a smarter approach than guessing. The W-8BEN itself includes a question about U.S. status so if she fills one out and checks the wrong box, that's on her — but better to ask upfront.

0 coins

My business partner and I had a whole argument about this last spring because we hired two contractors around the same time — one in Vancouver, one in Seattle — and tried to treat them the same way. Obviously we shouldn't have. The Seattle one got a W-9 and will get a 1099-NEC if we paid her over the threshold. The Vancouver one got a W-8BEN. At least we figured it out before we filed.

0 coins

Zoe Wang

Author

Vancouver versus Seattle is such a clear example of why location matters so much here. Did you have to redo any paperwork once you realized?

0 coins

We had to go back to the Vancouver contractor for the W-8BEN since we'd originally sent her a W-9 by mistake. She was confused about why we needed a different form but once we explained it she sent it right back.

0 coins

The U.S.-Canada border creating two completely different tax situations for contractors doing similar work is exactly the kind of thing that catches small business owners off guard. Good that you caught it.

0 coins

Has anyone dealt with a Canadian contractor who also does some work while visiting the U.S.? Like if they come to a client meeting here for a few days — does that change the 'work performed outside the U.S.' analysis?

0 coins

Work performed inside the U.S. — even a few days — can potentially change the analysis, especially for income allocated to those days. That's exactly the kind of fact-specific question where a tax professional or the IRS itself is the right source, not a forum. The treaty between the U.S. and Canada has provisions that might address this, but I wouldn't guess on the allocation.

0 coins

The 'where performed' piece is not always a simple all-or-nothing question. Some situations require allocating income between U.S.-source and foreign-source based on where the work actually happened. That's beyond what anyone here can answer definitively.

0 coins

Figured it was complicated. My contractor came down for a two-day workshop earlier this year and I've been wondering about it ever since. Going to flag it specifically when I talk to my CPA.

0 coins

Balance on my business account for 2023 was showing higher than what I expected after I'd made all my estimated payments on time. Used Claimyr to reach the IRS business line and the agent pulled up the balance owed for that tax year — one of my estimated payments had been applied to a different year's account. Got that sorted by following the instructions the agent gave me for submitting a written correction request. Keeping detailed payment records for every quarter now.

0 coins

Applied to the wrong year — does that happen often with estimated payments?

0 coins

The agent didn't say how common it was, but she confirmed it was what happened on my account and what I needed to do to get it corrected. Having the payment confirmation numbers made it straightforward to document.

0 coins

Payment applied to the wrong year is one of my quiet fears every quarter. Good to know there's a process to fix it even if it's annoying.

0 coins

Foreign contractor paperwork aside — has anyone had issues with the EIN they put on 1099s they did file? I sent 1099-NECs to a few domestic contractors this year and two of them gave me EINs that don't match what their names suggest they should be. Now I'm not sure what to do.

0 coins

If a contractor gave you an EIN that doesn't match their business name in the IRS's system, that's a TIN mismatch. The IRS sends backup withholding notices in those situations. For 1099s you've already filed, the best step is to call the IRS or consult a tax professional about how to correct the information — the form instructions and your notice, if one comes, will tell you what's needed.

0 coins

No notice yet, but I filed in October so it might still be working through. I'll keep an eye on the IRS Online Account for anything that comes in.

0 coins

TIN mismatches are more common than you'd think when contractors are using EINs for LLCs they set up themselves. Some of them don't realize the name has to match exactly what they registered with the IRS.

0 coins

Came into this thread knowing nothing about W-8BENs and now I realize I need to go back through three years of payments to foreign contractors and figure out what I collected from each of them. This is not how I wanted to spend my weekend but here we are.

0 coins

Zoe Wang

Author

Honestly same energy. I thought this was going to be a quick yes-or-no question and now I have a whole records project ahead of me.

0 coins

Three years of records is worth going through carefully. If you find gaps, documenting what you do have and getting missing forms now is better than having nothing if questions come up later.

0 coins

The IRS's wage and income transcripts go back several years if you need to check what was reported on the other side. Doesn't help with the W-8BEN situation directly but useful for cross-checking amounts.

0 coins

My whole business model is working with freelancers overseas — designers in Eastern Europe, developers in Asia — and I went through a painful learning curve on all of this. The short version after consulting with a CPA: collect the right form before you pay anyone, not after. It's so much easier to get a W-8BEN before you send the first invoice payment than to chase it down six months later when the contractor has moved on to other clients.

0 coins

Zoe Wang

Author

Before payment is the obvious answer in hindsight. I'm going to build that into my contractor onboarding from now on — W-8BEN or W-9 before I process any payment.

0 coins

That's exactly the system I use now. I have a checklist: form received, form reviewed, payment processed. In that order, every time.

0 coins

Building it into the onboarding is the move. I lost so much time chasing paperwork from people who had already moved on. Now it's a condition of the first payment.

0 coins

For anyone who ends up needing to call the IRS about a business filing question, the business line — 800-829-4933 — is usually better than the main individual line. Hours are the same, Monday through Friday 7 to 7 local time, but the agents there are set up to handle EIN questions, business accounts, and employer filing questions, which is where contractor paperwork tends to land.

0 coins

Didn't know there was a separate business line. I've been calling the main number for everything and sometimes the agent clearly didn't know what I was asking about.

0 coins

The main line can help with some business stuff but for anything EIN-related or about 1099 filings and business accounts, 800-829-4933 is the right one.

0 coins

Does the business line also handle questions about withholding on foreign payments, or is that something that goes elsewhere?

0 coins

For withholding on foreign payments specifically, I'd start with 800-829-4933 and ask the agent at the start of the call whether they handle international tax questions or whether there's a different number for that — the IRS has specialized lines for some international topics and the agent can point you in the right direction.

0 coins

Zoe Wang

Author

Coming back to update: I emailed my Canadian contractor and explained what I needed. She sent back a completed W-8BEN the same day — apparently her other U.S. clients had already asked for it and she had it ready to go. So I have that in my file now. Going to have my accountant look at the whole picture before I file, especially the tax treaty question someone mentioned, but I feel a lot better about where I stand than I did when I posted this.

0 coins

Having the W-8BEN in hand is exactly where you want to be before your accountant looks at it. Mentioning the treaty and her location in Toronto specifically will help them give you the right answer.

0 coins

The fact that she had it ready from other clients is a good sign — it means she understands the U.S. paperwork side of working with American businesses. Easier to work with than someone who's never heard of the form.

0 coins

Glad it came together quickly. Keeping that form with your 2026 business records along with the invoice and payment records should give you everything you need.

0 coins

IRS AI

Expert Assistant
Secure