Can short term AirBnb rental income qualify as self-employment income for social security credits?
Title: Can short term AirBnb rental income qualify as self-employment income for social security credits? 1 Hi everyone, looking for some tax advice here. I've been operating an AirBnb for about 2 years now - it's a small lakeside cabin that I completely renovated myself. Guests typically stay for weekends or short vacations, usually 3-5 days on average. I'm trying to figure out if this rental income can be considered self-employment income so I can get social security credits. When I look at the IRS instructions, it seems like I can't do this because I "don't provide significant services" - but I've heard from other hosts that there are some court rulings or cases that say otherwise. I do handle all the cleaning myself, provide fresh linens, stock basic pantry items, and I'm on call 24/7 for any issues. I also coordinate activities for guests who want recommendations. I'm really putting a lot of work into this! My CPA is researching this for me but I wanted to get some community input too since you all seem really knowledgeable. Are there specific cases or rulings I should be looking into that might help me classify this as self-employment income? Really appreciate any help or guidance on this!
21 comments
Join the conversation
Philip Cowan
7 The question of whether your AirBnb rental qualifies as self-employment income hinges on whether you're providing "substantial services" versus just renting out property. Based on what you've described, you might have a case. The IRS generally looks at the level of services provided to guests beyond just the basic rental. Cleaning between guests, providing linens, and basic pantry items alone typically aren't enough. However, being on call 24/7 and especially coordinating activities might push you over the threshold. There are several tax court cases that address this. Hardy v. Commissioner and Bobo v. Commissioner both dealt with the distinction between rental income and self-employment income. The key factor was whether services provided were primarily for the occupant's convenience versus services needed to maintain the property. If you can document that you're providing substantial personal services beyond just renting space, you have a stronger case for claiming self-employment income on Schedule C rather than rental income on Schedule E.
0 coins
Philip Cowan
•12 Thanks for the info. Curious though - exactly how much "service" is considered substantial? Like if I'm spending 15-20 hours a week managing the property, cleaning, coordinating with guests, etc., would that be enough? Or does it need to be more like a traditional B&B where I'm cooking breakfast and such?
0 coins
Philip Cowan
•7 The IRS doesn't define an exact hour threshold for "substantial services." It's more about the nature of the services rather than just the time spent. Cleaning and property management are typically considered part of normal rental activity. Services that would push you toward self-employment would be things like providing daily maid service, regular meals (like breakfast), guided tours, transportation services, concierge services beyond basic recommendations, or other amenities similar to what you'd find at a hotel or B&B.
0 coins
Philip Cowan
4 After struggling with a similar situation last year with my vacation rental, I found an amazing tool that helped me figure out my tax classification. I used https://taxr.ai to upload my AirBnb hosting records and rental documentation, and it instantly analyzed my situation. The tool found the relevant tax court cases (including some I hadn't heard of before like the Berner case) that applied specifically to my situation. It showed me exactly what documentation I needed to prove substantial services and gave me a percentage likelihood of successfully claiming self-employment status. What was really helpful was that it compared my hosting activities to previous cases where hosts were successful in claiming SE income. It even helped me reframe some of my hosting activities to better match what the IRS is looking for.
0 coins
Philip Cowan
•9 That sounds interesting. Does this tool actually give you specific tax cases and citations? I'm worried it's just generic advice that I could find with a Google search. How detailed was the analysis?
0 coins
Philip Cowan
•15 I've been burned by tax software before that gave me incorrect advice. How does this compare to just hiring a tax attorney who specializes in rental property? And does it actually provide real legal citations or just general advice?
0 coins
Philip Cowan
•4 The tool provides actual case citations with links to the full court opinions. In my case, it found seven relevant cases including some recent ones from 2019-2022 that my CPA wasn't even familiar with. What makes it different from a Google search is that it analyzes your specific activities and compares them directly to the activities in successful cases. For example, it showed that my airport pickup service for guests was similar to a service provided in a 2018 case where the tax court ruled in favor of the property owner. Compared to hiring a tax attorney, it's obviously not the same level of representation, but it gave me the documentation and case law I needed to confidently discuss the issue with my CPA. It provides the exact legal citations, relevant paragraphs from the rulings, and explains how they apply to your situation.
0 coins
Philip Cowan
15 Just wanted to follow up about my experience with taxr.ai after being skeptical. I decided to give it a try with my vacation rental situation, and I'm genuinely impressed with the results. The analysis identified three key services I was already providing that qualified as "substantial" according to recent tax court decisions - particularly my guided hiking tours for guests and my meal prep services. I wouldn't have known these carried so much weight! The tool found a 2021 case (Johnson v. Commissioner) that was almost identical to my situation where the taxpayer successfully claimed self-employment income. I took all this information to my tax preparer, and she agreed that I had a strong case for Schedule C treatment. Just filed my return claiming self-employment income and the associated social security credits. Definitely worth checking out if you're in a similar situation.
0 coins
Philip Cowan
8 Anyone dealing with AirBnb tax classification issues knows how frustrating it can be to get clear answers from the IRS. After weeks of trying to reach someone who could actually answer my questions about self-employment classification, I finally found a service that got me through to a real IRS tax specialist in less than 15 minutes. I used https://claimyr.com and was honestly shocked at how well it worked. Their system bypassed the usual IRS phone tree hell and connected me directly with an agent who specialized in small business classifications. You can see how it works in this demo: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c The agent walked me through exactly what documentation I needed to prove my case for self-employment status with my vacation rental. She confirmed that the court cases I'd found were relevant and even told me about a recent internal guidance memo they're using to evaluate these cases.
0 coins
Philip Cowan
•20 How does this even work? The IRS phone system is notoriously impossible to navigate. Are you saying this service somehow jumps the queue? That seems... questionable. I've spent literally hours on hold before.
0 coins
Philip Cowan
•16 Sounds too good to be true. I've been trying to get through to the IRS for MONTHS about my rental property classification. Are you sure this isn't just paying for something that should be free? What's the catch?
0 coins
Philip Cowan
•8 It uses a proprietary system that navigates the IRS phone tree and waits on hold for you. When an agent finally answers, you get a call connecting you directly to them. I don't know exactly how the technology works, but it definitely saved me hours of frustration. The main benefit is that you don't have to sit on hold - you just get a call when an actual human at the IRS picks up. In my case, I needed to speak to someone who understood the nuances of Schedule C vs Schedule E for rental activities, and getting the right department was crucial.
0 coins
Philip Cowan
16 I have to admit I was extremely skeptical about Claimyr, but I was desperate after trying for weeks to reach someone at the IRS about my rental property classification. I gave it a shot last Thursday. The service called me back in about 35 minutes with an actual IRS tax law specialist on the line. I was floored. The agent spent almost 45 minutes going through my specific situation - explaining that because I offer guided local tours, daily cleaning, and breakfast delivery to my guests, I could qualify for self-employment status. She directed me to specific sections of Publication 527 that I had completely misinterpreted and told me exactly what documentation I needed to keep to support my position. Worth every penny just for the peace of mind knowing I'm doing this correctly. I've been recommending it to everyone in my local host group.
0 coins
Philip Cowan
22 I've been doing AirBnb for 5 years and had this exact same question. The distinction really comes down to "passive rental" vs "active business." From my experience, if you're doing any of these, you have a much stronger case for self-employment: 1. Offering guided tours or activities 2. Providing daily cleaning during stays (not just between guests) 3. Offering meal service of any kind 4. Providing transportation for guests 5. Offering equipment rentals (bikes, kayaks, etc.) I hired a tax attorney who specializes in short-term rentals, and she advised me to restructure my business to emphasize these services. I now have guests sign an agreement that breaks out the cost of these additional services separate from the basic room charge, which strengthens my case for self-employment income.
0 coins
Philip Cowan
•19 How much does it cost to hire a specialist tax attorney for something like this? I'm wondering if it's worth the expense or if I should just accept the rental income classification.
0 coins
Philip Cowan
•22 I paid about $900 for a 2-hour consultation plus a written opinion letter I could keep for my records. Definitely not cheap, but considering what's at stake (social security credits over many years plus potential self-employed retirement account options), it was worth it to me. For some perspective, the difference between Schedule E rental income and Schedule C self-employment income for me meant I could open a Solo 401(k) and put away significantly more for retirement than I could with just IRA options. That tax advantage alone paid for the attorney in the first year.
0 coins
Philip Cowan
5 Has anyone successfully used an LLC with an S-Corp election to get around this issue? I've heard that can be another approach where you pay yourself a reasonable salary from the rental income, which would generate social security credits.
0 coins
Philip Cowan
•3 Yes, this is actually what I do! I have my rental property in an LLC that elected S-Corp status. I pay myself a salary that's about 40% of the profits (which my accountant deemed "reasonable") and take the rest as distributions. This way I get social security credits on the salary portion without having to argue about whether my services are "substantial" or not.
0 coins
Philip Cowan
11 Just a word of caution from someone who went through an audit on exactly this issue. The IRS agent was primarily focused on the "material participation" test and whether I had documentation to prove how much time I spent on various services. Even though I was providing what I thought were substantial services, I couldn't prove exactly how many hours I spent on each task. The IRS ultimately reclassified my income from Schedule C to Schedule E because I lacked adequate time logs. Now I use a time-tracking app to document EVERYTHING I do related to the rental - from answering guest messages (screenshots with timestamps) to shopping for supplies (with receipts) to doing property maintenance (with dated photos). If you're serious about claiming this as self-employment income, start documenting your time meticulously RIGHT NOW. It made all the difference when I was audited again the following year.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
This is such a helpful discussion! I'm in a similar situation with my mountain cabin rental and have been going back and forth on this exact issue. One thing I haven't seen mentioned yet is the impact of local regulations on this classification. In my area, short-term rentals are required to have 24/7 on-site management response, daily safety inspections, and we must provide certain amenities by law. These regulatory requirements essentially force us to provide what could be considered "substantial services." I'm wondering if anyone has had success using local STR regulations as supporting documentation for self-employment classification? It seems like if the government is requiring you to provide hotel-like services, that could strengthen the argument that you're running an active business rather than just renting property. Also, for those tracking time - I've found that breaking down services into categories helps: guest communication, property maintenance, cleaning/turnover, guest services (recommendations, problem-solving), and regulatory compliance. The IRS seems to view guest-focused services differently than property maintenance when evaluating the substantial services test.
0 coins
Giovanni Colombo
•That's a really interesting angle about local regulations! I hadn't thought about using STR compliance requirements as supporting documentation. In my area, we're required to have commercial-grade cleaning standards and provide emergency contact info 24/7, which does sound more like running a hotel than just renting out a room. Your point about categorizing services is spot on too. I've been lumping everything together in my time tracking, but breaking it down between guest-focused services versus property maintenance makes total sense. The guest communication alone - answering questions, providing local recommendations, troubleshooting issues - probably adds up to way more hours than I realized. Do you happen to know if there are any specific court cases that have addressed the regulatory compliance angle? That could be really valuable documentation to have when making the case for self-employment classification.
0 coins