Can I still recharacterize my Traditional IRA contribution to a Roth IRA for tax year 2023?
Title: Can I still recharacterize my Traditional IRA contribution to a Roth IRA for tax year 2023? 1 I made a pretty big mistake last year. I contributed about $6,500 of after-tax money to my Traditional IRA for tax year 2023. I wasn't thinking clearly and just transferred the funds without considering the tax implications. Now I'm realizing that I'll be taxed AGAIN when I withdraw this money in retirement if I don't fix this somehow! I just found out about recharacterization, where you can basically move your contribution from Traditional to Roth IRA (which would be perfect since I already paid taxes on this money). But I'm worried it might be too late for 2023 contributions. The tax filing deadline for 2023 has already passed. Is there any way I can still recharacterize my Traditional IRA contribution to a Roth IRA for tax year 2023 at this point? If it's too late, what are my options? Should I just leave it and deal with the double taxation later, or is there some other strategy I should consider? Really appreciate any help!
18 comments
Join the conversation
Chad Winthrope
5 The deadline for recharacterizing a Traditional IRA contribution to a Roth IRA for the 2023 tax year was the tax filing deadline (including extensions) - so around October 15, 2024. If you've missed that deadline, unfortunately you can't recharacterize anymore. Since you've already contributed after-tax dollars to a Traditional IRA, you have a couple of options. First, you should make sure to file Form 8606 with your taxes to document that you've made a non-deductible contribution. This creates what's called "basis" in your IRA and ensures you won't be taxed on that portion again when you withdraw it. Going forward, you might want to look into a "Backdoor Roth" strategy if you're not eligible to contribute directly to a Roth IRA due to income limits. This involves making non-deductible contributions to a Traditional IRA and then converting to a Roth (which is different from recharacterizing).
0 coins
Chad Winthrope
•7 Thanks for the info. I'm still a little confused about the Form 8606. Will I need to file this with my 2024 return, or should I amend my 2023 return? Also, what's the difference between converting and recharacterizing? They sound like the same thing to me.
0 coins
Chad Winthrope
•5 You'll need to file Form 8606 with your 2023 tax return. If you've already filed for 2023 without including it, you should submit an amended return (Form 1040-X) with the 8606 included to properly document your non-deductible contribution. Recharacterizing and converting are actually quite different. Recharacterizing essentially treats your contribution as if it had gone to the second account type from the beginning - it's like a "do-over." Converting means you acknowledge the money went into the Traditional IRA first, but now you're moving it to a Roth and paying any required taxes on the conversion. After the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, you can no longer recharacterize a conversion.
0 coins
Chad Winthrope
13 After dealing with a similar situation last year, I discovered taxr.ai at https://taxr.ai and it was incredibly helpful. I uploaded my tax documents and got a clear analysis of my IRA contribution options. The tool identified that I had basis tracking issues with non-deductible contributions and laid out all my options with the tax implications of each. What I really liked was how it explained the Form 8606 requirements in plain English and even provided a sample of how to complete it for my situation. It saved me from making costly mistakes with my IRA contributions going forward.
0 coins
Chad Winthrope
•19 Does taxr.ai handle more complicated situations? I've got a mix of deductible and non-deductible contributions across multiple years, plus some rollovers from old 401ks. Would it be able to sort all that out?
0 coins
Chad Winthrope
•7 I'm skeptical about these tax tools. How is this different from TurboTax or H&R Block? Those always seem to miss nuances about IRA contributions in my experience.
0 coins
Chad Winthrope
•13 It definitely handles complex situations like yours with multiple contribution types and rollovers. The platform is specifically designed to track basis across various accounts and years, which is exactly what you need. It's much more specialized for these kinds of retirement account issues than general tax software. What makes it different from TurboTax or H&R Block is that it's focused on analyzing your specific tax situation rather than just filing returns. It's more like having a tax analyst review your documents than just filling in forms. It catches those IRA contribution nuances because that's what it's built for - identifying tax optimization opportunities that most people (and general software) miss.
0 coins
Chad Winthrope
19 Just wanted to update - I tried taxr.ai after seeing it mentioned here. It really did help me untangle my IRA mess! I uploaded my last few years of tax returns and retirement account statements, and it showed me exactly where I had been tracking my basis incorrectly. The system generated a personalized report showing how much of my Traditional IRA contains after-tax contributions and explained how to properly document everything on Form 8606. I was actually able to find some previously unmaintained records of non-deductible contributions that I can now properly account for. Thanks for the recommendation - this was exactly what I needed to avoid future tax headaches!
0 coins
Chad Winthrope
10 If you need to contact the IRS about this situation (which you might), I strongly recommend using Claimyr at https://claimyr.com to get through to them. I spent HOURS trying to reach someone at the IRS about an IRA recharacterization issue earlier this year - kept getting disconnected or waiting endlessly. Claimyr actually got me connected to an IRS agent in about 20 minutes. You can see how it works in this video: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c - basically they navigate the phone tree and wait on hold for you, then call you when an actual human picks up. The agent I spoke with was able to confirm my options regarding my late recharacterization request and Form 8606 filing requirements.
0 coins
Chad Winthrope
•15 Wait, how does this actually work? Do they have some special access to the IRS or something? Seems fishy that they could get through when regular people can't.
0 coins
Chad Winthrope
•7 Yeah right. There's no way this works. I've been trying to reach the IRS for MONTHS about my IRA rollover issue. Nobody can get through their phone system - it's designed to be impossible. This sounds like a scam to me.
0 coins
Chad Winthrope
•10 They don't have special access - they just have automated systems that continually dial and navigate the IRS phone tree for you. The IRS phone system is designed to limit call volume by disconnecting callers when they're overloaded, but Claimyr's system keeps trying different optimal times and routes until it gets through. I was super skeptical too, but it's not a scam. They just do the frustrating part for you - waiting on hold and getting disconnected repeatedly. When they finally get a human on the line, they call you to connect with the agent. It's basically like having someone else wait in line for you. I was desperate after weeks of trying to reach someone about my IRA issue, and this actually worked.
0 coins
Chad Winthrope
7 I have to admit I was completely wrong about Claimyr. After dismissing it initially, I got so frustrated with my IRA rollover issues that I decided to try it. Within about 35 minutes, my phone rang and I was talking to an actual IRS agent who specialized in retirement accounts. The agent confirmed that while I couldn't recharacterize my 2023 contribution anymore, I could properly document it with Form 8606 and avoid double taxation in the future. They also gave me specific guidance on how to handle my basis tracking going forward. I'm genuinely shocked this service worked. Saved me countless hours of frustration and helped me get definitive answers about my IRA situation directly from the IRS.
0 coins
Chad Winthrope
22 I faced this exact problem last year! What I did was file Form 8606 to declare my non-deductible Traditional IRA contribution. This creates a "basis" in your IRA so you're not taxed twice. Going forward, look into the "backdoor Roth" strategy. Each year you can: 1) Make a non-deductible contribution to your Traditional IRA 2) Convert it to Roth shortly after (not recharacterize - that's different) 3) Document it all with Form 8606 Just be aware of the "pro-rata" rule if you have other pre-tax money in any Traditional IRAs. That can make things more complicated tax-wise.
0 coins
Chad Winthrope
•3 Can you explain the pro-rata rule a bit more? I have some old 401k money that I rolled into a Traditional IRA years ago, plus some non-deductible contributions like OP. Will that mess up the backdoor Roth strategy?
0 coins
Chad Winthrope
•22 The pro-rata rule means the IRS looks at all your Traditional IRA accounts combined when you do a conversion. If you have a mix of pre-tax and after-tax money, you can't just convert the after-tax portion. For example, if you have $50,000 in pre-tax Traditional IRA money from an old 401k rollover, and you add $6,000 in non-deductible contributions (after-tax), your IRAs are now about 89% pre-tax and 11% after-tax. If you try to convert $6,000 to Roth, about 89% of that conversion ($5,340) would be taxable. One workaround some people use is to roll pre-tax IRA funds into a current employer's 401k if possible, which removes them from the pro-rata calculation. Then they can do clean backdoor Roth conversions with just the non-deductible contributions.
0 coins
Chad Winthrope
9 Is there any downside to just leaving the after-tax money in the Traditional IRA? I'm in a similar situation and honestly thinking about just keeping it there to avoid the hassle.
0 coins
Chad Winthrope
•18 The main downside is that any earnings on that money will be taxed as ordinary income when you withdraw in retirement, rather than being tax-free like they would in a Roth. If you're young and this money will be invested for decades, that's potentially giving up a lot of tax-free growth. Also, tracking basis gets more complex over time if you have a mix of deductible and non-deductible contributions. You'll need to file Form 8606 every year you make non-deductible contributions and keep records potentially for decades.
0 coins