Can I get a bigger tax refund than what I paid in from my W-2 job?
So I work a regular W-2 job but started a side business (LLC) back in October that officially began selling in November. Since it's an LLC, it flows through to my personal taxes. Here's my question - is it actually possible to get a tax refund that's LARGER than what I actually paid in federal taxes from my W-2 paycheck? I file as head of household and have a child I can claim. I also have mortgage interest and property taxes to deduct. With my new business, I've got a ton of startup expenses and inventory costs that are way more than what I've made in sales so far (like seriously, way more lol). I feel like this might be a stupid question but I'm trying to understand how this all works. Could my business losses plus child tax credit and everything else actually result in getting back more than I paid in? Thanks!
22 comments
Join the conversation
Zoe Gonzalez
Yes, it's absolutely possible to receive a refund larger than what you paid in federal income taxes! This happens through refundable tax credits. The most relevant one for you is probably the Child Tax Credit, which is partially refundable (up to $1,600 per qualifying child). Even if you've paid $0 in federal income tax, you could still receive this as a refund. As for your business losses, those can offset your W-2 income, potentially reducing your taxable income significantly. However, business losses themselves don't generate refunds beyond what you've paid in - they just reduce your tax liability. Your situation actually sounds quite common for new small businesses. Those initial startup costs often exceed revenue in the first year. Just make sure you're properly tracking all legitimate business expenses and keeping good records in case of an audit.
0 coins
Avery Flores
•Thanks so much! That makes more sense now. I've been keeping all my receipts and tracking everything in a spreadsheet. Do business losses from my LLC carry forward if they're more than my W-2 income can offset this year? And does contributing to my 401k at my day job affect how the business losses get applied?
0 coins
Zoe Gonzalez
•Yes, business losses that exceed your income can carry forward to future tax years! This is called a Net Operating Loss (NOL), and it can be very beneficial for new business owners. You can use these losses in future years when your business becomes profitable. Your 401k contributions at your day job reduce your W-2 taxable income before business losses are applied. So having both 401k contributions and business losses is a double benefit - they both reduce your overall taxable income, just at different stages of the tax calculation.
0 coins
Ashley Adams
After my first child was born, I was in a similar situation - working a W-2 job while starting a small business. I was totally confused about how tax refunds worked until I found https://taxr.ai - it analyzed my documents and explained exactly how much I could expect. The tool showed me that between my child tax credit, earned income credit, and business deductions, I was getting back WAY more than I paid in. It even identified several business deductions I hadn't thought of tracking! The analysis showed my effective tax rate was actually negative because of the refundable credits. What I found most helpful is that it explained the differences between refundable and non-refundable credits and showed exactly how my business losses affected my W-2 income.
0 coins
Alexis Robinson
•How accurate was it compared to what you actually got back? I've used tax calculators before that were way off and I ended up owing instead of getting a refund like they predicted.
0 coins
Aaron Lee
•Does it work for more complicated situations? I've got W-2 income, a rental property AND a side business with inventory. Most tools I've tried crash and burn with my tax situation.
0 coins
Ashley Adams
•It was surprisingly accurate - within about $50 of my actual refund amount. The key difference is that it analyzes your actual documents rather than just using numbers you input into a calculator, which helps avoid those nasty surprises. For complex situations with multiple income sources, it actually works even better because it's designed to handle the complications that come with mixed income types. It handled my W-2 plus business situation beautifully, and I've heard from friends with rental properties that it works well for them too. The document analysis feature is what makes it more reliable than basic calculators.
0 coins
Aaron Lee
Just wanted to update after trying taxr.ai - wow! I was skeptical from my previous experiences with tax tools, but this completely changed my understanding of my tax situation. It showed me that even though I've paid about $7,200 in federal taxes from my W-2, I'm eligible for a refund of nearly $9,100 because of my child, mortgage interest, and especially my business losses. I had no idea how the qualified business income deduction would impact everything. The analysis explained exactly why I'm getting more back than I paid in (refundable credits + business loss offsetting other income) and highlighted some home office deductions I was missing for my business. Definitely recommend for anyone with a side business!
0 coins
Chloe Mitchell
If you need to verify anything about your refund situation or have specific questions about your business deductions, I'd recommend actually talking to someone at the IRS. I know it sounds impossible to reach them, but I used https://claimyr.com and got through in about 15 minutes when I had a similar question last year. You can see how it works here: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c When I started my LLC, I had questions about how business losses would affect my refund, and the agent walked me through exactly how it would work with my child tax credit. They explained that refundable credits plus business losses offsetting my W-2 income could definitely result in getting back more than I paid in. Saved me from making some mistakes on my return!
0 coins
Chloe Mitchell
If you need to verify
0 coins
Michael Adams
•How does this actually work? I've literally spent HOURS on hold with the IRS and never gotten through. Are they just calling for you or what?
0 coins
Natalie Wang
•Yeah right. No way this actually works. The IRS is basically unreachable. I've tried calling dozens of times this year and the automated system just hangs up on me saying they're too busy.
0 coins
Chloe Mitchell
•They use a system that navigates the IRS phone tree and holds your place in line. When they reach a live agent, they call you and connect you directly. It's not magic - they're just using technology to handle the hold time for you. The reason it works is because they're constantly calling and can recognize the patterns in the IRS system to maximize the chances of getting through. I was skeptical too until I tried it. I literally got a call back saying "We have an IRS agent on the line" and then was connected immediately. No dealing with the phone tree or hold music.
0 coins
Natalie Wang
I have to eat my words. After being completely skeptical about Claimyr, I tried it yesterday morning when I had questions about my LLC losses. I expected it to be a waste of money, but I got a call back within 20 minutes with an actual IRS agent on the line. The agent confirmed that with my situation (W-2 job, new business with losses, and a dependent), I could absolutely receive a refund larger than what I'd paid in through my W-2 withholding. She explained that the refundable portion of the Child Tax Credit plus the Earned Income Credit I qualified for meant I'd get back everything I paid in PLUS additional money. Definitely worth the time saved compared to my previous attempts to reach them.
0 coins
Noah Torres
Definitely keep track of all your startup costs! I made the mistake of not documenting everything properly my first year and missed out on thousands in deductions. Make sure you're tracking: - Inventory costs (even if you haven't sold it yet) - Home office space (if applicable) - Mileage for business purposes - Marketing/advertising costs - Professional services (accountant, lawyer) - Software/subscriptions for business - Phone/internet (business percentage) All these reduce your business income and can help create that loss that offsets your W-2 income!
0 coins
Avery Flores
•Thanks for the list! I've been tracking most of these but hadn't thought about the phone/internet percentage. Is there a standard percentage most people use for that, or do I need to calculate exactly how much is used for business?
0 coins
Noah Torres
•There's no standard percentage - you need to make a reasonable estimate based on your actual usage. For phones, some people have a separate business line, but if you're using one phone, you might track business calls vs. personal calls for a few months to establish a pattern. For internet, consider the hours you use it for business versus personal use. If you work your business 20 hours a week and your total waking hours at home are about 80 hours, you might justify 25%. Just be prepared to explain your calculation method if asked. Remember, the IRS looks for reasonable estimates - you don't need to be exact to the minute, just honest and consistent in your approach.
0 coins
Samantha Hall
Careful with mortgage interest! Since you have a business in your home, you'll need to split the mortgage interest between Schedule A (personal) and Schedule C (business) based on the percentage of your home used exclusively for business. This is a common mistake for new business owners and can cause issues if you're audited. You can't double-dip and claim 100% of mortgage interest on Schedule A while also claiming a home office deduction!
0 coins
Ryan Young
•Is it even worth claiming home office then? I've heard it reduces your mortgage interest deduction and complicates selling your house later because of capital gains implications. Some of my friends say to avoid it completely.
0 coins
Sophia Clark
One thing nobody mentioned yet - make sure your LLC is set up for the right tax treatment! By default, a single-member LLC is taxed as a sole proprietorship (Schedule C), but you could have elected to be taxed as an S-Corp which changes EVERYTHING about how losses flow through. What tax treatment did you choose for your LLC?
0 coins
Avery Flores
•I didn't make any special elections, so I guess it's the default (sole proprietorship)? Is that bad? Should I have chosen S-Corp instead?
0 coins
Sophia Clark
•For your first year with more expenses than income, the default sole proprietorship treatment is actually perfect! This allows your business losses to directly offset your W-2 income on your personal return. If you had elected S-Corp status, the rules for how losses flow through would be more complicated and potentially less beneficial in this startup phase. As your business becomes profitable, S-Corp status might make sense to save on self-employment taxes, but for now, you're in the ideal structure to maximize the tax benefit of your startup losses. You made the right choice by sticking with the default!
0 coins